← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2277/2003dismissed

Amar Singh v. State Ofpb.

2015-11-05Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain18 pages



         

 !"!

#$%&''&'% ()!#*+     

 ,#-.

  /$ 01/ &                  

       

            !  

"  # $%&'  ( )      $$ & *(

+(" ,,,,  2&

        

 )  -.- --(

  / (&   (* ()   1 &       )       & 2 * ! "

  &   (.3241 1    5 56    7      ) ( )                      



  

     (--(---81

              (           



   

  

 ( ..9(&:&   $ ( :)  ;    (     

                )  %     *< 4   6   #--"$(      <     

 )  %     )   < 

  ) ( 

     

<  

  

 <  )  1

 <      

       1         

   )=

    <      

  :)  ;       

      >          <     )        * ?

-8.      %  & 

  =@  & (  

    )   + (  ' <  4; 6  1      

      

   %  &   '(     % ( $ A

0 (

  ) $        

    

=       1   )      <     :)  ;   @                 

        :)  ; )    BC"*;< ( 

     < )        )  

 

         ( )(               <

  )       

  

 -  



   & = & !&"(7      :  

 !&"( :)  ;        

        < 2-   <

       ( 



?-<   92-      

            

5&$5 5=&5  :)  ;   !&"(  )    <  

)  ) BC" 

  :)  ;     ) =0& !

  !&"<    ! )     %  &   <  

)  )

BC"B   77BC"+       ; 

 (     >:

 BC"=          :)    ;     BC"A    ) 1   )  BC"' ;      ( :)  ; 



     $  = 0 & & 

      0 BC  C   )   BC"$(      

 ?1 1  %    & (     )      <          

              )  (          &   9    0

    0   "  (.9 41 1  50"056        

 1  1        & 2   )   3-...3    0  (             D1 :       (

C  

  ) 

C   & 0"0(           =   

<"2 ?..9  ) "< =

<        )    (    



   :     ) (   1  C  A  !(      ! % &  ! .1    )      

      (  1      )       & 2                  

    -1  )        )  

   (     1 :  )    $ %&  '  (  )  (      ( $$ & *( 

  )    +       &      "    )      C        :    (             

    

        $ A 

         

  C  1 =              :)  ;        

  )    < :)  ;    )           < 7

"2&:&  $ & ( :)  ;         

1C           <(   <      <     <  (       )       <    <     <& (  

      



  

         :      )     (   

 7          

   )   

  

  <     )         

  

     (      

 



  !"#     

         



   $ 

 $    %



 & ?1 =       <)     



"?&:0& (  

 )     0&>A        

      )      =      

 &  ; 

  * 0   %( 

 7      >&A  9   %      (  )  )  ..9      )  >&A 9 ..9& (     D         >&A(    

          21 =       :)  ; 

    )

& 22          

   &=;("

 &  %(   



  D1 =          

  

               

   

   0   91 =          

    :   <        ?..9       0:& (* 

..9                   B)  + "  

 

 BC!       

       !A & + "  ! % & (  &+" "<   (     )           0   31 ;   ( &          

     "!&"= & ("?&:

0&   ) 

"2&:&  $ (  :)    ; (         -          ? <     < )   

        %  & (             =       )                   (

           0 BC        

 =         )

& 22   

 =        

        

      

 )    )) 

  

 .1 :) 

    

-1    (    $   A         

 )                    

       

    " "

 --3...( $ A     

(  C    (

)                

      1 

 $ A   

 C   C  & (  

 )          

$ )(                       

  )  )    

 

$       





 )       

                

      

          :         

          ( 0          

    ) (   '  ( )* "



 +



1 :

                 )  

   

         "?&:0& (  

 ) "2&:

&  $ ( :)  ;    (  *<         %    ) %    -#-"$( <    

 )  %  :)  ;    

     <

 (  )    

             )5  

      & ( &  

)    <      

                         <(   



             )    %  &    )   <  )    <   BC"!      

