← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1772/2003dismissed

Navjeet Singh v. State Of Pb.

2015-11-04Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain33 pages



     

 !

"#$%$&' ( ) 

   

  *****   +,- 



    

   

  

   !

 

 

 "   " #### $ ./"/ "%,#%012 34"%"/56470&"8%

 24""/ "%&"8% ! ./"/"/56470&"%/642"4$&"/ $7%"8%  

 $ %               &     

        " '( )* '))+  ,

              +)- .

   / $*0)1 2.

 /23   4 "      ,

                    

"  "          $)))5&               "  "   "

'

%   

      ''

)'

'))'

- 6( "

" &78

 /  

    ,& ! 

 !"

,

   "

   9     1: 3 :  

   :  

   

1  3,   :  

 282 ;

 ",   ,, 

<   

, ,",  2!  2  ,  !   

 !   

   ,     /"      8      "

= 

"

 " 

     7  

           7    =   & 

,  ,  , "  

   ! 

,    =   "  "   %"/  > .! "

   "    8

     "8

" 7 ! 

,   "8 "     " 78  

 "  "         "   ?@ /  =  ,

"A.?@ /5'

,             ,    =

'+ )'

'))+  .! "

      ?@ B + =  '( )'

'))'

  .

 

 =   

   :  >  "   

?@ !8      

, , "8 "   "  ! 

:"     ?@ ?8

  , 

            ,

 ,     

   ?@ ?5$ =   

           +)-  ./  ,     :   

 ,        

'- )'

'))'

& 

, )* )+ '))'

:  " ?@ A          ,      2!  2

,

,8    ""?@ :5' 

 = "   "      

   $-+/ / "

,  /

 % ,""  /      C   ./  '- )+ '))'

( %   ,                +)-  ./       &   :   

 ,                +)-,    +6 ./ ,

  "      "   .

              

@"

"  @,   -  @"

        +$+  / /

&  ,"    ,            "  , "     ! 

 :       ,    "       ,  

  =    ,

   ! 

"        282   "      

  , "  1! 

3 2 2,,

   :," ,  '&+ .

  "  2!  2 * .

    @"

B9& $B    

 =     :

 /  7" :D

, ,  "   @"

 

"  

  !  

       

       

,        B9&'               =  

                 /               +)-./ , ,   "      "  :,      :   

 , 4    $)

   ,        "               $$ .        

      /     

       !     

 "    "    "  @"

   $'

.

 

 "            '6 



A.     8

  ,,     7



    "       @      

  A.           $+ :       , 8  ! " : 

,  ,  :  > 7       $6 :                

,   "  &@"

   2: 2  ,   ""

      "         ,      &@"

 

             8 ,  , 

    $( :                          "   ,    =    "   

          

     @"

 

        "    ,     $0 :      ! 

      

9 

,  @   

 

"   7  

"    $0$/  /     ,  , ,

   :         ,

 ,  ,    " $- :      78

 @"  9&$B      ,

        "78

   ,  . ,   ,  8     ""

   "      $* :                         "      9&0  B



 B     %" /  >  "   , "8              

  /%& 

 ! 

       

",

  $E :            "   78

    ,  .

 

=  7 9&6.! "



     , "   .    8  , ,      

8  

') :        

     .! "

"   ,    2: 2  . ,    8     : 5   ,

           

8   :     .

 

=  "    "     

      , 8    " :    " " B9&$B    

   =       :  /   7"              .

&  ! 

"  ,  '&+                       8 "        

    ""   '$ >                              

 :            

  "           

  @

"  

  8 $+ 8    , "

       "

  ''

:                         

,2!  2 

    ,

,    +)- ./  %                 

$"0 $&7/&4&"/9% "" 6&52  :!;

  :$0$&;  !<)=  >%/  9%  ""    1&

(:;   :$0$&;   <  &4  $%/  $&7/  9%

"" 6&52<<!:;  :$0$&;?? '+ =            "    "

    " 9&+ ! 

  9&'  "   78  

  ,                 

 2!  2,  ! 

,     8  "

"    , 

       "8                        ! 

 

  :     &@"

   " 

 

      "   

" :       

         

8 - 6( " ''

)'

'))'

   "     B9&$  B      

  =    : /  7"   

    ,  , 

, 



             E ))  ",   8  :      

   " ,    .

 

=  

"         "   " '6 :      ! 

.

,   " ,   " ",    , 

   "         %       ! 

 ,    2!  2 ,            ,

   

   8 ! 

,

,   +)- ./ :           ,     8 ! 

   , "    /           

        

              /            ,    "          '( .          '0 %  8 - 6( "

''

)'

'))'

"  "  

 ! 

,8  :  > 9&'78

 &@"

              ,     /   : 

,       ,  8    8  

> 5

 /  : 

,  8      "/  : 

,  

, > . ,       ,            ,       /    : 

,     8

"> "  " " 

! 

     % "   "  "",             "      

"   ,

 " ,

      , 

 "

  "  ""  9&6.

