High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/369/2014allowed

Payal Aggarwal v. Arun Kumar Goel

2015-01-23Mr. Justice J.C. Verma6 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* ")+",- .

"-"0 11",2"0 3

,1+$%4-* 5,' 6(5"-5")., %3&"#$2'#5 5,'")#(55",7". %3&"#$ ,#5$8$#'#')$, ( ,7'0""'). %3&"#$ ,#5$,$(8)%$)#

,"0*

(+'# ,($$6')1"%$&,$$ 8(($((')4-2"- (8$&'

'& 8$, ,7")&$ "1,$$7$)##($00%"#$%9

2'#5&)($:+$)#'"0,$0'$

8$,7")$)#');+)&#') '0$%4-#5$80"')#'

.8$#'#')$,5$,$').'(8$)%')1 "%;+%'&"#')4$ ,$#5$&'3'0&+,#"#<+,+6(5$#,"(')&$/9

=5$)#5$%$ $)%")#2"(0$"%')15'($3'%$)&$.")"880'&"#') 2"(73$%+)%$,,%$,>+0$ ,$"%2'#5$&#') / , "7$)%7$)# #5$2,'##$)(#"#$7$)##80$"%#5"#)&)('%$,"#')') "&# 5"%8"(($%5")%(")%('1)"#+,$( $)%")#5"%4$$)4#"')$%4-

"#5$, #5$80"')#'

25'(&0($0-,$0"#$%##5$%$ $)%")#.)#5$8,$#$@# 7")"1')1#5$0")%")%0"#$,)#5$80"')#'

')&00+(')2'#55$, "#5$, &)3$,#$%#5$40")68"8$,(('1)$%4-#5$%$ $)%")#.')#")"1,$$7$)## ($00 5$("'% "880'&"#') $)%")# $3$) #5+15 2"( (#,)10- &)#$(#$%4-#5$80"')#'

.8$#'#')$,5$,$').4+##5$("7$2"("002$%3'%$ ,%$,%"#$%

4-#5$02$,&+,#25'&5'(+)%$,&5"00$)1$')#5'( ,$3'(')8$#'#')

+)($0 , #5$ 8$#'#')$,A80"')#'

5"( +,1$% #5"# #5$ "7$)%7$)#(+15# ,"##5$ "1$)% #5$8,&$$%')1( #5$&"($)#)0- &5")1$($)#',$)"#+,$ #5$(+'#")%$3$)#5$("7$'()$'#5$,8$,7'(('40$ ),'(2",,")#$%"('#2+0%)#')")-2"-5$08#5$&+,#')"%;+%'&"#')1 #5$ 7"##$, $

$&#'3$0- ")% &78$#$)#0- "#5$,. (+&5 "7$)%7$)# 5"( &5")1$%#5$$)#',$#$),")%#$78$,"7$)# #5$(+'#")%5"(4,+15#') '((+$(25'&5",$#5$,2'($)#",'(')1+# ,$"0&)#,3$,(-4$#2$$)#5$ 8",#'$( +)($0 , #5$ %$ $)%")#. ,$(8)%$)# 5$,$'). 52$3$,5"( +,1$%#5"#)$'#5$,)"#+,$ #5$(+'#'(&5")1$%),")-8,$;+%'&$'(&"+($% ##5$8$#'#')$,A80"')#'

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

+,#5$,#5"##5$("7$'($3$)#5$,2'($2'#5+#")-&)('%$,"#') 5'(80$"(+15##4$')#,%+&$%(+4($:+$)#0-,+)(&780$#$0- &)#,",-##5$$",0'$,(#")% $)%")#25$,$')$@$&+#') "1,$$7$)##($002"("%7'##$%")%#5$,$2"()80$"#5"#'#2"(2'#5+# &)('%$,"#') 7+&5 0$(( #5"# #5$ ("7$ 2"( ,$(+0# ,"+% , 7'(,$8,$($)#"#') $,+("0 #5$'78+1)$%,%$,,$3$"0(#5"##5$02$, &+,#&780$#$0-3$,06$%#5$8,3'("88$)%$%#+0$ ? ,%$,>

.25'&5. ,,$"%-,$ $,$)&$.'(,$8,%+&$%"(4$02*A B

C ? #'("&)&$%$% "&##5"##5$(+'#2"( '0$%)/9

9D2,'##$) (#"#$7$)#2"( '0$%)

")%,$80'&"#')2"( '0$%)

