High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4507/2016dismissed

Gurchain Ram v. Piara Lal And ORS

2023-08-09Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti5 pages

!"#$# % &'('

) ) ) ) ''''

# %* +$'

,,-

,,- '''$. %/% ) 0,)-'-) ) 0,)-'-) ) 0,)-'-) ) 0,)-'-)

*$%

)*'12#* 3-#%42 53 %/)*' *.

6-#%427/8 "

! * # %*' )*' *%9-#%427/8 "

! * 2*$. %/% ' ' :::::

)7';* 6< )7';* 6< )7';* 6< )7';* 6< 2.

# %*=*"2 #% >2 $!#6/*8#$# % #>.=4%/ */* /

$$/ 1? #8#6 =/4 ;-%# * #8#$# %<7 $2# *.=*7%%@=* 78#/52#"25 ** $ !

"2>%

$1%#$$=/#%@"= # %.* "/#%4$' 2"

$ ! # %*

# %!#6/1?*$. %/% ' =%/**/* =6 #$1 **/1?6#>#

# %52#"2#$.*

#%#%4 /"*.

$$/#% $=# ! * /"6

%/.*> %% #%3=%"

# %1? 2%-=1=/46 $$7 $2# *.=*.*

#%#%4 > *9 $'''$2 5%#%*/" 6 =*

22 =$$2 5%#%4*%" 6 =* 2*6 %/> $=*#%4 6$ > *6 $ 52#"2 5 $ #% 2 5%*$2#. ! /"* 2 6/*' 2

/!%/ $' %/ 5*/#*"

/ /> 6#$2 28 $$2 5% #% 2$# .6 23=/4>% /1 *$B/!%/ $5**$ #%/%

*!*!* >=$#%4 #%C=$ # %'%

# %# 5 664/

% .%#%42 $1%> /!* > $2 5%#%?66 5" 6 =*

%/5#%/ 52 $1% .%/1? 61#*'2" .? !

# %#$ %%@=* ' 2

# %5 $" % /1?!#6#%4*.6?52#"2#$ %%@=* ' %!

#% 2 *6#* "#8#6 6# #4

# %7 *$. %/% '

2#>$6!"6 #>/ 2*

13 #% 5# # %*'2 %6?4*=/4

*$. %/% ' 2 / " %$ *="

8 2 52#"2 5 /> 6#$2/ 1? 2 .

# %* !

* 2 3=/4>% %/ /"* /

&' ' && '2.

# %*2 /!#6/ 6 2#$3=/4>% 52#"2 6$ /#$>#$$/1? 2%//# 6#$ *#"

=/47 $2# *.=*8#/ 3=/4>% %//"*/

/ ' ' &&' 5 25 *$

2>!* >=$#%4 2 *

'23=/4>% #% 6/

/ ' ' &&#$ %%@=* ' #$"6 #>/

#/$ 2 %6?$ =*" !6#42

%/.

$$ 452#"2 2*$. %/% *?#%4 1$ *="

1?>#$*.*$% #%4 #% 23=/4>% %//"*#%2#$!

8 =*'2*$. %/% $ ' %/ 8% 13"

# %*4 */#%4 2=$ !$ 1? # %*'2#*

!!#/ 8# #$%%@=* '2@"= #%4 =* 2 $5* %46?

"2/ .* .* ? ! # %*#% */* *$ #%2#>!* >=$#%4 ! *$ #/ .* .* ?'%!

# %#$1 **/1?6#>#

# %'2*! *7 #>.=4%/ */* .

$$/ 1? 2 @"= #%4 =* /

%%@=* 7> ?9#%/6?1$ $#/'

=%$6 ! * 2 *$. %/% ' *4=/

2* #$ % #664 6# ? *#**4=6 *# ?" >>#

/1? 2@"= #%4 =* 52#6.

$$#%4

2#>.=4%/ */*/

/ 7%%@=* ' 2/= ? !

@"= #%4 =* @"= 2/"*/

/&' ' && 52#"22

#%/ !#% 6# ?'%!

# # %*B3=/4>% /1 *52 #$/#$ 1?#%4 3=/4>% %//"*/

/&' ' && '2 6!#6/1?2#>5 6$ /#$>#$$/1?6 *%///# 6#$ *#"

=/48#/3=/4>% %//"*

/ ' ' &&'2*! *7 2*8#$# %.*!**/1? # %*#$ 5# 2 = >*# >> ?9#%/6?1/#$>#$$/' '

2 8" %$#/*/ *4=>% %/2 84 % 2* =42 *" */"

*!=66?' #$>

* !*" */

, 6!#6/#8#6-=#

'& && =*"2 #% > 2*$$9#%4/"6

*6#! ! .*> %% #%3=%"

# % 52#"25 $ /"*/ 8#/ 3=/4>% /"*/

/&' ' && '/>#

/6?7 2$=# !#6/1? 2.6 #!!5 /"*/1?=.2 6/#%4

$2 5% $'''#$ 2 5%*$2#. !

