Kulwant Singh v. P N Ramanan And Another

  

         

!"#$#%&'&()
 *+,-!(".&(/0 #"&"&(#1 2#1'+'

 !3!(!(!($"0#1'

 #'4($#("'

)  56  . * 6.  1#'#(")7 ',&'0!.(&8$9%!"#814#"&"&(#1
 :0#"0#1"0# #41"#1',%!,(#-'4!4#13!;<#!,,-#$" '##"0#=+$/3#(">  <#1##11#$""0# #41"#11("  :0#"0#1"0#=+$/3#("'0+,$<#1#41"#$&("0#$&/#'"> 77 77 * 6. 

6

7
7 7

%+3#("' ((#?+1#77
 ,,; !1#"!@#((1#%1$ 44,&%!"&(&'$&'4'#$ !&(%!'# 34+/(#$&(41#'#("1#9&'&(&'"0#1$#1$!"#$ 


A

((#?+1#77 84!''#$<;,#!1(#$ &9&,+$/# .#(&1&9&'&( 86+$0&!(!8 9&$#-0&%0$##(%#4#"&"&(#17$##($!("
-!''"1+%@1(( &,&(/-1&""#('"!"#3#(" #!1$ 1#'#("4#"&"&(#1&'$##($!("
<#1#"0#,-#1 +1" 0#4#1+'!,#("&1#B&3(& 1$#1'84!''#$ <;,-#1 +1"8'0-' "0!"

$##($!("  
74#"&"&(#10!$  4+"  &( !44#!1!(%# 1 "0#  &1'" "&3#  (
AC
 -0#(  1#3!&(&(/1#'4($#("'-#1#;#""!44#!1#-!' 1#D+&1#$"&,#-1&""#('"!"#3#("-&"0&("0&1";$!;'8!'41#'%1&<#$+($#1

&9&,1%#$+1# $#8
 ##($!("
74#"&"&(#1-!'$&1#%"#$"&,# -1&""#('"!"#3#("8-0&%0&'!,'1#,#%"#$&(1$#1$!"#$A
:1&""#( '"!"#3#("-!'("&,#$-&"0&(1#D+&'&"#4#1&$$!;'8-0&%0%+,$<#

77 #?"#($#$1'+&%&#("1#!'('+4"(&(#";$!;'13"0#$!"#'#19&%# '+33('   -#9#18&"-!'(


8&#!"#131#"0!"'#9#( 3("0'!44#!1!(%#8!(!44,&%!"&(+($#1 1$#1 +,#

  8
 8-!'

&,#$<;$##($!("
74#"&"&(#1-#9#18-1&""#('"!"#3#("-!'!/!&( ("&,#$.&3+,"!(#+',;8("&%#"1#'4($#("'"E-!'!,' 1$#1#$"<#&''+#$##($!("'!($E0!$!44#!1#$(
E 0#4#1+'!,'+<'#D+#("&("#1&31$#1'8!3(/"0#1'8!,''0-"0!" $##($!("
74#"&"&(#1$&$("&,#-1&""#('"!"#3#(""0+/0%!'#-!' 1#4#!"#$,;!$=+1(#$1'!&$4+14'#("0#3#!(-0&,#8'&3+,"!(#+' !1/+3#("'(!44,&%!"&(&,#$+($#1 1$#1 +,#

  8
 8-#1#("

!$$1#''#$0#!44,&%!"&(&,#$+($#1 1$#1 +,#

  8
 8-!'

$&'3&''#$(C

A8-0#(!/!&(-1&""#('"!"#3#("-!'("&,#$!($ %!'#-!'!$=+1(#$"




A1&,&(/-1&""#('"!"#3#(" ,"&3!"#,;8 9&$#&34+/(#$1$#1$!"#$


A ((#?+1#77 84!''#$<;,#!1(#$

&9&,+$/# .#(&1&9&'&( 86+$0&!(!8$##(%#$##($!("'
!($C -!''"1+%@ !3"0#9&#-"0!"$##($!("
74#"&"&(#10!$!44#!1#$ 1"0#&1'""&3#(
AC
!($$&$("&,#-1&""#('"!"#3#("1!<+" ;#!1'!($    3("0'   0&'&'3+%0<#;($"0#4#1&$"0&1";$!;' 41#'%1&<#$+($#1  8
 8-0&%0%+,$<##?"#($#$+4"$!;'13 "0#$!"#&''+#'+33('0#1#0!'"<#'3##($"!$=+1(3#("' 0#-!;"0#%!'#-!',&(/#1#$(1(#!1,;C;#!1'1&,&(/4,#!$&(/' (,;/#'"'0-"0!"$##($!("'-!("#$",&(/#1("0#%!'#((#1 "0#"0#1/1+($"-!'(,;"0!"-0#( +1"-!'%34#,,#$"4!''!

0!1'01$#18'+%01$#1-!'4!''#$0#1#&'(/1+($"&("#1#1#&("0# &34+/(#$1$#1('"!("1#9&'&(&'$&'3&''#$8@##4&(/&(9&#-"0#

77 !%""0!"%!'#0!'!,1#!$;(-<#%3#E;#!1',$0#"1&!, +1"&'

$&1#%"#$"/1!("'01"!$=+1(3#("'!($$#%&$#"0#%!'#-&"0&(3("0' 13"0#$!"#1#%#&4"%#1"&&#$%4;"0&'1$#1

* 6.     
 '=@' :0#"0#1'4#!@&(/ 1#!'(#$ ) #'  :0#"0#1 #41"!<,# ) #'