Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. And ANR v. Surinder Singh And ORS
! "#$ %#&'( $) " ( !$ *+,+-.
.* -*.+*./*.
+*.
/*++ *+/+*+// $01
( (221 .
"$1 3' $
" !44( 5 3' 4
" $$ 6#$& 5
! "
# $% $& '() '*+ "+,($''& "+,($
- !
. !
# - !
# / !
- ! "
01%(' %(2 %+' %+2 '2'3'221+,($
45
/6 !
!
"
1'+21+,($
- !
"
# $& '%+%+2 "+,($
0 6 !
"
1'%*1+,($
-. !
"
1+,'1+,+(
/ 6 ! "
.- 6 . !
"
1'+)1+,($
! "
1'%(3'*,1+,($
0 7 ! "
5 !
"
# % '1'()1+,($ # % &1'%$1+,($
8 !
"
# ( (,# '($ "+,($ "
# '+, "+,($ "
# ( *# '+( "+,($
"
# ( % * '2# '+% "+,($ "
# ( % &2 (,'+&1+,($ "
# ( &# '*( "+,($ "
# +& +2# '*% "+,($ "
# ( & 2 $ (( (+ () +, +* +& %, %( *(*+# $% "+,($ !44( 5 *& 0 "%' !
6 "
8 +2,2+,() 7# +)+) "+,('
9
!
69
"%(! !
"
!
! "
"
: "
!
" !; ,*,%($$$ < 1+
0 !
;!
= "
"% "
6 " !
" !
" !
; 0 6 +%,2+,(& < 1(*
- ! ; "
!
= 6
,+,++,() 0 !
"
! # $& "+,($ 0 0 6
!
9
" # %(' %(2 %+' %+2 '2''22 "+,($ !
!
! 0 ; 8 : !; ,*,%($$$
"
: " >
6 6 ;
!
6 " (,;
"
!
6
+&? " !! !
!
"
0
!
! " !
;
666),?
.
6 6 "! ;
"
=
"(,;
!!
0 ! 6
6 ;6 <!
!
# + !
=
!! ;4 .
!
!"
# !
$ ! 8 ;
6 " < %&'(%)
*+ $, ;
6
"
" " : !
! "!
!;
,2,&+,(* " ; .
"
4 !
(,,'+,(* " >
6 ;
!
! ;!
"
: "
!
.
"4 !
"
" ! ,2,&+,(* " 66
"
6 4 !
" !;
! ;
"
6,2,&+,(* "
6,*,%($$$ ! 8
! "
!
:
" !; ,*,%($$$!!
; !
!
6
-""%".#/0#
,)!* $
!
6 ! !6 !
6
6
@
" " :
> !!
;6 ! !; !
"
8 " = 6
- !
"
0 6
- #A9 6 "
B !
! ;.
B.
" B !
! ;! +,,%
!
6
!
(',*+,(, !
!
"
60 "
! +,(, > "
""
! " "
"
!
!
0 !
!
; " !
!
6 0 !
6
6 " 6 ;6 ! " 6
"
-"! "0 !
<
! 6 ! ;!
!
!
!
> !!
;6 ! "
: ! 0 !
! "
0 "
= "
!
7
: "
6 "
" !; ,2,&+,(*
"
6(,,*+,,'
"
6 " <
7
"66
"
!
!; ,*,%($$$ "
"
! "66 0 ! ! !-
;
"
!
; !
!
1
!
6 ; ; ; " 6 ;
"
6 6
!
- "
+,;
" ! " .
! "#1 %&2".
)$* 0 - "
6
"
!
-"
"
6($2) +,,+"
6
" 6 6 1> 6 ;
" !
< < 1(
!
Sr. No. & Name Date of and DOB Appointment
1. Surinder Singh 03.06.1998 22.02.1975
2. Shashi Kapoor 16.07.2002 04.03.1978
3. Santosh Kumari 11.03.1993 20.07.1977
4. Nirmala Devi 01.12.1978 14.05.1961
5. Bimla Devi Year 1983 15.10.1960 7;!- (,,+($$) 4 .
! !
6 6 ;
- >
<
: "
!
"
; 3 % #1 3" ) * . " 4# ++ )*(5 , !
!; ; 6 ;
" !
"
: -
;
-"
(& +,;
0
+
! " #$
%
&
!
'
("
( !
!
)*(
+
, A " ! !; ,*,%($$$ < 1+ ; !
- .
" $
/
% '
. ( ' '
-123
&4
5
0
)* "
6*2
(
7 5
/ 8
(
!
/
!
'
(
9
9!
%
(
5
. 9
# 3
!
/
'
/ 3
&4
: &
' '"
;
;
"
# 3 #
' ; <3
= " 7
3 (
' ' # "
>
3
!