((+$( 2$,$ ,"7$% )

")% #5$ 80"')#'

5"% &)&0+%$% 5$, $3'%$)&$)9/

=5$)#5$&"($2"(8$)%')1 ,$3'%$)&$ %$ $)%")#")%7")-88,#+)'#'$(5"%4$$)#"6$).#5$"880'&"#')+)%$, ,%$,>+0$ 2"(7"%$)

9 4($,3"#') #5$ &+,# ') #5$ '78+1)$% ,%$, #5"# #5$ 8,8($%"7$)%7$)#2+0%)#&5")1$)"#+,$ #5$&"($")%2+0%,"#5$, $@80"')#5$ "&#+"08('#')(+,,+)%')1#5$%&+7$)#.'$."1,$$7$)## ($00%"#$%

.'(&780$#$0-2,)1 =5$)#5$"7$)%7$)#"002$% &780$#$0-&5")1$(#5$#)$")%#$), #5$&"($ $)%")#.25$,$') $3$) %$)'"0 $@$&+#') #5$ "1,$$7$)# "( "0( 8"((')1

&)('%$,"#') 5"()24$$)80$"%$%.#5$4($,3"#')#5"# ) 8,$;+%'&$ 2+0%4$&"+($%##5$80"')#'

.'()#&,,$&#4($,3"#')( #5$#,'"0 &+,#7"%$')&)&0+%')18"," #5$'78+1)$%,%$,')#5$',,$0$3")# 8,#')",$,$8,%+&$%"(4$02*A

!!" #

% %

5'(4($,3"#') #5$#,'"0&+,#'()$'#5$,&,,$&#) "&#(), ')0"2")%,"#5$,8+#(#5$$)#',$7"##$,')&)#,3$,(-$)#',$0-')%'

$,$)# 7+0%#)0-#5$$)#',$(#")% $)%")#4-2"- "7$)%7$)# 25'&5'("002$%3'%$#5$'78+1)$%,%$,5"(&5")1$%#5$$)#',$#$@#+,$. 4+#$3$)#5$#$),")%#$78$,"7$)# #5$(+'#5"("0(1#"($"&5")1$

#2'#5(#")%')1#5$ "&##5"#"7$)%7$)# 2,'##$)(#"#$7$)# (#")%()%'

$,$)# #')1#5")"7$)%7$)# #5$80"')#"(#5$0"2

"7$)%7$)# 2,'##$)(#"#$7$)#'(0'4$,"0#5")0"2 "7$)%7$)# 80"')#.4+#25$)&0$",')#$)#') #5$8",#'$('(#%$0"-")%%'0"#$#5$ 7"##$,4-&5")1')1#5$$)#',$80$"%')1(8+# ,#54-#5$%$ $)%")#.(+&5 "7$)%7$)#&"))#4$("'%#4$1$)+')$7+&50$((7"#$,'"025'&57"-4$ ,$:+',$%4-#5$&+,# ,&780$#$")%$

$&#'3$"%;+%'&"#') #5$7"##$, ) "7'2"(3 "-"")%")%#5$,(.

E"2$,"0%

/.#5'( +,#')8"," #5$,$')5"(5$0%"(+)%$,*A

)+,7+65')153+,(5",")<"+,.

E .#5'( +,#&0$"0,-5$0%#5"#25$,$#5$%$ $)%")#4-"7$)%7$)# #5$2,'##$) (#"#$7$)#2")#(#&780$#$0-3$,5"+05'(80$"%')1(4-&5")1')10",1$ )+74$, "&#(.(+&5"7$)%7$)#&"))#4$"002$%"

#$,&77$)&$7$)# #5$#,'"0

#'("&)&$%$% "&##5"##5$#,'"05"("0,$"%-&77$)&$%")%

/ #5$80"')#'

5"("0,$"%-&)&0+%$%5$,$3'%$)&$25$,$"(#5$%$ $)%")#2"( #0$"%5'($3'%$)&$4+#"

#$,($$6')17")-88,#+)'#'$(#0$"%#5$("7$. 5"% '0$%#5$("'%"880'&"#') ,"7$)%7$)# #5$2,'##$)(#"#$7$)#

) ",45"#'E"03 "0'8")%")#5$,.

