Jaspal Singh Tiwana And ANR v. Mohinder Singh Sandhu And ORS
!"# $%& '( )*!
+ !
','-./0'''1'(/2 ((2 3 %/12-./-'1/4'1(/2 ,1( %*
!
"
#
$$$$
%!& ( ") *) "*!) - . /. 1 - +, (, ((
2
%"& 3 ( 4 !
(
( (( (
! # 0 !
# 5
# (
6
2 (( "* *8 !99:
;
6 *" *< "**"
;
(
= ( *8 *8 "**"
;
( ") !! "**:
( !
"9 *9 "**94!" !" "**9 %#& 0 ! # ( ( :) > ? / @ @1
04
(
- 3 55A0 - *<#!*) *<#!*:
+ #* *< "**"
B !5 8* ( *<#!*< #* *< "**"
B #8 5* ( (((,
;
6 !5<8
( .( 0 , *! *< "**"
#* *9 "**"
(, 3 @ 3 ?
( - 3 !<A- - ;
3 #55<)
*! *< "**"
#* *9 "**"
+ ( C0B B !!
(
!9 *8 "**"
;
( ,
, C0B (
+ , 0 #
B :8*****4A
+ ;
(
= ;
( B "# ( ( C0B B ""
( + ;
!9 *8 "**"
+ , (
( %5& ' ( #* *# "*!) (( ( ( #
%)& D *" *) "*!) ( ( #4 "
D+6 2
"
( ( ( 4 !
+6
(( 2 2
D !8 B ( -- D !# B ( -- %:& ' ( ") *) "*!) (, ((
2 +6 ( '
( + %<& E ( +
, ( (, (( +6 2 ( E
= , +( 2 ( ( , ; ( (
2 ,
:) > ( = , 2
( C ( 2
( A
, , ?2 ( (
(,
( (
( :# (
( A
!
"
%8& E ( +
2
( @
( @ ((
!"#$$%&'()*++(*+%,$ @+( 2 (
:# ( (
+( (,
+
, >
(
+( , (,
(
,
@+( 2
9
6 ( A #$"
%
&
&
'
&
&
"
( )
"
*
"
+
( ) &
, "
( ) &
&
"
%
(
"
(
,
( "
* -.(/!0
//.( + +*123%'"4&5546
-
./
&
0
"
/
( )
* 1 / & (
&
&
' &
&
&
( ))
"
( )
&
"
*
( ) &
2
& $3 & "
&
&
&
5
"
5
"
&
"
%
"
*
&
5
6 "
"
%
""
%
5
7"
6 "
0 "
*
& 0
"
*
& 0
5
"
8
0 ' "9
%9& E ( +
(( , :)/1 D !# B ( -- (( , +
(( (( (A /1 + ( F /+1 F /1
F /1
+
((
(( . %!*& E (
,
+ ,
+ + ( ( (( ,
( .
,
(
+= (, ( ( @+( 2
/!* +!0/7*-
(*+ *!/8./ !//#$2$"9&
"!
!/&4#, , ( (
2 (
(
,
2 +6 +6
, D !# B ( --
,
B ( ) < D !# -- D < B ( !< -- ((
, %!!& E ( (, +
( @+( 2
!)! !// : 0/ +;(<*#$$2"2& "*!! /&9'3 +6
( @+( 2 ( ( +6
>
+6 + @+( 2 @ @ (, (,
%!"& D + ( ( +
( A2 (, 2
+ +
A2
> (( 2
(( (, ( :) ( +(
+, , 2 ( ( ( ( .* :
** !*! =#$2$"'&
"!
!/&,'$
!*:/! = -! =#$$3"24&
"!
!/&#%, %!#& D ( ( !
(, +
/ 1 (( 2
+ 2 ((,
(+( A2 ( %!5& > ( +
( ( %!)&
= + + @+( 2 (( + -
( + - (,
((, (+( , + '
+(
(
(( , :)/1 (( = A !
7 (( 2
+ , 2 G "
,
%!:& :# ,
( (( :#/"1 ( , ( (( :)/1 ,
( +
, 3
(+( , (
(
3
2 ( 3
(
(, (( ( 3 (
2 ( 7 +
, ,
, @+( 2
/ 1
(
(
:) ( (( %!<& !
!>(!"
+ & ? /! = #$22"#& "!
!/& 535 @+( 2 (
,
+6 ( +
(
+( A
+
,
, ( (
+( (( ,
( (( ,
, 2
2
+(
,
+
%!8&
*++
*! !
#$2,"2& "!
!/&99, @+( 2 (
( ,
(, ( ?
(( :)/1
, , ((,
( , ,
+( '
,
+ ,
+( (( +(
((, ((
,
( +( ( ,
3
,
, +( + + '
( + ,
+( (( +(
((, (( %!9&
3 , 3
( (
((,
2 3 2 (,
( +( ((
( H
, (( ( (, ( +(
+ ( ,
( ,
( ( ( ( (
, (
,
,
%"*&
(,
((
2
( ,
, (
,
:) ' ( (
= ,
:)
?, ,
,
,
:# ' , + ,
, + ( ,
(, ( , +A
:# :) %"!& @+( 2 -
((,
+ (( ( (( A 3
4545;#$2, ( @(*!
+* (*
+/! = +*@ *5 !" "*!#A #
5
"
8 7
5
"
:
"
%
'
7
"
8
'
5
"
;
<
)
"
/
5
"
*
"
*
"
*
5
"
+
5
"
%
7
"9 %""& - ( ,
(
( :)
+ ( 2
+ 2
, ( (
0+ / 1 +
!)! !//: 0/
.* :
** / 1
(( ( ( +6
+6 ( @ @ , 2 ( ( , %"#& ((,
(+(
(( 2 ( ((
= ( ((
2
+
( ( (
2
2 =
2 ( 6
( 6 2 (
D !# B ( -- ((
2 ((
( + ( ( ((
, ( %"5& +
+ 2
(, + !" "*!<
# % -& /7 7
4 I4 7 +( I4