Raj Bala v. State Of Haryana And Another
! !" "# !!! $ %$
!!!
!
" #$%& '()*+&!
!( *!**+ $ )$!)* + ,* *&* -(. $*' $! Ms. Aditi Girdhar, AAG, Haryana.
Mr. Gaurav Sethi, Advocate for respondent No. 2. //// !
!( *!**+,('
$ 01* 1($. ,
2'&, ($($ ((3 !!" "'
(451$ ((( 1+
&(,- $6
&$& ($
-241-7*$45''1 1(& 3 !$ ,& (+28$ !" ! 9 (( ""! !" " & :
- + 3;<=3>- # < ( + <;=> $2 * 1,5=2 (2 > -" 9$, $(1+ ?2 -241-* 4 ( 2
7$ ,15 (7*&''1 0&(12 (! "! $ * $ 0 1 1( 7$ 2'1 ,
+2 7 '1 ( '1 2 @ * 7* 11,
22
$'7**$2 $(&,*$$,. ,*$
2 A &4 ( '$'$ , *$ .( ( $&1 , $ ! 11,( * *$ 2 $ (&,*$ !! .2 7 4$ 3! ;!" <! +2 7 $ ( , *$ ,*4&$*(- 7*2 .2
" (($
(*$ B!
*(5&$$ !! ;! <!" " -.2 2' ( +2 11 $ ! 2'1 *( , 2 *$ 1($ (&,*$ $7 ! *$$- 7* .2 $&$ ( 1 ,7* & (+2- *1(*$(&,*$6(1 ,7**$!+2 2A( 2 A ( ( $
&2 , * 2- .2 42 &
& ! *$$- '1 C *& ( +2 22( $' &' *$ (&,*$ ( +2 $$(( *$ .(! %2 $,
' !+21(*$$2 1 -*$7 -*5 711 $&1 .( ( 1 *$ ( 611 *$ 2*$ ( 4$*$! D$ - 2'1 2 6 7 4& .( *$ (&,*$ 4 $&1( 7* '$
1. , 115! +* 16( .2 7* ( 1 (4& (&$$ !?** 11,
-'$ 7 $, $(! 3! 7 2'1( (*11 7 '$ (,
'1-7*$ -& 6' 1&2 !" *11 $'$ & ;3 ! *$, 7$ $2(
.2 7 $$(( ( *$$- ''1 7 1( 3 ! & ( +2 7* 7 6' 1&2 !"*11 $'$! :! ''1 1( 45 ' $ 7 (1 ( 45 '
2'&, ( $($ (( 3 !!" " 45 1$ ( (( 1 +
&(,- $6 &$ & ($
- 241! 1 , ,,$.( * $($-'$ $. 7 1(! #! D$ (&
1$'$ ,' $$,&(*''1 3 ! 7 (1 ( 45 1$ ( $1 &$ 7*&
3 '$'$ ''$ .2 $$(( ?" =
A&$ ;>! ! "8& ( +2 '115
2($,*$24,
, '$1 $4&(*$!+2 .2 $$(( (&$ , =
A&$ "8>- .2 $$(( & <: ! =
A&$ 38> $ 115 , $(7*& 5.1(0& !*$ * , *11 $'$ =
A&$:8> 7*5.$ .27 & (41 *$ 4
($& !"+2
! $$ * - ' $ *( 1( ''1 & =>=4>
! $ 6 , , E , +2 & ( ''1 7 1 (1 ( .( $($ (( ;! !" " =
A&$#>! $ 01*(1 1(
))!3<:< " " - 6 , ($ * , , , 5 7 , $ ('$'$2
$!+($2 1' 7 ( ( .($($((" ! !" "=
A&$<>!$$$( , .2 ?" =
A&$ ;>- , ''1 7 1( & ($ + 3 !7*** 4 (1 ( 12 5,$& ( *(&$ -& & (4
! &$*$4 $.(* *. ,,($2 7**$*& ( 7 $ ( '$15 $2 *2 ( *$(15 7 4 $.( * & 3"9 7 2( & ( * 4 - ''1 7 (1 (! $,&(*& !"+2 '115 2($2*.$54,
, '$1 $4&( *$ * 22
- *$$- * 7 $F&$( 4
($11 ,7*& ( '1-7* *$*& (!
: <!
! " 1( $'15 '$ ' ! D$ &
1$'$ ,+
(451$ (&
1$$ !"
15$,&(*(&$ , -$ & (4
!+*7 *. ,( '&7**$*& (- $ &1-
1. '$15! &''$* -6 71(,2 8
$ &'((*$ $(=
A&$ > ( 1$5411 * 2 +2$'1( $$(!'$$2* -*$ ) D6$ *($$((45?2 11-241((":! !" ""-7** 1 '1( $$(
A&$ "!*$7 .( *7 *$ !"+2,. 2 A .2- $ &1-
*42&
& !''1 1(45' $&
! 7 1 $0( 45 1$ ( $1 &$ .( $($ (( ;! !" " =
A&$ #>! 7 $ 2'1 41 * *$ 2$ * '$2 +2 & ( $1!
