High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4102/2015allowed

Rakesh Kumar v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-07-24Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain9 pages

#$%& !'( )* +

%+ - .% / / !.

0 (+ %0 1'2')3/ 45/)567) *'( 0(53(( 0 %0

/ '89'7!36(:) *'( 0'7 8';

'85 )'

53(( 05' )(530 ( 3(( 2364 4(5 0)0)'()< 73');:(5'0 )* 60(; 97950;:(5 '33*'( );:(53(( 0 00( 0'( (5'33'795*59' )2)'(2=;'00) , 79')2)

.'0 )* 6 0(53(( 06;2(()(5'((53(( 0 )'6(*5' 4 4(5 0)03');:(56(5 0(7950;:59' 02 )0 20* > 4(530 0(*?#&#;& (5 ((6( )'

5 6( 9' )2) ;: (5 (0' * 60( ) 86)42 ('

))*0)'() ?

4' ((586)42 ('

))*0 (5'0 )(0'* 60(7(53(( 03000)'33'; 0(5 90 '33'(* 60(795*59')':);: )':

5)':9'* ) ) 0)0)'()@ 6;8*(( 3':2 ( A='* ( (5

'2 6 ( * ( * 6) ( ; )3 ()7(5'33' 9' 0)0) ( ; )2) ' (2=;'00) ,

5 '33*'( 9' ) 0 0( 0'( (5'33' (53'(5'((5 0)03');:(5* 60( * 4(5)': 4(5'33'6;8*(( 3':2 ( * (* 6) ( ;* :)( (53(( 075 *7(5* (* 6) (;)3 () (2

5 0( 0'( '33*'( 9' )2) ;: (5 * 60( ; 9 ) 2364 ) 0)0)'()< 3 4(5'((5* 60() (5'(5 3 90( '04(5(2 9 (5;'030 )) @

56;2 (5'((59B30);:(5* 60(; 9* (0'0:( (5'9')) 9 ;: -;(5/6302 60( /'2) *'( '0 *'( 7

)'7#&</?

(5 (505'

)7'0 )* 6 0(5/('(6;2(()(5'(

*(53(( 05') (* 23)9(5(5* )( ')) 9 0)03') 0* 4(5)': 4(5'33'7(5'33'9' 045(:)2)'(2=;'00)'

)(5 0)09'045(: (0=*');:

(5* 60(; 9

'0)'0 )* 6 0(53'0('

)306)(53'30 ; >

5 '*( (5 *' 5'

) '0 (5'( '33*'( > * '( )': 4(5'33'9'' 9);:(5* 60(; 9 ) 0)0)'()@ 6;8*(( )3 ( A='* ( 5* ( 9'( ;)3 ()9(5!(0*(.4'/0*6(5 0(: 5 B()'( 5'0 49'B)' '

)(50'(0 ,

'** 6 (

=)3 ( * (7 (5 '33' 9' )2) ' (2=;'00) 5 '33*'( 9')> 40=*' 4 (5 0)0('> 4(53'(5'((5 * 6 ')0( (:* 6) ( 02(53(( 0'; 6((5* )(

23 ) (5 0)0* 4)': 4(5'33' , 95 (5* 6 *'2( > 9'; 6((5'*(7522)'(:*')(5 3(( 075 9075* 6) (* 2( (5* 60('59''(60)'360 '

)(52'((09'() (5* 60('(20('0 5'33*'( 00= *' 4(5 0)09')2);:(5* 60(; 9 50' '4 );:

(5* 60(; 9 0)2 4(5'33*'( );:(53(( 09' (5'( 9 (5'2 )2 (*'00) 6( @ 7*(

? 0 2 , 7(5* 60(*'

( '04(5(2;:

)'30 ) ?)':

50' '4 )( (':00 67* )0) (545( '0 6 86)42 ( -;(5/6302 60(

5604'0) 4 '042 ( (26 )0/*( @ 9' * )0) ;: -;(5 /6302 60( !