! "

  

"  "   

   ,            %"  / 

>  '+ )'

'))' "    ?@ 7      ?@ 75$   ,         "8     "     $'

+)  "    '+ )'

'))'

%  " 9&'" 78

?@ /  ,         .

 

 =   =  ,

 ,  .

  "        ! 

,      

A. "@  .

6&> $&7/9% "" 6&52<??:

; 

:$0$&;)(!

,      "

     

    

 %   : 2  "  /              "

 ,

 ,   "               ,          @                     ,          "      ""       "      

  A.     

4           "     $

$&7/9% "" 6&52 (:(;  :$0$&;) :;&4 /&0670&4&"/9% ""%&"4 21  &%#"    $#=  0$  46  (  :;  

:$0$&;)?

 '- .  "    "  8



"    

 "  "   9&'78

    8 /   : 

,    "8 >        "

  "   

 "          ,     ,   , 

  8 ">            /    : 

,                     '*            

 ,  ! 

 78

,

    "       5:        

     ,    2!  2  9&+! 

                             

,   "  &@"

    ""      : 5    , 7

 ,     &@"



    ,    ,  

            

  :  7  ,    ?@ 9(5$   "" 

 ,  

 "           ,            %     "   

                     "  'E                   " 

,  

"  " 78

7   " 

  @"

   

 ,   

             "     )E )E '))'

       $+6       .

   ?        

",     4   ?

  " ,              

.  4        4      ,

"       @"

   

,       "  %

  ,  "75$"/$9% ""   $/  ):

;    :$0$&;  @    5  $&

$&7/9% "" A % <:(;  :$0$&;

!(  @"

   " 

 

     " 9&+! 

,   ,

               "      "    9&'

" 78

 ,     "   .   ,     ,   

",       , %   4        "                           "        

,  , ,        %  ,  "  3&A %9% ""1& (:(; 

:$0$&; +)

          9&'  "   78

    ! 

 

             "

 .    ,     ,          ,      ,  , 

  "       "  ,           "      ""  

 -/%/"9%/04 /$>/25&A % <:;

:$0$&;

(:

;=606709% "" <:!;

:$0$&;!

     

    "    9&'  "   78  

,   +$ .   "" 8 ,   ,  

   " ,  ,

 "

"  @

           %   @

           " "        &   ,   ,

            " 

       "         "      " ,   ,   ,    ", ,8    



  ,        "   4  +'

%   

  9&'

" 78

     9&$B C     , , 

   ,"             78

  "      ""  8 ,    ,    

      

    8             "   , 

"         .      "    ,  "    "   >       "    "9&'78

         ,       9&'  78  

               &@"

     "    ++ %          .

 

=       8             "      

 8  

''

)'

'))'

%      '+ )'

'))'

9&6 .! "

.

 

=   

    '+ )'

'))'

,  78

( )) "

 .

 

=       ''       "                

        

  "   "       ,      "          ,  

   8 ,  ,

, ,   7

  8   8    .

 

= ,

   .

 

                   %  @,          "   

       .    

                  



                  .

 

=      A    > ,    

    %  ,   "  /10/%/9% "".%"&7

!:;    :$0$&;    :

;    0  $&7/  B /556  9%  ""       :;   :$0$&;  ?) :

;

+6 %                     .! "

  "

  :      9&6 . ! "

    &

 @"

      ,



        : :              "   :   ,  ,  8

  :    "        , "

  :     .

 

=        ,    :    ",    "

+( %                           !   

 "     '&+                    

              " " 5   ,          " B9&' "  

  "    ,

    

  " B9&' "  

     :   ''

)'

'))'

,

 ! 

/""     - +) "   9     

""  "  

:8   ,

  8 ,   





  7 '&+   

"  =  4  

 " ! 

 '&+     

:    ""             "8



"   "

/   : 

, = ,

  "      ,8

. 

  

  ! 

 '&+ 

,  

B9&' "  

,



F "

     ,     " 

:    

 

     

,  ,     8    7 .   , ,    ,

  

! 

/""      "   :            ,

  

"    &@"

      "       , " " " .! "



 &@"

      "     B9&'  "    

 

           .

   "   B9&' "  

    

                ,    

  +0 9&6  .  ! "  

  "   &@"

    "  & 



     7  " 

 



   &  ""

                 8 ,     &    "

 "  , 

 "    C

8       B  B    "  

     ",

   7  B  B    

8         /

   ",  & , 

,                "     8  "  &   .

 

=  &       "      .

 

 =     

             8  ""

 ?

    "                    ! 



     . ,            

+- %       ,            B9&$  B    

 =     : /  7"

:D

, "   @"

    ,

   & $ 0"@ +"    "  * ("   "

,   A 

,   , @&  183 :     @&      ,       "       " B9&$B    

    > ?@ B$5$     $$ +) " ''

)'

'))'

    ,, 

,  .

"

     "

  , E )) +) " ''

)'

'))'

,   8

    - 6(   "

 .

