High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4284/2014allowed

Harbhajan Singh v. Sbi & ORS

2016-05-30Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!" #$%!&'

"() * !+,(!-!./( ""+ 0+1 ."!"!2 3!4"(+ 53"

!" "!# $ %&

6("(+ 5+"+ #!5!5+7!&,!83""(-13/7"9

,+ ++3""( 5+"++"9 ' 6("(+"(-13/7"(13,+5+"3"(/"9

+"$ %.!"5+"+8!:!5!)3#!")

+"(5""+ %+ .!,!)3#!")

++53" ;;;;; "!# $

'()*

""+<,-#"+!//+3 "(5+#3/"!"3 ,&"(=#1"/1+"51+1!#""(-13/7"!33#+3!"3 > ??)8(+,&+#+& '?) @'<*@ !/8"(#"(!, +3+3 %.!"5+" +8! :!5!) !+3 #1 + "( 5""+<,-#"+1,7""(!",&+"1 "(+/"+3!33

3!"3 @ ?*>)1+3"./( %!/!./( !7/!+(!)+3"

.7,)!"!!(!3"(5+5+"&351"""( !"(+ "( 5""+)!7&)!8!./( (+"!./( !7/!+(!)+3"

6!+!#()(1+3!51+(,++8+)!7&)1+3"./(!3 !+,(!-! ./() ,"( !3 !"(+) !

"+ "!2/ "( , "

7!+"&"(!7)/""(5+5+"& "(5""+!3( !"(+ 7+"/!/38"("(!2(,!255!33"#31#""( !+#(+5+"""+!35+")+1"/"7+"/!/ "(5+5+"& 8"("(!2(!

+7"3,++8+ !3"3#(!+/"( ! !,"&) +1"/ " 5!/ "( -13/7" !3 3#+

!/"()"(,-#"8+ 3),1""("+!1+"!7"

!!#1!37#(!#!7!+373"(!7!333" /+!"55+"1"&"!33#"(+/!+3"(+1 +#+3"(8"(8+(5 !1+ "(5""+(!,5!#3 +#+3, +"( ,-#"/1+"),1""(!7(!!, +23.(1,7""(!"51+1!#""(-13/7"!33#+) "(!2(!"+#+&5!"+&!71""(!"(3#+3!71" %+ .!,!) !+3 #1 + +53" 1,7""(!""(5""+<,-#"+(!!!!3"(+73& / "(1")8(#("7!"!!,!8(! +7"3 !#""

351"3,&"(!+3#1 +"(5""+.(1,7""(!""(

+ 5""+ 8! " (/( !3 3+& " 5+"#" "( 8+(5 !3 5 "(5+5+"&!3(!3,<!33"!!"(+73& !313+"!2"8"(3+!8"(1"#!"(1+"#7""(+#1 "(5""+ (!(!+3"(!+3#1 +"(5!+"!3/ "(+1/("(751/3+3+!3 "(8"(!""(,!21/(""" (!!"!!71"5#"!"++!/"( +!135!&315"(7)+!"(+ /!"(7#!1 !#"""!"#+7!5+#3/!/!""( ,++8++!3!,"(/!+73& +#+&(&#13(! ,7+/!"!3#!+ 1=!7/"(!+#(+5+"!3"( !7(13",!##5"3!+3!+&#1+ ( +/! ! 33 !1+ "( !"(+ "( 5""+(!

",33),1""( !#"+7!"(!""(+8! 1+3"./(!3"(#+#17"!#)"(,++8+)8()"!2/"( , " 7!+"&"(!7)/""(5+5+"&7+"/!/38"("( !2!7!,!3!+!"(8+(5 "(5""+<5!

"813, !+##!=+#+7!3/"(7!""+,!#2""("+! 1+"/+!"/,+"&""(5""+)8(+!)=< !#)(8+(5 (!,5+3(,!2813,!",+"&"2"(=#1"

"( 3#+ ,& +!/ "(+ 31 "(+ ,& / "( 77!, 5+5+"&)5!"!37!#(+&!&!5!"+&!71"1/("",

+#+3),1"""(7!+!373!(!,!35"3 (751/3+3+37/"(,-#"!8!"( +3+ !1#"5+#3/(+,&"<!3

5"""!3!83 ),+-.$/ '"!# * ()0.