Balbir Singh v. Balwinder Singh And ORS
!"# #$%& '()*(+,- *.'"(/"$01 3"3"$ ( 4 (5)5 *.6"$# (/"$01*$#31 (5 222 57$# $35
88888 (0) #'+%& (*9"#)55*$,#:!*3 (31 7 3"3"$ (
1"5!":".( :"5"$7 3"3"$"$:;"$05)7 (:"5(+76 (531"5 )(3)$# ((3"!. 31 $53"3)3"$$#"*,1*5' $7( (( #'+ 7.*"$3"*.'"(/"$01,7 3"3"$ (1 ( "$,!1*.. $0"$0(# (#*3 #
$$ <)( & 61 ( '+ 31 .6 ( !)(3 $ $$&# 75"3 !535 1*# #"59"55 #31 5)"3)$# (/ !3"$-&31 ":". (! #)( # ( 51(3,31 *5*.5(# (#*3 #= ##"3"$*."53("!3)#0 ,
*$!1;).* $$ <)( & 61 ( '+*77 *.*0*"$53(# (31 .6 (!)(3 6*5*.5#"59"55 # 3"5!.*"9 #31*3!535 5->&6*5"975 #$ ' !*)5 $$&"."$0!7" 57.*"$3*$#5)99$(95(5 (:"! # $#*$35?*$#,*$#!)$5 .(31 7.*"$3"6*5*5; #3# 75"331 5*9 '+79$31 5*9 #*+61"!131 !)$5 .(31 7.*"$3" !).#$3# 75"3#) 3*'5 $! !$3*!36"3131 7.*"$3"3"5)(31 (
)(0 #31*361 $31 7.*"$3",7 3"3"$ (1 ( "$,1*#$3 : $;$6$31 (# (# 75"3!535 5->&,1 !).#1*: 9*# !97."*$! 31 5*9 $"35 .'+79*56*5(# ( #'+31 .6 ()(33 "5)(0 #31*331 "97)0$ #(# (1*5' $9*# "$1*53 77 *.*0*"$5331"5(# (6*5*.5#"59"55 #$ = '+31 "(5377 ..*3 )(3 (# (31 .6 (!)(3)$# ( / !3"$-31 ($$&7*+9 $3!535( 5).35"$"$*..+# !"#"$0 31 5)"3*$#6).#$3' 3 (9 #*5"$3 ("9( :"5*'. (# (3"5*77 *.*'. 77 *.6*57( (( #61"!16*5*.5#"59"55 #$= '+31 "(53 77 ..*3 )(3/"$! *77 *."5*("013!( *3 #'+31 53*3)3 )$# (/ !3"$
*$#$ 0).*(/ !$#77 *."57(:"# #*0*"$535)!1 (# ("(5377 ..*3 )(3,$.+( :"5"$6).#' 9*"$3*"$*'.
3"5!.*"9 #'+31 7 3"3"$ (&( :"5"$"5331*331 .6 (!)(3 6*5"$*3 *("$01)((+*$#31 *77 ..*3 )(31*5$3!$5"# ( #31 9*3 ("*.*57 !35' ( #"59"55"$031 *77 *.3"5!.*"9 #31*331 7.*"$3" !).#$31*: ' $!$3*!3 #'+1"5.*6+ (3# 75"331 !535$31 5*9 #*+*$#31*33'+793"5)(0 #31*3#"59"55*.31 5)"3:"# "97)0$ # (# ( 31 3("*. !)(3 *$# *"(9*3"$ 31 ( '+ 31 "(53 77 ..*3 )(3*.. 0 #.+1*5!*)5 #0( *37( @)#"! 331 7.*"$3""$ *#@)#"!*3"$1"55)'53*$3": ("0135"$31 5)"3 - *("$01*5' $7(:"# # ? $3"! "5' "$0"55) #331 # $#*$353':"*3 # .*+*5 *.5; 7"$0"$:" 631 *!331*3$7( @)#"! "50"$03' !*)5 #331 # $#*$3'+$*3)( 31 (# (61"!1"50"$03' 7*55 #'+31"5)(3 A *($ #!)$5 .
(31 7 3"3"$ (5)'9"3531*3*0*"$53*$(# ( #"59"55*.31 5)"3$*!!)$3$$&7*+9 $3!535)$# (/ !3"$ -& ,*77 *.." 5*531 #"59"55*.31 5)"3)$# (/ !3"$-"5* B# !( C*5# "$ #"$31 # ":". (!