' '7 7 '
; ? (
;
& + 1<-@<6 ;% )<?*-) *A*-) A (
, A!!
"
!
! +
6 6
6 ;6 <!
,
4 .
!7# (+($$ "+,,, - / "
! +%,$+,,+
" " :
6
6 ;6 <! !
!
" !6 "
"
: "
!
"
! 6 6 ! ";>3B%+ )CC11 -**?"%5#
!
# +
!-
; 4 .
! !
!
!
0 ;
"
%- . .!
%6 7 >.!
D)! 3B%+ )C*6A -**?
7 (
<
'
- .!
%6
?
&
"
(!, $
"
6 6 ,),*+,,& 0 6
!
(,,*+,,'
" : ;
.
! > $!+$
6
!
,$,&+,(+ < 1'; 8
""
!
!;;!
= =
!
; - "
-
:
!
" 6 6 ;
0
B.
;
# + '; ;!
0
"E #
AE
"
&
#" "
' E F # 3
# ' "-**C ?#>D)B
"
< '
5
( #
'
"
!
&
" 7
# $
7
' '
"
<
1 (
<
&
9!
F
G C (" "
7
'
#
!
"
&
"
7
'
! @
!
6" (0 +
! (6
!
6 (+,*+,(% < 12; !
.
!;
6 ;
-"
6
(,;
; 6 " "! !
!
!
6
"
!
! ;
:
0
& ' !
+ "
'
"
'!
(
&
3 < / . 5
' &
"
.
"
, ($
$7" 6 6
%(,(+,(* < 1) 0
"
!; ,*,%($$$ ,2,&+,(*;
< 1% ! ! H H + <%
0@1-*)A &
E % 5IE E3
3B%+ -A?A
-*))"D.+ A1? -*)- >%.C6 -*)? E # 3
& #>%<33+ A6C -*)A E
# I 4< %#%3>" % 5 # % >
% 5 $
= + ))<)1<6
A%%<-6*? A?) .!
)
/ %(B ' %#%3>
. # 3
39<%
" # <9 ) # <>
/ %(B '
"
EH # <9+$ )
'
3
&4
E H
% B '
/ # 3 & %#%3> %(B '
9
9!
%
"7 = # $ # #
%#%3>
H H + -??<3 &" @)-*)? ( B(
5
:
, 0 ! " (,,'+,(* < 1* !
%+J.:#(.(9%HB9D3HD%HD.(&H+>(
%
# H H + )-<%
0)*C-*)A &
<% @*1-*)A"%#%3> :
% 5# % 3 > E B
(
9 + 1?6<)-?@<-%CA<4
1 @1-*)A"
%
/
%(B ' , 0
"
- :
" "! ! ! +%,2+,(& < 1 (*
! - !
! "
! ;
.
!
>
!
" ! E #
,$,&+,(+
!
8
$6 %.1
"
; 1
+*,++,(&
!
" 6
-
!
; < !
!
6
; !; " A 0 6
# 5 0 . + --6<-% C-<J C AC-*)A 3 9<ED D
/ ' K3H3% + -C)1 -*)A # E # 4
3="
%#%3>" &
":
?@ = )6?-*)1 '
. + -)- -A--*)10 D9H>49 (E.( '
!
3H3% E F E3
, 0
"
!
6; !
,&((+,(*
; !6 ")&( 6
-
!
; "B
!
6 ;
"
!
6
"0 !
;
! ""
! 0 "
!!
1 -
- B
E 3
% 5#% 3 >
% 5 $
= + ))<)1<6 A<%%<-6*? *A*?) + *@*1-*)A .!
A
( # 3
/ % (B '
H
39<%
"%#%3>"%
# <> "%#%3>"%
# <9+$ )"%#%3>"% B
%( ' ' %#%3>
/ 3
?)+ 3B%+ -A?A -*)) ?))*-*)AH -+
(
?)+ %#9: %#%3>"
!
(% #+ 6#D5 #< # :5D 3 #+ ?)## #< # D 5 %#%3> #D5 #< # 3 " #+ )6
)* .
?)+
7
3 + I
!
)*
/
(
3
.!
: %#(3>
% 5 $
= + ))<)1<6
A%%<-6*? A?) 9 + ))-@<?A@ 66-*)A
%( ' '%#(3>
+ %
%#(3> .!
3 & 3
61)%(B '
%
7
.!
."
/
; A" ;@ " +(,*+,(&
; !
,&((+,(*0 6
C3
*1))-*)A .!
.
)
3 9<ED" %#%3>" % "
/
E
"
'
"
3
)-)*-*)- 3B% + -A?A -*))
"&
" "
*1))-*)A
.!
.
-
+ & "
, B6 ; "! .
