Dalbir Singh & ANR v. State Of Punjab & ORS
! "
!
#$%& !'( )* +
%+ , -% . . ! -
/ (+ %/ 0'/. 123 ) *'( /(24(( /
%/ 5'6'.21'3 )) ) *'( /'3 0'8
%/ .7/576'/3 ) *'( //4 ) (
9 '02 )'
2' 1 (2 4/ ( 4(( ( (2 ':'/) )'() 93 4') 8; (2 -'
) *<7( *( /3 )7(/ !4'/(6 (3 0'8# /2 /(3,(2 *( /,&3):2*2(2'44*'(
)8;(24(( /7 = (2-'
) *<7( *(3 => # /2 /(3,(2 *(,&3:')6)
/;3(2'*( (2*''/(2'() )'() ?
>==34782) > ?
>==37)7 (2 *(3(2 .('( 0'8 712(( '*<7/9@ 9'*/#3>=A'
'6'/'& '
)3(7'() '152'A232'/ '/'
/(247/4 (( 74 7*7 )7(/' 64B'( ):' 2'6:' :)8;
)'()9 >=>34782) 9 >=>37)7 ?
(2 *( C)':'/) )'() >>3 (2 *( / ') (2 D3EF4/'*/ /1'/676A '
)'
) 3EF 4/'*/ /*2'2E 2/'
('():(2(2':'/)3(24(( / ) 80*( 3:2*2:////)( (2'/ )/ * 7/(3:2 )':'/))'()
3)(/6 )(2* 64 (2'*<7/)
'
) D 3EF4/'*/ 2/'(/3(24(( /)) ('
;
'44'8 /(2* 7/('1' ((2':'/) (2/ * 7/( (2/ *' . 6 (2'
/38 1 ('()3)'44'8 /(2 * 7/(3:2/ (2* 64 :' 2'
*) 2/'(/3(24(( / )'44*'( = (2 *(( (2 *( / (28' (207)16 ( (2 7/(
9?
>> G!2'/'6''
7A2(' 2 0'8.('( )7(/!4'/(6 ('
) (2/3)*))
> 2'62' 18 )6)8;(2 *( /3(2 /)/2' 8 6471 ) (24/ (4((
-'/ )* 7 /(24(( /)) ()47((2'*((2'( (2 4(( / 2') ('; ) 80*( '1' ( (2 ':'/) (2 *( /3:2*2:////)( (2* 7/(8 :3:2 )':'/))'()
3 2'
*)(2* 64 / 63EF( 3EF4/'*/ '
)(24(( /)) ('
;'44'8 /(2* 7/( 786(() (2'( ' 6 (2/ '
/ 2') '44/ '*2) (2 * 7/( '
)
!2'/'6'' 7A2(', *' #74/'&3 (2 * 7/( 2') 2'
*) (2 3'44*'( = (2 *(:')3:2*2 :':/ 1;)6)8;(2 *( / /' 2'8 '1 )
(2'8 *(2/ 3(24(( /'/7 '8( '''
;/6);'''8 '1' (/0*( (2/'44*'(
(2*' '*<7( '
)3 4'/(;2'( 86' (' ) (2/'
/2'8 4')212/ 3(24(( /' )/( 81/'
()(2'6/
744 /(3/'
*:'4'*)74 07)16 ( !212 7/( !2 ! 46 ( 7(2 /(; ))( '!(/*(%'1(/'(E-'
) *<7(
*( / '
) (2/3 9 #& !- >3 ' 742) 8; ,8 (2 .74/6 7/( .4*'-'( 44'#&
?>= 9G !2 ! 46 ( 7(2 /(; )) !(/*( %'1(/'( #. 7(2& '
(2/3)*)) > > 9
(2 (2/2'
)3'/ )* 7 /(2.('(786(()(2'( (2'44*'( )8;(24(( /7 = (2 *(:' ( 6' (' '8 / (: /' 3 '6;3 (2'( (2 4(( / 2') '/');
'') (2/6); 1 80*( '1' ((2':'/) (2 *( / '
))) (6471 (2':'/) (2/ * 7/('
;7/(2/ 2
9 /6);'''87 = (2 *( ; /(2'
/ :2 ) ( A.*( = (2 *( 7/(2/3'44*'(
= (2 *(*'
8) ; (28' (2':'/) (2/ * 7/('
) ('
; (2/ 7/( (:'7/(2/786(()(2'('1' ((2 /)/ 4') 8; (2 *( / )6 1 '
'44*'( ) 8; (2 '
/7 = #& (2 *(3(2/6); (/
8 /(2* 7/(3/'(2/3'44*'( = #9& (2 *( / // * )47(( (2* 7/( 744 /(3/'
*:'4'*)74
07)16 ( ,8(2.74/6 7/( 7A'62'
) .('( '/;'
'3 >>?#9& #& 9= '
) C '6'A/2 ' ' 2 . 1'/ / 64'
;-() '
)'
(2/3#&#& >
'/)'/ )* 7 /(24'/('
)4/7)(24'4/ 8 A
?
