High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3868/2015dismissed

Union Of India And ORS. v. M/S Kanhiya Dhaliwal Developers And ORS.

2015-12-18Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'(#$#)*#+,

'%''-%!,".+/0.1#$+#"!+2,%'%&"+2##'$#'-%!,#3#4.%

".#+& #"%"%'#+& 5#+&/& 6&7!'.%2!.!4%3!4#8#49#+&,!".%'-! ".#+& #&9'-#'"&

!" #$%&'" '& ( !)#$*+"

:.#".#+ #9+"#+&4$!49!9#+&)!2*#!443#-"&##".#;/-0)#'"< *#+##++#-"".# #9+"#+&+'"< :.#".#+".#;/-0)#'"&./4-*#+#9+"#-%'".#%0#&"<

+#&#'"( +1.!.9/+%,-8$!"#+ +!)%"7/)!+,-8$!"#, +".#9#"%"%'#+& + !;!'!'&!4,-8$!"#, ++#&9'-#'"&" + %2/&.!'&!4,, /';!*, ++#&9'-#'"&="> ?????

'& ( !)# ,-

#"%"%'#+@-##'-!'"&@ '%''-%!!+#!00+%#8#-".#+-#+ -!"#- A ''#B/+# @ , 3.#+#*2 ".# !994%$!"%' %4#- *2 +#&9'-#'"@94!%'"% + -%&$8#+2 -$/)#'"& !'- %&&/!'$# -%+#$"%'"9+-/$#".#&!)#,.!&*##'!443#- +1.!.9/+%, -8$!"# + +!)%" 7/)!+, 4#!+'#- $/'&#4!99#!+%'0'*#.!4".#9#"%"%'#+@-##'-!'"&&/*)%"&".!"' +#!&',)/$.4#&&$0#'"+#!&'&.!&*##'!&&%0'#-!&".3!'-/'-#+ 3.!"$%+$/)&"!'$#&,".#-$/)#'"&!+##&&#'"%!4!'-'#$#&&!+2"*#9+8#- '+#$+-,9!+"%$/4!+42%'!&/%"+9#+)!'#'"%';/'$"%'#/+".#+&/*)%"&

".!"".#&"!0#".#&/%"3!&+$'&%-#+!"%'".#!994%$!"%'/'-#+ +-#+> /4# 8#'".#+#&9'-#'"@94!%'"%&.!-'"%4#- +#94%$!"%',*/"$.&#'")8#".#!994%$!"%'3.%$..!&*##'#++'#/&42 !443#- .# -#"!%4#- 3+%""#' &"!"#)#'" 3!& %4#- $'"!%'%'0 !44 ".# -$/)#'"&,3.%$.3#+##'$4&#-,".#+#+#,".#+#3!&''#$#&&%"2+ 94!$%'0'+#$+-".#-$/)#'"&,"./&,".#!994%$!"%'3!&9+#)!"/+#" ".#*#&",".#!994%$!"%'$/4-.!8#*##')8#-!"#+".#94#!-%'0&3#+# $)94#"#,%'#&&#'$#".#%&&/#&3#+#+!)#-'&/99+".%&$'"#'"%', +#4%#& /9' ".# ;/-0)#'"& +#'-#+#- %' .- / % 0 1,2 *, 3-,- # 324-,- 0 56,) 7- 0&6&-5- ', - 0%5 !50 - 0 56,1,28, 9

:5 55 +

;

8, ;*-%5 ;)

+ !;!' !'&!4 -8$!"# !'- + %2/&. !'&!4, ,

/';!*,!99#!+%'0'*#.!4".#+#&9'-#'"&&/*)%"&".!"'9+#;/-%$# 3/4-*#$!/&#-"".#9#"%"%'#+@-##'-!'"&%'$!&#".#-$/)#'"&!+# 9+-/$#-*#+#".#/+",!&%"3/4-.#49".#/+"%'!-;/-%$!"%'".# 4%&*#"3##'".#9!+"%#& .!8#.#!+-".#4#!+'#-$/'&#4+".#9!+"%#&!'-!99+!%&#- ".#9!9#+*C

+-/$"%'".#-$/)#'"&3/4-#'"!%4%'"&.+"%'0".# 4%"%0!"%'.#+#%&'-%&9/"#"".#+!"%-#$%-#'-%$/44#-/"%'".# !+#)#'"%'#- ;/-0)#'"& !& %" .!& *##' 4!%- -3' !"#+ "!C%'0 %'" $'&%-#+!"%'".#!$"&3#8#+,%'".#%'&"!'"$!&#,'0%'0".+/0.".# +#942 %4#- *2 ".# 9#"%"%'#+@-##'-!'"& " ".# !994%$!"%' &##C%'0 9+-/$"%'".#-$/)#'"&,".#+#%&'&9#$%%$-#'%!43%".+#0!+-"".# !8!%4!*%4%"2".#-$/)#'"&,)/$.4#&&%"&'!"/+#!'-+#!&'& +".#&!C#

*+#8%"2,9!+!0+!9.A".#+#942+#!-&"./&(@ D

" # " $

" "

' ( ' ('$!

$ %) $ * %

$ # ! % "" %

+%* !

% $ !

# ,"$

. / &! !

01+(-* 2 1& 1

&* 2 3 * ' (

&#& $

2 1&3 "3% 4$5$ " 6% & 73568

9 .&

! %

" # %

356 0%

& &!

! 6!

" "

!* !

"$&1 * ' . 99* 1

# &"

<+ &=$ ! "

-7$8

" ! (!

3 4 +>

%' = <0

&* !

7 0"3 /% ' * 0, %0 # /0 # 00 "1

! 1 '

! " # %&

"$& "0%

& % *

%"$ %

7 %

" ?

+> $

% %

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