Sarvesh Mathur v. State Of Haryana And Another



  


     







!

"#$# %& ''  

 



    

 
&  () '

*
 + * ))  

 

 

 





 



 
  



+ * )), '

- .

!     "   #  $%  "   "

 & ' % () * "+,  
- ./ '.
'01 2
3 "  + ,  + *   %     "+,   " % 



   *+ 4  % + 5%  .6 .7 '.
-

%+ ,"    "

 ,  ,*      +   ++ '

  ,    
- ./ '.
' 01  2
3 5 , 5 "+, 0  3 +  "+,  % 8 "5    # 

 9  0:#3  "* ! "+,  ,,%

  12+, 8"5   # 

9  0:#3 *5$%# (",;"

'

)   ,,%  5 , 5$%    ""     "+       ", % ,   %  "     5 "  

"

  %    ) , #  , ,       "

  !  "+,     +     "  % , ,,5 <
:%*$%11+ ,
7..8
=.. +,5 5  ,, ""

 #+ + %  5,, , ,"   ""  "+5 " "+," * %  5% , "

 ""

  "++

%, 1" 4   + *5 ,5+ )"+ 1 , 1 

'

)   "  5,, , + ,    *$  ""  1 + %  1+ ,  
> ? " 5 *$   ""  5 

  *,,8  % *  , %   +    ,%  1 , 1  @   )",,  ,$  $  5    (", # ,, 55,,%""+," + ,  ""   5   5    "+,

,  * ,  :#   ,  "+, "+, % "+,

/ )  "+ , "" ,% ," *$"" , "!1   )"+ !1 "

   + "

 ("  

A

+  ?"* 5   ,%,   *

 5 

 %  *,,   !  + + ,  5   * ,   ,  1 # ! ""

& ' >* , ""

"+    5$  (+  ,5% 1 

    ",8+  B  "+,   % ,% + ""

& '

/

 > 5   %%   ""

 "

 *

   5* + ++ "+, 5 "   5  +,     ""

 "++ 5%*% 5% ,"

+$% , 1" 4   +

, 1 

?

:% *$%    1 , % +, 

 ," "" /  "(+"+*+"

+  ?.2 >. "   !  5 % ,%   5 % * "+,     # +  " # + ,  1  C    %,   ""

 "

5 $* +, > " +, "+*7 '.

01 (35 "  % % ,%  , 5,, , 5% %  :# 5 "  5 5

 *  "+,

%% "

  9%,    !  5 *4 , # +,  *%

  "   % ", % ,  *% "++

 * :#   "

 5 $ * +     "     + "+,

! "

 ""

 ,+ ,"  *$"" *

+%   1    % +   )"+ !1  + @$  ,   @)8(C  "

    1 % ,    ,  "   " 1 ,5 , "" %  D / !   

 "+,  % * + ,  *"$   "

 5 $   ,   "+, 8+ 5 , 

 * "+,

!  "5 2"

  

 ," 5 "   ,  ,"  "

?>0/3#  01 2
63* # ,E )#

6

%+  5 "  "+  * +    .-
.

'.
-01 2
?3 !    

  +, "  "   5   12 +, "* * ,%%* %,% " " ,  C1" 4 5 " 

 % * $ $54 

*   !   

 12+, " *+, ,5 , 1"%  , "  * %

 % ," ,"", * %  +    ",  + ?

;%  , " , 



  "  *++"*

8 "5    # 

 9   0:#3  *% % ,     

, "    * ,%  "+,      %  12+,    " * "+,  * ,4   9 " ,  %  

 
   ,+  *+   ,  ./ .= '.'
 5    ,    , 4   * %+," *  !  , ,,5 <03 ! 

"+, & # &88
'8
>'7 
- ./ '.
' 0   "+, 
- ./ '.
'3 5 % 4  *

 #++  ,"  C

%+   + 5   , *  

#

?

0*3 !   & >?'2F  
6 .= '.
' 0   "+, 
/ .= '.
'3 5 , %  4  *

#++," C

%+ +5,*  # 0"3 !   & '
.2F  
?

.
'.
- 0   "+,  .7 .
'.
-3 5 %  4   %  )

 9( 2)) %+

%4   "%A*,"5  *+

 " 

"+, 5"++ *,  % 

;

 9( 2)) %+ #

9( %+   !  + 5   , *

#++," C

%+ 03 !   & //6>8#8'.'.8C2+, 
'

./ '.'. 0   "+,  .= ./ '.'.3 5 % 4   % )   @   %+

%4   5  5,"",5       ,  4   5      "+,   %  

  ,%% +5 *

*  G*,% # # & ?

''.
- !

"+, 5"++ *,  % 

;

 @   %+   #  %+ ! "+, 5, *

#++," 

%+ 03 !    "+,  & ''7>?  
=
.

'.
-   + * #C

%+" %#

9(

%+  ) 8C;:

%+ 5 "

4 *

"+,

! +5 ,* #C

%+ *%  *+

 ",

 D > 9 " ,  

  

,,1   ++ "  ,"

 "


?>0/3 #     + *  #   ,E )# %+5 "  

, + "   +  "",,*" ,,%* 

>

)"

+

 )"+!1    * 8 "5    # 

 9   0:#3 ,   " ,  +       "

  *  G*,  + #   )9 0 *," )  9 % 3  C"+ "

   4   ", "+4       ,  '/."5+  "+ = ) ", *+* #

- (   ,,    5 , *  " %+ ,"  ", "+, 8 +*   (   +  ," ,*  "


?>0/3#  * ,E )#

%+  * "   ,   * ", H % + #  + 

 
.

,,  #   +,* %

 ,%  % ,  "++

 *  12+,   8 "5   #

9  0:#3 5 " , * 1+ *  C"+ "

     "

   *  G*,  + #    ",, ,  '/." *+ 

!  %    

  "

   "++

* "+ 1  7.." *

 "  +

  , * 1+ * C"+ "

  #  %     "

   %   !  8 + 

7

" 1 %  ""

,%% ()5 

+  *",
'

 %      4  %81 %% <+   5%     .6 .7 '.
-  %+ ,"D #  ,   )

 *% 5 +

 "+,  
'

.
'.
-  4   +    4             *    

! , 1 "

+   ,,5 <III#+, G ",     

  %

 %  "+, %  +""   " ,"

+   ,2 +, )   "

  5 "  :#G 1 +,  

  %  5 %     %  ""

 5   %  )   , "+G" ,"

+ "+, G",   

 "#,,

   ,$ $ ,  +  9!   ,  :# "+ $ *"$   "+,   "+, G ",    +  

,+  " 
7 -7 6>?
/ .6 '.
'

D
/ )   

)

 "",     ", "++   "%A*, "  "++ "+, *"% " !    5   %   ;

 

9(   2)) %+      #++  ," 9( %+  5JGJ,G*

#++," C

%+   ) "    % "   4 

=



5 " "* + *JG  +5"* ,"",""" %   ", 

    "  *      +  )"   *   % *" 5 "  *"" *

#++," C

%+5,, ! #    % "   4    * 1 %   )    5 ", % + *"  5 , * 4   *    *,  * ,%  "" +4  *

","

 ""

% 2",,J+  
6 5    "

%  ,  ,*   ""     ,, ,5 *    +     , ," #++," %+, %        ,,*  )"   "  ,"   ,     ,, * %  1+ * #++," %+" ,,%     * 5,,    "     + * 5 ,5 * $      +"  
?

!   ""%, ''  

+ * )) +,



:  $%8

$/

:   *,

$/