Balbir Singh v. Balwinder Singh Etc.

   

      

!"#$#%&'&() **
  !+,&-.&(/0 #1&'&(&'"  2#-'3'

!+4&($#-.&(/0!($"0#-'

#'5($#("'

)  67  . 8 7.  -#'#(")9 -8.&(/+!:$1%!"#:-"0#-#1&'&(&'" (#--#'5($#(" 

 ;0#"0#-"0##5-"#-'+%!+(#4'5!5#-<!=,#!++4#$"'## "0#>3$/<#("?

 ,#-##--#$""0##5-"#--("  ;0#"0#-"0#>3$/<#("'03+$,#-#5-"#$&("0#$&/#'"? 99 99 7. :

7 (#  0!'  !55#!-#$  -  -#'5($#("    :  $#'5&"# '#%($%!++ 0!1#0#!-$"0#+#!-(#$%3('#+-"0#-#1&'&(&'"!($ 0!1#!+'%!-#3++=/(#"0-3/0"0#&+# <53/(#$  &(  "0#  5-#'#("  -#1&'&(  &'  "0#  -$#-  $!"#$ @
   ((#A3-#99 :  5!''#$  ,=  "0#  +#!-(#$ $$&"&(!+  &1&+ 3$/#:.#(&-&1&'&(:0&++!3-:1&$#40&%0&(!(!55+&%!"&(&+#$,= "0#5-#'#("-#1&'&(&'"!+,&-.&(/0 $##($!(",#-#"0#+4#-

9
9

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

"0'0!-#&("0#$&'53"#$5-5#-"=( "0#,!'&';&++$!"#$
  @**0#'!+#$##$$!"#$ 

:

&(!13-$##($!(" -#1&'&(&'":0!'!+',##(%0!++#(/#$ 0#  5#-3'!+    "0#  &<53/(#$  -$#-  '04'  "0!"  "0# !$$-#''    $##($!("     -#1&'&(&'"  4!'  /&1#(    61&++!/# 80B0#4!+:#0'+0&++!3-:&'"-&%"!+!($0!-64#1#-:!5#-3'!+ "0#54#- !""-(#=:5+!%#$(&+#:'04'"0!"$##($!(" -#1&'&(&'"&'&(!%"!((9#'&$#("($&!( 66 !($&'+&1&(/&(

!(!$!0#%5&#'5!''5-"!($$-&1&(/+&%#(%#0!1#!+',##( 5-$3%#$0#5+!&("& -#'5($#(" !($"0#5-#'#("-#1&'&(&'"

!-#"0#-#!+,-"0#-'!($&"%!((",#,#+&#1#$"0!""0#

99 5+!&("& -#'5($#(" 4&++(",#B(4&(/"0!"0&',-"0#-&'

5#-<!(#("+=+&1&(/&( !(!$!"03/00#&'0!1&(/+!($&(($&!0# '!+#  $##$  &(  !13-    $##($!("     -#1&'&(&'"  0!'  ,##( %0!++#(/#$  0#5+!&("& -#'5($#(" $#+&,#-!"#+=/!1#"0# ($&!(!$$-#''$##($!(" -#1&'&(&'":%(%#!+&(/"0!"0#&'

!%"3!++=+&1&(/&( !(!$!!($"0#-#,=<&'+#!$&(/"0# 3-"!,3""0# 5#-<!(#("!$$-#''$##($!(" -#1&'&(&'"("0&'%!'#:"0# '3,'"&"3"#$'#-1&%#4!'##%"#$,=4!=53,+&%!"&(  (%#:&"

%<#'3""0!""0#5+!&("& -#'5($#(" 4!'B(4&(/!,3""0# !%"3!+!($5#-<!(#("!$$-#''$##($!(" -#1&'&(&'"!($ &("#("&(!++=  !&+#$  "  3-(&'0  "0#  '!<#  "  "0#  +4#-  3-":  "0# '3,'"&"3"#  '#-1&%#  ,=  4!=    53,+&%!"&(  (  $##($!("   -#1&'&(&'"  !"  0&'  ($&!(  !$$-#''  &#  61&++!/#  80B0#4!+: #0'&+ 0&++!3-:&'"-&%"!+!($0!-6%!((",#%!++#$5-5#-'#-1&%#&("0# #=#'+!4 0#+#!-(#$%3('#+-"0#-#1&'&(&'"0!'&(-<#$"0&'

3-""0!""0#5+!&("& -#'5($#(" 0&<'#+&'!(:'#""+#$&(

!(!$!!($0#0!'!+'("/&1#(0&'%--#%"!$$-#''!'4#++( "0&'4!=:0#0!'%(%#!+#$0&'%--#%"!$$-#''!'4#++!'!$$-#'' 0&'  ,-"0#-  $##($!("     -#1&'&(&'"  !($  <&'+#$  "0#  3-"  " 5-%##$#A95!-"#!/!&('"0&< .&(%#"0#'!+#$##$&(!13- $##($!(" -#1&'&(&'"0!',##(%0!++#(/#$!($5+!&("&6'%+!&< "0!""0#;&++&'&(0&'!13-:$##($!(" -#1&'&(&'"%!(("

99 ##%"&1#+=%("#'"0&'%!'#4&"03"$&'95-1&(/"0#;&++!($5-1&(/ "0#'!+#$##$&(0&'!13- 0&'%!((+=,#$(#,=&+&(/"0# 5+#!$&(/'  !($  +#!$&(/  #1&$#(%#  (  '3%0  %&-%3<'"!(%#':  "0# &<53/(#$  -$#-  $!"#$  @
   ((#A3-#99 :  5!''#$  ,=  "0# +#!-(#$$$&"&(!+ &1&+3$/#:.#(&-&1&'&(:0&++!3-:&''#"!'&$# 0##A95!-"#5-%##$&(/'!/!&('""0#5-#'#("-#1&'&(&'"!-#!+''#" !'&$#0#5-#'#("-#1&'&(&'"&'5#-<&""#$"&+#4-&""#('"!"#<#(" !($"0#-#!"#-:+#!$#1&$#(%#&('355-"0&'%!'# 0#-#1&'&(&'!%%-$&(/+=!++4#$

7.   

**
 '>B'