5)'9"55"$,1 1*5#(*6$31 *33 $3"$31"5)(33
!"
#$ = 97)0$ #(# (31 .6 ()(3!. *(.+( : *.531*331 )(36*5"$*3 *("$01)((+*$#1*#!*.. #)7$31 7.*"$3"3# 75"331 !535 "975 # 31 5*9 #*+ $ "35 . '+ 79 1 7.*"$3"&7 3"3"$ ("5*( 5"# $3:"..*0 *(6*.*,61 ( *531 !)(35*( .!*3 #*3 *$!1;).*1 !)$5 .!).#$3!$3*!331 7.*"$3"*$#31)5 !).#$3# 75"331 !535$31 5*9 #*+3"5*.. 0 #31*361 $*77 *. 6*57( (( #,31 !5351*#*.( *#+' $# 75"3 # D 1 *77 *.6*57( (( #6"31 <7 #"3")5#"57*3!1$!9"$0 3;$631 "97)0$ #(# (7*55 #'+31 3("*.)(3$1 "(53 77 ..*3 )(3 1*5 $ "31 ( 0": $ # "$"3 "$#"$0 ( 0*(#"$0 9*"$3*"$*'"."3+31 *77 *.$(6"31( 0*(#3!$#$*3"$# .*+31*5 ' $)(0 #31*331 *77 *.
6*57( (( #E)"!;.+*3 (!9"$03;$6 #"59"55*.31 5)"3 7*(3+51).#$35) (' !*)5 *).31"5!)$5 . !)$5 .(31 7.*"$3"#"#$3"$(931 7.*"$3"*')3#"59"55*.31 5)"3,5)!1!99)$"!*3"$0*7' 36 $1"5!)$5 .*$#31 7.*"$3"51).# $3' 3*; $31"57( @)#"! F1 $!535 5->&1*#*.( *#+' $ # 75"3 #' ( "."$031 "(53*77 *.$( ! "73;$6. #0 '+31 7.*"$3"*$#31 ( "5*'5.)3 .+$ <7.*$*3"$ 9 (0"$0(931 "97)0$ # (# (*5361*36*531 3 *("$01)((+(# 75"3!535$31 #*+ "975"3"$" $"35 .3$.+31"5,31 7.*"$3"6*5!*.. # )7$3# 75"331 !535'+791)01"3"5$3!. *(*53*361*3 3"9 31 (# (6*57*55 #,31 7.*"$3"' "$0*( 5"# $3*7.*! 5"3)*3 # *(*6*+(931 !)(35*3 *$!1;).
*, : $*3 ("$3"9*3"$,!).#$31*: 755"'.+!9 7( 5 $3+*..9 *$5,(# (#*3 #"$#"59"55"$0 31 5)"3"5*$(# (9*# "$3 *("$01)((+6"31)3 <7.*"$"$0*$+( *5$5( 31 5*9 *$#"5*: (+1*(51(# (7( @)#"!"$031 ("013531 7.
( : (31 !"(!)953*$! 5"$31"5!*5 6 ( ' +$#31 !$3(.31 7.*"$3" /"9".*(.+, "97)0$ # (# ( = 7*55 # '+ 31 "(53 77 ..*3 )(3*.55) (5(931 5*9 "$"(9"3+*$#".. 0*."3+ G 7"$0 "$ :" 6 31 *!35 *$# !"(!)953*$! 5 *5 #"5!)55 # *': ,*!! 73"$031 ( :"5"$7 3"3"$*$#5 33"$0*5"# 31 "97)0$ #(# (5, 31 5)"3"5( 53( #3"35("0"$*.$)9' (1 7*(3" 56).#*77 *(' ( 31 !)(3' .6$?- 51*5*.( *#+' $9 $3"$ #*': ,!5351*: *.( *#+' $ # 75"3 #'+31 7 3"3"$ (&7.*"$3",31 5)"36).#7(! #)(31 (
F1 31 ( 7(3 (5.!*.7*7 (59*+' *..6 #35 31 @)#09 $3H F1 31 (3' ( (( #331 7(3 (5($3H F1 31 (31 @)#09 $351).#' ( 7(3 #"$31 "0 53H