← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4135/2016dismissed

Gurbax Singh v. Jaswant Singh And ORS.

2018-01-08Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal6 pages



      

    

     

!

""  "# $

"  

"% $ "    !"#$%&!" $&'

"

& '

  ( $) * # ' 

($) *   + 

' 

',( $) * # ' , -./($) * $ ' !""($) * + 

 "% $ "0 111     

" "",

$ 56 5739 %""

$ : $$ , "* $ ( ,$  )$  # %%,* $ ;3 8 $#  * 383 +  ": + *  % *

$" 

*   #" $"/""



"% $ "0$

" +, $ ),   3< $ $ 7< 7;

3<=3 " /  "#$  . $

" +  *, (% ""

"" $% / >* 

"#" %,: $

$ )$  >$/

3<<3 :  $ ( " ,""( ,$   ,

$"  ?503 $ 3@ 3<=7(  ?50@ $ $ 3@ 3<=7(  ?506 $ 3<=7$ ?;05$ $3@ 3<=7#

) $

$,, , ,++"#

 #  +

,$* )

 +  "$ ",

$" 

 ,$ / " ;35 -," 38 /," $

: #

,$ , $     % ""

""  +

+  "$ ,$ + / %* "

"0$ + $"  9   33



/ >* #","  $$

+ $"# " $+ /, 

"% % :+

 : 

2@4 %% , +, $ "

 +  "$ >$/  $

 #" $"/""

 A #  %%     3@ 3<<6

,"

* $%% ,

 =8< +3<<6#" $"/""

      56 3<<6 $

 "$  #" / $  



  2;4   )   "  + .

   +, $ ),   358 + 3<<= " /-   $

" *,$

" +  $ *,   

++ *  >$/  $

3<<3 %""

$ :  $ ( " ,""( ,$ (>$/

$3@ 3<<6%""

A #  %%    $ >$/  $ $ 56 3<<6 %""

:

    =8< +3<<6# ,, ,(,,$ ) $ 

"$"( ,:$ + $" 3 38# "

) $$

  / $ + $" *,$ $

" # % *

$"

"#"$

$)$ >$/ $ $

577@ : ), $  C  )" D( ,$ $$ *, #" $ 

++ * $

$ 3<<3 %""

$ :  $ ( " ,""( ,$ (

$ 3@ 3<<6 %""

 A # %%  $ $ $ $56 3<<6%""

    =8< +3<<6# ,, ,(,,$) $$#  $% 

 " +

%,++$) $

"$

+  ",

$" " * E     : +

$ "#

),$ 

+  "$"(%%,*  $ < 3@ + "

"$

>$/ $

577@ #" +, $ : - #  .- > #$ # +/% >$/ $   58

"$" 

 "$ %%,*  #" ,, # $ )$ $ @3 573; $

>$/

$53 577@%""

$:), $ C )" D(,$ #""

"$



( * #"+,

"   "% * + >$/

3<<3 

*  (  #  > * " #  +,

> * 0%     

 "" + >$/  $

577@ $

 ,$ "> * /  +

* # #"" ,$:,> +)  +> )$  ",

$ $ $ 3@ 7;

577=  A$ / " 96 -," ; /,"#"" ,$: # $/- +)  +

%  $ " 

 $ ,   )$  ",

$ $33 7;

577=

" "*

>$/ $

$3= 3<<3$""

E >$/

#  "

 "$  

 " +, $ : )    53 577@(

( ") $ "# ),,

 " "

,,

,$ $"%   /$ "

 $ ,

 *   +   *

 +* 

577@ #  #" %""

$  "

#""

"$ $ < 3@  @3 573;($"/""

 > * ": ,$   "   +

"E

"(

"/ #" ,/ ,:$"/""

$$ 36 @ (

",$# #""> */  +>$/

3= 3<<3"  * $$

"$>$/ " +,: % 

  

 $

" #  ) $

"   

 $ $ - #, $  +

 , (

(

: #,, "

%  

 "

" +

 ) $ " $ > * " : $ 53 375 

" "

%% $  

 "

" + " ) $  $" $:

$ *  

 > * "+, :

# $"/""

$$

%%,* $ ;3 8 +, $

A # %%   " ,: 

 > $"%*%, " + 

# %%,*, $    *"

#"/$  +)  +

+  + / $  +": + * 

*  

  " , $:  $ +,: % 

   $/

 * %""

$), 358 +3<<= :

,  53 577@ ", $:

"

"$ $

$  <  3@   )$ $ @3 573;

 ,,

 $ " + "

*  +     *"

( ,*  + * )  * $"++ *  + %, , ""

 +     >*   +)  +

2=4  # ,$    , )      5< 7< 5739( ,  $ * "

, + 

 %  /$   *  * "

   *"

 #" +, $ 

 %    $

%  +, $  ++$) $ $ 73 7= 5739  "  $   5< 7< 5739(+ ,, # $ #"%""

$&F  

     

 

  

  !

   

"  # !

  $ %%         "  & '

 (    )



!      *   (   )&     "   )$)

 ! )           

       !)  

#  )))       +    *      

!

    

!    #   

      

  ), 2<4  ) % + /

  +$$ ,"* $ ( ,$ (  #" + $  

 

 ), %% ,  33678 + 3<<6 #" +, $ 

   $

"/ #"$"/""

$ 3;

3<<6

#"% / "  # : *       $+ +, +,"

++$)  " $#"," % % "

$ /% "

/%,:

* ")$  $ $ $3;

( / $ $ 5< 7< 5739 #" )*

      39



 $> /  #"  $ "> *   % )" , * " +

"

@7(7770F  5@  

( *"

 #" $>  $  /  + **" "

  + $ $ 5< 7< 5739 #"  * " $$  % *

$"  * $(+

$> / #" $"> * +

* " + "

57(7770F  ) 

( "  $$, * $  

**/"* "%%   * $  ) # +**/"* "" * $ ) ( "  " *, $  +  / "

*

"  /", $

 :+,+,"

++$)$ $73 7= 5739$

"   " ,"   *  %% %  *  

$"    - 

/ (

($"/"" " )" %  # * " + "

87(7770F   * ) $+ /

+ +, +,"

++$)  "  

 " $ $   $ % "

+  "$* " > A , )*  : $"( +,#

* "$ $  * )

* "" ,$ 

   (" $&'

 "#'! 7= 573= 

* ?

"  $0% -  "0  ?

% ,  "0