-
! +*,++,(& ! "
- ! !
6 ;
0
" ! C 0-?*@-*)1 + "
5 " :
A? = -@-*)1 '
' 0 D9#H>49 ' :
+ -)- -A--*)1 '
3H3%+ -C)1 -*)A ;D(E9D D9#H>49 (E.( %
'
=
#
(
# "
EH 3
;D(E9DD9#H>49(E.(&
' / "= ' # <=
#<=
/
EH
'
! .
< %#%3> ' ' ,
" 7# %&*( "+,() "
!# '() "+,($
"
!
6 ;
!
!
"
6 " 6
!
! !
,+,++,()
= 0 !
< 1$
! = +HA))"
---*)6 # 0 + & .
"
)A@"# . D0 &
+ )*-*<-6$ @- )--*)6 # 9" %I= ": &
' % 5#% 3 > %(#H)-*)@"% 3 '
( )?-*)6"
(
. & .
"
)A@. "
(
,
# <
# 9!
9 %I= "%#%3>": , 0
= !
"
!
6" !
6; !
5
6
6 6 6 - :
- "
(,;
6
;!
-
!
"
" 0
!
6 '6 "
6 "
!
! (,,*+,,'
"
" ;
(,(,+,,'0
1- +
"
"
"
# "
&
!"7
. 5 "
: 3
D# : 4 ( $ :
+
(
%
(
"
(
'
# ' 1?H
(
! #4 +.D.L.+.%%.
" D+ +.+J+.%%.
" :+ +.$.D.J.+
" )1 "
7
'
(7
/
3
5 &
!" & " # $
'
/
"
" '
'
7
"
(
! B
/ " "
5 "
"
7
/ '"
, !
- "
6-;! !;
! 6
"
! " !
!
0
"
; - ,2,&+,(*;
!; " "
6 .
"4 !
(,,'+,(* ! ! ; 1 -
,&((+,(*; ; + ! ;
= 0 6 ;
!
6
(,;
(,,*+,,' !
;
"!
" 6 0 6 !;
! " !
6;
" < ; " !
=>
!
! !
"
D ;
6
(,;
"
!
!
"
:
"
!
!
;
! !
" 6 ;
;
!
;
- "
6
(,;
(,,*+,,'
"
!
" : !
; !
! ! "!- " ! ="!
:
0
=>
@ & !
M
/ "
0
(
' )*
& "#$
(
"
B
7 "
:
7 '
"
"
6
$ " '
/
"
"
!
)*A-**C ( M
(
"
'
!
"
'
5
'
7 7
"
/ )*. ! "
<
<
3
7 "
/
H "
$
'
! !
&
"
% 1? "
/ " !
" ! 1? ! ( !
<
<
)*
)*A-**C
&
! 1? "
1? "
"
! ( !
%1? "
.
))( 5 1?
;
" "
/
#
<
<
<
/
"
(
' )*A-**C
"
"
7 7 "
/ (
'
!
/
!
! ' "
"
/
!!!
!!!
!!!
9. These appeals have been pending for more than four years after the decision in Umadevi. The Appellant (Zila Panchayat, Gadag) has not considered the cases of respondents of regularization within six months of the decision in Umadevi or thereafter.
-
10. The Division Bench of the High Court has directed that the cases of respondents should be considered in accordance with law. The only further direction that needs be given, in view of Umadevi, is that the Zila Panchayat, Gadag should now undertake an exercise within six months, a general one- time regularization exercise, to find out whether there are any daily wage/casual/ad-hoc employees serving the Zila Panchayat and if so whether such employees (including the respondents) fulfill the requirements mentioned in para 53 of Umadevi. If they fulfill them, their services have to be regularized.
If such an exercise has already been undertaken by ignoring or omitting the cases of respondents 1 to 3 because of the pendency of these cases, then their cases shall have to be considered in continuation of the said one time exercise within three months. It is needless to say that if the respondents do not fulfill the requirements of Para 53 of Umadevi, their services need not be regularised. If the employees who have completed ten years service do not possess the educational qualifications prescribed for the post, at the time of their appointment, they may be considered for regularization in suitable lower posts. This appeal is disposed of accordingly.
.
, 6 ; %"7 -& )
* ! < "
: "8 -!
6 "
6 ! "
!
< " 6 ;
; 6 "
; " ;!
6
(, ;
"
!
;
:
!
:
;
" @
! "!
!
0
"+ (
@ (
?
" "
"
( #
J'
?
" 7 "
( !
( ?
6& " 3 : ?" '
#
J'
#
! )1+ "-***
! )*. "-**C&
+ "
: ( E 3
# J'
! #" K
7 ' B
#
J'
'
(
)*
" D
D
"
)*
D
D
"
&
)*
5
'
))( 5
E3
(#
'
(
)-B
# J'
'
'
,
!
