High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3901/2016dismissed

Kuljit Singh v. Gurmeet Singh

2017-02-21Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh8 pages

Pooja Sharma 2017.03.01 10:51

$% &$%''

(%)$$ !"

$'* +$

#%$'$ , -%(%."/%/ /''0+1./$

$% -%&/ 2"/1$"!/ 0+1./$

%"$%$'* +$ "$*%$'$ %$1 *$

"/'2$$

$+ +$%% $

"$ '

+ / %'$ !/'

+$%+$%'+/$+4

/ +

*/''$+25

6+!$6 % 07+"

/ /

8 48

$+/'9

!"&'(%)$$ !": ;%

50"$ /.' "$./'$/%$"/"$*$

$+/'

%*''$''

* <2

*"'$25=/5 '*$.

.*$% %)/ .$ "$ /!%$$)$ '$

+/$+ >

8/ +/ %+ %$.

!"$%$'* +$ !$$?$.$+/ +%$!

'$%$+"$'/ $+$$+ / + '*$%

$% / 1$' %%$.1$%5 /.'

' +/$+

4 4 =/'

$+ 25 "$ *$

$%0 ="

."0 "$ %$'* +$ =/'

*%.$$+$+$?*/%$1 +$%+$%+/$+ 4/'"$

$+/**$/%

"$%$/ $%"$' =/'+$.%$$+ /1%

$%1 +$ +!)$ / + +$.%$$ +/$+ 48

*/''$+ 25

6+!$ 6 % 0 7+"

/ // +$?$. /**

=/'/

$+$'* +$ )1$+/

+/$+

%'$ !/'

+$$?*/%$ +!)$ / ++$.%$$ +/$+ 48

0="

."=/'/

=$+25"$% %1 +$%+$%+/$+

4/ +"$./'$=/'

?$+

!=% $ '/$)$ @% '/$)$ "$.

' =/'

$+ 4

4 "$$1 +$ .$ "$ *$

$%=/'.

'$+

4/ +"$$1 +$ .$ "$%$'* +$ =/'

'$+

"$%$/ $%"$*$

$%)1$+/ /**

+/$+

%*$%) ''

')) #/=/% B//'

/)$ (%)$$ !"=/'=% !

5$ $%$+/'(%*%$$ !" /

=/'+ ''$+1 +$%+$%+/$+4

"$%$/ $%/ "$%

+/$+ 4

=/')1$+25"$*$

%*$%) ''

$/+/++

+$ .$25')) !#/=/% B/ %*%1 !"$ .%%$. $'' "$%

$ / +/**

=/'/ ' ''$+1 +$%+$%+/$+ 4

%+$%'+/$+4

/ + 4

/%$'2 $.)/$% ."/

$ !$ "$*%$'$ %$1 *$

7$/% $+. '$

$%. $ +'"/"$% % "/' /**%$.

/$+"$./'$ "$% !"*$%'*$.

1$/ +"/' $%*%$$+ "$ /= 1 1$+ "$./'$"$$1 +$ .$

$%=/'.

'$+

4"$*$

$%2%!" %$.%+"$.*5 "$5$/% , 25=/5 +$ .$0="

."=/' ''$+25"/%/

!"0#/=/% "$ /)$ (%*%$$ !" "$$1 +$ .$ "$ %$'* +$ =/'.

'$+

'*$%.*5 *%$*/%$+

0(%*%$$ !"=/'%$.%+$+/ + (%)$$ !" "$

%')) !#/=/% B/=/')1$+ +$ .$

2"$'/)$=/'+ ''$+ 5 "$!% +"/"$*$

$%"/'

%$/+5/1/

$+$ $

1$**%

$' $/+"

'$1 +$ .$ 7$/% $+ . '$ %"$%'2) '"/"$*$

$%=/ $+')) #/=/% B/ != "% !

%$.%+%$ !"$ %"$5$/% ,

"$. .$% $+1

/!$*%1$ %$.%+ ="'$ /)$"$

*$%/ '7$/% $+. '$ / ''2) '"/"$')) ! . .$% $+ B// != "/

% !

%$.%+*%1$"$ %"$ 5$/% , ' $.$''/%5/' "$%$1$ $$ %5"$ /)$ (%*%$$ !"=/'%$.%+$+ '$/+ (%)$$ !" '/ '"$/%!)$

$/% $+ . '$ "/ "$ '/ + $1 +$ .$ =/' *''$''

"$ *$

$%/ +'/)$. + 2$*%+.$+ '* /

!$ .$ "

*/%7$/% $+. '$

$%"/'/ '%$

$+* "$ +!)$ '

#$!%& 87/= A$%/ +

/ + !

(% &%) * & !+ ! >

> '**% '. $ ' 7$/% $+ . '$ % "$ %$'* +$ "/' **'$+ "$ '2) ''

')/+$25 $/% $+. '$

$%A$'2) '"/"$

)1$+25"$*$

$/+ !$1 +$ .$ =/'

''$+2"$%+$%=/' $1$%."/

$ !$+ "$*$

$%/+*$+ $1$%/.

.'25)1 !/ "$%/**

%/++

+$ .$"$ %$'* +$ =/'/ =/5'%$/+5/ +=

!$?$.$"$'/ $+$$+ /1%

$%/ +%$)/ $+*%$'$ 2$ %$"$2$!

'%/% "$+/$

?$+ $ > 4 /

+/1 "

$.=/'/ % '"$+25"

) 2$ %$"$2$!

'%/%=/'"$*$

$% 5=" $1$%%$/."$+ "$

.$ 2$!

'%/% %$?$. / +%$!

'%/ '/ $+$$+ 7$/% $+. '$ %"$%'2) '"/"$*$

$%="

8 '*$.

.*$% %)/ .$"/'./$!%

5/1$%%$+ */%/ "$*

"/"$%$'* +$ =/'= $% *''$''

"$' *%*$%57$/% $+ . '$ / ''2) '"/"$= $%'"

* "$%$'* +$ =/' $1$%

'*$ 2$ %$ "$ % % "$ $ +0 $/% $+ . '$ % "$ %$'* +$ '2) '"/. $ ' 2""$/**

'=$%$"$'/)$/ + 525."/ !

!"$"$/+ $/ +*%/5$%.

/'$0'2'$B$ /**

=/' )1$+ % /++

$1 +$ .$ "$ /**

' =$%$ % !"

''$+/ +/''.""$*%$'$ *$

/2 $2$+ ''$+ 7$/% $+. '$ %"$%$'* +$ "/'/ '%$

$+* "$ +!)$

A C2 $"$*$?% "$./'$ ,

!-$ #$).-) $/&

0& !$) # #$!%& 8

/ + "

% "$./'$' ,

% ,+0

%,+0

0 0

(% $#%

(% >

'1.!& +22*" #&3& (&$ # 4 +

#& # $02 "

%/'$'40 #&/

(% # $!%& *3 !

(% 8 0 + '% $% * # $!%&

0&'

#& ,+ , %

(% #$!%&

8>40!

(% &/

#& ,+

0 (

% # (

(% 8

0'*+

(% (!

&/ 5 $ 0! !,+ # $!%& >8 0 +!

(% + 0&&!

(% 8

0,+*3 !

(% -%

(% 8

/ + ! !2

(%5+

(% #$!%&

%/'$' >0

'**% '. $ ' A$/%+ "$ /%!)$ ' /+1/ .$+ 25 $/% $+ . '$ % "$

4 */% $' / + "/1$ / ' ! $ "%!" "$ )*! $+ %+$%' / + "$% +.)$ '/1/

/2 $

$ "$ /.'%$ !

! .

