Satish Kumar & ORS v. Rama Shanker








 

 

!

"
#$%
&'
()
#*
#$#+$, - $)%
&.
//
0



/1

11111111

)2)2#$ 3 / /

 
/0 11111111

4#$"

$)
 %
 56
/1
 /



0

7















 
  

 



 





0

78
1
 (9


!


 




 ""
 


# 

$%
 

 %
&'



( )( *)+
'

$%
 


$%
 !
'
'

 


$%
 
&


'

 * 

 
$

 

& 

,
- 


.


# 

,"
# 


 
#
/

/'
0




"

!% 





%

$"

1



 

2 




 

3

 
$

&
2

4 )( 56)
7
$'
 

2
 


 
 

 
1%
 



'
& **+8!



9
7 9'
 



 
 
 

3
'
7

& +(*48!







7

 

1

 

 

2 8!

 

$
  



 
 

3

8
2 *

(
' 
 


 
 * :


2 

(!

 

 
&


 
 
'"
!
;
    

        

      

    
 
 

     

 

       !

"  

   

#   





    $

% &

 

   



       &

   $

  

  &     

  '  (        $

)$*
* *

/
 


 

 * (


&

 
 
 
 !

 


$%
"
 
 "

 
 %

 
"




%


:
$"
'


"
 
 



 
! < 
"

 


$%
 
&

# 

'




 
!
'


"
 
 



 
! ( < 
"
 

""

%



 

 %
$
 

 
$

 


=7 <*8


$
 
 


 





"
 
$


 
1
'
$
 
 

3



 
%
$"
2 ()*58*
'


'

'
$%



2 8
2
 
'





 


 
%
'
 
$%
 
"


 
$




$%
 
'

$%
 
 
'





 
"
 


 
'



 

 
8
&

,!
 < 
"
 
 %
 
   
&

,!






 

 %
$
 

 "
 
 %
 

 


'

$%
 

'




 



 +



 %

 




%
 
 

 
%

&' 

3


#

 

 

 


$



 $

 
  


 
$
#"


3 

 
 

 %

 


 






>





 


 "

 

 %


$

 


 
$"



 

 %



 


 
"
 

"


 




"


$

',




1



"


 









'





$ 






 '
 
 $


 %
 $

 
 

#
$%




$


$
 ?

1

 

 





$
'
 



 
$
&

$


 
#"






  

 
    

 

0


 


 
'





"


 



 '
 
'

 



 






%


"
 

$ @
 



$"



 


 
$

A8 @
'

$%
 
'

 

2 

 
 
'

3

$"



 
"


$

$%
 
9B$
7


!

"  # $ %& '


() ) @
 
 




 

"

 


$%
 

 %
$ 
 # 


"

%
$




1


 

$ 


 !$,

#$(9
 , 2);%
*


 
$'
 


 
!
2
 

!& 

,


 

"


# 

 


 
"


% 



 

$

',


 


"


 


4+
%

"

 
'



'
$

 
 

3

 



 
1

 

 




 $,

 

3

 
 



"
 

$ (


!


 


' 
"
 

3


3
$%
 




%C
 


$

#

#
 
C



C

 


'


 



 
%
&'

 



$


%

$%
 






$
 



 "
 
 %
 




 

$%
 




 
$





 
 %
  + 0


 



 3

$

%






'

 
 

$%
 
 

" 






 



 
'
 


$



$%
 

 







 

%




,"
# 
 > =
 '
 

'
4+
%

"

 
 

"

 



 
%
*)+
9

"
 

',"





'



'
$
$%
"




  ?

"

'
 
"

 


 
 

"








 
 





'
 



 

$
$
%

'



 

3


#"

 
'
$%

 1

"

'






'
$



%

' 





 

'
"
%
 
 



' 
 


  




 '
 



%
 


%
$
"
 


1
  
 %

"

%

 
%

 





"





 



 


 
#"






 *+,- 
1
 


 

'
"

$

/ 
$


3

D 

 
%



 
3 

  

' 



 
$


 
3 
'



 

 
 


 

 %
'



 
# 


$%
 
&

'


'
/+<9 ))2$=%
*) @
 


$!"
 
E

 %
"

'"
$!
+,,,-  

        

   .  /    #   # .  0       

  .-12 3 





   

 

   

 # 

&        

  

  .-12 3-  '  



   # .-12 3#    # &   

   &  

 

  "# 

   !

  



# 

             

  ,,,*
+,,,!

 '   

  "    ( &



 





        #  

  

 .-12 3   

& 



 

#    # 

  4

 

&      -   

         

   

 

       

   -  ' 

         

      

 

    ,,,*
 *


# 

'

"



 
"

$"
"


#
/
 

2 *




A8 @




 
  
 

'
$
$%

2 *


 
'



$"

$%


 




 
 




7





 


2 * ** 1


 
"

 


 $

$%
 % *(






 
 

2 

 


#
/

'


2

1





&

$
 $

'

"




 
 %



 $


 % %



 
#"



9B$
7


!

" *+,- 
1
 


  
'
,


$%
 
 
# 
'
"




"

$!"
""
 


$
 
 


 
"


'


'
"
 
$

  
9B$
7

$
 


 
"

'
"


$

'

 
,'"

 
C

 
 



$!"
 
 
$
'
$"


$%
 
"

' 



 
 
"

 

&


 

'




$!"
'
 
$%
 
9B$
7


 
"
 


%






 *4

 %
 
9B$
7



 .  /  ,+ 0

   #


 .    ' (

'
1 
 




 
"

 

$
"

 "

"

 
"



'
"






"



7
  *+ 1
'

 


 


',"

'




 

"
A8 @

$


$
$"

*> 1
'

 


$
 
"


$%
 

 %

 
3

$"

$

$





 





 
"

$"

 



# 


 
" *?






"%
%
' "

 

 %

 
"





.
%

 
'
 
"

 %

 

$"

 *6






 



 

3

 
"


% *5 "



%
 


 


0

7  
2@ =

<  
,"
= <  
$
2@
&.

-2
.