27 )47()'*( /* /)'/(2'('
) (24(( / :''*<7/)) )'() ?
>== /(247/4 (( 174 7*7 )7(/' 64B'( ):' C)':'/))'() >>3 (2 *( / ') (2 * 64 4';'8 ( (2 4(( /
11/) '1' ( (2 ':'/) (2 *( /3 (2 4(( / ) 80*( 3:2*2:////)( (2/ * 7/(3:2 )':'/) )'()
3)(/6 )(2* 64 4';'8( (24(( / 2 4(( / 8 1 '() )) ( 4// '
; 7/(2/ '44' 2 '
/3:2 :/ ('():(2(2':'/) (2/ * 7/(3 )'44'8 /(2 7/( !2'/'6'' 7A2(',*'#74/'&3) 07)16 ()'()
> 3(2 7/(')(2* 64 /(2 '*<7/)'
)D?EF4/<7'/;'/) 2 712(:' (4 () 7(8;
'
; (2* 7 (2'( : ((
=F !2'/'6''
7A2(',*'#74/'&3(2'6 7 ( * 64 :'/)7*)/ 6 ?EF4/<7'/;'/)( EF4/<7'/;'/)3) /)/)'()@
2 712(6'; (8'/'
('*( /(2*''7*287((/<7/) ( 8 (*) ( 47( (2 /* /) (/'12( :2 6 ( 1 * 64( /6'( /1'/) 1'7'( (2'*<7/)'
@
273:2*2'/ /* )/'( (24/ (4((
'/+
#& H2(2/(2'
/3:2 2')) 80*( 7 )/ .*( = (2 *('
))) (*2' 1(2':'/) (2/ * 7/( '
;7/(2/3*'
'44*'(
= (2 *( *' 2'
*6 ( (2 *' (2/ '
/3 :2 '44/ '*2)212/ 7/(#&I #& H2(2/'44*'( = (2 *(*'
8 )8 /(2 *( //; 174 '07)16 ( (2 12 7/( / ,8(2.74/6 7/(I #& H2(2/(2':'/) (2 *( /4')7
= (2 *( *'
8 *2' 1) 8; 1 (2 7/(I =
2/'
(4/ (2 *('/B(/'*()8 :+
#& ;4/ (/():2 2'
( '**4() (2 ':'/) 6';3 8; :/(( '44*'( ( (2 *( /3/<7/(2'((26'((/8///)8;(2 *( / /(2)(/6 (2 7/(3:2(2/2 80*( 8( (26'7/6 ( (2'
)3(2'6 7 ( (2* 64 (24/ ( :2 6(4';'83 /(2'44 /( 6 ( (2 '6 1(24/ (/()
#&2'44*'( 2'('((21/ 7 ) :2*2 80*(
( (2':'/)('A +
/ ))(2'(/;7*2'44*'( 2'86')F #'& (2 4/ 6'A 1 ( :' 4/ ( / /4/ () 8 / (2 *( / '( (2 (6 :2 2 6') 2 ':'/)3:(2 B:A/ 6(2)'( (2 *( /, ':'/)J #8& (2/*'3:(2 B:A (2/*4( (2
(*/ 6(2 *( /7 378F*(
#&3 /:(2 B6 (2/ 6(2)'( (2 *( /, ':'/)3:2*2/4/ )2'/(B4/
! !
!
