Rajiv Tangri And Another v. Pooran Chand Uppal And Others




    
     

!"#$#%&'&()

!*&+!(,-&!($!(".#-  #"&"&(#-'

/#-'0' -&, -!(.!($ 11!2!($".#-'

 #'1($#("'

)  34  5
6 4
5


-#'#(")7 -"024!8.!(1!295#(&-$+%!"#9:&".  --*0(4!8.!(1!29$+%!"#9-1#"&"&(#-'!($ - 5 !.&94#,!2&$0('#29-1#"&"&(#-' -#;!("!''&!($-'.:!(&!&(9$+%!"#'9 --#'1($#("'!($ -5-!<.5.!-;!!($- !*!"!8-!9$+%!"#'9 --#'1($#("7&"&!(8   =.#".#-".# #1-"#-'2%!2(#:'1!1#-;!><#!22:#$" '##".#*0$,;#("?

 <#-##--#$"".# #1-"#--("  =.#".#-".#*0$,;#("'.02$<#-#1-"#$&(".#$&,#'"? 77 77 4
5

;10,(#$  &(  1-#'#("  -#+&'&(  &'  -$#-  $!"#$  @

((#A0-#7 9  1!''#$  <>  ".#  2#!-(#$  &+&2  0$,#  5#(&-  &+&'&( 9 0-0,-!;9+&$#:.&%.<*#%"&('&2#$<>'!($"".##A#%0"&( :#-#  $&';&''#$   2'  &;10,(#$  &'  ".#  -$#-  $!"#$  

((#A0-#7 7 9  1!''#$  <>  ".#  2#!-(#$  &+&2  0$,#  5#(&-  &+&'&( 9 0-0,-!;9  +&$#  :.&%.  1-1'#$  '!2#  $##$  !2(,:&".  $#;!($  $-!"   <!2!(%#'!2#%('&$#-!"&(!;0("&(," 7:!'!22:#$"<# $#1'&"#$&(".#0-"!($".#%!'#:!'!$*0-(#$" -&2&(,".# <*#%"&('"".#$-!"".#1-1'#$'!2#$##$
.!+#.#!-$".#2#!-(#$%0('#2'-".#1!-"&#'!($.!+#!2' %!-#022>,(#".-0,.".#&2#

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
":!'0-".

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

 '0&"    ".#  12!&("&'  .!'  <##(  $#%-##$  :&".  %'"' %%-$&(,2>9".#$##($!("'!($!-#.

77 1#--;".#&-1!-"%("-!%"<>#A#%0"&(,'!2#$##$&(!+0- ".#12!&("&'!'1#-"#-;'!,-##;#(""'#22A =@  :&".&(!1#-&$":;(".'-;".#$!"#1!''&(,".&' *0$,;#("
".#$##($!("'!($!&2"1#--;".#&- 1!-"%("-!%":&".&(1-#'%-&<#$"&;#9".#(12!&("&'%!(,#" ".#%("-!%"'1#%&&%!22>#(-%#$<>:!>!,#(%>%0-" #%-##'.##"<#1-#1!-#$!%%-$&(,2> -&!2%0-"3' -#%-$ !2(,:&".  !  %1>    ".&'  *0$,;#("  <#  '#("  <!%8  -".:&". ".-0,. -#'&$&(, &%#-9-%('&,(;#("!($".#!11#!2&2# <#%('&,(#$"".#-#%-$-;!"#-$0#%;12&!(%#3 $;&""#$2>9 #,02!-5#%($ 11#!2@@:!'

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

$&';&''#$<>".&'0-".#-$#-2#!-(#$$$&"&(!2&'"-&%"0$,#9 0-0,-!;9$!"#$ '.:'".!"-;".#'!&$$!"#$#%-##90-".#- "&;#":;(".':!',&+#(-$#1'&"".#<!2!(%#'!2#%('&$#-!"&(

7@7
"%;#'0"".!"(D D912!&("&'7$#%-##.2$#-'&2#$!(!112&%!"&( <#-#".#A#%0"&(, 0-"-1#-;&''&("$#1'&"".#<!2!(%#'!2# %('&$#-!"&("".#"0(# 70($#-".#!%%0(".#!$".# 0-" 
"!2'%;#'0"".!"-#12> ':!'<"!&(#$&(:.&%.".#> <*#%"#$"".#$#1'&"!;0("9-!&'&(,".#<*#%"&(".!"'&(%#".#!;0(" :!'("$#1'&"#$:&".&("&;#,-!("#$&(".#$#%-##9".#-#-#9#A#%0"&(&' (";!&("!&(!<2#!($&'2&!<2#"<#$&';&''#$"#-<"!&(&(,".#-#12>9 &;10,(#$-$#-$!"#$@ :!'1!''#$$;&""#$2>90($#-5#%"&( ".#%"9".#!;0("&'"<#$#1'&"#$:&".&("&;#!22:#$<>".#$#%-## -
  


