High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3911/2015allowed

Surjit Singh v. Dhanpati Devi And ORS

2016-01-29Mr. Justice Arun Monga16 pages

!"#"

$ % &&'

(% )* (& + ( ,*

! "

#

$ %& %%'%(

)))) % *

#" +

# , ( -+

, .

*

# +

, ( ,*

-

& .*/ -

#

/ .& %'(

0 0

1

20 #

!

4

"

$ &%(

# +"

#

+

#

4

+

+

0 +"

+

+# 6 76

# 8%9+ %:+ !

$ %:;< #

#

"

#

=6 76 ( + 8 + !

$ >%%& -

#

#+

"

%&9&48;1 5 %3

/

%.+

+"

#

#

%+ %<+

#

# #

"

%&&% ?

%:

;8 (;;. 1 5 4.3

%+ %<+

4 /

6 76

! #

-

(

$ (# "

6 7 6

5 %.=%(;

#

$ %

+

$ >%%& " "

@

/ .& %(0 0

#

# +

(;

;.

(;;:1 5 4<3

1

$ %

3 #

+ + "

#!

#

#

# ;+ %<+!

$ >%%& -

$ (

!" !

"

## #$%

& &!

& '(

&

"

)*%) + "+ !

%)

(

&* & & , "-

) . / 0+ $+ 123+

& !

& &

#$% 5

+

&

&! 3 !

*

)*%) -

)*%)

"&*

)%) ! && &

"

&

-

&

& !

) &! %$%

!%) "

' +

& &!

&

) &

3 & " 5

5 - * & &

& ! &

&

!

&

"

& &

")*%) &

& &

& ( & +

& &

& && &

"&

"

)*%) , &/ & && 16 " .7 6 " +.8(9+777+# ! !

&

&

"

6 & 89 6 & &/

-&+ !

&+ & +

& !

+

&

"

&&

! !!

5 !

&

,

& " "

&&

!

!

&

& +

" / & & &

)6 ".26 "8 9 ( !

& +

&

!

" !& &

&

" +

")*%)

!

#

(8 ;.

(;;:1 5

4:3

A(

"

& "

& !

&

& - " & : "

,

& &

+& !

"

!& &

&

&

5

(& !

& !& &

! &

& !

( !

#+

'

" & & ! "

" &

&

&& "!& #

! " & + !+

"

?

+#

"

4

+ "

" 5

$ >%%&

B+ "

!

=

-

+ $ 9:(;;:# ;% %% (;;8 -

+"

0+" 0$ (;;>(;;:

+

# # ;:

;> (;;:1 5 493 ? = 6 76

#

$ %

4

4 =

%:

;< (;;:1 5

4%.3

+"

#

#

"

#

"

"

"

$ >%%&

5 ;+ <++ %.=%(;.

-

+"

"+" # "

#

00$ <%><(;%;

0

+

%( ;% (;%%

4 (

! &

+

"

& "

;*

& &

!& &

& & ! & &

& &

!

, & ! !

&

" &

!

" !!& &

!

, !0 -

%9 %;

(;%% ? ?

%% %( (;%. 1 5 %&3

+

# %+ 9+ #

$ >%%&1(483

$ (;<8

$ ..&9 $ B!

#0 $ ?

+#

+ !

4 " !

$ %:;< !

#+

$

(;

;% (;%>1 5 4(;3 / .& %(0

"

$ %( B!

0 B!

+# (9 %% (;%> 1 5 4%83

" 0##

!

+

# $

#

0+ +

0+

#

C "

#

6D

0

!"#$%& '()D

0*

+

#$$$&,)-&-

).$

+

+ 4 +

!

=

!

4 $ +

!

!

"

- 0

# C +

+

4

$ & %(

?

+# + +"

%( ;% (;%%

#

+

#

"

4

"

+ #

# %+ %<+

+ $ >%%&

$ %:;< ?

+#

!

$ %:;<

!

4

+ !

0+

"+

# +

4 +

+

-

"

+

#

# +"

?

+#

# #

4 !

$ >%%& " + @

# +" 0 /

#$$$ &%) - &-

)

+

#+

# # #

+

#+ #+ +

+ # #

+

+"

0 +

" "

?

+# !

5 " + +

#

0

#

/

0 +" #

! "

+ $ %& %%'

%( +# +

0+ "

4 +

+

+" "

#+

!

= "

+

# 4

+

#+

?

0

+"

+

C "

# %+ %< + # %;; C " +

+"

-

4 #

%( ;% (;%%

4 +

C+

?

0

(;

;.

(;;:

+

# ;+ <+

!

"

+ "#

?

+# +

!

$ %:;<

+ #

#

E #

+

" = " +

4 # ! + 0 @

+!

#

#

+

-

#+

"

%&9&48; 1 5 4%3

$ %:;< !

$ >%%& # 8%9 + %:+ #

4 +

+

(+ 8+ @

#

44

#

#

"

E5 # +"

0##

1 5 4(3

+

#

9 # !

+

5 -

4

#

%:

;8 (;;< 1 5 4.3

+"

+

#

# A)! &

+

5

"

& +#+* &"

/ " &

6 <

0 -

# +

(;

;.

(;;:

(8 ;.

(;;:

#

4

+ # #!

#

-

+

#

=

4 4 +

#

4

+

#+

+"

-

+" 00$ <%><(;%;

4 +

+

+

"

4 -

!

#+

+

+ !

4

+

# 0

4 + + "

!

# 0 +"

"

-

#

$ %( B!

# # 1 5 %83

"0##

+

+" # " $ -

< !7

, &;

-&

" & 6+ ( (+.

25

6 7

25 +

.1= 3+ <& 6

: "

%$+

'+ 8*$9+ ")"' )+ 6

"+ <& + 3 !

*%+

!

257 +

."

4 + >

+<& +

6 ,

? 6 "+

4 %+6 "+

! "5 "

!

:

( " ! + " !

5 5 & " + "

&!+& "

"(

"

! 6 , <

&

& + ! ! @

"

0 " !&& "

!+

"!5 &

(

! 5 "! + 6 * .

.

25 < ;' 6 6 7

25 + /=.1=3+ A <&6

? '

167!+ <& , &;

/ " "

" 6+ : " !

& '6

+

! ! + .

25 + & + 6 7 25 +

"

3+ <&6

""'

& +

&+ 6 , 6 " ? 6 "+

4 %+ 6 "+ & "

6 ,6 " ( &

& + & @ "

& !

" + 1&

& ! "

/

!

6 * 1& 1 6 & +

1& 6 7!+

<

B 1 6 * ( 64= 1& 6 7!+ 0

# #

+

#

/ .& %(0

4 #

#

+

4

+

4 !

5 " +

@

#

0

5 "+ +"

+

@ +

+ +

# %& ;< (;%<.;

;< (;%<

+"

/ .& %(0 0

-

4

"

0 + $ .( (;%> A =

F

+" #

'

# % + %< +

+ $ >%%&

$ %:;<

@ #

4

"

" +

#

"

&&'

"

.

( ,* /