High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4471/2013allowed

Kulwant Singh & ANR v. Rajinder Kaur & ORS

2019-03-28Mr. Justice Arun Palli6 pages

!" #"$%&%'( )

+,-. '!/%'01 '# '!1"2 "!%!%'"2& 3"2&,& 4%'#"2+ ,2 '#!1"2& "&5'#"'!& ( 6 7/ 7 / 2"&"'!( 2 /,-% '%8 #3$ !"8

2!1"5"!%!%'"2& 2+ 2 '9%2 '# 8 #3$ !"8

22"&5'#"'!' 2+%2!%/1 2: 8 #3$ !"8 2 2/ '#""5/,2%8 #3$ !"8

22"&5'#"'!' &;- 3< ,5! 8 #3$ !"8 2 2 &1;,5! 8 #3$ !"8

22"&5'#"'!'= 2/,'#"2/%'018 #3$ !"8

22"&5'#"'!'

7 /82 -

<!1%&5"!%!%'8!1"5"!%!%'"2&$1 --"'0"!1"2#"25 &&"#>< !1" %3%- ,#0" ,'%2 %3%&%'8 1 '#%0 218 # !"# ?

$5<

''"@,2"A 8><.1%$1!1" 55-%$ !%' 2"&5'#"'!' 1"2"%'8%" 4%'#"2+ ,28&"";%'0!.%!1#2 .!1"5"!%!%'5"'#%'0>" 2"!1 !,2!

,'#"2/"$!%' ?8. & --."# '# .1%-" --.%'01"2!.%!1#2 .!1"& %#5"!%!%'8-%>"2!<. &02 '!"#!1"2 ! %-" 6 2"&1&,%!61 !5 2! !1"%:5,0'"#2#"22" #& & --.&(A B1"%&&,"2"0 2#%'0#"3-,!%'% 525"2!< #"$" &"#'""#& !>"#"!"2:%'"#1"2"

2"8%'3%". !1" >3"8!1"52"&"'!

55-%$ !%'&! '#& --."# '#!1" 55-%$ '!%&5"2:%!!"#!

.%!1#2 .!1"52"&"'!5"!%!%'.%!1-%>"2!<! %-"!1" 2"&1&,%! !%&: #"$-" 2!1 !!1"5"2:%&&%'%&02 '!"#!!1"5"!%!%'"2 '-<!&"$,2"!1"-%:%! !%'5"2%# 2"&1&,%!>,!'! 2 '< !1"22" &'&%-">"$'&%0'"#!!1"2"$2#2: !"2#,"

$:5-% '$"C

& -2" #<'!%$"#%'!1"2#"2# !"#

*82,-% '%8 -" 2'"#$,'&"- 55" 2%'0 2!1"5"!%!%'"2&81 #>2,01! !!"'!%' !1%& ,2!!,-" 2#"2

!1"#" %3%-2$"#,2"8 * )8!&,>:%!

!1 !!1"-%>"2!<02 '!"#><!1"!2% -,2!3"22%#%'0 '<-%:%! !%'!1 !: < 2%&"%' %-%'0 2"&1&,%!81 &>""'.1--<"22'",&-<02 '!"#><!1 ! ,2!><&%:5-<2"

"22%'0!,-" !1"& %#2#"28.1--<%0'2%'0,-"

!1 !1" ,-"& $'! %'"# %' 2#"2

2" 2"52#,$"# 1"2"%','#"2(A

! '<!%:" !"2!1"%'&!%!,!%' &,%!8!1"5- %'!%

: < & 0 %'&! --2 '< !1"#"

"'# '!& > '#'1%&&,%!2 > '#' 5 2! 1%&$- %:( 23%#"#!1 !.1"2"!1"5- %'!%

%& :%'22!1"25"2&'

!.1:!1"523%&%'&$'! %'"#%'2,-"& ! 2#"2 DDD"@!"'#8'"%!1"2!1"&,%!'2 '<5 2! !1"$- %:&1 -->"