    5#%"&(".#%"&'-#1-$0%#$!'0($#-)7 3

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

($#-5#%"&(@ 9B9".#0-".!'".#1:#-" #A"#($".#"&;#-$#1'&"<!2!(%#'!2#%('&$#-!"&(

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

7D7 .#  -$#-  $!"#$     ((#A0-#7 7  '.:'  ".!"  (  9".#$-!"'!2#$##$!2(,:&".<!2!(%#'!2#%('&$#-!"&(:!' $#1'&"#$&(".#0-" .#2#!-(#$%0('#2-<*#%"-'.!'+#.#;#("2>!-,0#$".!"&(
  

    9   

&+&2 @9".#1#A0-".#2$".!"<!2!(%#'!2#%('&$#-!"&(&'"<# $#1'&"#$:&".&("&;#,-!("#$".0,.".#0-".!'1:#-"#A"#($".# "&;# 
(".#'!&$%!'#9".#!;0(":!'("$#1'&"#$:&".&(":;(".' ,-!("#$<>".#0-" ('#C0#("2>9&":!'.#2$ ".!"".#12!&("&.!$ $#!02"#$  (  ".#  "&;#     $#1'&"  !'  :#22  !'   ;$#    1!>;#(" ('#C0#("2>9!11#!2&2#$<>12!&("&:!'$&';&''#$
!;".#+&#: ".!"&"$#1#($'01(!%"'#!%.%!'#
(".#1-#'#("%!'#9".#$#%-##:!' 1!''#$<>".#"-&!20-"9".#!11#!2:!'$&';&''#$&(:.&%.-#'."&;# ":;(".':!',-!("#$9 5:!'$&';&''#$(D!($".#-#!"#-9 ".#12!&("&'&2#$!(!112&%!"&("$#1'&"".#<!2!(%#'!2#%('&$#-!"&( :.&%.:!'<*#%"#$"<>'!($.#1#-!"&+#1!-"".#-$#-9 -#1-$0%#$!

<+#9,#'"'.:".!"".#"-&!20-"&(!%"$&-#%"#$".# $#%-##.$2#-'"12!%#(-#%-$".#$-!"'!2#$##$!2(,:&".<!2!(%# '!2#%('&$#-!"&(!;0("&(," 7!($$#1'&"".#'!;#&(".# 0-""&22".#(#A"$!"#.#!-&(,&# .#'!&$-$#-!;0("'" #A"#($&(,".#"&;#-$#1'&"".#<!2!(%#'!2#%('&$#-!"&(&(+&#: 1#%02&!-%&-%0;'"!(%#'".#%!'#.#"-&!20-".!$".#$&'%-#"&(" #A"#($".# "&;# 
!;".#+&#:".!""!8&(, &("%('&$#-!"&(".# %&-%0;'"!(%#'".!"".#1-1#-">:!'0($#-;-",!,#:&".".#&"&!(8!($ '7$##($!("':#-#-#C0&-#$",#"".#'!;#-#$##;#$<#-##A#%0"&(,".# '!2#$##$:.&%.".#>!&2#$"$'$#'1&"#$&';&''!2".#&-!11#!2!

-#,02!-'#%($!11#!29".#0-"0($&"1-1#-"#A"#($".#"&;#.# "&;#%02$!2'<##A"#($#$0($#-5#%"&(51#%&&% #2&#%"9BD9 !($0($#-5#%"&(@ 9B.#-#-#9
!;".#+&#:".!"&( ".#'#%&-%0;'"!(%#'9".#-#&'(,-0($"&("#-#-#&(&;10,(#$-$#-".# A#%0"&(,0-"9#A"#($&(,".#"&;#"$#1'&"<!2!(%#'!2#%('&$#-!"&( "&22  .&'0-".!'<##(&(-;#$".!"(:".#'!2#$##$.!' !2-#!$>  <##(  #A#%0"#$   .#-#  &'  (  -%#  &(  ".#  1-#'#("  -#+&'&( ('#C0#("2>9'!;#&'$&';&''#$

4
5
    '*8' =.#".#-'1#!8&(, -#!'(#$ ) #' =.#".#- #1-"!<2# ) #'