High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3899/2014dismissed

Gurbachan Singh v. Tarsem Lal

2015-12-04Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*

+ ,-."&/")0')1/ 2 $#'#')$- 3$-(,( "-($45"6 2$(7)%$)# * 85 0

-$($)#* - 05"66'9 %:&"#$ -#/$7$#'#')$- - ";,(/,7#"9 %:&"#$ -#/$-$(7)%$)# <<<

=/$#/$- -$7-#$-( 6&"6 7"7$-( 4"; .$ "66>$% # ($$#/$?,%14$)#@

.$-$ $--$%##/$-$7-#$-(-)#@!0 =/$#/$- #/$ ?,%14$)# (/,6% .$ -$7-#$% ') #/$ %'1$(#@ <<<

55 -"6 3'%$ -%$- %"#$% +

9 $)# )#-66$-9 5,%/'")"9/"%-%$-$%$:'&#') #/$#$)")#7$#'#')$-9 -/$ /"%&$"($%#&&,7;#/$%$4'($%7-$4'($('$"(/79>/'&/

-4(7"-# 7-7$-#;AB90/"/7,-"%95,%/'")"

($:$)")"77$"67-$ $--$%"1"')(##/$("'%-%$- "'6$%")% >"( %'(4'(($% :'%$ ?,%14$)# %"#$%

9 #$)")# '( .$ -$#/'(&,-# -'$ 6;9 #/$ &"($ ($# ,# ') #/$ $?$&#4$)# 7$#'#') >"(C'( #/"# #/$ #$)")# /"% &$"($% # &&,7; #/$ %$4'($% 7-$4'($(&)#'),,(6; -4-$#/") ,-4)#/(>'#/,#"); -$"()".6$ &",($ ) "&#9 #/$ 7-$4'($( >"(C'( 6;')1 6&D$% (')&$$.-,"-;9 B9")%#/$#$)")#/"%(/'

#$%/'(.,(')$((

# (/7 9 ,-, ")"D 476$E9 - ,??"- "6 "%9 5,%/'")" ) %$ $)&$9 '# >"( 76$"%$%9 ')#$- "6'"9 #/"# )$'#/$- #/$#$)")#/"%&$"($%#&&,7;#/$(/7')%'(7,#$)-#/$ ("4$>"(6;')16&D$%(')&$$.-,"-;9 B/$#$)")#>"( &)%,&#')1"6#/.,(')$((')#/$7-$4'($(,)%$-#/$)"4$ ")% (#;6$F GC( ?")#" $E#'6$H # >"( %$)'$% #/"# /$ /"% (/'

#$%/'(.,(')$((#(/7 9,-,")"D476$E9 - ,??"-"6"%95,%/'")" ) " &)('%$-"#') #/$ 4"##$- ') '((,$ ")% #/$ $:'%$)&$ ) -$&-%9 .#/ #/$ ",#/-'#'$( &)&,--$)#6; &)&6,%$% #/"# 6")%6-%"-($4 5"6 = "77$"-$% ') (,77-# /'(&6"'4")%7-:$%/'(&"($5'D$>'($9/'(#/$- #> >'#)$(($(9 )"4$6;9 "6 I'(/") = ")% 0,(/'6 I,4"- =9 "6( &--.-"#$% #/$ &"($ ($# ,# ') #/$ $?$&#4$)# 7$#'#')0,(/'6I,4"-95>$- ':'(')6$-D ,)?".0#"#$ 6$&#-'&'#; "-% =9 #$(#'

'$% #/"# #/$ &)(,47#') $6$&#-'&'#;J,"4$#$-0I

K+>"()4')"6 6#/,1/9 ') /'( &-(($E"4')"#')9 /$ = %$7($% #/"# #/$ ("'% 4$#$->"(')(#"66$%').,'6%')19>/$-$"(#/$%$4'($% 7-$4'($( -4$%7"-# 7-7$-#;B &&-%')16;9'#>"( 4"')#"')$%.;#/$6")%6-%#/"##/$("'%>'#)$((>"(>):$- .; #/$ #$)")#) "); &"($9 #$)")# &,6% "6>";(7-%,&$ #/$ $6$&#-'&'#;.'66(#7-:$#/"##/$7-$4'($(>"(')%$$%'),($ "#/$-9')/'(&-(($E"4')"#')9/$&)&$%$%#/"#/$/"%)#