! !
6 '9.
/ )5* /'1:;)
$*!$
!
6
"; < :
!
"2* 6 ;
"* -
"! 6 ;
6 ; -& ; %"9)
$*,! "
6 6 " @
:
" "8
B
- "
+$;
;
!
<!
6
! " !- !
!
6 "
" " : > ! !
6 !
6 "
6
($2) +,,+ " " " ! ""
(,,*+,,'
- !
! !-
"! !
!
! "
6
"
-
0
; ""! "
" "B
! " ")&& 6 ;
1! "6 !- "
! ; "
"! !
! 7
- " ! )&& 6 ;
"
+,;
0 ! !
! "
6
! ; - 6
6 ;
! ! " !
6
"6 6 ;
0 ! +%,2+,(&
,
6 !
6 "
" 1 -
! !
! ; " "!
"
: ;
! "
6
" ;
- !
; ! :
6>!! !6 !
6 ;
!
6
(,;
(,,*+,,'
!
"
" : !
; + ! ;
= 0 ! !
,2,&+,(* ; !
!
!
!
6;
! " < A!
!; " ,*,%($$$
6 ;
!
6
(,;
(,,*+,,'
"
""
" ! " <
6 6 6 !
);
;
+,(*
; "
- 66 " !; ;
; .
! 0 ! "!
"
"66 !! "
!
!!
"
; ! ; =
"
!
!; !
!
; <
!
(*( " ">
!
! !
!
; < 0'& '&- -1;550<5
+ +
,0 6 !
! "
"
"
! !; ! !!
< &+ !
"!
"
;
;
"
!
0 < '69"
()
* $ @ !
"
!
"6
; ! !
= " ;
;6 "6 ;" :
; 5
6
;
" " = "! "!
"
; !
"
!
6 6 "
!
!
!
<6 ; < 9: :)
!* $
-
6 6 ; .
!
"
! "
: " ! !
A""!
!
- "
!
!
; 6 ; !
; !
;
;!
6
;0
+ #
" 6 ) 3 5 E3
% 5IE >%.
+ -* )-
/
5
/ "E
.
'
E "
(
!
#( #
'
! )@ .
(
'
/
#
'
#"
-*+
)@ !
"
"
! ( "#
-):
5 # '
'
#
#
. --(7
# % 5
#
3 :
F ( 7 "
F 7
! & " 3
#
3 AN( "# "
"
"
%
# 3
"
" "
'
7
&
"
'
"
" ' '
(
'
"
"
.
.
," ' !
#
! .
--C 3 B
.
--C 3
5 7
"
5
"
, 0 " B !
! ;.
;
!
"! ! 6 ;
!
6
!
"6 7# %+'+ "
+,() # &
!
" 0 !
= "
- !
"
!
6 !!
; !
;6 6 6
" ,$,2+,()"" (2,)+,(' " 6
/ 4 ; !
; "
!
6 " 7# +)+)
"+,('!!
"!
;
"
"
"
6B. >
"
"" "
"
6
!
6 0 !
E !
6 "
!
6
"
"! (',*+,(, 0 6 :.
" ;!
"
" ! "
6 ";
-
"+,$ ""! @
..
!
: 6
!
!
; 8 "
:
" !;
! !
!
!
"
! "
6 1!
!
" : " ;
" ! !
!
"
!- "
6+,,'"
"(,;
6 # ( % *&
; !
"
!
=
"(,;
!!
6
7
! ;
!
!
! "
: ;
- 1> -
.
"
!
! ="! ! =
! - 6
"
; ;
6 A!
!; "
6 6 ;
:
; ,*,%($$$
6
; "
"
!
" 6 " .
! .; ; ! "
");
" "! !
6 6 ;
" "
! ! ! ! ;6
0 !
!
6 "!!
; "
!
6; ! ; 8 !!
;
6 "
! 0
!
6" ;!
6 ;
!
.- "
B. "
: " 6 ;
- "
"(,;
(,,*+,,'
"
6
;
;
6 ;
6 ;6 <!
;! !
6 !!
"
"
!
!
; !!
" " !; ,2,&+,(* 6 ;
"
"66"
6 !
!; ,*,%($$$
"
6 ;
!
6
(,;
= ),? !
(,,*+,,'
!
;!
;
! "
6 " ,2,&+,(* !
; !
,+,++,()
;
! - !
6 6 ;
6 :
!
!
" ! "
<
0
"
" + 6 ;
!
6"
: "
6 " !
"!
" !
; " 6 ! 6!
! ";
"! ;! 5#4@7> 8F45B +%(++,++ @ BB0/F 8BB7# 8F45B 7
E - 7