High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/437/2019dismissed

Divisional Canal Officer, Hisar Water Services Division Hisar And ORS v. Manish Kumar

2019-01-22Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur7 pages

#!$$

%&'!% (%! ))$$ !

*%!+! !(,+-% (% .!) !

/%! " %/0,+-%12%& $# 3%$& '%4& ())$$

5(!% ())$ ! (#6 $!72 % $4

4! (%8 $2 $2 ())$ % (%!!!

())$ !&0( (%!+))% 64 (

# !& ($4%8 $2 $2 ())$! !

5(! %!

))$(!6 $2!

(9+2-

)!! 64 ( $ 1+2&'!%&0(%64 69 $64!(,+-%:%!) (%+%;

$ &<( % ( $$ % !(%

(!6$$0 (%6 %$0%

(!6!

6% & 0 ! 6 %)%)%))%

( !5( ! () %%!) (%! (!%!

*$$2,-%!(%($% + $ .

=,-%-% 0% 2% -)%!% 2$< < ! + *$$2,-% (7 + $ .

=,-%% 0! ) % (% -$4--6%!!!(0 (9-6 (4%

0%2

2> %!+))$4 $0 % (%% (%2% !)% ()%#!! (%+$! %> %!+))$4 $0 %

(2%! %2 (2%- & () %0!

- 2 ( 2% )%)% 4 0 ( ( ($) ( '% +$ +%

)% - 0! ( )+ 4$$ %?> + #?2% (!0%2$4% -- ( ! %0 (%0$ > %!+))$4 $ 0 % (%%0!)!!2!

()% )$! & 0($ +% (% 2 (%0! !%#+)(-%2%2 0 (%0$ (> %!+))$4 $0 %5(-

%0!% %% ?2%';?8&@(7%A %;%# !% $8&'!% %%6 &0( ($ ()% 2! (!%2%&0( (% ( $- +!(,+-% 0+$6 $ > %!+))$4 0 % %- ( $5(%!)

6 % +!(,+-%& ($0%&0!

- 2(!2%)%)%$4& (% %&! (0($%+% B+!

0!)% & 0!%2( $4 0 (%0 (> !+))$4 0 %) )%!0!)+ %! !)

(%)% ;(%1;,++&?> + #?2%&A %;%# ! #!& '!0! 7% %!)% (%)% & (- (0($ %+% B+!

0!)% 6! (%)% &

0%0!)!! #+% ())$$ ! (%% 0 (%0 > %!+))$4 ! %0 % (2%0!+)($5(0%

0! ($$264 (%!) (%64

$269 +%;

( 5( $ 1+2&'!%&

%(%2 +!$ %

()% !&!

! (0%22%#2!

(!9+2- & !

))$(!6 $64 ( )% - =% +!$ %))$$ !+6- ! %( %2( $4 - ( $+! (2%0! 62- 64

(%!) (%& (% %&> %!+))$4 0 % %-+ $ .

8= ,-%-%0!%2( $40 (%0 (# (% $% +!$ % ( ))$$ ! 0$$ !

)%+! ( -)+2 9+2- 5( %!) :+!( ,+-% ($$2 ( 0% )%-%$4 ( 2%+ 0! 2!

)% )$! ! % (!) %)% ;(%1;,++ 0! ) 0 (+ 2#24))% + 4 (%2 ( $- 0 (+ !+))$42 )4 (!%)% (-5(0$$!

$$0 9+2- ! $%$4!) 4 (0% %+2(

6 % %0 ( (! ) % % !$- (!

%2%&% % 6- (9+2- !%%

"# $%$ % $&''()&* +!

,-. // 0 1 !

2 # $%$ $ " 3! / 2 &'4. )5* )!6!"* &'. % % 0%0+$60%% ()%- %!&!!) ;

6 ( %! ;

6 ( !

%)%+ !+%"8

# !

% &'

9+2- %%!"2 % "1 $

# 0 /!7$ &''8)5*%7 % $$9'50%-2 >)%!!C)+6$ )$ 4D!- ;

6 ( (!

62#A($$20 ( ()(%!C)+6$ )$ 4E (;+)%- +% ($!+%"8 ( )#

% ) *

+, - .

& * 1 1

)

) 2 )

% ! % !

& %

& *

. &'

( !

!& ( 1+2& 0($ %2( $4 %)% 2 9+2- (;+)%-+% &($ (0% %(! 6!

!! (%+$! 0% -)$0 ( )% (-)+29+2- )!!64 ( 1+2&((! 7 + (#%+! !)% 2!0( ( 7)$ 6 % %6 % 0! ;(%1;,++&?2%&(6% !) ( 2% !+6- (!%)% 6 %

5(%)%

0! $6 % % -6%&

+% (%

(%!%%#$6$ >2 ( %(%2

&0( ( ()!! (-)+20% !$ 5(% % $!%#$!

&))% (6 +!6($

( %!) (% % 9+%- ! (! +!$ 0! +0$$ '0#%& (!-0! > (0% - >!

5( 1+2 - ( $+! ))% + 4(6 2# ( $- 69 %6+ (%)% (?> + #?2%F % )4 (% 0!!+))$ (-&($2 (%0! -)$ (%+$! 5($% +!$))%26($

())$$ #(- $4%2+! (!+))$4 > %0 %0!%2( $4 !

))! (% (%0! 62- '0#%&((! 6 6$ ! 4 (+% ! 0( (% )4 (%)% (6!+))$

( $0%5(%+$! 0+$(#9 %6 !+% %(%2 (-

%2#))% + 4

69 (%)% %!!! ($!

>) 0(!))%2 %)%!)) 9+!

5(!-!$ 72(%5( -)+20%0!2!

()+6$ )$ 4)!!+

%#$ )% )$! 5( 1+2(!%2( $4 % % !

2! (0% % (%! %8!

& (%!-% (!))$

!-!! &&4&'4- )

* A( (%!)72%! G!