      (       

    < 7

        )   < 7

    )    >     "?&:0&  "2&:&   $         1   )    < 7

    %  & 

    ;<  7  :)   ;        <   

 (           <   < :)  ;   )     

       @      

  

     :)  ; )  BC"=       <       

   <  <       ( :)  ; )   "= &  !&"     )     @

     ?<     <:    & 0"0(    <     <  ) "<  ?..9"2 &:&  $ = <       -9           *    )   & (                                  <    )   (          (       

 ) (   C  !A    )     



? ..9

+" ) "< BC! !% &   & +" "<  )    

  < &  

) =  

 ? ..9(    +   (  " &             

$ A"(!

"(+ & "  "

   



            

             "  $   :    

C  (      

  

   ! 0 

      = )(      &&"=     .    

   <(   

    

*  -  $ )(     )            

..9  

 BC! 

? ...9            

    -9      

  (

  

:    )

( 

      ) )

 

        0              %     <      & (                

 BC!

           

1)           



    )  &

           ! 0 

         & (                     )

5         0 7 (    )   

      

             

-    ?<  

 <

     (       <  

  :)  ; (

               ) ;   %  &      <=  %  &   )   < B)



 )    )    < 7

        )     < E  F 

             

       



(           <& (            

 

?1 $ )(           

  (          

      

    <  = 5&0    ,

( -  ) .

 "&





# 

  #1 E;

   

      

  

   (  

 

    <  & 2   )        

    )  &    

   & 2?

  )    

     F

: /  0

 #&



 &( = 5C0   

  #1 34& ,,,,,,,  :      C    &   3        

    (         

        

 <  & 2?       

     : 

   # G2?"   

     1:       (   (

 

     ) (      

        1 46            

 H 46   (       

    )  46         

 

       

           H 6    )   



                   

       ( 

                      

          (     

            

  G >        )              

 

    

)             

  "

    & 2    )        :

 <     

(  (  

    C        ) (          )            

      

       ;  

 

  0             )     F

D1

= 5C0          

   1 

   )* ""



 +% 

  #1 E'5&>         )

& 2 2?   (         

         (        )       )  )

 

       )   & 2   (           C               

                   )

 

 ( )    )(     

   

      (  

        <    

F

 ( )       

  (      

 

          

<      & 2     

     C   0      C        

  &    

     )

& 2?   (

     

 

  



(                         &    C  

      & 2 2?    7 (                  

 

.1

   )              

..9      >&A(     )      9 ..9& (    D   

       : , 



  2&



 2(   -   

     >&A ! )

%   0                  )      @   <     

 = IC 0  

     3    '   &



 +%  



               

)        <    

:   



 1

)* +&



 !"(   3          >&A   ! )

%   0       

     

             >&A :     

( 

                 (  )              <    

   >&A     

   "2  :    &    $ (    :)   ;    (        

  $=0& &    

C    $=0 & &  "1(      ) BC"0 

            $<" 0  '  & (                 0  BC (          )  BC"%           

       BC"$      



 0   BC (     

           

             

 -1

! )

%   0    4  

546   )* "



 !



  #1 E2-

    

     

                     7       (    * 83.

-D.3.

  + )  : =

   /   &  )&   "H -46

40  6 29H

  0     * 83.

6  (    

 "     :  (        

     <*              (

        @   >  & A     (

(   )    F     (     

         C   9  

  1

 (   ) (                   

      & (   D      

       

 

   )

    &   22          

  = 5&0      3  # .  .        1  &

 

  !! 

    

    )

 & 2 (22 29

        & (         :)  ; 

)     )

& 22   

 )    )  

 )       ..9

         :)    ;        -9- --!        (    



   0  & (     

   0      )   ):     <        

       $<    

      <    

 )  

  $ )(         )) ( 

  )) 

  

 ( )         )   ()  1 

                          

   (         )   

   0   



   

)

 ?1

        "?&:0 &  "2&:&  $      0&>A 

             (     )                       

               A           

      

  

         

   

   

 (        (     

      

 



         

     ? <     <   (  )    

     0        

       7 (      





   1    =     =      2        

     0 /  $  (* (

               :(    (  0 /  $  (* (

 <  )         

           $%&''&'% 6 7