"
#&H2/ '
':'/) )/(2 '/(3(2 7/(' :( (2'44*'
('
;'6 7 ( B* (2'6 7 (':'/))8;(2 *( / 3(24/ (/() '(2 (2/'
* /)8;(2'6 )/*( 378F*(
#&'
):2 '/' '11/)8;(2':'/) (2 *( / 6';3 (:(2('
) 1(2'((2;2') (6')'
'44*'( ( (2 *( /7 )/*( =38;:/(( '44*'( ( (2 *( /:(2 (2/6 (2/ 6(2)'( (2':'/) (2 7/(/<7/(2'((2'6 7 ( * 64 4';'8( (26 6'; 8 /F)(/6 ) (2 8' (2 '6 7 ( ':'/))8;(2 7/(+
/ ))(2'( * 647( 1(24/ ) (2/6 (2:(2
:2*2'
'44*'( ( (2 *( /2'86')7 )/(2 78F*( 3(2)'; :2*2(2':'/):'4/ *)'
(2(6/<7( / 8(' 1'* 4; (2':'/)2'8 B*7))
#&2 *( /2'3 /*4( '
'44*'( )/78F *( #&3* )7*('
<7/;'(/1 1 (*( '(2 4/ (/()'
)1 1(26'/' '8 44 /(7 (; 8 12'/)3'
)6'A'
':'/))(/6 1(2'6 7 ( 4';'8( (2'44*'
(
#9& ;4/ :2 2' ('**4()(2':'/)7 )/78F *( #&6';38;:/(( '44*'( ( (2 *( /3/<7/ (2'( (2 6'((/ 8 ///) 8; (2 *( / / (2 )(/6 (2 7/('
)(24/ *( =( =2'3 '/'6';83'44;( 7*2// *'(2;'44;
( '// *7 )/*( = K #$ %& >
2* 4 .*( = (2 *(:'* )/)8; ,8 (2.74/6 7/( C '6'A/2 '' ,*'#74/'&3:2/ (:' 2) (2'( (2 '6 )6 ( *'//) 7( (2 *( '(/ > ;'/ (
? '*(6 (3:2')) 1.*( = (2 *(3 :':(2'
80*(( 4/ ) 6 '*( (2'
/3:2 '
)2')8 '*<7/)387(
'** 7 ( '/ 7 /' *7) 1 4 /(;3 1 /'
* '
) (2/ )'8( * 7) ( 80*( 7 )/ .*( = (2 *( / )47( 1(2':'/) (2 *( /'
)*'6 1212/* 64
2;2'8 1 44 /(7 (;( A* 64 '(4'/:(2 (2/ '
/3:2 '
):''*<7/))'6
2 80*( ( /6 <7'(;
:/3(28 ( .*( = (2 *( '''8 ;( ''
/:2 2') (8 '8( 80*( ( (2 *( /7 = (2 *( '
*:'4'*)74 '
'// 07)16 ( ,8(2.74/6 7/( )' /')4 576'/3#>>&.@9?
'
(4'/'1/'42> (207)16 ( C
'6'A/2 '' ,*'#74/'&B(/'*()8 :+ L> 2 '8 /4/ )7*) 4/ /4/ ( (2 -1'(7/,)(/6 ( 7/(2'((21 ' <7'(;
2/ ) (2 /'68 (2 ((7( '
) /(*9=3 9>'
) ?(2/ (/'
'() ( /'(;3'('( (26'((/ 4';6 ( * 64 ( (2 :2 '/)4/) (2/ '
) /(28 ( (2.('(3( (/76 ('(E'1 * '
) 4/'(4/ .*( = ' /4/ (('(7( /;
68 )6 ( (2) *(/ <7'(; 6'((//'( 1( (2'*<7( '
2 *(:2*2:' '*() => '
:''6 ))'(/>;'/2'(24 ( (' )4/ 1'
'/116 ( (2 *(; (2,'1/*7(7/(, (2/ ;
7/* 2 ) 2*26 .*( = 4/ ) 6 '*( (216 ( (2 *(;8; 7/ 1(2'(7*2 (2'
) :
/ :2 '
) :''*<7/) 7 )/(2 '6
87( :2 * 7) (3 '** 7 ( 4 /(;3 1 /'
*'
) (2/)'8(0 (2/ A 1// * =1('
44 /(7 (;( *'6* 64 '( 4'/:(2 (2/ 2*( '6)'(/6 1 <7'(;
(24';6 ( * 64 7 '*<7( '
)/(2'6
47(()/ (;3(2*(
@ 1'*2'
*( (2'
) :
