Mukhtiar Singh Etc. v. State Of Hy.
! " # %&''&$ ( )*+ ""(, -./ +32-2 $$$''&& 4 0 + 5 $$$ '6 7$ () ""(, -./ $$$
4 0 +32-2 $$$ '6 ! "#$ %&'($ (' ) #
.
$+062 +2 %!67!
2''&& $ ( )*+ ""($ .
$ %8 2 !67!
2'
$ () ""($ .
$&.2!! 5!
2+$ 99999 (' ) #*% 2 6 %2&&6':!$$! %& ''&$ ( )*+ ""(6 7$ () ""(2 %27 0%%;063%$2 31 % %&''&$ ( )*+ ""($ 2'
''&2 &6 52''&&32 ;063% 7 66 "#$"<$ ""( 6 6 66
$"<$ ""(! :2 5 2 ''&&*06 27 6 32&&:3 * + ,- +. .
+
/
(- ,.
("< 6:2 =>
75 """?*2 + 5
=#
:5 @""?*2 + A%2 ( ( 6:2 => A%2 @"?*2 + %2 :7 !:%6& 2&&2:0&6 0 0
&5$ 22'
0 2 $"<$ >>)!
'2 01 %26 !%0& +32;0 6:
66222:%'&56 B,- /' % 2%$&3:2
%+326.2 +32: 332
7&&32%#$(".$B225 26 0+6+ &!25 06 :%3 % 16:22+0 2! 6 +57 %6 :2 22! 06 &: %6 :2 ;&&!
06 12 %6:2A: 3$25''62
.2 +32$0 2 2 %%!25 6 &&1 2.2 032& ' 5 660&33 2 &3! 0' :22 25 26 .2 +32 :2 2
'7:'$ 02;0 !2&&6:$02!
230&&6:62%:
1 5206$ 06 +576 12&162%'&6 ' 2 65$%'&' 5 6!:220% ' 32 62'632%!06' &6 %2'$ +32 : 26 2% :2 2 : %6&&5 A%6$
%'&2 %&! ($" $ >><206 : 2 32606 +("<?( (? =#? => !:2225 66'&630&56&%6 &$ 2'
00'' !A%6 B* +0 22 26 ! B* $$$ ! B*( $8$2 5! B*= ;7 33 :&! B*@ $+$$ ! B*)+20! B*< ;6 +32! B* #20'+32! B*>0& +32! B* ".2 +32! B* + +32 6 B* ;7 .&2 6 & 6 6 76 60% 576$ +% 06 06 + ( ( 2 6
60 : 66!:2 2566&&2 %3 76?% & '0 2% 6 & 66 2 &&3 &7&&6 32%$25: &&60'&62 76! 076 6:&6$ 2 &0 !'
'6 &660% 76!7666206!6 7$ .
$+062 +2 %!& 60& '
32''&& 0 %6 2 2 & 0
6 &: 6 63 2 72''&&2 : 660A'&66&5 &6332 $2 0 %52'
02 7 &16$.012 +32''&&26& 76 * %;0 2262%'&' 5$26;0 %6A'&6 2 2 &636 50& +32 5.2 +32$ :A6622 &0 26%%6
'&3 & 0' 2 '
0 76! ' 0& &5 2 %0& B*>6.2 B* "!:2:
0
&5 6 0% &&56 '25: &3 &2 *06 +("<!( (6(= 6 < %$ B*> 6 B* "%6%'
7% %2 '&%!2 !
6 3 0 & &$ ;0 &&36&5 76 5 .012 +32
%6A'&6 52'
0!20! &262 B*>6
B* ": 33 $ 2 &0 6&&3&&53732
&*62''&&$ 2%.012 +32''&&%62
A$ .?(! 2 ! 2 7&7% %6 0 0 &&5 %'&6 2 '
$ 2 : 3 %7 2 %'&' 512 ''&&$ 2%6&7666 0''
2 0& %5 2 &2%$ 7 2 06.012 +32''&&62:&&5 2: 6 732 2 &7%$ 2''&&!' 2065 !27& 65 32&&:3' 6&06306506 & *
"
# +0 2 > ( &: "
"
@ = .3&+32 "
> @ +5: # ) 12 ( ) # 22 26!.
$&.2!& 6'0567 &! 50'' 62'
0 5 5322;0 0 6 50& +326.2 +3227 60&5'
76 %6&766!20!'
56 6%&2''&$ 272 62& 60& 2' !''
62 '' 1! 620 &:627:22
1
6% 20 %2& 60& 2''&&! !
2'
0'
7627&7%2''&&*062 %%2$.2 B* "3727 2 6:22230* 06$ 73;0 !2 % 00 0 36 00 .6& &&3! 21 :2 2'& 662%$2''&0 %6 52 +2 '
76A$ .? $2'
03!.2 &0 6;0 !20322%0& 66 2'&2'&!666%62.012 06:6 732 006 + ) $$62 +32:6 732 $ 2 6 $"<$ >>) #$(" .$ 2 ''&&* 0627 &%10&*62;0 &&36&50 6 52% %60'
76! !:22%'& 2.012 +32:&636!2&&36;0 &6 0'2% 5.2 +3260& +3227 %6$ '52.C A$ 6263 %A$ ? 2:32& 2;0 2 '
76$;0 $(!=6@: 6& 663 0 &60&62706622 6 50 &2 7%:' 60'$ '26 A$ ? $ +32:' 6 $"<$ >>) 50 +0 3 76 6 6 1 A$ ! :22 2 66 5 ;7 33 :& B*=$:62 36 $"<$ >>)$&&!.012
+320626 76;0 2%7 5& !:252 :2622'&%%6&5$' .C !2:
032 2%@$ " .6:%6&&5A%6@$(@ .$+02
6&5 0626$2 :2033'2 6&&36&50
6#$(".$ :7 !1'37:22''&&27& 65 32' 6 %66232 062 270 2;&!26;02&& %2 ''&& 62' 6& 6506 3 52%$ 2 ''&&: & 36 & 520 76 6 66">$"#$ ""= 62527 : 66%A%0%75 $+!:2& 0'2&63272''&&!25 62' 6 & 65 06 3 5 2%$ %& ''& $ ( )*+ ""( 6'62 %6 %$D0&5! 7 $ () ""(&6%6$ +.
*3 (' ) #
%&67$ )5 .5 4
89: 4 - ;
4:
)5 .5
.2
;
4: