High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4029/2018dismissed

Vikram Dutt v. Sarabjit Singh And Others

2019-12-18Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur11 pages

!" # $ !# % &%'(( )

$ %#)(& *+

() ,!-" *+

()

.(+( /"'(//'( 0

) -(12#'# -3((3

) (+ # ' ( ) ) "'

) ())- 3(/'((3 ) 0

(# )//-( ##/

/ )' (/#( ( 24 /- (&%'( .(((5#(- ( # (+- 3#/ -('(/'( 3 6 7/

(#+))/ 68

'((&%'( 4/ ('#

(( ) 35# (3)/- '((( /- !"

' - 3( 3/"/- #(() 3#/ 5# ( ##).(+)3 -(& %'( '(((") )#0

#'()- ()' (// 7/(3 )3-( "'# ( // - 9 8 (+) ('#((5# (//(2.(

3((//' (*))//*#(- 3( ( (// 3((3((//' (#

! "#$%$&&'()*) +& ,(-*. -/*)01.&&) ' &(*.(# (' ((#/ ( ) (+ - 8

'( +12#3 /"') () )# 3(()/-3 / -( &:.(24 (&%'( / & 3(((/ ($) ;# / '( / (43 ())-( / )& )/<

( & (# %(-/%( // * ( 2# )' ( ( (+(+) (()$);# * )/-3 / -()( &" -(&%'( '($);# 3(3(-'( / ( ()(3(' #/+ #+

(+) (()((/.(12#' # (2#)('#(( ( ### ()( (+ ( )( (# %(-/%( // * .(3(//' (# -3-

2$ 3 " #$% &&' )') ) )04) 5 6 '6)'7&(* .,(( -*.()*) +& ,(('#( +# ( ( ) - ( ) )+ ( ) ( # (/')(( / 68

*'/- ( (12#'# '(

###3 -(#3# (12#'# )/ ( +) -( *))// *#(- 6 # 5#/- #)(/ +/ +680 =( ()(3)# ) (#))- >3+ ))((+/ () .()( 3(% &%'(

;#/3%'( ))/- /# )('#(( ()#(())- -3- '/ $);# %(

#(( (/ ( 3 ())-(2 (/ (.( +/?#'?#+ * (#24)(/ ( )/

/ ) ( ( ( ( )/ - ))/3 / )' / *'2) /3) # 5#3((3

)3#.( /

+()( 0 =)/ ()((3 (# ))-( @//#/-2# -( (=/ #

((( )#) (#))-(#'(( (>'(#3(3) //- +(( +# ) -()(3( (*))// *#(- 3// ( >'( # ' & ( (&%'( 8 %#) (& / #/ ( ) ($);# 3((/())- +# ( % &%'()(+'/ '(( ) /''()(= #( #'(( (#(//#+( / 3( 24(&%'(%($);# 3(((& %'(((+)$);# )) (+' (+$);# ( >'(#+/ + 89 ((12#'#)#( )) 9 7#//)#($);# ( / ))/# ( +/$# "' )/)-(+)(3)'

(*))//*#(-('#((343( ))-)#( 3//

8 ' ( /'/( ('/3%(() (' (.( ))/3 " 6('#((

//'#'@//(/'( (- ( 8 -(+ #)3()- ())-/

-%(

#(()='#(()'5# ) (#))-( (/324) )) 3 + + #) ( ) ( ( )'(( ) ())-( (/3(((' #( # = ($);# ('( /())- (3( 7#/ ()( (()'# 6 ((+ /-

'>3+ () 3(#( (#( )#) ( + ())- - ##/ ((#/ )# " ) (#))- -3- #7#/ ( ) +( /-(- - ##/

#'( (>'(##'(# #(/( )/#)(&#'

)08))+-*.&)& "*))) ')

&(*#$$ 57$3

*&( )&* )9):'0 &*)&

;

*)/(<.*-*. (),9)

1)5174: *#$$25 7##

" ')=*-*. )0(;) '(#$%#5%73 () ',)*(>*0)*: <*)&

) ' *&,), ) / &'-*.&)& ">.

+)4) ' &(*#$$!5#7 3$) ')0() '*) ,(-*.)&*1= &(*#$$

527 %? #)) ('# ( ##'( ))

$ , !-" / #/ ( )( ((' ()#)( ))-('//- /'() %(%(

-/ 3( /+' (3/'/)+ /- ,&(%(

#(='#(%(

#( ( %( $);#

9(/ 3//( +#

85#(())- %(()='#( ,&(%(7/(//#+'' ())- ()3(# )/'(%(

#( (/'/( ( ())- /'/- 7/ ,&( #$);# 3//='#(

%(% &%'( )#( ())-( /-(//'(//#+ 0

3,&( %(7/( )' (# 7 #/ 3#/ / '# ( ( ) 3( / (3((///+/# (# /(//#++/#(%(%(

#( ( %( $);# ((/ (())- ( (%(() %%(%(

#((2#/'/+/@//

8) ((/ (())-3(((( 5# (( ( (%((),&(#/ (+(//#+3(7/''( (()=/#

(() ( ###()/( - )' - # 3 )(#((

5#) 3(//'#'((+// ( +#3((( (//'(

)#(/#)) ('# ( )/ (&#'

;)++) ,(-*.-**) ,() '

&(*#$$35 757

= (+ ( / #/ ( ) 3( ( (+'(#'(()/'

.( )# # ( ( ( ( ( )((//- /# +'(& %'(3((+)'3(/-'(#)(>'( ##/ /-( (*))//*#(-3

- (#3( -(+ (&%'(3 3#// #(()(( (3// 2# -7/( +##'()(#'(2# )' 3(((&%'( /( &'( (( (+)$);# 3( )+)'(#'(+ (&%'( / '( / (43 ())-=/ )#((2# / -()3 ### )(/- (+$) ;# >3+ (#+/+ 89 ( ( (12#'#'2#)' ### -'(12#'#)#()( )=/)#(())/ / -($) ;# # ( +/$#"'

)/)-(+)' 3(( ( /-.($);# (#'(/- #' 3//

8 3(( 3 / #) - ( *))//*#(-3(/ '())/('#(( (/'( (- (/ 8-.( '

())/(

6))/-( $);# / '( / (3(2 (/

( / ( ) ( +/# /

:4 -'/68 3((+#//-/ ( /' # )

3((324) /' ')3 ) '# 1+(#'(())/# 6 ( +/ $#( / 5#(3#/ 3 3(((#2 ()3#/# ()()(()#) (#/ //3()'# 6 (#/

7#/ ()(/'( '# ( #+//='#((++

3 $) ;# ( ) ( 2#'

##// )#//-3($);# (+- #(-2#( (33( ='# ((&#'

- ##//-( - /3 ( ( # #'( )# ( ) ") ())-'+'( ))#- ( 3( /#/))' (/

()+( /-#

(7/,&(( //#+(+- 3(# )/'

#((/'/( 3(33 (/ ( ( ))- ( 7/#/ (/ 2/#+3 ())-)#( ' )#()( '(/- )#) )'(# )(

$ (# ()($);# 3((#'( )/)-+)'3 / /((3()( @//#) -( ))/(( /# (.( #( +((3+# ) ' )+ ( ) ( ( # ( /' @( '($);# 3((/())-( )A% &%'(((//'//#+ 3,&(7/ -+# 3((7/(

( / 3 ( ))- )# 3(( ( #

5#( +# ()(.((' #'( ( -()((3(3() $) ;# +())- ( (5#3(((/ #-(5#((

6 # (/3( /*)().() -*. )*( (

) ')

&(*#$$35%757!?3 3((/-3 ())/((>'(##()33' (//3))# ( #(#/(

2(3())/#

6 (/-)'B.(5#/ 3(())( ##//-(- /3 '# -(/#/ ()

.(# (2 (()( # ()(3( /'' +/-3)# ) ())-/- ) ( 3(( ))-( /# #( ()#) - )3( #3=()3 (>'(# #*/ 9 (# =3#'(+ )/-//'/)( )-3(#

#/ (>3+ (# )'+- '

#(/('# ( .(5# # ( -(# )&#( +))#-( '+)/(()

)#(

0 =( )( (()( )#)( ) -(12#'# (#/'( ( ((/ +#

()(' " (#'(( ) (#(#'()3)#) ( @((24))'3 #( )/- #)() +)'(+/-

-()# 6 ( +/ $#(24)=( "'# (#

/( (#'( '( ()(/- "* (#( /# C ( 2)(('())/ # 6 ( +/ $# -/ '( #

))#()#(+

8 5#/- 3(/ '(+ (/# ())/ /# 6 (

+/$#3() 3 () )- ( -//3'3

+ ))# ( ) (+( )/3

+))# ()(( "#( 3(/3 / ( () # #/''(24))'( ( (/ - +)))))/

())-)'((+/#

9 >3+ / ( - + ( +3#/(+

( ()' (/# 1604*%2#$%? 5

7 @(()"': D