D '6

5'.'9'

7# &#&C7 950 (5'; 3 ) (5'((5* 60(5')*0( 0 2(2( (2( '04(5(2 (5 (2 04 ':B) 040'

()5')B30) E5000 4( 86)42 ( -;(5/6302 60( /'2) *'( '0 *'( 7

-*' #630'&7 ( 9' 3 ) (5'( B( ;:

) ? )': ' 302; *'(50F60)'*(* 6) (;30 02);:'3'0(:

9(5 (5'(30 ) 0(50' ;:

)5* (0 7'(530 ) 30*0;) (>(530 )30*0;)6 )0(530 (5 .2('( *( '

(3'0' (586)42 ('0B(0'*(); 9+= G< '0'(50('3*(* *0 )/*( @ (5 7 60 3 7*'0:00 ' 60 (5 60((5 3 90( '04(5(20F60) 0) '*(30*0;) 0' 9);:(5 ) 0 *)60 @ (5 )2':'((5('4;B(0'*()+=

E50'

:30 )B) 040'

();:(5 60( 0(5 ) 4 '

:'*(30*0;) 0' 9);:(5 )7(5 60(2':7 ()*0( 70 2(2( (27 '04 6*530 ) (B*) 4(50(:)': ( ('7

(5 645(530 ) 04 ':B) 040'

()2':5' B30) , 3' 0') 4 (5'; 9 6)5 9(5'(95 '

30 ) 0(240'

();:(5 60( 0) :'*(7(5 60(5'(5)*0( 0 2(2( (2( '046*5 30 ) (5(2 04 ':B) 040'

();:(5 60( 5'B30) () (0 2(5'

46'423 :) 30 (5'((53 904 ( (5 60()*0( '0:

) ( ))( ;B0*) :( 2((5 ) 86(*

/0')* (5 60(5'B3' )(5'2;('

* 3 (53 90B0*';6 )0/*( @ (5

# $ %"$ & '( )*+,(*&(5 60( ;0)+ G/*( @ (5 )7 (027' 9B( (27 (5 04 '30 )B)5'B30)7'

/*( CF6':;0' 0( 07(5 *( * 6); >);:(5'33*'

(795 (5(25') ( '*(6':B30) 5'((5'33*'( 9') '*'( 95 '! *59' ((( 45 6) 5' ; * )0) )' 4 9(5 (

, C 795 (9''*(6':5'0) 5 0)07(5 645 3')'(0(5B30: (5(2B);:(5 04 ' 86)42 (7 9 6) 5' 30'() 0 2 @ , C

9 )0';(( B(23023( 0: 0'6(60 5'33 495*5'(5 60(3 90( )'9(5 ((5'(245('0 ;(9 7( ( *'0:( )*) (5'33' 5 0)0(60 6(7 ( ( ; B3) ( /6*5 30 *)60' 0)07 (5 645 3023( 0:#* )( ')*0'3'0(&'0 *7

(00 027 (5'()'( 0:(4'

(245(36((52 0)0 '

) ' ) )':

5: ) (7 5 907 * 23(:( 3' 60(0 2('> 4 ( ('

*0*62('

*95*55'33 9(5 (5(2B) B'237 ( *'

( ; ') (5'(7 (5 '33'

( 5') ('0()9(5(562 : 0)0)( ;3')'

)*'2 9 (2;6((63 '

)0 ;;);:(5(5)':

30 675* 6) ('> 0B( (27 0(5'( (5 60(9'3 90( B( )( /6*5 0)0'0 ( >(5'9 (5%)'

)(5 0'

''0 > 95*5 60(5'2 6))(5030'*(*( 2('(6'( 6*5'(5'

)( 5'0( 0)'6( 0 30 *) 47 (5 645' ' 0)05'); 3')

@ (5 '2 *( (5 )* (5 60(

'2'0>'(5'

::' 7C@#&/C7950(5 60()*'0)(5'((5* 3'

)B0* (5860)*( ( 40'

((2( ) '(5 47 (5'; * '3**30

( (5 * (0'0: *60(' 47 ) : 4 0 9(55 ) 4 6*5 860)*( 7 ( 40'

( (2 9 6) 50 ( '2;( (5 860)*( ( B( )(2 (':B);:( 5 60(' *') (530 *3 F6(:95 *0*62('

*'0( ; ('> ( '** 6 ( 0B 4' 4(5 (29(5 95*5'

*0(' '*( ( ; ('> 7 (5 60( 0(' ( (5 860)*( ( 0=B'2 (5'(0'( 02 )*'( 95*5 2': *('(B( (2 5 9 43''40 2 (5)* '33 (+ G(9'**3()30 *3('(6( 0:0* 4 I)

/*( @ (5 ) 0 *)60(5'(950'

30 )B) 040'

();:(5 60( 0) :'*( 30*0;) 0' 9);:(5 )7(5 60(2': ( )*0( 0 2(2( (2 '046*530 )

(5 645(530 ) 04 ':B) 040'

()2':B30

' 60( B0* (5860)*( *'

40'

((2( ) '(5 47 (5'; * '3**30 ( (5 * (0'0: *60(' 47 ) : 4 0 9(55 ) 4 6*5 860)*( 7(5860)*( ( 40'

((29 6) 50

('2;((5860)*( ( B( )(2 (':B);:

( ' 4 ' * 23 ( 0)0 9 6) ; '*( 4

)04'0) (5860)*( (5'(9540'

( 4(2 26('

6:(5 60() ( ((5860)*(

( B( )(2 530 *3 F6(:(5'(95 2 *0*62('

*'0( ;('> ( '** 6 ( 0B 4(5 (29(5 95*5'*0(' '*( ( ; ('> 7(5 60(0(' ( ((5860)*( ( 0= B'2 (5'(0'( 02 )*'( *0*62('

* 95*52': *('(B( (2 (5 60(;:

< ( 9 '*() ((5860)*( ( ) 7(9 6) ;) : 4( ((5860)*( 95*5 (5'; * ' 4'(30 7(6 ) 6;(): 8 : C 0 *2':' ;2')( (5)* (5 60( -" ./& ' *) +0(&- "

& ' ')+1*%

3.% & ' 4)*+4* !

56 /5

6&738 9& 0114 )(+ *7 (5 60( 5') ' **' ( B'2 95(50(50(0*( 3'*);:(5'2 )2 ( /*( @ (53 90 (5 60(( 40'

(B( (2;:

)?)':9'0' '; 5 60(5)(5'('

3 90 (5'( 50 ( (5 60( ( 3' 0)0 (5'( ( * )0 *'0: 0 2( 4 (5 ) 86(* '

30 ( 4';6 (530 * (5 60(*'

(;('>

'9':;:36(( 63302( (530 ) 095*5'

B( *'

; 40'

() B( ;:

) (5 2'B262 30 ) ? )': 9' '** 0) 4:5)302; 9 49 0)+ G5'2 )2 (2') @'*((53 90 (5 60(( '04(2(5'(2':5'; B) 0 40'

();:(5 60( 0(5) 4 '

:'*(30*0;) 0' 9);:(5 ) 5'2 )2 (30 )(5'( (5 30 ) 5' ( B*) ? )': ( (' 0 '2 )2 (7 (50 9' 6*5 0(0*( (2

E5(50(5 60(5' 50 (3 90( B( )(5 (2;:

)?)':(5F6(

E5' ) 6;( (5'((563302(B) @*'

(('> '9':(5 50 (3 90 (5 60(( 3' 0)0' 2':; *'0: 0(5 ) 86(* 0( 30 ( ';6 30 * (5 60( 504) 30'( (5 *( 9 6) ') ( ';60)(:

/*( 5'7 (50 07 ( ; ' 9) ( 30'( 6: B(

, ;:

)2'B262 ?)':7(567*'

;302(() (5'*(* 6) (;30 02)9(5 ?)': 00' ;:

)(5* (0 (53'0(:

E'0 ()' 49(5 '*'950(2 0) '*(5'; 30*0;) )0(530 (5.2('( *(95*5*'

( ;B( ))(506 )0/*( @ 0/*( E '0)' 49(5'*'950(5(2B) 040'

() ;:(5* 60( 030 02'