   "     

      ,  

   &@      "    



       

.  

 ,               @  .        ,   ,    &@     

 

    

   

%  , 

" $>$"/A %9% ""

):(;  :$0$&;? = 0C"9% ""

"" 4%/ !:;$0%!?   60$ $&7/ 9% "" 6&52A& !:

; :$;!@< +* %      

                    

B9&' "  

, , "     ,  "

 !   

 .    ,  8  "

    "     

"       

 8       

  "    &   "  ""  8    "     8

     ! 

    .  , 8

  

 ,    "  /  

       "

    +$+/  /     ! 

"      282  " 

 , "  

2 2, ,

   :, "  '&+ .

 

" 2!   "  

  ! 

,  2!  2       "     !   

        &    5          

  "           !   

 ,     

     "               

   "      , ! 

"    78

,

  "   :,8  ",  2!  2  "

   

 

  " 

 %  ,   "     2$4  9%  ""     <:(;  

:$0$&;<?) +E .                           +)- ./    A"   "   9&0B

 

 

 "     !   

 ,  

 , 

 

 

 , ,   

  "

   

    ,, 

 @       8     ,  ,     :      / %   ,.

, 

 ",   " ",     ,    "     :      ,8   :    " , 7   

,  8           ,    :         ?@ ?

  

,

  6)   +)-./ & ;9         ,         ,     "    

  

,    "   ,   "  "       ",

" @         G  

           H "  "   I     "     "    "          JH9    

 

         H "  "  I "    

 ,   I< 6$ % : 2"/  ""-

 9%D%/$0A % <:;  :$0$&;<)@   ,  & ;%         

          

            

    "          

"

 

          "  "      "      "  

"         ,    

 ,   

"8         ,             

  "

                            "       ,

     ,          

.             "                   "    

 9  /  ,        , , 

      8 ,         "   "        

 

"  "

     " .     ,        ,  "

@   $) .              +)-      

 ,  " @   . 

                 

        "8    ,      

/

,          ,     ,       ,    " "   

 

        +)-.

   /

 4 "        ",  "

 < 6'

 "    7  0  &4  "/%  9%

""    1&  )  :;   :$0$&;  ?

: 2@/  ,  & $'

;A       

+)-  ./           1 3  

   "" " 1 3         

      "    ""    "   ,   9      "" "   ,     "         %                +)-  ./                      

            

          "        "

      

     



         "      "      "   %

       "

 "  8  ,

 ,    "   "     ,   ,         ,   < 6+ % " ,   ,   : 2@/   >%//&44C9%

""$/A % :(;  :$0$&;?@   ,#/0&  $&7/  9%  ""    1&  @:!;  

:$0$&;< ( .

 ,   ,  ,  : 2@/          +)-./            

       

   "       "

 

          " "   "  %         +)- ./ / ,         ,  ,     8 ,        " "      +)-./ 

         8 ,             "

         

 7  " "                 "        

  :   / %     ,  .

    , 

 ",   " ",     ,    "     

        ""     

  .          

"      ! 

    ,        ,  ,         , 

    " " 78  

      !   

  &  ,   ",   2!  2     ,            ,2!  2,   "    ! 

"

 ,

 ",  2!  2,, 

  

    "

2!  2,

 ! 

    

 8 ,    

.

" "   ,          ,    !   

          "    ""       "  %     

      

  +)-./ ""   



             &   

 

,2!  2  ! 

                   

   8  "

6& 59% &$&&4$ &4"/%  :!;  :$0$&; !



,

,  ,  8  8 8 

,

 : 2"/

 ,           +)'./     +)6&..

./ .

5A$02>9% ""-/%/"

 :!;  :$0$&;(!



,,   ,  8        : 2"/  / ,      

  

+)'./ " ,     9$5&4D60B9$51  :!;  :$0$&;() %  8

 ,      ,  ,   : 2@/ "       

,2!  2   ! 

       

        8 ,     ""             " "      +)-./

 6( %        4  

   .

$"0 $&7/ &4&"/+%:

6;

 , ,"  F2!  .      ,

 

, 

"    ,          %     ,    , @"

 

   .

>%/+%#%:

6;  ,        "       ,  "              "         ,   & 

""   " 9   

 ",  , ,, 

    ""     ,   $%/  $&7/+%  #%  :

6;       

  

  ,    , ,     

   7             .    

 "            / >    ,         

  

:     ,  

  "

 :  :  



  

      ,     ""8 "  .  

     "  6- .                  

             : 

           

                       "

       .  

,5  :     

 "      %     , "  ,                :,        

  "           +(-1$3/  /      6* %  8

 ,"    

     "   "             /      +)-./  " 

   " :,   ,     "   ,   

     "  "       6$ )))5&   "                  "  "        "

=   F 6) )))5&   ! 

"        +(-1$3  /  /  %   

  "          ,    / 9    "       

 "   "    "  C02(= ) :

 ;