← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3950/2018dismissed

Pardeep Kumar And ORS v. Naresh Kumar Garg And ORS

2018-08-13Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

  

               

       

   

            

          



      



 

  ! ""# $%                    

           

 

 !"#$% &'(&)*%%+!  *)) $ 

 !

"#$

%&!'



 ,,,,, %+!  *)) $-' )"  * ++ ( 



+,# + *

 !+!

 -# '

. / '

%

/

0

   " 1#0  2 3% '+ 3" 0 +  4

+  "( ,#    0 +5

#'

*

3!  0(

 

6% +

((+ '

# 7   8 # 494



  '

&'

%   " :

&'

:

 !

 #3#  '+# 34

 

5 

   +

5   (#  2 3 



+)"





++ %<  ++* ((+ '



 !     

 6  

+ (  45

 #  7    &'

       !# * " &(( ++

&# "

 *  0 !  -#30

    )"

+ #3"

   3#   4

 

545 0

++* 

; =)"

"(  (#

  ((+ '

" 4

 

++

5  4

 

5  ((+ '

+5  (#  2 3 )"

((+ '

"  ''#(5

5 ;  

+4# +

#4

%*"

"(  (#

 

)"

((+ '

"  !

#'" 4# + 3* "# # '

 '

#

 '00

 8  # 4 94



  '

&'

*"

"(  (#

 

 )"

((+ '

 +5



+5 (# 3

 ((+ '

 #

0(+5

(

%  

5*/)"

((+ '

( 0

 

<  0

  "  

  >* % #

 

# 4% ((+ '

" 

 



       * ((+ '

 "   '  

#

*

 ((+ '

  '   

 

 4#

 

50  3 0

'  "(   (#

"

"( -

"(  (#

*

((+ '

 )"

 # 0 ++ "( -

'" 

 *

((+ '

++ #"( 

4#  !

+ )"

 ((+ '

* ++ 0+ " +' #'

 '0(

" %"

* ++ ' #'

*"*0'!

++ # "( * " +

'+# 5 0% * "0

'

* ++

4#

)"

# ++

#"( "

+5# '

 (( "*0

50 3 0

* "

)"

((+ '

 + 3

((+ '

3

++ # "(!

0

)"

*"(*

((+ '

*       (     7# " ?

+% (0

 7# " ?

+ * ++ !

" "(

" "(% ((+ '

* ++

" 

4#

= # + 

 "

 ' '#

3 ,# 4

 

5 (  (#

4#



+( 0  +5 "

'#

 )"

    #40    0  45 '# + 

" 

0<  5

 



 ( 0

+5

      " 1#0  2 3 @ 

0

 "  '

  4#

((

#

 5+   7

+B # 5&  0/ *  !.

'"  !

? 0

%    A 

 5

 

"

        0  *" '" 7

/ " &33 *

'

  >  *    *

   "#  *" '"  

 #  &(++ >(

 /"(

#0 (# 3% ++ 



%* 4 5

 %  %"

(

" 

+  ++

 

   '#+

0 +5*#++ /

"  0  <  % 0 ++ * # 4%# '

'

#4    ((   (#

     4

    #

''#(

45

 4#

"  B #(( "  '

% "

   #(  -#30

  "  #         !"#$% &   '())*+,-   +&#-./*0 # 1    $  2  $

' ,**3 +,-   + - (3.415 "#     $6 ',**,+(-   +&#-/7

18 $6  9! ',*:)+,-  + - .;: & #40   45'# + 

( (+

+% (# 3 #

0(+5



5*/ )"

  + 7

 )"

;

! 

"   

  45* 5

 '"

 *"

 "  (+

  (#  

0(+5

(

  

5*/B  !

+5 3#

"  (+

+ 3

  + 

 4  0 '#0

8ACDE&

A# ;6

CD(#'

0 B '0 ) A

# *#+ (

 #

  

#   +      %  (# "* '0 %% D;0(

3

04#

(   *"

 ' 

#  0

5

 ;  +     %"  '0 0(

3

04#



( '#+

4#

%(

3

0( '#+

4#

 

  % % D;  &''  '# +%  (+

+* "   (#

3#

0(+5 3

 + 

4 45* 5'#0

5 ! 

% 0+ "

" (+

4

 

(-

45" 0 # +"

# 3#

 (# 3 

4A '4

(+

"  " 

 "   < 

 

 4#

 #'"

"

( !

((

'

 (# 3

*"

B   3#

!



+ 4+  *  +#  (# 3

4A . " (#( %

4

-#30

 " # & 5<   8 !' (),7+,-   +&#- ;.(0           $       ' (),7+(-   +&#- .:   B

 %   3#

 -#30

"  #  #(  45 &(( ++

 &# " 5 9        ! 5 1  95 21 < !$ '()).+,-  + -3()* 

45 "  #  4   -#30

 *  (  45 > :4+  7#( # $6      !   '()):+(-   -/(:  # + "

 0

0( 3#

"#3"

#3"

(

 (# 34# # "

' 

  5*

3* "

+ ) 4  

% '# + "

+  -#30

  > :4+  7#(  #  $ & $ 5< 5<     9   5<',***+(-  + -,3,*"

# * 3

+( ' (+ 0

34

 

B $ &$ 5<5<=%#( %> :4+ 7#( # '#++ #  '

 ( ' (+  4  /  !

* *" +   '   ,#

4

 

+B 4

+

 

  % 3

5'

0(+

45

 0#'" " 3"

  )"

$#3  "#+(+ " 0 +

0'"

+

/,# " 0 +*"

3 !

''#(5 ( '



# +%

"

 B "

 '# + 

% ( # ;

4/ ( '#+ +5  -#30

 0(#3

 '(   '#0

#((+ # '# "

3  (#

4+5%

+ " 

    0 <   ''#

 

7

# 4( '#+ +5

     '

 .

F (#  

( 1#0  @ (

*

4A

0

'

   



" 

0<   ''#

 

)"

4#

0

< 

0 +5     " 

)"

0

 '

5 3 * 4#

  %

((





" (B  

(+

* "

* #("   

 

 "   < 

 

 4#

  B

'  "  " 



4#

"  * ++ " 0 +%     '#+ ''

 '



(-

  4

  3

&( 

( *%

+  -#3 " 



 #  '

 ,#  " 0  *"5 "

  '   "   0   <   )"

-#30

 #( 45'# +

"

'  !

*( '#+ 

' '#0

 B

        > % #( % +

+  "

#04 

+" %2#3

"

 3 "8! '

#3"

0  

+( 

E

+ 5%7

)" # 45

/   !

 #    '  

;+

4

 '"+

 ?

" G 7" H 5  

 

 >

 

 0  9 

 

5 "

 

 0#'"

+

/ ((+ '



G 5* 3"# &'+

0

(+

!



G 5"

+ !

7

 0    0 + + !

7

*" "  !

0

5 0 # * ++

 F "#   +5

,5 

  (4 4 + 5 ''00

3 "

+

"# *" '"*

54  '

 * %+#"+

%*

'

'

 '0(  

 (

+5  + !

 4 3

% #  

+'

((+ '



 3# 4

 

 3

   + 0

* "0  '  

0 + / +5  ++

"# # !

"#

'"!

5"

0 ( '

*"

"# ''#(

'"'0(

+50#'"+ ( '

 # +

"

 !

3#0

0#'" +  '  "*  -#30

        % #(  

 + 3"

  ( '#+  

' '#0

'

((+ 

7 0 + +5%

   -#30

% "  #    ''

 (+

 +

+ ,# 4

 

5*"

"  0 +"  



 3#   0  '

+  ' +

%  '#

 '

+ +   15  "#      > % #( % 0  +'#

 E" *

 

 4#

18 $6 >%#( B " !

*

% B   05 + #

4+ ''

 '



+54 #

"  0 +5   

    

+"

*4#

(+ %*#+

" * "  " 

(+ *"

   3

   4#    5

   "  4  "

 "  '#

  (

+ 0 +5  ++  

<  

%

+" 

0<  '0( ++ 3' '#0

4 #

 

"

* '  

" 

(+  "1#0 2 3* #4- ';

"4# '# +

"

 (

#

5 + '

" '

'

+ 3"

'"

/ " 

0 5* "  " 

"  < 



"    (# 3 

4#



50 3 0

'%

45' #'

"*0

 0+ "

3# -

3"( ''#(

 )"  4 3  #  (+

  (# 3  #

0(+5

 

5 */  & "

 4

 %  " 1#0  2 3

 *

 4A

" (+

"  > 

  (# 3 (

* 4#

 4

3 '

 #  45 " 0  B  '

 "1#0 2 3%

%*" +

(+

(+5% "

 #3"

 (#  ,#

  (#  2 3     "1#0 2 3

3 4+

0

+"

4

+ '

'



 (# 3 3

#++5 0(+5   

54#

8A'

* '0

A

#  45 '# +

% ! 

4



(!

  (#  2 3   '#+  4#

  '00 '

5 7  '0

A 

# %   + '0 04#

%% D; 0

5

 ;



% % D; 0

5

 ; B 4

! 

 '

 (# 3  ++5

54#

%

+5 4

#  *   +  45  (#  2 3 * "

 3

 '

+  4#

 4  

 # #  &

'0

A

# * (#'

458/



+C;%

 '

+0

 B '0  ) A

%



 #3"

  ++

 ' 

" 0* " '0

A

#  + 45  (#  2 3  8/

 

 ' '+# 3 +

  "

 '

'+

+5 (

"

++*" '" 5( 4#

'

 45 (# 3 )"

"

+3 (#'

'0

A

#   "1#0 2 3

" *   "

'

3



#'

'0 %'0(#

'

4

;"

 4#

7" "1#0 2 3

'0 45" *  

 '

5% '0

A 

#   +  45  (#  2 3    0 /

5 ( '#+  4#

 4

3 '

   45 " 0  &++ +

' '+# 

* '0

A

#  (# 3%

# '

 '

 (# 3  4#



  

  (#  2 3  #

0(+5   

5*/  '   (# 3 

4A '4

(+

" 

 ( 

34#



50 3 0

)" # 9   >%#( "



+

+"

*

 ( (

  7#'" ! 

 4

 4  45  #  4 +*%

 %  #     

5 (

 ++ 5  0

3#+ 3 ' &# "

# &'

*" '" 5*



'   !  

+-#  '

 # + 

 "

 #3"

 '

"  -#30

 '

 4 ((+

  '    45 > I4+  7#( # $6    >%#( B"

3

"#3" -#30

$6    >%#( 4# #

4+   

> I4+ &( A# + *

5#'"

 *"  # ( ,#

!

0#

4A

 '4

 (+

 +

+  C"

 4

+ 

 

+"

#3"

0 ;  

+( # "   4#

%  0

5 (+

(!

  ''#(5

5   #'" 4# +

 "

 !

 #'" 4# + * "# # '

# 

 '

%  ( '  ' (+

 4

 45

"

"   ''#(5

5 #'" 4# +  "

 !

 #'" 4# + 3 * "#  # '

 '

#

'00

&'

% #4

'

)"

 '#

0

0#'"+ (#'

50

+ '

 

 @ +

+   ''#(

4# + 3"

!

#'"4# + 3* "# # '

#

'00

&'

B " !

*

%'

'# +



-#30

9   >%#(   "+ + 0 '

+ 4+



 9!

"# $   2 '(),3+(-   -((( #( 45

% " # "

+

 



 *"

 #3"

  

  +

+  ++ ( !

 !

% '0(+

4+  & 5<> % #( %  +

+   (+

"

"  ''#(5

5 4# + "

5#'"4# + 3* "# # '

# )" # "

+

3 



++ 

+#

((  ! 

3

' '#0

"+ ;

A 

(

5 ( "

4

*

3+545 ;

&(( ++

&# " 5B  %  #+ *

;

 #

3*"

5"

'+ 0 ( % ( +

"  &0 3"

4

" 3"+5*

!

53

+%"

 3  &(( ++

&# " 5.# "

+

0

+

+%

 4

4+ "

 4#

  '00  

'5  (  (  

"# 

 (   &  # ++* !  

 45

/

 '  

 !

 # 

' '#0

%     '#+ ''

 0 +5 4 #  

+"

%

+4 '0 3# 

   '  

  3  '  45  # % '    + 0

!  

+-#  '

B*#+"



!

5 7 3+

'"

'  &5<>%#( "

"

+ 9!

 "#> % #(   

 

 

    

 +

+  ++ ( !

 !

%

 '0(+

4 4+ B " !

*

%

'

 !

!

 '

 0  -#30

& 5<> % #(   7 0 + +5%          > % #( % # '00

!

 +5,# ;



+*"

5* (+

((+ '

  '

(+

3  ;''#(

5   4# +

 !

5 #'" 4# + 3 * "#  # '

#

'00

&'

)"

 ( '  ' (+

*

" ("(+



"(4

3+5 3!

*" '"* '

!

45 + 3 (+ '

B " ' '#0

%

"  # +

 &"# 7 3+ %  *"0 

  (

5* (+

%



4A 

 '

 *"

 "

 *  (  

5  (( 5>* %

% #'"'

!

5* " 

  "    4

 (  

5   4# + 3  3!

5#'"4# +

'00

&'

   !+!

  )"

 4

3 % -#30

   #(  45 '# + 

"

3

3 

 )"

5,# +* " 

( * * $ &$ 5<5<>%#( B 4

'  

+5 +45 #

(-

+0# 4

 

3

&0 * "   # #

0

'5 (  '

4 '0  3#  

  *" (

&'

4

?

3 +

#  &

#("  '# 

 %    '#+

''

'5 (  

 #  45

;

+   3

 4

         0 +5  * " 

   

/ "0 #+

 (#(  !

B " !

*

 0

% B   

5 (

 ++ 5  0

+  3#+ 3  '  45  &# "

 4 +*% *

!

'   !  

+-#  '

 .   3 3 

 %

 

'' 3+5 0  + 0

 '      $,/'(),:   19"- J2#+

I       C"

(

/ 3D



D C"

 (

4+

D