High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3799/2016allowed

Attar Singh And ORS v. Randhir Singh And ORS

2017-09-05Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh5 pages

!"#$%&'%()$$* )((#

!"#$%&'

"( )"

*#$%&'

(% +++++ $* )((#,& +" ( ( % ' '"

,,!

% %

-

$./0-( %*1"$%% , ,2/%! # 4"*1

5% %

4 4 % % /, " ( "

/* % "

(% 5(,

"

/ %', # ( 6/' ( !

%, %%

( "(,

*1

,,* !&

8%

#/ 9 ' "*

%7 ,,#6/%! %%'%

89( % , / 9- 89 %/ - ' %"*

%6/%! %%'* ,#/,, %& %* % !/( !" "(,

%( % % +"(,

, /(!

%7 ,,* !

5% 9 (/(% * .'/% *1 2

:

, ; 3 ; 2

&/ "

" ,1 %"

!"# * !" % /* !" 4"*1 (& /

,,4 '

',,%+"(

,%"4 $./ 0 ',

! " !" " / ((1 " * 7 ,, %

.'/% *1 " 2

:

, 4" % % " 1 8 +"1

&%"

"1 4 ((1 %',

" (%5(,

*, < /" /* % "

" (%5(,

% %( % % 5( & / "

""

( 1% %' ( <

/"/* %"

"( * !4 / ((1

%*

!, %"

' *

!

! %"

,*! !"/ %%% !

!*1( !", & /* */ '"

'4 " ,4 %/

%&'#" 4 /!"*(, %%*14 "4 %"' 1 %4 %

( $./0 < !/% 4 " &"' "

'( % 4 % * "

(,

+" '(,*

"(, % !&

''

,< !/%"

" 4

* 14 "(%5(,

4 '0.

% "/!" " 4 " (,

%% & %' "

% *1 4 1 .

'"

+" , /* %*1'/, "

"((% %4 ,, " '"

! / % '

% *1 " ( 4/,% '

/ (6/% '"(%5(,

4"

'"' "%1 /, ( ! " (%5(,

"

/((% " (/!%%4 ""/* "

(& ((%%/,

% "% ,'%/#

8 "==*14

" 1

' '(, *

% (, % !

''

, /, " ( 1

( 1"'% (' *% "(& ,1"

'/!"*(, %%*14 '/,% * &% " , (, % ! %( .'

%/ % !'$"/* %*1'/, "

"(

%"(%5(,

/ ( 4,,# " ( % %, 1 '',/ "('% ! 4 (,!" ( "/ 1& % !"< !/%"

%&'"(

% ' / !/% ,,4 % " (, % !

''

, <"

&" %'/, "( #(/%"( (0* '/, ,1"& / ./ ((%%4 ""( ',/% % (/!% +"'

* 1% (/ */",%( , 4 "

(, % !'

* ,,4% 1 ! "

,/,

/, '

/ 6/1 " ' ! ( 1 4"

'" '

* '( %*1'>?/ ,,1,% "

"4 % * "

(,

@=*, " $(. /

!

" # $%# &

'

# ()*)+*, +, (-. '/,,% / '

( (, % " (, % ! &

(& /, %4 %%% "1

,& . ' ( %8 "6/%!# %"/0

A ' ,,1 ,1B !*" " >!, " % <%

'

# * '( (,!4"

'"/!"*

' % 4"

,

!6' % 7""" %/!" ( & ((

' & %6/% "'

C 7""" C +" %"/,%'

//'"(6/% '"" % 4"

'" '

* '( %?/ ,1 1D 9 / %4/,%

', % 6/ ', /, (,, D - 7"" " ((% % ' / ,,1

/% ,,1'"

!" / %'"

' "'

C $% $ ! ,/,#"'/"/,%%', %

" / " %% ',

4/,% * * % *1

"% 8+" (

'4"

'" 1* ( 4"

,% !4

,%/%%/, +" ,1 ,,/ & %."

/ &E /, "(%5(,

,%( /"

'

*6'% 1 "!/%4""'

.

% ", !" ( (,'/,,% / "

%6/%! <% (/ *,1# " ( "

& ',

% ",& * 4 %"* 7 ,,(/(% *.'/%*12

:

"1 #"* 4" #/ '

&/ @ !"

% " 2

:

,+"

' /!"* %%%*14 /".(, " (, 4"

(*1 "1"

%*',

!",&* 4 ( " / ((1 4"

,

! , % "

& /* ,1F " #

-

%GF <"

& 4

#<

% ' "( "

"

,/"

' % / " 1 *1 6'

"4 ,1"!/%"

"4 %, 1

"

,/ 1"?/ (& ((%%/, %+"

#

,/ 4"

, % ! " "

'%% 1 /'"

% ! "

""((%

%"

' 1 '(, %

' & %6/% " '&1 G% " '

'/ '# " % (/!% '

*

,,4%/

''% !,1 % H " ! ! # " ( ,,4% +"

"4

,,4%/*6'( 1 '

#

50*%( %4 "

,/4,,*

! %%4 %" "

,,* , %

&/ " (%5(,

( /, +" ( "

,,

, " %% 4 #

, %1

,%#4 "/

%6/"

" %, 1 (! "

,< ',

%"

1"

! %" * "

,, '

/(6/% ' " "( %/ !"'/

, / 0 1.()*- + 203, I3J/, K 7""(

!5 % 15 7""( *, 15