High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/41/2012allowed

Narender Nath Puri v. Satish Kumar Kapil And ANR

2015-03-16Mr. Justice A.N. Jindal10 pages

"#$%&%'

() *( %%%%% "( +(!*!

, !)-*.(-/ 0"

)( %%%%% !/ "!

,# 1(% 02

()/ "(% 1(% 4 3 !) 2

((!/ " %% 1(%45-*.(-"!02

((!/ " %% )/ "()! "3 6 ) 4*( !

) ! *( *"

(( 07

) "! *

!6 "8 !!

)

( 7%%2/!! 95):* "8 !. !! "8)

94 "/ 0 "(.!

, "7( ; ), "'

)

3 0 *(< ="

( %%

) 0("

"0 !( * 82*(8 "2 !. !! "8)//09 "8 . " "90% %

"( "

" % >4* 8." 9 ( <= ;!

00 /0 %?2, (''2*(8 "95(5" (9"30 /." *) ( 5<

(!) (@ @=3 00 ."0( $%%??2

(

2&2>%) !

)!!9 (" * .) 4* 8."

//00 *( " 3 0//0 %'

%7%&

"&%%&95,)% %-%, " 2

"0 !( * 82*(8 "2 ) ; ))(

"!##$% "'%A%A() )/ "(8( !00) !/0 " 3 *(

(!/ " % /0 "

> () ( <= " &%'%?? " /5."

2&?> ;( !/(. *."

?2A>;) ))/ "( "

" % ) 0( 5 / ! ; ) "

)(. " "8!0 "!

( ;! 9 / ! 95(!/ " %2 " "!00."!; ) ./0 ! "

"(!/ " %%".

'>;!

/ )/ "( ;( !/(

)!0 "!

( ""

*" %%'2$>;! 9/ ) .

("!

(

)/0 3 *(

(!/ " %95 "

">(!/ " % % !!(5 !" " ;! 0!

8(" 95 (!/ " % /(. "8("!

(

)/0 95/ "( " 3 *(

(!/ " %% "8052(!/ " %28 /(/( 9"6 (

'2> "?%'%??"

3 ! / "(> "

" % %$%??9*)/ "(( *! "

! )3 ..

9()

)(.!

8(."% &% )( 0 ( )/ "( 8)!0

:* "

(8 !( "/5."

90"!0/(

)/0 ;) ) )! 0( 5 9" / "

">(!/ " % ; ) ";

")! .)

4* 8.""

/*(!/ "

% "/ !!!!

)/0 %//08 "!)4* 8."

( 0 *(;! !. !! "&%%&"

8*0(, //0< ,= 0!

!. !! " '%A%A% ) ! *( *()( 0( " ) 4* 8." '%A%A " ,) *( "8/"

)!* ) / "( / ! "5.

*"; ) 2)!.!)000!

9 / 95)/0 "

)/ "( "

" %!/((.!"

)8(."% % ) :* " //0 " <"":*( &= !

$%'%'"

94 "!;( 0 95/ "( "$%'%? %% ( !

,%"):* "//0 "(!/ " % ) . /(5(

(("!

(

)/0 "B*! " ")".

() ( ( / !

)90"!0/( ") *(%) / "(/(5

!. !!0

):* ")8( *"

< = ) ) 90" .

*" ;! "

/ !

; ) ") . ( 95( 0 *( ") 4* 8.""

//0

(:"!

.;! 0 < = )(!/ " % !0!

0 90 /5"

'2>/0*!).

*";) )) / "() / ! ; ) C < = ) * "

" / !

*"; ) ") .! /*0 "( 8! (! "

(.!

, "A

),/ 0 % ")(/052(!/ " %! ));!(B* ( /5 "05 .

'2$> )/ "(;) ))(!/ ") 0;5!

9"( 5"

; 00 "8 /5% '% )3)( 0(" *"!0

()/( !"

/(*! ) ./*8" (!/!! 959 )) *(!90 ;!;00!)//(

6%)30!

8 ")( *8))4* 8."

//00 *(;) ) !

(

,&$2 95) ! "'%A%A% $% D(" *"!0

()/ "(3)."05 ""

) ) 94 "! 0 95 / "( ;( !*// ! )3 9"

00 ; " (.!

, " A

) ,/ 0 2 ?$& <)( " ( ( (( ! @) @=2 !/ 005 ;)" )( ;! "

//0 0 95(!/ " %

(!6 "8:"!

. 8(" 95)( 0 ( "8(!/ " % / ! ) .

*"; ) "/(

;

")! .)

/!! "8

(% D(" *"!0

()/ "( *()(!*9. ))(;!"

:* "

) ( *( "8 ) /"

, "

)(

(2))*8 05 " / ! "8).

*" *0 "

)39"

:/0 " 95) () (%;!!*9. )(!/ " %

() (.

3 "//0

() (! . "7%7% 9

():* "8 *(; )/(5( / ! ."

( ;) ) ;

*0 !*88!)) () (

./05; ))(.!

(/!! 95)( 0 *(% 7% , "A

)2( !!*"

!!!

"$%!# !

"#!

& ' !#(

(#!

& %% )#*( +"

+", ' !+& +"& "%#

& -''

'#!

.".

<=E)( ""5!* (

!/ /(

(."