/3:2 6'; (2''44) = /)(/6 6'/A('78;(2 7/(( A/F)(/6 (2'6 7 ( * 64 '
; (2/ 6'/; (7'() '
) :
/ 7**)
4/7') 1(2/ * 7/(( B212/6'/A('7 (2'*<7/)'
2/ /3.*( = 2'( 8 (/4/() '6'
/:2*2: 7)')'
*(24 *; 1'( ( 1'
44 /(7 (;( (2'
) :
/26';2'3)7( '/(; /' (8 '8( 6 (2 *( / / 6'A 1// *7 = (2 *(( 1(212/ 6'/A('7/)8;(2/ * 7/( '((2 ('
* (2/'
) :
/3:2 '
)'*<7/) )/(2'6
* 7/3(2 44 /(7 (;*'
8 '')8; 1'44*'( :(2 (24/*/8)4/ )
3'(2/F 7)1 *2 (2 7/(2)(2'(.*( = (2 '(7/ '
8 * (4/ ( ))( /6 <7'(;'
)( 1 /( (2 '/(*7'('
)4 /'
/3:2 '/ ('8 ( ('A')'
('1 (2/12( // *( (2 7/( = (2 *('
)7*2'4/ 2 7)8 (/4/() ' 6'
/ :2*2 ')'
* (2 4 *; 1'(
K
: (2' /')'7(2 /('( *'( ':8;
,8(2.74/6 7/(3(2/*'
(8'
; (2/ 4 B*4((2'( (2'
/3:2 2')) 80*( 7 = (2 *(3 *'
( A (2 4/ .*( = (2 *( / A '(4'/:(2(2'
/3:2 6';2')7/(2/'44' #&'1' ((2':'/) (2/ * 7/( 24/ 6'
( ;
/(2'
/3:2 2') ( A)(24/ .*( = (2 *(8; 1 80*( '1' ((2':'/) (2 *( / 2<7( '
:/)'** /) 1;
=
(2*' 2'
)3(7 )47()(2'((24(( /2') ) 80*( 7 = (2 *(3:2*2:////)( (2 '/ ) / * 7/( '
) :/)*)) ) ':'/) )'()
'44*'( ) 8; (26 7 )/ .*( = (2 *( :' ( 6' (' '8
#$ %&
27 6 / (:F(()(2'('
'44*'( =F (2 *( ;*'
8)/; 174 (2 ':'/) (2/ * 7/( 2B4/ L 7/(K7) .*( =F (2 *( 2' ( 8 1 6'
1 :(2 // * ( (2 ) (
* (' ) .*( 9#)& (2 *(3:2*26'
/ *4' 7/( /1 '07/)*(
/ * /(247/4 *'
86')( (2 /)/ 4')8; ,8(2.74/6 7/( .('( 0'8 '128/. '
) (2/3>>.744#&.?@> 2'6B(/'*()8 :+ L 2 7 )/ .*( #& :' 4782)
>= /478*47/4 2 *( /6')'
':'/) >=9 2/4 ) ()) (A /'
;// *7 = 212 7/( (2 '44')8; (2*'6'
( (2'6 8;
(2 07)16 ( '
) )*/ )'() > >> 2'
*) (2 '( 3@3EF 4/ '*/ 2/ (2 /4 ) ()(2'44*'( >>7 =F A 1 // * ( (2 * * 7/( (2 8' (2 07)16 ( (2 12 7/( 2 *( / )6) (2 '44*'( >> 2/ (2 /4 ) ( ) / (212 7/( 212 7/( (26471 ) /)/)'()
= >>' :)'
))/*()/)(/6 (2* 64 3 (28' (207)16 ( (212 7/()'() > >>
2 (/* (/ /; :* /)8;07)16 ( (2 7/( '87''6 .('(
3#>>&.?=>
: (2'8 07)16 ((2 *'/;* *7 (2'((2 '44*'( /// *) ( 2// ** 7)8
> 6') ; (28' (207)16 ( (2/ * 7/( 87( :(2 (2 6('( 4/*/8) 7 )/ (2 4/ .*( =F #& (2*' (2/(2'44*'( :') :(2 6('( /66)'(;'(/(2':'/) (2!(/*( 7/( )/(2*/*76('
*(2 6 )6 ( *(?= >= *'
(8'44)'
)(212 7/(*'/;* 66(() // / ': ' : 1(2/
2'44'' :)
2 /)/ (212 7/(
== >>)'()
= >>(')87( (2*/*76('