.-,1/#");$6$&#-'&'#;.'66( 6#/,1/9#/$-$&-%(,44)$% .;#/$#$)")# -4#/$)&4$"E $7"-#4$)#>"(7-:$%"( E=CB9.,#)#/')1&,6%.$%$&'7/$-$%#/$-$ -4#') $- #/"##/$#$)")#>"(#-")("&#')1");.,(')$((')#/$7-$4'($( 04,&/(9#$)")#/'4($6 "%4'##$%')/'((#"#$4$)##/"##/$

'-4 >"( -$1'(#$-$% ') #/$ ;$"- BKBB9 .,# /$ /"% )# .-,1/#");-$&-%#(/>#/"#/$')%$$%>"(>-D')1')#/$ 7-$4'($( -4 B#

$"6(&)&$%$%#/"#/$&,6% )##$66"(# -4>/4/$/"(.$$).,;')1#/$6#/#-,) /'(.,(')$((0#'66 ,-#/$-9 )'6I,4"-= "%4'##$%')/'( &-(($E"4')"#') #/"# #/$ #$)")# /"% " (/7 "# - ,??"- "6 "% >/$-$9 /$ >"( 7,-7-#$% # /":$ (/' #$% /'( .,(')$(( /":$ /$"-% 6$"-)$% &,)($6 - #/$ 7"-#'$( ")% 7$-,($%#/$-$&-% /$ "-1,4$)# .$')1 "%:")&$% .; 6$"-)$% &,)($6

-#/$7$#'#')$-#/"##/$),(#7-:$#/"##/$#$)")#/"% ')%$$% &$"($% # &&,7; #/$ 7-$4'($( (#-' 6"; ,7) #/$ 6")%6-%9 >/'&/ /$ "'6$% # %'(&/"-1$9 6"&D( &):'&#') ")% &"))# .$ &,)#$)")&$% 5'D$>'($9 -$6'")&$ 76"&$% ,7) " %$&'(') #/'(&,-#')

K $)#B 9%$()# "%:")&$#/$&"($ #/$#$)")#".'#9"('(.$')1%$4)(#-"#$% /$-$')"

#$- &,-($9 #/$-$ &"))# .$ "); J,"--$6 >'#/ #/$ 7-7('#')#/"##/$.,-%$) 7- 9#7-:$#/"##/$#$)")#

/"% &$"($% # &&,7;9 '( ,7) #/$ 6")%6-%9 >/'&/ /$ "77"-$)#6; %'(&/"-1$% /$ &"($ ($# ,#9 ') ) ,)&$-#"') #$-4(9 .; #/$ 6")%6-% >"( #/"# #/$ #$)")# /"% &$"($% # &&,7;#/$7-$4'($(>$ $.-,"-;9 B#'66#/$')(#'#,#') #/$ $:'&#') 7$#'#') )

5")%6-% '$ "-($4 5"6 = "77$"-$%')(,77-# /'(&6"'4")% ,66;7-:$%/'( &"($5'D$>'($90"#7"6")("6 = #$(#'

'$%#/"##$)")#/"% (')&$&$"($%#&&,7;#/$7-$4'($(")%#/$&)%'#') #/$ (/7 >"( ."%6; $

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

9 >/'6$

+ &)%,&#')1");(,&/.,(')$((#?,(##/"#9/$"6( "'6$%# 7-%,&$ "); $6$&#-'&'#; .'66 # (/> #/"# #/$-$ >"( " -$1,6"- ")% )-4"6 &)(,47#') $6$&#-'&'#; # -,) "); (,&/ .,(')$(( 5'D$>'($9 )#/')1 >"( .-,1/# ) -$&-% # (/> #/"##/$#$)")#>"($:$)"(('(#$%.;");(#"

-$476;$$(# #-")("&#.,(')$(( )%#/"#>"()$:$-#/$&"($($#,#.;#/$ #$)")##/"#/$>"("7$##;(/7D$$7$-")%>"(9#/,(9)$'#/$- 4"')#"')')1 "); "&&,)#( )- .'66 .D( # -$ 6$&# /'( ("6$( ")% 7- '#( /"# .$')1 (9 #/$ )6; ")% #/$ ')$:'#".6$ &)&6,(') )$ &,6% -$"&/ >"( #/"# #/$ #$)")# /"% ')%$$% &$"($%#&&,7;#/$%$4'($%7-$4'($( 1-,)%'(4"%$,##')#$- $-$>'#/#/$-%$-( .$')1 "(("'6$%9 ') $E$-&'($ -$:'(')"6 ?,-'(%'&#')9 ,)%$- 0$&#') ++ #/$"(# ,)?".-.")$)#$(#-'&#') &#9

$#'#').$')1%$:'% 4$-'#'("&&-%')16;%'(4'(($% $&$4.$-9

+ "?") -,) "66' ,%1$