()!0 (0!

390 /( /(5 )! 9" . "

) /*()!( (0!!

2; ) ")/(

00 ;

95) ( (!*) *()(/(

!) *(.5 00 ;2/5)/*()!.

"5 )(!*.;) ))

*()! ( ) . /52)3"

(0!!

(.5 //05 ")!.!* ";) )) ( !. 2

)3) "((! "

"!*)//0 ) *(.5295 (2(! "

"( )(!

(!(8( !)/(5 " *0 (0 8)(2!) 4*!

)!.5(B* (% <= E)( "( !(! "

(!*9 ! <=2) *( <= !)00 ()/*()!( ()0!!2

))! 9 " / !!!!

)/( /(5 *"

( ) "(2 (! ( !*) / !!!!

" )3"

(0!!

(C"

<9= .5 ( /5." ) 3"

( 0!!

00)("!"

!;) ) )3(* "(!/

)/( /(5

.) ";) )/ !!!!

";!!

9 " 95)/*()!( (0!!*" 0 (! (

/ !!!!

" )3"

0!!

(2"

)4*!

)!!

(B* (!2)( *"

"5!*./ 95

)3"

()0!!!("!.

/ ! " "" "; )) "(% <&= ) /*()!( ( 0!! /5! ) /*()! .

"5 )(!*.;) )) ! ( /5 *"

() (; ) ")/(

( (( "

!*9 ! "<=2) *(.52 "//0 . ")!.!* 2;( )/*()!( 0!!!*) *()((0 !).59" 0

2 "0* "8 "//( /( !!00 ("5

)

; "8(0 !2".05# <= ):*

/( /( "35" 0!95)3"

(0!!

(C <9= ) 0 3(5

/ !!!!

"2 (/( ""

!/(/ !!!!

)/( /(5 ") :*

!*) "35" (0!% <= !/(!* "(!/

"5(0 ;) ) .590 . *"

() !! "!)000 ) "!"

(2/*()!(20!!

(0!!2 !)!.59% <'= ) !!

"5/( "8!*"

() !! !)009 ") !(

*(%F A% D(" / "(@! *"!0(0 */ ".

"8 )() !0;(/ ( "

%&'

(

( '

?% ") )()"

20(" *"!0

((!/ " %

() ((0 */

%$)* $+,-

+(/

+"'

)" + "

$,01" % (( '

% "

"@90,*/(. 9!(3 ), A

) ((!/ ! , "&'<=

),/ 0 2 A77*"

(;) ) ;! /" )3"

(0!!

()( 8) !6 (! !!

"C9*) !, "8 ! *()("

8 3! )3"

(0!!

)( 8) !6(! !!

" ")!.!* 2;)" ()!*

!/ /(

(." ! ( )/0 "

0! /5)/*()! .

"5; ) ")/(

: %) "@90,*/(. *()()0

!*"

(# '(

% )

, )

- . )%

. /

* *

(

1 * /

2 % )(

(2 !; ) ") !(

) *(;)() .( !/"

"8 )( 8(":"!

(.6 "8/5."

)90".

(

((! !!

!*) !( " !"

:( ! " 3 *(

)/ "(%)(

(2 )0(" ( 0 *(;!B* "

(( " ! 9!(3 ". ") ./*8" () *0 "

8 9) "

) )! 9 :* " "; )0;% )( 0 *(;!0!

(( " 9!(3 "8)) 94 "!( ! 95)/ "()3 0( 59" " 3 0!* "?%'%&% )//00 *(

( ! ./05)0 )//0 !"

. " "90"

2)(

(2)/ "( )!9" /( 3

)( 8) .6!*9. !!

"! ")B*! ;))() "( !0 90 9(! "

" / !

) .

*"; ) " .

() () ( 0 .))/(

( 8 "005 :

./0 " .5 9:"

()(03" (*.!"! 3(;) ))0" ( 0 *(>:* "8 *()!

//05 !4* 0. "

%)!0 )!! "9":* "*052 9*);! *( "8/"

)//0;) );!)0 9 . " "909*)( !"

!/ (956 "800)(03"

! " "!

( "9 *):"!

. " / ! "8) .

*"%)0(" ( 0

!*!!)(03"!0; )!*94% % ")

(! (*.!"!2) "!"/ " !00 ;

) ./*8" ( ! ! !

; ) ( " ) ( 0 *(>:* "8 *( ).( (!) " "; )0;

950

6 "8 " "8! "). "4* 8."8(" "8) ( /!! 95)( 0 *(C) 9!(3 "!

)//00 *(3 ;) ) ) !/ ( "! ;( 8 3" "

)

9!(3 "!. 95) ! *( ")4* 8." '%A%A/!!

" !

"!##$;)(95 ;!0( ) *( "8/"

!* )/ "( / ! "5.

*"; ) 2)!.!)000!

9/ 95)/0 "

)/ "( "

" %!/((.!"

)8(." /( .) )((03" ! "

(*.!"!% &% ) /( ! ( ( //( 9

( ) ( 0

*(>:* "8 "7%%'%, ").( !B* 2) ( 0>:* "8 *( ;

*0 !/ !

) .( :/ *!05 "

/( (905 ; ) "/(

$ .

")! .)

( /

( /5

) ! (% #"'

1/2