Mahender Ram v. Sardul Singh
!" #"$%&%'( ) *
+ ,"'#"- . /"!%!%'"- 0"-&1& 2 -#132%'4, /"&5'#"'! ( 6 72 77 -"&"'!( -2 ..18 #9$ !" -!,"5"!%!%'"- -2 ':""915! 8 #9$ !" -!,"-"&5'#"'! ;;; <,"!,"- -"5-!"-& 3$ 3 5 5"-& . = >" 33?"# ! &""!,":1#4."'!@
>"-"
"--"#!!,"-"5-!"-&-'!@ A <,"!,"- !," :1#4."'! &,13# >" -"5-!"# %' !," #%4"&!@ ;;;
77 - 3 0%#" -#"- >"%'4 && %3"#
*8 -"'#"-"# >= %9%3 1#4" - %9'8 2%-& 8 !," 553%$ !%' .9"#>=!,"5"!%!%'"-81'#"-2"$!%') %9%3-$"#1-" #"8 &""B%'4 "C!"'&%' !%." ! #"5&%! !," > 3 '$" & 3" $'&%#"- !%'8 %' !"-.& !," :1#4."'! '# #"$-"" # !"#
8, &&%'$">""'#"$3%'"# ' ' 553%$ !%'.9"#>=!,"5"!%!%'"-53 %'!%
8%! ? &. %'! %'"#!, !!,"&1%! %3"#>=,%.? &#"$-""#>=!," !-% 3$1-!'
8 '#,"? &#%-"$!"#!#"5&%!!," > 3 '$"& 3"$'&%#"- !%'?%!,%'+# =&8 %3%'4?,%$,&1%! !," 5"!%!%'"-53 %'!%
&, 33 &! '# #%&.%&&"# 3 %'!%
, 55"'"#!>" '%33%!"- !"5"-&' '#?,"'!,". !!"-? &
5-'1'$"#%'!,"$1-!8%!? &'3=," -#>=!,"$3"-B ,%& $1'&"3"!%!%'"-53 %'!%
? &'"9"-%'
-."# !," !" ,%& &1%! - !," #"$-"" 5 &&"# %' ,%& 91- ?"9"-8 &1>&"E1"'!3=,%&$1'&"3 55-%&"#,%. !,":1#4."'!# !"#
,"-"
-"8 ''#"5&%! > 3 '$" & 3" $'&%#"- !%' ? & >' %#" .%&! B" ' !," 5 -! !," 5"!%!%'"- ' -"&5'&"8 %! ? & 53" #"#8 %'!"- 3% 8 !, ! !," #"$-""5 &&"#>=!,"!-% 3$1-!'
? &$'#%!%' 3 %' ' !1-" '# !,1&8 5- ="- - "C!"'&%' !%." $ ''! >" 4- '!"# ' $'&%#"- !%' !,". !!"-%'%&&1"8!,"!-% 3 $1-!#"$3%'"#!,"5- ="- '#$'$31#"# &!,1&(
!
A "
#
$%$ &
'
(
$
)
, 9" ," -# 3" -'"# $1'&"3 - !," 5 -!%"& '# 5"-1&"#!,"5 5"->B ' #1" '# !,14,!
13 $'&%#"- !%' !," . !!"-%'%&&1"8 . !,"$'&%#"-"#9%"?!, !!,"-"9%&%' 5"!%!%' %& ?,33= #"9%# ."-%! '# %& !,1& 3% >3" ! >" #%&.%&&"# -!,"-" &'&!, ! -">"%'4-"$-#"#,"-"%' !"- '$"#"#3=8!,"#"$-""# !"#
8-" #& & !,1&( +
& &
# &
, - C
$%"8 !," #"$-""
? & $'#%!%' 3%'' !1-" '#&%'$"!,"5"!%!%'"- %3"#!#"5&%! !,"> 3 '$"& 3"$'&%#"- !%'?%!,%'!,"&!%513 !"#!%."8,%& &1%!&!##%&.%&&"#%'!"-.& !,"& %##"$-"",%&$1-!8%' "&, . 2%'4, '# !,"-& 9 '., ' 2%'4, F"'! '# !,"-& GA D*) 8 #"$%#"# ' A *)+H8 -"5-!"# & *)+ 7 D)8?,%3"$'&%#"-%'4!,"&$5" "C!"'&%' !%."1'#"-2"$!%') #" %9%3-$"#1-"9%&I9%&!," $'#%!%' 3#"$-""8$'$31#"# &!,1&(
+
$ + + ./ 0
1 $
$
2
/0 +
3 + 4' $
+ *&
+ % . / 0
+
$% $ $
+ ( ./ 0 5 6
$
7" -'"#$1'&"3 -!,"5"!%!%'"-$13#'!$%!" '= #"$%&%' ! !," $'!- -= '$"#"#3=8 !"- !," !-% 3 $1-! #"$3%'"# !," 5- ="- !," 5"!%!%'"- 9%#" -#"- 1'#"- $, 33"'4"8 ," 5-"
"--"# ' 55" 3 4 %'&! !," -%4%' 3 #"$-""
,"& %# 55" 3%"%9%3 55" 3 *
*? &#%&.%&&"#'
>"%'4> --"#>=!%."!%& '! #%&51!"# !, ! !," :1#4."'! -"'#"-"# %' !," & %# 55" 3 ? & '"9"- && %3"# '= 1-!,"- '# !," & ." , & &%'$" !! %'"# %' 3%!= ! ? & 5&! #%&.%&& 3 !," & %# 55" 3 '
8 5"!%!%'"- !,"' $,&" ! %3" !," 5-"&"'! -"9%&%' && %3%'4!,"-#"-# !"#
*%" !"- 3.&!A=" -&
"!, ! &%!. =
7" -'"# $1'&"3 - !," 5"!%!%'"- $13# '! 5%'! 1! &!,?!,"$'$31&%' --%9"# !>=!,"!-% 3$1-!? & "%!,"-$'!- -=!!,"5&%!%''-"$-#-&1
"-"# -. '= . !"-% 3%33"4 3%!= '!,"? B" !,"5&%!%'8 &&B"!$,"#1! >9"8 ' %'!"- "-"'$" %& ? -- '!"#8 %' "C"-$%&" -"9%&%' 3 :1-%&#%$!%' 1'#"- 2"$!%' + %9%3 -$"#1-" #" "!%!%'>"%'4#"9%# ."-%!%& $$-#%'43=#%&.%&&"# 2"5!".>"-)8
+ : ' -1' 33% 1#4"