* '

'*(30*0;) 0 ' 9);:(5* 60( ( ( (545( (5'; )* 3 ( (5 03 ) (( '046(5'(' 60(*'

B(2 0(5) 4 '

'*(>2'> 4 )3 (7 (5 ('

(*'7;6(5'

860)*( ( B( )(5')30 ) 95 '*' 06*5 B( *'0:2') 6( 53 90( B(5(2 0 ) 4 '

'*(26( 60 3 *'00:9(5((53 90( B( ) 6*5 30 )7 )3 ) 4 63 95(50 (5 3'0(:

)'6(2'> 6('*'( (5'('*( (5 60(95 5'B)(5(2 50 (5 4 @ (5 0 '

: (5030 (5* )( 644((5'(6*5'

3 90 B( (2*'

(;B0*) '*'>

'( 5'

5'0462 ( (5'( (53 90( B( ) (2 *'

(;B0*)950(5'*( F6( (36'() '

* )( ')*05' (230)6 E 0' ( )0'9 ' )( *( )3 ) 4 95(50 (5 30':0 0 B( 04'0)( '* )( ' 0)0 0'* )( ' )*0 55'0( (52'((0(5'(950(5 60(5'(5 3 90( B(2'

)(5'(3 90 (046'();:'

('(6( 0:2(7(5' '330 30'(*'(53 90( B( (5(2B);:( (* 22 40 6 )(5'( (50(5

0(530 %

** 22 )'( (0 *(3'* '

:2('( (53 90 (5 60( >(5

@ 2'0*('0(586)42 ( (5 60( 6>'2'

(50 %'

4''

(507 #&#& J 0'2 '

*5':'( K/'56360' '

'.''

) (507#&#&@@'

)

?C ?L'0*5'0'

/ 45 653'!'

) (507 )*)) , ?

0 2'306' (5' 0')86)42 (7(*'0(5'((5 60(5''233 90( '04(2B) 0) :'*( (5 (2 04 ':B) 040'

()5')B30) 53 905'; * 00) ( ;B0*)( 2((5 ) 86(* '(0'2 )2 (

@ 73'* 4'2( ?)': 0B( (27(5 60((5' 3 90( B( ((530 );:

)(5'(*'62') 6( *'950(5(25'; (36'() '* )( ')*07(53 90 (5 60(( B( ) (('> '9':

5*06B(5'(950(5 60( 5'3 90( B(2'

)(5'(3 90 (046'();:'

:('(6( 0:2( 6*5'(5.2('( *(7(5'3 90( B( )(5'2

(5 *' 5'

)7 ' ('() ;: '0 ) * 6 0 (5 3(( 07(509')': 20: )': 4(5'33' 5'2 9'* )6;8*(( )3 ( A='* (9(5!(0*(.4' /0*6(5 0(:

50' '4 ) 0

=* 23'

* (5 0)0 9(5 (5(2302(()(5'((5* 6 ')0( (:* 6) ( 02 (53(( 0 (5* )( ' 0)0 5'22( ;86('; 5 2'((03 ) 4 (5* 60('(20('0 53(( 00) ( '4 /'5 9'7 !(0*( 60)'360 5 6 0') (5 '33' 04'0) 402 ' (53(( 00 20* (5* 60(5')(53 90 ( B( )(5(260(507 2: 3 7 (5'*('

)*0*62('

* (5*' 5'

)7(53 905 6)5'; B0*)( ) 6;('

(' 86(*''4' ((*5 *'(

0 (5 0' 2 ( ) '; 7 (5 30 ( 3(( ' 9) 52364 ) 0)0)'()< 73');:(5'0 )* 60( ; 97(') 5 0)0)'(), )2 4(5'33'' (2=;'00) '** 6 (

=)3 ( (5* (23 )9(5 (5(2 302(()' (')76;8*(( (5* )( (5'((53(( 09

9)3 ((5* (63( ? @

53(( 05''33'0; 0(5 '0 )!(0*( 6)4720('0 060(5030 *) 4 (5'33'

#'85 )'& 6)4

, 2> #0( 3 0(0&