' / +)1 ! =

' $ /**

% ')) ! #/=/% A/ B/ / + *$%) ''

$/+ /++

$1 +$ .$ / + + ''/ "$%$ /%$ '*$+

5"$*$

$%)1$+/ /**

')) #/=/%

A/ B/ "$!% +"/$'

) 5 #/=/% B/ '$''$ .

"$) '/D$..%%$+ /%+ 0="$%$ 0 /)$ %$'* +$ =/'=% !

5)$ $+/'(%*%$$ !" '$/+ (%)$$ !""$

=/' **'$+ 25 "$ %$'* +$ "$ !% + "/ "$

=/' )/ /2 $/'"$*$

$%"/' / %$/+5/1/

$+ )2$% **%

$' $/+"

'$1 +$ .$/ +

$+$?/) $"$ B/ %$'/ +/**

=/'+ ''$+ 4

"$ !% +"/"$*$

$%"/+/ %$/+5/1/

$+$ $

1$**%

$/+"

'$1 +$ .$ "$%/**

=/')1$+25"$*$

*$%) ''

$/+/++

+$ .$25')) !#/=/% B/ *%1 !.%%$. $'' ' "$%

$=/')$ $+

"$/**

"/"$) '/D$"/'..%%$+ /%+ ="$%$

/)$ "$%$'* +$ =/'=% !

5$ $%$+/'(%*$$ !" '$/+

(%)$$ !""

'/**

=/'/ '. $'$+25"$%$'* +$ 25 =/5

!%$* 50="$%$ 0 =/')$ $+"/"$/**

=/' )/ /2 $/'"$/**

$+$/%

$%"/+/ %$/+52$$ + ''$+ +) $+ 50"$/**

%*$%) ''

$/+$1 +$ .$=/'

)1$+="$ "$' =/'

?$+

/%!)$ ' "$*$

$%"/+ %$/+5 $+ $1 +$ .$25*%+.

! ? #, "$ /)$

(%*$$ !"0="

." ' "$%

$ */%/4 "$* 0 =/'

'*$.

5'/$+25"$*$

$%,*

"/"$./)$D = %) B/= "%$!/%+"$$ %5 "$ /)$ (%*%$$ !" "$ %$1$ $%$.%+/ $%$?$. '/ $+$$+ ' /1%.

$/% 5'"='

"/"

' /.=/' "$D = $+!$

$%,*

/ +"$=/'

%$B %$+*%+.$"

'$ %$$1 +$ .$ "

'/'*$. '/

%)/ 1$ $1 +$ .$"$*$

$%,*

=/'1$%5+

!$ /2"

'./'$ %)"$ 2$!

!"$%$ ' %$B %$)$ *%+.$"$#/=/% B/*%1$ "$ $' /' "$ '/)$ /%$ )/ $+ 25 $1$ $ $*/%)$

5"$/**

%')) !#/=/% B/=/'

$1 +$ .$/ +"$'/)$=/'+ ''$+ 4

"$%$/ $%'$. +

%*%+.

! "$'/)$= $'' /++

+$ .$=/'

)1$+0="$%$/'0*%1 ' +$% %+$% > $ ,#"/1$2$$ ) $+25"$+$

#%.$+%$)$ +)$ =$

-%$1$%0 "$ %$'* +$ ,+$ $ +/ "/' / %$/+5 *%+.$+ .* $'

' 5$/%'0 ="$%$ 0 /)$ (%)$$ !" +

.%*%/$+ "$%$ ' $$+*%+.$#/=/% B//'= $''

/++

+$ .$/'"$ $' '$

/%$'

$ *%1$"$

/.'"$' "/'2$$

$+25"$*$

$%= "%$!/%+"$+ '*$

%$/+5/ +=

! $''!$"$'/ $+$$+%$!

