Chanan Singh v. Jagtar Singh


 

         

!"#$#%&'&()*+

,!(!(-&(., #"&"&(#/ 0#/'1'

!."!/-&(.,  #'2($#("

)  34  - 5 4-  /#'#(")6 '!(7,!(5!1/8$9%!"#8 /2#"&"&(#/
 :,#",#/",# #2/"#/';%!;(#<'2!2#/7!=>#!;;<#$" '##",#?1$.7#("@  >#/##//#$"",# #2/"#//("  :,#",#/",#?1$.7#("',1;$>#/#2/"#$&(",#$&.#'"@ 66 66 4- 

4 721.(#$  &(  2/#'#("  /#9&'&(  &'  /$#/  $!"#$ 
A

((#B1/#66 8  2!''#$  >=  ;#!/(#$  $$&"&(!;  &9&;  1$.#

-#(&/ &9&'&( 8.!89&$#<,&%,!(!22;&%!"&(&;#$>=2;!&("&/ !7#($7#("    </&""#(  '"!"#7#("  "   %1("#/  %;!&7    $##($!("  <!' $&'7&''#$ "",#"&7#2/#;&7&(!/=,#!/&(.8/--!&(&8$9%!"#8 !22#!/#$    ,&'  <(  (  >#,!;    /#'2($#("  !($  22'#$  /#9&'&(

#'2($#("&'!;;<#$"?&(2/%##$&(.'!($7!C#'1>7&''&(' /.17#("'    >",  2!/"&#'  ,!9#  >##(  ,#!/$   &;#  &'  !;' 2#/1'#$ "  %7#'  1"  ",!"  2;!&("&  ,!'  &;#$  !  '1&"  /  2#/7!(#(" &(?1(%"&(/#'"/!&(&(.$##($!("/7&("#/#/&(.&(2#!%#1;2''#''&( 2;"7#!'1/&(.7!/C#$ !($1;;=$#"!&;#$&(,#!$("#2;!&("( /&.&(!;2;!&("8&"<!''"!"#$",!"$&'21"#$2;"&'<&",&(;!;;!C&/9&;;!.#

66 !>!$&!($$#'(">#!/C,!'/!(17>#/'!&$2;!&("8%1("#/%;!&7<!' &;#$>=$##($!("8"<,&%,2;!&("&&;#$</&""#('"!"#7#("<8!"'"!.# /#>1""!;82;!&("&<!("'"7!C#"<!7#($7#("'#<!("'"2;#!$",!" ",&' 1/",!'."(?1/&'$&%"&(""/=!($$#%&$#",#2/#'#("%1("#/%;!&7 !($1/",#/<!("'"7#("&(",!"$&'21"#$2;">#!/'C,!'/!(17>#/
A C,#<!"(17>#/

 8C,!"1!(&(17>#/
8!'2#/%2=?!7!>!($&/ =#!/
**6*8'&"1!"#$&(!/#!9&;;!.#($#/.!/,8&'"/&%".!8!($'!7# &'/#%/$#$!'<(#/',&2!>!$& -!&$!7#($7#("<!'$&'!;;<#$>= ;#!/(#$$$&"&(!; &9&;1$.# -#(&/&9&'&( 8.!89&$#/$#/$!"#$
A
 ((#B1/#66  $7&""#$;=8  ;!<  /#;!"&(.  "  !7#($7#("  <!'  !7#($#$  !($ /$&(!/&;= (  !7#($7#("  &'  "  ># !;;<#$  !"#/  /!7&(.

   &''1#'  !($ %77#(%&(."/&!;1(;#''&"&'',<(",!"<&",$1#$&;&.#(%#",!"2!/"= %1;$("7!C#!9#/7#("'#!/;&#/ (2/#'#("%!'#8;#!/(#$%1('#;//#'2($#(",!'/#;&#$12( !

     

   

  8


&9&; A
!'<#;;!'!1",/&"=",&' 1/" &(       

  

 8
  4!<#/!;$
+

(",#",#/,!($8;#!/(#$%1('#;/2#"&"&(#/,!'!;'/#;&#$ 12(!,/##1$.##(%,!1",/&"=(3>;#-12/#7# 1/"&(  

     



 8



&9&; +8 <,#/#&(&"<!',#;$",!"<,#(2/2'#$!7#($7#("&'"#;!>/!"#/#>1""!; #9&$#(%#8'!7#%!(>#!;;<#$ !7",#9&#<",!"'!/!'>?#%"&(/#.!/$&(.?1/&'$&%"&(

1/"&'%(%#/(#$8'!7#>#&(.;#.!;&((!"1/#!($%!(>#/#9&'#$#9#(

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

4-     *+

'?C' :,#",#/'2#!C&(. /#!'(#$ ) #'  :,#",#/ #2/"!>;# ) #'