← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4183/2016allowed

M/S Mkl Publicity And ANR. v. M/S A.N.S. Construction Ltd.

2019-01-30Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan3 pages



       

   !"#$"%&'&()

* +,'+-. /01&%&!2 ($ (!3"  "!&!&("'

   4   +,'('!/%!&(.!$ "'5($"(!

+)  6.+   -.

"'"(!) + ($""5 7$8% !"7#!3"5"!&!&(" + 9 ( (' 17$8% !"7#!3""'5($"(!  :::::::

 -.7;

.< 3"  5"'"(!  5"!&!&(  &'  $&"%!"$  = &('!  !3"  $"  $ !"$

 

75 ''"$02!3"&8&1/$=";/(&&8&'&(<7 1 ($3 7'!&>&(= ##!3"5"!&!&("'6$"#"(%"#3 8&(=(!#&1"$?&!!"('! !"@"(!?&!3&( (&("!2$ 2'#3 8&(=5/!&( 55"  (%" 3"  # %!'7  &(  0&"#7  ?3&%3  "  "A/&"$  !  0"  (!&%"$  # $9/$&% !&(=/5(!3"5"'"(!5"!&!&( "!3 !!3""'5($"(!#&1"$ '/&! '"">&(=!3""&("%8"2#

7, 1(=?&!3&(!""'! (0"&(=5/!! (!&%"7!3"5"!&!&("'7?3?""$"#"($ (!'&(!3"'/&!7( 

55" "$0"#"!3"& 1/! ($'/=3!!&@"##&1&(=?&!!"('! !"@"(! 3"" #!"7!3"@ !!"? ' $9/("$#

B ($ 

B( ?3&%3$ !"'(?&!!"('! !"@"(!? '#&1"$02!3"5"!&!&("' (!3"("C! $ !"0"#"!3"& 1/!&"

!3"5"!&!&("'#&1"$ ( 551&% !&( #!3"&''/ (%"#$&"%!&('!!3""'5($"(!,51 &(!&##!'/5512%"! &( $%/@"(!'!"( 01"!3"5"!&!&("'!#&1"!3"&?&!!"('! !"@"(! 3 ! 551&% !&(? ' 11?"$(

&(5/'/ (%"#?3&%3!3"5"!&!&("'

?""'/551&"$!3""A/&'&!"$%/@"(!'3"" #!"(!3"("C!$ !"0"#"

DE !3"& 1/!&" 

'&(%"!3"5"!&!&("'$&$(!#&1"!3"&?&!!"( '! !"@"(!7  %'!'  ?""  &@5'"$  /5(  !3"@   ('"A/"(!127  !3/=3  !3" &@5/=("$$"$ !"$  

!3"5"!&!&("'6$"#"(%"? '$""$!0"

'!/%>###3 8&(=(!#&1"$!3"?&!!"('! !"@"(! ." ("$%/('"1#!3"5 !&"'3 8"0""(3" $ 3"#&'!$ !"##&1&(=#?&!!"('! !"@"(!02!3"5"!&!&("' ? '

B(?3&%3$ !" ' 1'(!3"("C!$ !"0"#"!3"& 1/! &" 

B(?&!!"('! !"@"(!? '#&1"$02!3"@ '!3"2$&$(!3 8" !3""A/&'&!"$%/@"(!'##&1&(=# ("##"%!&8"?&!!"('! !"@"(! (!3" ("C!$ !"0"#"!3"& 1/!&"

 ( 551&% !&(? '#&1"$02 !3"5"!&!&("''"">&(=#@!3""'5($"(!,51 &(!&##!'/5512!!3"@!3" "A/&'&!"$%/@"(!''!3 !!3"2%/1$#&1"!3"&?&!!"('! !"@"(!7?3&%3 $%/@"(!'?""'/5512!!3"@(

 !&'!/"!3 ! #!"'/%3 $%/@"(!'  3 $  0""(  '/551&"$  02  !3"  "'5($"(!  !  !3"  5"!&!&("'  ( 

!&11  

&"# 0/!!?@(!3''!3"5"!&!&("'$&$ (!#&1"!3"&?&!!"('! !"@"(!($&$!3"2$"5'&!!3" ? $"$%'!'0/! '/%31 5'"(!3"&5 !$"'(!?  (!!3""C!"@" ($3 '3'!"5# '!&>&(=##!3"&$"#"(%" (8&"?#!3" 08"# %!'?3&%3 "5"%/1& !!3"5"'"(!% '" ($&(1&("?&!3!3"5&(%&51"'#( !/ 19/'!&%" ' 1'#!3"" '(!3 !!3" 5"!&!&("'@ 2(!0"5"%1/$"$#@0&(=&(=("%$!3"&?&!!"( $"#"(%"7 #!"'"!!&(= '&$"!3"&@5/=("$$" ($'/09"%!!5 2@"(!# B

, '%'!'7!0"5 &$02!3"5"!&!&("'!!3""'5($"(!7!3" 5"!&!&("' "= (!"$("?"">6'!&@"#@!$ 2!#&1"!3"&?&!!"( '! !"@"(!

DE 3""C"@51 2%'!'#B

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

* D -.E '3 @'3"    F3"!3"'5" >&(=," '("$ ) "', F3"!3""5! 01"

)"',