Sudhir Mohan v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"#"
$%&&'
(% )*( & +, +& ----- !"#"$%
&'""
( ()"* (+%
&'" ,(
"(*$&%
$ -"#"" ..... , +& .&/ 012 /("$$0 ( ( 1211 3(4# (
("& ' '&# "0" (
" ((,,'"$ ," *5,
6%72%89: " ,(
"54 3(16 "# %;*"$ <" /* $"
"04("$,,( '
("( 3"
"
"
*4& "$ ,,'111= "'("#" "! "5 (*0( 0*$" $' '
3"
"$$# " >$'+ >"
(""% ' >(3" " &*"$$# ( #"1=%( 0" , >$'+$$"4"
% ' " ( #" 19% ( ( /(, "*' &$ 5 3+ 3(
/ "'
(>$'+$$"4"
* ("#""-"5
-2- +"
!" '(5 ( -"5 "'("#"
" $* 1=119 , ?'* , &"* &$ 5 3+ @"$ 19 3+ A '$* 0 ' *' , ( "++" ( &$$"0 ) (* *" "
,, $'" "50 ( &$ 5 3+ ( &$$"0 (
"5"?"' "
*
!"
# 7 <" /* $'
(""
( *'
* 4# (
"$/(,'"#( "5,"'("#" "! 161216%(00 "5 ;* "( 5" " *( " " B"" ;*"$#?'*,(3+ ,*( *45 (" ( "$ 3+ 5" 3"
$"+( (
"'0"*(#,( 3+ 3"
(?'*&0@ A
,' "$ 5"
/$"* 7 " = , ( 0* $ "4* ?'* , ( 3+
* 4# (
"$ /(, '"# ( "5 , &$ 5 " "'("#"% "#"" ( "5 " ?"' "
* $$% & ''
''(
) * " " " '
+,--.&
-3-
/ 01 +
'' '
1
( 1 +
23 4
)5 ''
,6
'
+ 3
'
"
7 $8
'
,999: +
''( "(
;2( 45+ ( ,999 : <699 :
* ( * " 45+ ( <699 :
6999 :
'
"* " 45
(6999 :
* " 457 = *45 ("",( $*("
4
4#( -"5"'("#",' *', ""4&$'" %"3 (
* " '$"50 (" ( & 3( ( -"5 "'("#" ( ' 0 3 (* " "0" ( , ("&0'"* $
("?'(;*" ('&# ("
4
<" /* $ , ( " ( ,$$30 "0*5 A (" "
( ' $ 0* $
* 4# ( " -&5& 55 161216%($"
4$#,( *4& "$ ,,'%"'("#" "!("
4', $# "0 ( 5" , 0"0 '('"$ "
&"$ ( ? , (
-4- ,"'"$ '5 ' ( "
" 554 , ( "'("#" "! 00C0 $#;* *( " " B"" ;*"$# "", *'( 5"'
("( "$$0", "# *4 " " 5""$("&04* (?'*,(3+ ("(3"
"54BB$5 ( 3"
& 0" "#
*# , ("0 4,(",( ' 0 " ( '*
"4* ( *'
* 4#(
-&5 ,0(,*' 4 ,5 4#(*4& "$ ,,' ,*( *45 (" ( "
' , $ & ( $" 3"
;* 4 &, 4# ( -"5 "'("#" $, ,5 ( &*
,,'"$ " ("( '*$ 4($ $"4$,"#$"
4#( -"5"'("#" *45 ("(
',' $"4#( (
,,'("
4,* 4#(
4#5"+0"#,' (( *' 0* $
* "
3('((00 C03"
;* &,#($,($" 3('( &$ 53+ 3"
(*0( ( $*
4# ( -"5 "'("#" ,*( '
(" *4 ;*$#% ( &$$"0 ("& "$"
#
" $*& 0( $" (-"5"'("#" $, 2 (* "0* ("' 0("4&"0*5 ,5"#
'&%( '"4($ $"4$ "#,'&#,"# "$$0 $
" *'($
%,"#%'"$#4'& ,5(554 ,(-"5"'("#"%3(
( $*" , ( , ?'*,( &$ 53+
-56 /* $,(
"$ (",, "&,$ 4# (>$'+&$ 5D"'("#" ,,'%$$"4"
" '
(" ( ("
4' *' (&$$"0) (* *",5(,*
, / "*'5 ( ( " ( &" ("&0 3 ( ( "5 , &" 3 4# -"5 "'("#") (* *""