($ , $ ( &1 ' - $1 &$ * $,*15
($( ($&2 7*1( 2
,''1 & 3 ! ;! *.
($(*$,&2 (. (451$ (&
1 $ ' $ 711 1$ ( + &
1 ( 1$ ( &
1 $'$ ,$ !" (*.1 $&115'$& ((&2
A( 7* '$ ! D$ ( $1 &$ * (1 ( ''1 3 ! $.
+ 3 ! $&
($
# -.' /0 12 34 1 114 3 5 364 2' =>?*$- *&$ 5 F&$5 -$$1- - ''$ $2*.( * 5'$ 4 ,*& (* 22( 5 $7** &*'$ &1(4$(,*$ 7**& (-* &$25'$(,
&*'$ $* 7***''$ *.22(! =">?*$ &*'$ ( ,* &$-*254$$ ( $ (- *$&2 * 25$F&$-$* '&$' $ (! =3> 5'$ ( ,* &$-1*&,* & ($$$ $&'
- 25 4 ( ( 45 &* &$ $ * '&$' * F&$5 - $ $1 - * 7** * ''$ *. 22(! =:> ?*$ * &$ '$( ,
5 '$ & ($ &4 =>-* => * '$( , $ ' &* '$ *11 4 22 ($ *- (*7
$*$(G =4> &40*'$.
1& =>-* 25'$( &*'$ *( 4 & ('$ 7* * &$ 6, E * &' 7*** F&$5$$1 22 (!H $(1 ,7* '$ -, &1$$ 4 2( * 0&(,2 I41 +&'$2 &$ ( (
- 1(J7
48 8 9 6 )'/' !
'H-7*$ (0&(,2 -' *.4 $ (7**2& 4
($(7*1 .6 ,'7$& 3
!$!9 (0&(,2 $&
& ($ "
!" #
< $
!" #
% % $
&
$
$
$ $ H $$$(4.- ! 9((""! !" " & :
- + 3;<=3>- # < ( + <;=> $2 * 1,5 =2 (2 > - " 9 $, $( 1 + ?2 -241=
A&$8>* 4 $, $( 7$ 2'1 '$ ' $ 0 1 7* 2*$ * .2! &$ , &$ ( 45 '1- .2 7 $$(( 2(5=
A&$">!+(.27 &( *1
- ,4&:5$ !7 2 (*& (+28$ !" $ ( , *$ ,*4&$*(!*$$- .27 $$(( 4$ * ), $ & <: ! =
A&$ 38>! $& 1 * 7 1$15 ( * & (8 $ '115 2(*7 *7*6 .2 1 ,7* *$ ( '$.(( ( (&$ , 1& * 2! $
&2 ,(-.242&
& !11,(15*$*& ( '1 22( $' &' *$ ( .( 2 7 '$'$( 45 & !"+2!&$ , -& !"+27 & (4
6' 1&2 !"!
15& ( '1($1!$$2 ,*$, *- .27 , $$(( ?"=
A&$;> (.$ .2 $2 (
**( $$(* 4$'1 711 4$*), $7* *$ 7 $$((& <:
;
!
4 , $( * 11,( &$$ 6 '1 ;! <!" " ( 7* ' $- 7* 2*$ .22 6 7 4& .( 4 , $&1( $,$( ( - * F&$( $2 *$ (&,*$7* $2(*&$$ (2$7 $'$('1! *$$-*$ ,'2$* 32 * $, $ !
( '&(. 45'$ & *$,$( ( A&1-.(7 '$'$(7**7 $&1( (2*$.226 74&
2-7**$ &1( * ! '$*.$ .2- (.( '$'$(45& !"+2!*$ .1($ 7*'$ & 7*5*
.27 , $(F& $1 & ! " +2! + 6 45 & !"+2* 1. '$$ *. ,( '&7**$*& (- *$( 7** 4 41 *( (
($((&$ ,*&$ $1$,$( ,*11,(&$$ (( ;! <!" " ! * .$5 (&2 $1( &' 45 & ! " +2 *
*' $ ( 6 71(,2 8
$ &'( (*$ $( =
A&$ >- 1$5411 * 2+2(("! :!" "" ) D6$ *(=
A&$ "> 4
($((&$ ,$1!*$7
.1($ , $.$ ' $$2 $.2!
($ *.$ .2$,*$2*4,
,$4& '$1 +2$ !"-*$ 2$* & 2$1,
*$! .74.-2'&, ($($((3 !!" "'
(45 1$ ( (( 1 +
&(,- $6 &$& ($
- 241 & ( , 2 $( ,15 ( 45
9 ' , '$ $2 1 $. ! D$ ( $1 &$ ($(
($'$ *1,*'$.
& 3 ! ('$ '1 1((7 .$& 0&(,2 'A &$! 9!
$2 1$. $( ,15-( (! ! ( ,2 11 & ''1 = >- 5- (( ( $( ,15 711! ! !" "#
!
!( *!**+ ():;& ?**$ '6 ,8$ ( 8 ?**$$'$41 8