*:(2 7(* ( K 9
/ **'
' 86')( (2 /)/4')8; ,8(2 .74/6 7/( )' '
('6#)')&8;-3>>?# &. 9@
** /) 1;3(2'
:/( (2<7( (2'('
'44*'(
=F (2 *( /)(/6 * 64 *'
8 ) ; (28' '
':'/) (2/ * 7/(:(2 (24/ ) 6('( 4/*/8)(2/
#$ %&
2'
:/( (2<7( '''8 '8'/4/7' (2 4/ .*( = (2 *( .78F*( #& (2/ 4/ )(2'(''
/ (()( '
'44*'( (28' ':'/) '* 7/(4/(' 1( '6'*<7( /A 14'/(; (2 '6 7 ( * 64
:/37*2'
'44*'( 2'( 8) :(2 (2/6 (2/ 6(2)'( (2':'/) (2* 7/( .78F*( #& .*( = (2 *(4/*/8(2'((2 *( / /*4( (2 '44*'( )/78F*( #&2'4'(2':'/)'(/* )7*( <7/;31 1 (*( '(24/ (/()'
)' /) 1 44 /(7 (;
2'/ 1( (26 .*( = #9& (2 *('
:/( (2<7( :2*24/ )(2'('
;4/ ) ('**4((2':'/) (2 *( / 4')7 )/78F*( #&326';/<7/(2 *( /38; 1'
'44*'( 3( //(26'((/( (2* 7/( /)(/6
(24/ *3 (24/ .*( =( = (2 *(2''44;
2'
17'1 .*( = (2 *(38 1<7(B4*(3(2/*'
(8(: 4 (2'( *'
F'**4('
* (2':'/) (2 *( /4')7 )/
.*( = (2 *(3 (2 ; /6); '''8 :(2 (2 '44*'
(E'
/: 7)8( '44*'( /// * (26'((/ ( (2* 7/( /)(/6
2' /')7:'' * )/)8;
,8(2.74/6 7/( C '6'A/2 '' ,*'#74/'& 2 ;
/)/(2'(''
/ A 1(24/ .*( = (2 *( /A 1212/* 64 *'
(1(* 64 212/(2'
(2 4/ 3:2 2') 712(// *7 = (2 *( 2/'
( 4'/'1/'42(2/ B(/'*()8 :+ L 78F*( #9& .*( = (/4/()A4 1
:(2 80*( 712(( 8'*2)8; '*( 1(24/
/ /6 1 <7'(; (2 6'((/ 4';6 ( 3(67(82)(2'('4/ :2 ('() :(2 '
':'/) 6') 7 )/ .*( = #& *'
6'A '
'44*'( ( (2 *( /7 = #9& /6'A 1'
// *( (2 7/(') ) .*( 9#)& (2 *('
(2/12(*'
(8/7(/'()6/;8*'7''/7( /F )(/6 6')7 = #&/'):(2.*(
= #&(2'44*'
(8* 6 (()( /** 64
'(4'/:(2 (2/'
) :
/ 2/ (2 1 (24'
'
17'1 .*( = #9&/ 6:2*2(*'
8 //)(2'('
4/ :2 2' ('**4()(2':'/)6')7
= #& 4/*7)) / 6 6'A 1 '
'44*'( ( (2 *( /:(2(2/<7(( //(26'((/( (2 7/( * 7/3(2 7/(( :2*2// *6')7 = #9&:2'( 8'/ 6 )(2'('4/ :2 2' ( 712( // *7 =*'
(1(* 64 212/ (2'
(2 4';'8( (2 :2 2') 712(// *7 )/ (2'(.*(
K
?
*(2/6);'1' ((2':'/) (2 *( /7 )/ .*( = #& (2 *(*'/;4/ )) /7 = #9& (2 *(3'/ '1' ((2':'/) (2 *( /( (2 7/(: (
8* 64( ( (21/ 7 )(2'((2'6
F4'A
(2/:3(26471 )':'/) (2 *( / (
F4'A 1
2'64/ ) 1 )1/ 7 ) //0*( (2'44*'( (2 4(( /3 '6;3(2'('44*'( = (2 *(2'8
)*'6 14'/(; (28' '07)16 ( (2* 7/(3:2*2* 7)8
(28' (2':'/) (2/ * 7/( ;
@
/(2/' 6 ( )'8 3) ( )'
;6/( (2 4/ (4((
2'63'** /) 1;3)6)
#'02 )'& 7)1 6A #/( /4 /(/&