Bijay Shankar Halwasiya Etc. v. Bhiwani Sudhar & Vikas Samiti & ORS.




   
    

!"#$%&'()  *%&+(%!,%-%./%0&%%! '( -0 111

-0 -030 (/%!+3 (%-%! 2,%0+%4')(/%!%! '( -0111

!'0
 
   66666 -73 8&"#$--3!%!)+ !- 9 %'

/'( $-4'%!) 9 %'

-'( -0 $- +!7.%)%! $- %4 0(:34%-))%-&%!% $-$3, 0(:34%-2 -4%) 9 %'

-- !'0 )%! ; $-:%-%!&7+!7( %-) 9 %'

- !%%!, $-+% (!35'%) 9 %'

-- !'

$- %-

5+!7( !%) 9 %'

-- !' <
   

 (0- ''!!9,!7035 -90-&*3-0 '!'(0 3-'3!

--'

='( !0''3'!
! %(%08

!.

-00

,!7>3%0(!7-

9 (03'-

.%-%'!%0%.0-!*3!

'!.

8&- !'0 '/%0%../

'8 !0''3'

!9,!75-90!0+

'!0?%! ?

 -

    (%0  %.0  8

!  4537!

 !  '(0  - 90!  5 ''!  /( 8& %55.

%'!'( -0#%55.

%!'08 - ./ 3-'-0

,!7 %'!-

/%0- *

!'0 '(% !0''3'

%03'3!

'!?%!

?

!;

,!7%



.%-%'!%! !*3!

'!/'( -4 !'0'(%'%43.'0'-&83. !78&..

7%..&*!!7'(-

5.'0/%0 3!

'!8& ! %!'0 ';)5 -0( !)!'( !%4

%./%0&%$%..)%!0 % )(/%!%..

.&!'( 538.

5%-,.%!

!  9.%'!    '(  5-90!0    '(  %-&%!%  -8%!   .54 !'  

73.%'!    -8%! - %0  ')  ?=  %0  %.0  3!

-  '(  5-90!0   %-&%!%$3!

5%. ') ?=%! '083. !78& #.%/0@!' %'!0003

-4'4 ''4 
'0 '(%' !'( -!' %'!0 9 -!7'(

. %! 5.

&-%0!7 '!0(55!74%..0%0%.0-

0% '&  %!  5-'

'!  !-40    (%  !'  8

!  45.

 /'(  %!  '(

4!7 '!!'( !%'3- % 44 %.4%..0..

7%.%!

3!0% 
'/%0 '(%'.

3'

8& ! %!'*%&+(%!,%- %./%0&%)!/5 -)!%93- ! %!'0%! B(00!%!

/ C/%0'8 %!!


'/%0%.0 '(%'%!&0%.

3'

8&

! %!'0 ')!/5 -0)8&'( -%''-!

&!'( !%4 %!& '( -5 -0!%!  >3 !'.&- 70'

8& ! %!' 0!9.%'!

'( 5-90!0%-&%!% .54 !'%! 

73.%'!0 -8%!-  ') ?=)%-&%!%$3!

5%. ') ?=)'( %-&%!%5%-'4 !' /!

-0(5  ') ?%! '(

70'-%'! ') ?+4 '( -7-3! 0/ %.0 '%, .%4!7'(%''( ! %!'0! ..30!/'( % ('( -/(.

5.%&!7 -%3 )/ -%0!7 '!''( 5- *3

7 -%.538.

/(.

%'!7'( !'

0'538.

.%- %0%.00% '&'( 4%00 0 !0 -!7'( % '053'-'(!'( %55.

'!

 ?

%! '( %''

! !7 340'%!

0)'( %55.

%'!/%0%../ !

;

!!'

03'%0/ ..%0'( !*3!

'!%55.

%'!/%0 !  003  '  '( ! %!'0  !

.3 !7  !'

 '  ! %!'   ?    -%.  538.

 /%0  003  '(-37(  538.

%'!  !  %!,  (%0,%-  - 

;  ! %!'0 ';)5 -0( !)! 4!7',!/ '(0- -)/(.

4%,!7%55 %-%!

03')4% %!%55.

%'!0

,!7 %'!-

B!!

A3- #;C
'/%0 '(%''(

/

-'%!% '0/( ((% !' !7%7 %''

!'!'( 3-'%! (% '(0 % '08

)4537!

-!%55.

.

8&- !'0#5.%!'0) 3. !'(%9

!5%00

3-'
'0%9 '(%' %-.

-% 9.03'(% 8

!.

8&- !'

 %7%!0''( +'%'

%-&%!%%! '( -0!-

''( 0%4 038*

4%''

-%! '(%''( 03'/%0 0400 %0/'( -%/!! =




'0

3-'( -'(%' !!%5 ! !7.'7%'!)%!%55.

%'!/%049

8&'( !'

0'!7- !'03!

/( (%55.

%'!

/%0%.0 0400 ! <  %7%!0'/( ( 9.- 90!!'(03-'

/%0%.0 0400 != 


!0(-')'0 '(%'7-%!'5 -400!8&'( 3-'''(

!'0#5.%!'03!

'!0''3'

%03'%7%!0''(

-0# ! %!'00!'(!783'5-9 !7%(%! .

'%-4#'/0''(

-0/( %0'( !'0#5.%!'0!

-(%9 %!&  % '!!-(%9 %!&. 300'%! '.

03')%0'( & !' !8 .!7 ''( 9 !'&'( 5-5 -'&! 053'

< 3!0 .-'( !'0)!'( '( -(%! )(%03-7 '(%'

5%-%4 -0%../!7%55..

(%9  3.&8

45.

/'(%! '( 3-' -!7'( !'- 4%''

-(% %--9 %'%

.30!'(%'% -!0''3'!03'8&'( !'0!'