'$%$+/ +"$%$ ' $$+ $?/) $/ 5= $''="$%$ "/'2$$ )$ $+ "$/**

25 "$*$

$% "/ '* +$+

!$ .$0"$=/' /=/%$/2"$ ."/ !$ /)$ "$%$1$ $%$.%+ "$/**

%/++

$1 +$ .$./ 2$/

=$+ ./'$"$$1 +$ .$. + 2$*%+.$+ '*

!$ .$/"$ )$ %$.%+ ! "$$'

) 5 ')$ $+ "$

25"$*$

$%,*

)'$

"/"$./)$D =/2

."/ !$ /)$ %$'* +$ ,+$ $ +/ "$%$1$ $%$.%+ %)"$ B// $%$?$. '/ $+$$+ ' /1%'"='"/"$ *$

$%,*

=/' =$

/=/%$ %$!/%+ ! "$ ."/ !$ /)$

%$'* +$ ,+$ $ +/ "$ %$1$ $ %$.%+ "$ = $%'"

* "$ %$'* +$ =/' $1$% + '*$ 2$ %$ "$ % % ./'$ "$ %$'* +$ =/' = $% "$*%*$%5 '*$0"$%$=/' ../'

$' %'*$.

.*$% %)/ .$/ +"$. +"/1$!$ "$<.% ) ./'$%$!

'$%$+/!/ '"$%$'* +$ $ "$% %)"$ . $ ' "$* % "$/**

0 =/'"$./'$

$% "/%$'* +$ =/' = $% "$' *%*$%5 =/'"$*'

1$ * $/+$+./'$

*/%/ "$* "/%$'* +$ =/'

= $% "$' *%*$%5"$%$=/' ''$ '*$2$=$$ "$ */% $'= "%$!/%+= $%'"

* "$%$'* +$ 1$%"$' *%*$%5

''$ $+*% * /="/$1 +$ .$./ 2$ $+ . %/+ .%5"$ * $/+$+./'$"$/++

+$ .$./ 52$*$%) $+

"$$1 +$ .$

'%$ $1/ '+$.

"$./'$ $%$/%

$%/**

%%$2/

$1 +$ .$ =/' + ''$+0 "$ *$

$% )1$+ / "$% /**

/++

+$ .$0="

." ') ''$ *%.$'' /= "$*$

$%, *

./ 2$ /

=$+ $/+ $ %$ $1 +$ .$ / %$'" % )/D$ '/$)$ /

/.'/'"$ '=/'* "$*

)'$

*%1$ "$'$ /.' -%$1$%0"$*$

$%=

"/1$

**% 5.%'', $?/) $"$= $''/ +"$%$B %$)$ /= '"/"$*/%5 +$%"$ !/%2 +$ .$./ 2$*$%) $+ $/+/++

+$ .$ &'

#& ,+ 6 &7 +2 8 "/'2$$ "$ +"/"$%$ '/+

$%$ .$ 2$=$$ "$%$2/ +$ .$/ +/++

+$ .$/ +"$*%.$+%$ "$%$ "$/++

+$ .$ '= "%$'*$."$ /.0="

."=/'

> = "

"$D = $+!$$/%

$%%="

.". + 2$D = "$/**

'* +$+

!$ .$0"=$1$%0% !"%$2/ '= "%$'*$./ ''$ ="

."=/'/ %$/+5= "

"$D = $+!$ "$*/%5/ +"$*/%5"/+ %$'$%1$+ '% !" "/%$!/%+"$*/%5./ 2$*$%) $+

$/+$1 +$ .$

*"$ /. /$ '$1 +$ .$+$ 1 $= =/'/D$ 25"

'% +0 !

(% 1+

(% #$!%&

%/'$'

#EA 1 $= /.'/ + /=*'

/'$?* $+/21$0"$%$ )$% "$. $ '%/ '$+25 $/% $+. '$

$%/ + "$*$

2$ !+$1 + / 5)$% '"$%$25+ ''$+

7 8 * @"$"$%'*$/D !<%$/' $+ F$'

@"$"$%%$*%/2 F$'