&*' '5 $" 1919 3"
5& 4# *+(3 0( , " (" 0( 3(* " ;*#3"
0' *' 4#( *#/55
% "(*0(( *4 & "$ ,,' @/&$A% $$"4"
;*# 1113"
*45 3(3"
"4$ ( ("( 3"
&" # ;*# 3"
"$ 0 ' *' 4# ( >$'+ &$ 5" "'("#" ,,'%$$"4"
3( *45 ( ( *# /55
% " & $ =6 =121 3(( "50 ( -"5"'(&" ,5" "'( ,$$"0) (* *"3,* 0*$# 3"
(* ''$* ("$
3"
'"* ( -"5 "'("#" ( * ,
6%72%89: " (
$;* ,,'"$ ("
4 ' ( "5* ;*"$
( "''* , -"5 "'("#" 77 161("
"$ 40 ,,,' * ' =19:=1, ( / 8 ("& (" $" /* $ "
"0 4("$, , (
'& " " ("&0(*0(( '*5 "&"$"4$'
-69
,' (
',' $"
0 ("
4 5"
4# ( /* $ , ( ( 3('( ?"' "
* ,6 &
'"
3
<=9.<9<, 4;,<5
3
9.9,<9<< 4;,65
"
'
""
'
(
" 2345
*
&
'
'
'(
9>9.<9,> %
' ''
''1
1
''
'
989<<9,-4;,5
&
' "
23 45 "
'
'
(
( "?'
2('
' &
(
989<<9,- 4;,5 " ('
'
@
*
+
(
'
'
2'
("
-
( " ?' +% "
( :
"
(
A &
' "
'
( "
' 0&
-7- '
:
' (
"
'
B "
(+ '
969<<9,6
+ 2('
2'
'
2
2
"
2'
@ ) '
& +
989<<9,-4;,5
'
''( '
(
' +2('
2'
2' + 4;6
;>5
'
&
+
"
"
' '" '
&
'
969<<9,6
1 & ("&(*0(
',''"
("
4 * 4# ( (" "
" , ( 00 C0 , ( "'("#" "! "5%(3"
;* ?"5($,($" 0" 0 3('( " $*
4# ( -"5 "'("#" , ?'* , &$ 5 3+ (" ( 3"
*# 4* " ( 5" * ' , $*
4# ( -"5 "'("#"% ,"$0 3('(
' $"#"'3*$ ("&4" "0" ( '% ( $ "
4$# , ( 3"
$5 "0 ( 5" 4# *0 " " B"" ;*"$#" *("(3+
-8- ?'* "
( " "
'4 ( '*5( "$$0" (" ( ?'* , ( 3+ 3" *4 " " (" ( 5" 3"
30$# " (" ( 3"
" 54BB$5 (
5" , $ & ( $" 3"
4 &, 4# ( -"5 "'("#",5(&*,,'"$ 4," $*" ( 40"'('"$ 3"
;* &,#( "5"
(*$ , 4*
* "
0 (5 "$ ' (" 3( " 0"
',''"
("&04 * 4#( ( 0" %(
("&'( '$",#( " ("& "(
("&5 5"
(3( (* (0 ' 3('('"
' ( " ,( "4$ ( ("( 3"
;* * " &,'" , ( $ , $" 3( (
&$ 53+3"
?'* (0&''*5 "' % , ("(
("& ,"$ "+,( *' '40$"
4$#,(
',' ,,'"$ ( "4 ' , *'( "
4$# ("&0 4
0 ( %('"4($ $"4$,"# *'($"
( $"4$# , ( "
' 3('( " ;* 4 &, 4# ( -"5 "'("#"4,
0, $*"
&"$(,4#('5 "*(#( "5,>$'+&$ 5" "'("#"%'" 45 "0" ( "'" "$ ' $,$"3("'"
"#'&#, $
4,,' %(4* $ (
"5 & ("($
;* ''* "
" *$,"' 5
'55
-94#" $;*5 $# ("4 ',"# *' :0* $ ,,'
* 4#('5 "*(#"
00( $"
4$#('("0 ,,'"$%((* '"4($ $"4$,$"
'55 4#"#,( " 7 (* ($ (" ( , '&#
4# (
"*( 4"
' " , ( ' $ 0* $
* 4#(
& 5 161216" ,"$ "
0"#"' ,5
'55
( ",( = ( 3 "'' 0$# "$$3 ( 5 *0 1211 '0 "'&#;*"(
"
(
"3*$ 4"$4# ' "0" "#(,,'"$%"5"+3$"3 /, +& 2 ( .' B C((
"+0:"
% : C(( "4$ :