'3'0

?.'#2"(5$0%4-#5'(+,##5"#25$)"7$)%7$)#(+15# ,.($$6(# ')#,%+&$#5$ "&#(25'&52$,$"0,$"%-')#5$6)20$%1$ #5$8",#-")% "880'&"#')'(7"%$"#"4$0"#$%(#"1$.25$)#5$#,'"05"(&77$)&$%.(+&5 "7$)%7$)#'()##4$"002$%#5$("7$$

$&#'( )+87"+44$, 3# E#%3"#")%'"E'7'#$%. '3'0

$"0')12'#5#5$7"##$, "7$)%7$)# #5$80$"%')1(.#5$ )F40$ +8,$7$ +,# ') $3";$$#+ +'0%$,( $3$08$,( 3 ","-")"(2"7-)(.

'3'0 ?.%'(&+((')1#5$ $)#',$)10'(5"(2$00"()%'")0"22'#5,$(8$&## "&#,(#4$#"6$)')# &)('%$,"#')25'0$%$"0')12'#5"880'&"#')( ,"7$)%7$)#.')8","# ?

#5'(;+%17$)#.5$0%"(+)%$,*A

! !"

# $% &'

# (& ) ) ('(* (%+' $( ,

, '( '+'

#' -& & %.#&

% $'

/' % %( )'

% -& ' %- # %

'0'

# &'

% 1% +')+' 234 &'

&' +')+' (%.#&

( +,'

5' 1%

, %,'

) '11'

5' )0.)

% %1 &' ('6 &'

&' ,,

% 1% +')+'

( $% 1 )'

% + 1 )'6 274 &' +')+' (&%. ) % .(' (.& , '0.) '

% &'

( )' -& & % $' %+,'( ') )'8.

' !

+( %1 +%'!9 2:4 '1.( # +')+' -%. ) 1 ') % 0.(

% ') % +.

, '

%9 2;4 &'

&' , %,%(') +')+' %(

% ! %

1.)+' ! &#'( &' .

' ) & '

%1 &'

('6 ) 24 ( #''

. '* &' %.

(&%. ) )' '

+')+' ( 1 1 '(& (.

% &' +')') +( -%. )

$' $

') $!

% % &' ) ' %1 ,,

% < &'('

' (%+' %1 &'

+,%

1 % ( -& & +! $'

/',

+ ) -& ' )'

# -

& ,,

% 1 ') .)'

= . ' 3 &'('

' % !

5' ) %

'>&.(

5' ? &' )' ( % % ,,

% +)' .)'

= . ' 3 ( 5'

! ('

%.( 0.) '>'

(' ) &' ( ) '>'

(' (&%. ) '5'

$' .)'

/' (. +'

@ ' % .)' %.

) (.(( % $! %$('

-& ' )' ) # ,,

%( 1% +')+' ( &' %.

( +.( %

'1.(' $% 1 )'* '#

+ '* &%'( ) ''(( ! +')+' ( ) (&%. ) '5'

+ 1 )'* -%

& '(( )A% ) (&%'( +')+' (

00#5$($#$(#(1'3$)')#5$"43$;+%17$)# #5$)F40$ 8$@ +,#1"1"')(##5$%$ $)%")#(")%#5+( "'0#5$%$ $)%")#(

<$$8')1')3'$2#5$##"0'#- "&#(")%&',&+7(#")&$(.#5$ '78+1)$%,%$,)$'#5$,&")4$(+(#"')$%) "&#(),')0"2")%,"#5$,#5$ "880'&"#')73$%4-#5$%$ $)%")#0"&6(4)"A '%$")%0$1'#'7"&-")%#5+( 2"(&0$",0-")"4+($ 8,&$(( #5$&+,#")%(5+0%5"3$4$$),$;$&#$% 2'#5$@$780",-&(#(

? )3'$2 #5$"43$%'(&+((').#5$,$'(7$,'#')#5$8$#'#') )($:+$)#0-.25'0$"002')1#5$,$3'(')8$#'#')")%($##')1"('%$#5$ '78+1)$%,%$,.#5$"880'&"#') ,"7$)%7$)#')#5$2,'##$)(#"#$7$)#

'0$%4-#5$%$ $)%")#.'(%'(7'(($%

9 ')&$#5$7"##$,5"("0,$"%-1#%$0"-$%")%#5$(+'#'(

#5$#,'"0&+,#2+0%&780$#$#5$("7$2'#5')#5,$$7)#5(.$3$)4-#"6')1 %"-A#A%"-8,&$$%')1(.'

$0#)$&$((",-

( )

# * ( ) * ( # + *