-40

 +

'!?%! ?

/%04% 3'
'0 '(%'%55.

%'!8&'(

-0# ! %!'0-- %'!5 -400!'!0''3'

03')!'

-%.%) 3!

9 <  )/%0-7('.& 0400 !

= 

= ''( '(- 0(. '0 .)'4%&8 !'

'(%'%55.

+

'!  ?

    0  '  8  % *3 %'

!!!7  -%'!  '  '(

-4 !'0  4%  ! '(  %55.

%'! 3!

- +

'! ?

/'(3' %!&

''( -5.

% !70-4%'

-%.-

! %!'0+!

5.

% !70'( !'0#5.%!'0%.!

!%! / 7!

!'8 - 7-%!'5 -400!3!

)'( 0!'(!7 /-!7!- -;


'0!

-% 400!% '0!-

-%'!4%'

-%.'( -'(%! !'%!

%55..

%'!-'(

53-50 % !70%0%.0  !'0'8 5-53!

!'0

3. !'(%9

./ 3-'  D,!7-4%!'( -%!7.

) !%55.

%'!-- %'! -

B!!

A3- #;C/%0!'.

7%..&030'%!%8.

90!

%7%!0''( 0% - -) 3-0 ) 3. 8 5- ? 9 !    '(  5.

%0  '%, !  8&  '(  5 -0  %-

!'.&)4 .&!%5 ! !7.'7%'!)'( !'0(% .

%!

%55.

-'( -45.

% 4 !'%05%-'

0%!

/%0 0400 ! <  %! /( (- -/%0%-4 8&'(0 3-'!

9.- ''!!= 

)50% '0!7-3! '- *

'5-4%# %

.%4'( !'0!0''3'!'( 03'3!

+4.%-.&)('( -'5 && '%!'( -.'7%'!/( (/%0.%'

/'( -%/!50% '0(3. !'8 %../ '% '%0% ''

!'/'('(

!'0'.

5- !'.'7%'!!'

-40+

'!?%! ?



 ''(00'%7 )-

4%&8 4% '+

/( ( 0%0079 !!'( !

A'5%7 "

 !"#$%&!$'(&%)'(&*+,)-.-&/ !#(%+'(

)%+$&/+,) 0!"#$%12 3$&+,)%(') (0!"#$%&!$'(&%)-+,)-.-&/ !# (%+  (

)%+$&/4  -  #$5)#6  +  (

)%+4  +,)  0!"#$%4  (  '!$+  -  ( *)%#(-(+$&(&*$&7!&%+$&- -'!%,+,)--)#$) ('8(6") (00-0-$(+)$&+,)%$-%!8'+(&%)' +,)%(')48(6")$&'+$+!+)*4 2(3"6+,)*9%(+):)&)-(#4- 2"3.$+,+,)#)(9) +,)
!-+4"6+.-8-)0)-'&'4)9)& +,!/,&'0)%$(#*(8(/),('"))&%(!')*+'!%,0)-'&'"6 -)('& '!%,0!"#$%&!$'(&%)-+,)-.-&/ !#(%+ 3+,$&/$&+,$'')%+$&',(##")*))8)*+#$8$+-+,)-.$') (

)%+(&6-$/,+ '!$+.,$%,8(6);$'+$&*)0)&*)&+#6 $+'

0-9$'$&'F

G( ! %''

!'!05% ''(05-90!)''-%!05- '(%'+

C 5-9 0% &!%4

5'-% '!!4%''

-0 538.

!30%!

-'( -/-!73.% '0 
'0'( %! !'

0' 538.

(0'8

3- 
'- 4%!0%% ''(%'!

-'( .'7%'!

%-.

-!0''3'

!'0!-.!7%55.

-

0%!&0380''3'

-'( -%'!0'8 7( %''(

'4 

0!!%55.

%'!-0

,!7.

3-'-8-!7!7% 03'3!



!0 -%'!/(.

 !7%55.

 %- %./%&0  !' %003 (%0'( 5.%!'0% 4!30.'30 %- 9%.3%'

-

 !7%55.




!'

!'0%0%.0 % '!%55.

0 !' 44 !03-%'

/'('( !'

!'0%!  % '!'( 4%!03')!

/( (03 (%55.

%'!0.

)'( !'( /3. !'8 %!& (%!



00%55.


!0(-') -%'!0 - 9%.3%'!74 -'0%55.

%- !'- .&  !''(%!'(0 (%- %9%.%8.

-

 !7%55.

 

'( -0(%9 .

7%..& 83. !7%0'( &

.%4  %'

-  8'%!!7  %..  !

00%-&  0'%'3'-&  5 -400!0  %!  (%9

< 7'4%'

.&  -%0  '(  83. !7)  '(  0  !'(!7  -  '( 4 '   %-)  83'

0344%-& 0400%.%55.

0!'.

7%..& -4008.

; $- 9 -)'0%4%''

-

% 3

5%-'

'(%'538.

!30%!

%! '( -/-!73.% '0%

'!7'( 538.

(%9

-!'H''(00'%7 ' %!!'8 0% '(%''( 83. !7(%08

-0%'

-8'%!!7!

00%-&0'%'3'-&5-90!0 -4'(

-!

%3'(-'

0


!9 /'( %89  0 300!)! !7!*3-0 '!%. --- !'( 4537!

-0-!9,!7-'

=!0''3'!
! %)'(0 ''!)8 !7/'(3'%!&4 -')0 0400
 

         I%73''J

G(

5-'

-0. %.5%5 -04%&8 %../ '0

*3 74 !'H 0 G( -'8 ''(

5-'

-0-!'H G( -'( *3 74 !'0(3. 8 5-'

7 0'H 0