← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/405/2019dismissed

Vishnu Bhagwan Mangla v. Shanti And ORS

2019-01-18Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan4 pages

     

 ! " #

  "   

  "$% &' ()   



       *(  +!,* - .

- 

/ %( */

*0%$1 & '$% /%02%% /





 ! "# $ 33/& %0 /&/&$%&  )2$&456&3 76  /" 816/63/$970/ $%/&'/4&$+%0' 6/%4 :+8 &9 3%0$22'$% 6 &//&/.6;/$&:%0-'%   %0 &  / '&6/1)7 /0 /%1+ +81%02/ %' / &

0$'% 4/$/%0$%$6% /2''2/ /9$ ':$ &45%02%% /72$ % %06%8 %04$ $3/9 %%  &$%&)    %'1:/%% %$%9 %:$&%$< 3$%$ &%0$% %0$3/9 %% 0$&$/$&54 '$ '&$ &%0$/ %9 5 % & /%&  /$9 %:$9 &45%02%% / 2/$5 3%0$%09$54$ :&% $9 &%02$ %% 9$<%$6% / &'$/$%

0$22'$% :$&9&45%0$/ &' 6/%4 :& /&/&$%&  = 0 /&/:$'0$ 3& %0 6/%  

)

 = 0$9 %:$$ :&& /&/&$%& ) > )164?'%% 2$59 % ' % 1@A% %0& &$ %

  0/$%/1%02%% /&%0$9 &&2$ % 2$/$

:0'0%0 $9 %0:% % %0$3/9 %% :$9 % &$ . &  B69$/    

1  . &  B69$/  % &/&  0  $&$%  $ C

D>@ 10:$% 4'/ AC$9 & 0/$%/1$ %0/$22'$%  / $9 %:$9 &%$% 3%0$% $9 . &B69$/9 % & %0 2$ %  4  /$&  $  ?$5  B69$/  62%$  $  %0  2%% /  3$  4$$ ' '

&/$%    %0  2/ '    ?$5 B69$/ 62%$   :/1  %  :$ 2$&&%0$%%0/ :/%% /'2% :%0/3$/&% %02$59 %  4$$ '$9 6 0$&$22'$% :$&9&&9263 & /&/

! 3$33/& %0 /&/1%02/ %'/

&

,$/ &' 6  /%02%% /$/36%0$%%0$/ &' 6/% 4 ://& &9 3%0$22'$% 45%$% 3%0$%%0$22'$%

&6 &//&/.6; 4$//& /62 %0  : C%/$'% %0 /&/( E0 $22'$%    2''$5 4$//&  6 &/ 45 2/   % /&/.6; :0'02/ &%0$%   

  

  

 

    

             

    

     

    

 %0'$1%02$ %0$9/$45 $&% 2/ &6&3 ' %/$ 3%09$%%/$// 4 /%$/% %0%/$ 0'

% % /$& 45$/ & ' 6  /%02%% / $'<9/% /&/.6; G6 %&4 :( ".

 >  % &   %%'

(   )E $& 3F0$9$ 2$ % /:/%% %$%9

CCCCCC (*+   )0 6/%9$5$%$ 5%$3  %0  2/ '& 3  $ :  %0/  2$/%5  %  $%/  /  $9 &  0 2$& 3 6'09$

/$ & 6'0%/9$9$54?6%1$ & $6'0$9 %0$49$&$9$54 '$/5 /%0 26/2     &%/9  3  %0  /$  G6%     '

%/ /5 4%: %02$/%(

/ &&%0$%  /$9 %0$4$ :& $%/%0%/$0$' 99 '&16 %0 6/%' 9% %0 '

'6 %0$% 2% %0&6&3 '1%02$/%5' 6& 0$/$&%09$%%/4 /%0' 99 '9 % %/$

/ 9%0/$& 3 /&/.6; 1%'$/%0$%%0  6/%0$2 :/% $ :%02$/%5% $%/ /$9 &%02$& 3 /%0 26/2  &%/9  3%0/$G6%  '

%/ /5 02/  % %0 6  %$%  %0$%   $22'$%   /  $9 %  0$  4  $ :&  $%/ ' 99 '9 % %0%/$6 %0' 6/%$%&%0$% 2% &6 &3 '1  %0  2$/%5  :$  %  $4  %  /$  %0  9$%%/  4 /  %0 ' 99 '9 % %/$ 0'

% % %0$%%0$22'$% &9&9/5 $ /&/.6; 2/ &%0$% 0$4$ :& $%/' 99 '9 % %0%/$ %:A 6 &&  /$& 3 %0 /&/   %/%50 :%0$%%0' 6/%4 :0$&' 9% %0' '6 %0$%%0 2%% /0$&9/$45$&% 2/ &6&3 ' /$ 3%09$%%/ $// 4 /%0' 99 '9 % %/$   4 /%0' 6/%1

   $/ &' 6  /%02%% /0$ %4 $4% %$40%0$% 2% &6&3 '1%0$9 %' 6& %0$4 9$&2/ /% %0 ' 99 '9 % %/$ 2/ %0$'% %02/ %'$1%:$2$&& %0 $9 &&2$ %%0$%. &B69$/:$:% % %0$3/9 %%  0 $&$9 %:$$ :& % &/&0$&$%4 /%0 ' 6/% 4 :$ &%09$%%/:$2 & 3 /0'/ AC$9 $%

 %%0$%%$31 $ :$9 &%$% 3%0$%4$$ ''

&/$% :$2$&45%0 2%% / %02/ '  ?$5B69$/62%$46%%0/ :/%%

/'2% %0$&2$59 %19$  3%0/45%0$%%0/ & '69 %% 0 :%0$% ?$5B69$/62%$:$$:%   2% %0$%1%02/$5/

%0$22'$% %0$% %$& %0 $9 . &B69$/1 $9  ?$5 B69$/62%$0 6&4%0/ 0 &$ 6/ %02%% /& %0$%%0:% $/4 3'0$ 3&1$$ &:0 1 9 /6%$4 $$$4

  %// '    '$&   /    %0  9263 &  /&/  0 / &9&  :/1%'$/&%0$% %0 3%$%&

%0 /&/0$4'

%/6&$$ C2/   2  %09/% %0 6% "



 $  ,& )   9< D0%0/2$< 3@/$ &( #@

D0%0//2 /%$4( #@