.6 #!! %//!%/ $' %/ 75# 2/#*"

2/!%/

/> 6#$2 28 2$2 5%

. #% '''#% 2$# .6 !=* 2**$ #%#%4 2/!%/ $% #% *!*!* >=$#%4 #% C=$ # %1? 2 %/* #$#%4 %?$ * !" %$ *="

# %#% />#

/6?7 =*"2 #% > % ! 2 /!%/ ..66 !#6/ "#8#6

6 'B & ! && 52#"25 $=6 #>

6?/#$>#$$/8#/3=/4>%

%//"*/

/ ' ' &&52#"2#$%%@=* '2*! *7 2*6#!

4* /#%!

8 =* ! , 62 /

#%/!#% 6# ?' 5 , 62 !#6/@"=

# % ' /

/' ' =%/**/* =6

! * 2%! *">% ! ! *$ #/3=/4>% %//"*/

&' ' && 2*/* =6 / 6$5# 2/"*! *$."#!#"

.*! *> %"! **$ # % !" %3=4 6*#42 $ *! * %#%3=%"

# %52#"2 /$ $=%/*

DD=6 DD=6 DD=6 DD=6

' "*! *$."#!#".*! *> %"! **$ # % !" %3=4 6*#42 $7 "*! *$."#!#".*! *> %"! **$ # % !" %3=4 6*#42 $7 "*! *$."#!#".*! *> %"! **$ # % !" %3=4 6*#42 $7 "*! *$."#!#".*! *> %"! **$ # % !" %3=4 6*#42 $7 *! * %#%3=%"

# %' *! * %#%3=%"

# %' ; < E2* ? 52 > /"*! * 2$."#!#".*! *> %"

! " % 7 *! **$ # % !" %3=4 6*#42 $7 *! * %#%3=%"

# %72 1% .

$$/7 2 $ 2 % .. * =%# ? ! 1?#%4 2 /"* %/ 2 5#66!=66?!

#6/ 1?# 7 2/"*> ?1%! *"/#% 2"

$ !

/"*! **$ # % !" %3=4 6*#42 $1?

"2>% !2#$.* .* ?

*7#% 2"

$ ! /"*! * 2$."#!#".*! *> %" ! " % *! *

%#%3=%"

# %1?2#$/ # %#% 2"#8#6.*#$ %7 *1?

"2>% !

2#$.* .* ?7 *1?1 2'''''''''''''''''F 2*! *7 2 @"= #%4 =* #$ *C=#*/ 4#8 .. * =%# ? 1? 2/"*!

#6#%452#"2# "

%1%! *"/1?5 ? !

"2>% ! 2.* .* ? ! *1?2#$/ # %#%"#8#6.*#$ %'

2*! *7 2 #$ !=66? 3=$ #!#/ #% !#6#%4 2

# % %/ 1?

! 66 5#%4 2.* "$$ $.* 8#//=%/**/* =6 ' '

, *%/" =%$6! * # %* 6$ * #$/ 2#$$=

# %!#6/1? 2=%/**/* =6 #$1 **/1?

6#>#

23=/4>% %//"*#$/

/&' ' && $ /#$>#$$/ % ' ' && 52* 2#$

# % #$ !#6/ % ' ' '

2 8" %$#/*/ 2#$ $."

! 2.*$% "

$'% 2#$ *4 */7-"

! 2,#>#

# %"

* /$ $=%/*

' * 2@"= # % ! %?/"* ;

2* /"*4* #%4

*?#%3=%"

# %< * */* ! %?"#8#6" =* 568?

*$ GE2%H 2/"* * */*1" >$ %! *"

16 *52* 2/"* *

%? $=1$C=% */* /#*"

?>% !> %? * 2/6#8*? !

%?.* .* ? 1> /

*"=**#%4 .*# /$7 52% /!

=6 #% > 9#%4 2 .

?>% * /6#8*? #% *$."

! 52#"2 @"= # %#$$ =42 7

9$.6

* 8#//

# %! * %! *">% *@"= # % ! /"* 4* #%4 .*.

6#%3=%"

# %$2 1 $=13"

%? .*# / !

6#>#

# %'

2*! *7*4 */#%4 2@"= # % !/"*! *#%3=%"

2* #$ .* 8#$ "" */#%4 52#"2 %

# % !#6/ ! * %! *">% *@"= # % ! /"*4* #%4 .*.

6#%3=%"

# %$2 1$=13"

%?.*# / !6#>#

# %'2*! *7

9%1? *%/" =%$6! * # %*/ $% 2 6/ %?4* =%/'2.*=$ 6 !

2 #>.=4%/ */* /

"6 *6? #%/#"

.* .* .* "/=*#$1#%4! 66 5/ #>.6>% 2/"*.

$$/1? 2% -=1=/46 $$7 $2# *.=* $.* 8#//=%/**/* =6 !

2 / !#8#6 * "/=*7 &(' E# 2#$ 1$*8

# %7 2#8#68#$# %.*!**/1? .

# %*#$5# 2 = >*# %/#$7 "" */#%46?7/"6#%/'

%/#%4

# %$7#! %?7 6$ $

%//#$. $/ !' &'('

;)< ;)< ;)< ;)< $%/ E2 2*$.

9#%4B* $ %/

$B '

E2 2**. *