← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4095/2016dismissed

Balwinder Singh v. Shinder Pal And ORS

2016-06-07Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul11 pages



    

!" #$%& ' " !" 

   

 

     

    

    

          

   

   



 ! " #

  $ ! "  #   %%%%%      & 

 #         

" ''(# )#* $     #  +,-'.+/  0 +  1 2 "3 !

! 

1  #     #     # "

 # 5"

1!)      #1 !   "#  # "

#4 5 "

1!   )     ,('.+,! 

       +6  "  "  7" # !  "   " !  " /+-   ""  1! 5   # ##" # "

 8 !   +!     #      # 

  "! #    "    " (/  

    # 9  2 ")55 "!+::6#   ; "<    5  

      9  "

1 2 "  ! +::6 #   ! =   >! "

      " #       ##"  # "

        *          ## "   ?-  

9

!    7##"

! "   

1!   "  #  @       7##"

! 2 " 3 !  #

     "    "  " ! 

#    +,-'.+/!

 # 1!   A   7##"

 " 

 !  +!  ! " /(: ! # 5 5 !   5-/,    "  

!   !     3     7##"

""  B #  +# " #  *      5     "

 05! 5     6::     5 #" #      

!    C 5 *D!         

  

 5  "

 05  #" # "

"#  !   # 5 

  1  9 " @    3   $   "  C 5 *D!  "

  #  1       7##"

       !

   # #   + 6   

 ;+

   -/,  ' E

 +-:  ,  

 ++F  6 

 +,(  - 

   /+- <

 

1!#+-:'   !  !  C 5 *D      1 1 #   "   !   A    7##"

  "   "1 #    ! "

   # !

    +-6' 

   3 !

## " #-.   

# ! $   !   2 "3     +,-'.+/     #        "  #           +    "  "    ) # 3  #'(-'.+/   +,-'.+/ 5  9 "5 #"

     @    "  #       "      5       +,-'.+/ ##  # 5 5  

    

 ! 5   

 15   1  9"5?"       # 

 #   3  3        #"    

 + "      ! 1 $#

#    A   7##"

 5  3 2 "3 

   #"  "

"1#   "   5    $  

1   " 1

 #" 5  #5 #"   "

 1    1 " 5    "  9#1 

  "  

1

" # 1

        @   " #   9 5  # )  " # 

 



!"""#$% #&%'($) *+,+-&*+./0 12!""3#4% 34$  "         #  "  # !   +   1  9 "

         #  #     !  "   1 "55 !

"

 #   ,, ' " #      

 #  

#  *        "  #          

#"  

5   

##   ,,#     5$$ /+ 0

 /6 /012 #170/  33%  !" #  $  





%& '





         !"

  

 





 )* !"  *

 '

 

% 

     % 



   

 



%     !" #   

 

 

       

     

  +   

 

 (  , !"

  

 +%   -  -  -      +   

 

+%

 -   

      +      (   %    

         (

  

 , !"

       % 

 

    



   %  

 

  *

 '

% 

      



 

  

 

 

     *

 '

 

(

   

%     ./   

 

    

 

0   

  - 

    

 



    !"  (

(  (      

 

 

   

  

 

  

   (   

  

 (

 ( % %

   

 

     

  ) *%   

 (    

(

(



  ( , !"   

 

      

  

  +       %  &  '

 

     #2   

  /  *   " #  1  +!   "#"1    #5 !    6::   

  +     /(:    

 " 5 1

!  6   '.. 

1   +   "      8 ! #  5  5 !  "   "   +  "#"1       "$ #-.  "

   "$ # +/    1"   # 8 !  #"    "#"1   1  

1  5  #    3   3      #  1

 ?+   "    .    

    



     ( %      

  - !)3#"

45( 

         %  

     (   678 (          



    

9 

 % 

 4  

 

  64(   

 

 4

 %  ( 

(   

 

  :0 

%

    :88 (    

   678 (  #

  

 :9

$ 

 (  55( %    (    7 (  ;(

    % 

   (  

% 

  

   %      (

    (  $ 

 %   <

     (   ( %       (  

 (    =

 

   (

 









 4%   

 = 

 =

  (   

 &   

 

 = 

 (%( (  -

45( 

  -

6(     (



 0

(   



( 

 9

 $  

  :      (

 

   #   

 9

 $  

  :  55 ( %         (   78 (  #

    

 >$     7( %      (  48(  #         

         %           

 



0  

   



 

  

   

  

   :  



 







 

  - 



?

@    

 



 +









 0 

          







 4 

  

   (/  )     "  # ,+018 

   9 

!"""#!%#&%'!' ""  "

$ !



  #   

5  9 "#

      )          "5   9" 

           "  1    #  !  # "   ## "   0       "  3    5  1 ) ,+018

 9

!

 "  

 =+(  00 00 00 00   (     

 

  %?

@ 0 +A        

    

           A 



  -  

     ( 

% A   

 #( 



   (  

      ( 



 

 

 1 %    

  

  



 

    



    + 

 

        

      (

     

(      

 

 #    %   



      (

 

 





 

% 

 



(+ 



 

 

 B #



   



   (

  ( 

                          C

& 

  



  

 

    



      9 

      

    

  

  %

   

(    (         

       (



  (

    

 #   

 0 D   D !

 "% ?

@ $ A  

    

 D D !

 "

    

    

   ?

 A  

     (



      



   

 

5 1!  )   ?6,-F # '..(  :11;  2 &170/  9+ & . /0 12  "   '6:'..(  < <"$==< !"">%    1 )   #   5 #"   "

" 03       = ?

@   $  A   9 ( $ @    !

 "  

     

    

    

 +

%   

    # A - *  E(@    !

 "?

@ $ A   

 

 (    

  

  

 

%  !

"     , !

" 

     

, !

"   (  

F  

     

   

, !

(" 

 

 -    

1

9 &>

@  



A  $ A@  !$ ": :#( 

 

   

            ?

@   $ A     (%

  

  

 



#

    

 F         

   (    %  +  



 

'../6))F:+! ' )  $   G    #      '..6/ )) ,,+ ,   E    2 " 3 "5    ! 8 +:::6))(: 6



 ) 5  E5  '../')) (((

  

   

  

    (     4 5*C   *

 '

    

      

      

     4 5 *C%         555 *C   

 

  *

 '

    

 555 *C 



 



 

       

'

 

 



555*C

                  ?

(%

 -      (   

  

 

   8(

   

B4(    (

%#





            

     

 

 4 0   %  (

 

 



       

+  

  

 (   

     /

""  1! #   #       1   ) !  #

    !   )  #   "

   1  +   "# "

B !   5  #  B 1!  "1     +  "#"1   5

# " ## "         9 "   ## "              # ### " ! # 5 #" ## "  # -.             "  1   A   7##"

      1

5

* "5  # 9" ! ) #  " 1 " "   "  " #  3 " ##(#)*+,  #-,.#/)  "  1   " #    "   " #"" "5" # " !

  "#"     " !

 # "#  ## " " # "

      

# !   )           1 "55  1 3    " #     " #     

""  1!  5   .(!'.+/ 0  12 34 .526#76#