Piara Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab




    
 






 

 !"#$ %

&'()( ******++,,   & -.

**** +)  


 !
"
#$ %&!
%"'"

"



/**&* (- ")0 (++,,* /*12 (")0," -. * /* **&*3")0( +,* %"'"

"

(
#"

(++,," ,3" &'()(4 & .&'(5 ++-)2 .&'(56,4)

'+-( ,-)&7$897#:97#;97;
 (,,'( %*<* <<< -8*7$+* *(3"4(,

' )4(=+"))"+0,3"-) .-    6.4  &'(  )  (  (> (.  &'(*  1) .-)'

))))#%*;*#$$7",))),& -)'  ?)(@"   "  0)  ++,,>& .  &'(  5

++-  -)  &  7$8 
  )  ++,,    &'(  ) 2 .&'(56,-)&7$897;
))


( -)''- 03)+3  *#"$$$9>())-,+3 "-(-)' '-       4  (* ++,,>   &'(  4 -(  0)  -)  &  7#: 
  4(,  ++,,  & . &'(5 ++-)2 .&'(56,-)&7#:97;

))-)''- -3 )+3 * "$$$9>())-,+3 "

  -(  -)'  '-         (* ++,,>2 .&'(56,4,0)-)& 7#;
4(,++,, &'()& .&'(5 ++- 40)-)&7#;97;
))-)' '-       3  (* ,,  (    4 ))--,3* ''0)(0)"(++,, ,)  (  +  ++,"  4((  4  ) )    :*%*#$$7*   #!*8*#$$7"  ( - -+))(      ++,,>2 .&'(56,*(  ++,,    &'(  )  & .  &'(  5  ++-  4 - A-,3-+)):*!*#$$;) 7* #*#$$;"+0,3*
 3 4(4(, (()+ '

')(-+" ( &'( ) & .  &'(  5  ++-  ))   -(  A- )  ) -)  ()( * ,,3" %* *#$$%(34


,) +,() ''0(

0  )., * (  "    -('  ( A-  ) +--   ) )) #!*8*#$$7"++,,2 .&'(56,4,):*!*#$$7 )+(-)3+)-) 3(&-,") 2 .&'(56,()-)'-,+) ( )B)3-(03 +)-+( (++,4+),(' (- ;*7*#$ %* ())",)-,(++,, -

)(,,(++,,() +,)(  3'0  ).,  )"  ("  (  ++,  ()    ))  ---*  ( ,)&-,,+)-)(-)3-) (.,-()(++,4")',3")+) (0'  ---*42,**" *7*#$ %"4

-'(((-(,3++,, &'() & .  &'(  5  ++-  ()   +,)  (       4(  ++,,  2 .  &'(  5  6,  ()   +,)  (       *  )',3"  (  - )),'(++,>(' !*7*#$ %* () )",)-,(++,,+-++)-'(   ).- *    *8*#$ %"  ,)  -,    (  ++,, ++)  (  -  (    +  (  -"  (  +  ()


  ,3,)( *&- A-,3"+3&+, 4 3  B-)  3  ('4  &'(       (.  &'( -(C'  (  4> .4  =-       +   4(  ( ++,,"4(4, -(,-,)-,D )+3 + ))4+,))B-

>#*
()))B-) 4((++,,( ))& *&-)=-")-'(>>,4.-)> (. &'(?))@)4.-)>6.4&'(?))@) & * .4=-4('4&'( (.&'( (  ("  )  )-,3  4)  3  (  0,,'  &+(  ) + ,(0,,'") )( ((+

',,3,)(),)( 4(((*(3 (0)0'((D ,3)) )

4( )& *&-)=-")-'(>>,4.-)  (.&'()4)4.-)6.4&'((')) (  ( (  -  0 ( + ,)

)"()+- 4(+ (      ,3  ,0)*  -("  4(0      ( + -(-)-,(" 3 ')"4(("(4,,(0 .*&((,+)-) +(+3()()) ,(()3*
-(-)&7$8)7#:
"


4(("(++,,)0),4-,,3 +-) ,

-(-  + 0) 4(+ 2    )    )    )   (  A--     +)-+(++,,* ((+,,3,)((*(3 (0). (-))00 ,( (3 (0  ,3,)( * --( + ",, 4,,, 4(4+*(3(00)0' (-(( ))' ')(, -*   +(-)3  +)-) 3 (,) &-," (++,, &'()& .5 ++-() -)'-,+)3" ())3 4(++,,2 .

3(

-,,3"(0(++,,(0-


")) 3(,-"-+(,)*( (++,,,,(-)-)( ,)3-)' 3( *(,'4(( )-,,- )* (++,")',3")+)*
)
%"'"

"


* + , - 
.(
./  #$+0!