> '#'"#.%!1,!!1"-" 3" !1",2! ' 55-%$ !%' 2-" 3",'#"2!1"523%&!&,>A2,-" &1 -->" $$:5 '%"#>< '

%# 3%! !1"'"@! 2%"'# '# -&8% !1":%'22&,$1!1"25"2&'%&2"52"&"'!"#><

5-" #"28>< $"2!% %$ !" !1"5-" #"2!!1""

"$!!1 !!1"

> '#':"'!525&"#%&8%'1%&5%'%'8 2!1">"'"

%! !1"

:%'22&,$1!1"25"2&' E1"2"!1",2!%&& !%& %"#8F !1 ! &,%!:,&! %-><2" &' &:" 2: -#"

"$!8 2 >!1 !!1"2" 2"&,

%$%"'!02,'#& 2 --.%'0!1"

5- %'!%

!%'&!%!,!" 2"&1&,%! 2!1"&,>4"$!A: !!"2

&,%!25 2! $- %:8%!: <8'&,$1!"2:& &%!!1%';&

%!802 '!!1"5- %'!%

5"2:%&&%'!.%!1#2 . 2:&,$1 &,%!2&,$15 2! !1"$- %:.%!1-%>"2!<!%'&!%!,!"

2"&1&,%!%'2"&5"$! !1"&,>4"$!A: !!"2 &,$1&,%!2 &,$15 2! !1"$- %: E1"2"!1"5- %'!%

F > '#'& '<&,%!25 2! $- %:,'#"2&,>A2,-" 8 2 >.%!1#2 .& 2: &,%!25 2! $- %:.%!1,!!1"

5"2:%&&%'2"

"22"#!%'&,>A2,-" 8 1"&1 -->"-% >-" 2&,$1$&!& &!1",2!: < . 2# '# &1 -->"52"$-,#" 2:%'&!%!,!%'0 '< 2"&1&,%!%'2"&5"$!

&,$1&,>4"$!A: !!"22&,$15 2! !1"$- %: ?!1%'0%'!1%&2,-"&1 -->"#"":"#! ,!12%&"!1",2! !5"2:%!'" &"3"2 -5- %'!%

&! > '#' &,%!25 2! $- %:,'#"2&,>A2,-" 82!.%!1#2 .8,'#"2&,>A2,-" 8 '<&,%!25 2! $- %:8.%!1,!!1"$'&"'! !1"!1"2

5- %'!%

' '< 2"&1&,%!

%'&!%!,!"#'5"2:%&&%'02 '!"#,'#"2!1"- &!52"$"#%'02,-"8 !1"5- %'!%

&1 -->">,'#><!1"- . -%:%! !%'%'!1"& :"

: ''"2 &% !1" %2&!&,%!1 #'!>""'%'&!%!,!"#C

2,-% '%8 & -&-" 2'"#$,'&"- 22"&5'#"'!' 8&,>:%!

!1 !5,2&, '!!!1"%:5,0'"#2#"21 3%'0>""'5 &&"#82"&5'#"'!' 1 &%' $!%'&!%!,!"# 2"&1&,%!&"";%'0!1 !&1">"#"$- 2"#!>"!1" -"0 --<."##"#.% " #"$" &"#0 /%'01 2,-% '%1 # ,2!1"2&,>:%!!"#'!1"- &!# !" 1" 2%'0 !1 !%' $!!1"& %#2"&5'#"'!1 &>""'&5"$% %$ --<1"-#'!!>"!1".% "

0 /%'01%'52$""#%'0&,'#"28>!18!1"!29"1%$-"& $!8 *))8%' $- %:5"!%!%' %-"#8&,$152$""#%'0&>"%'0%'!1" 2: 4,#0:"'!

5 &&"#>< $2#%' !" "'$1 !1%&,2!%' )

2%&%'0,! $ &"'

8 & -&' $$,'! 4,#0:"'!# !"#

5 &&"#%'%3%-/,%!'

) ?)

1"& %#&,%!%&&! !"#!1 3">""'%'&!%!,!"#><!1"52"&"'! 5"!%!%'"2& 0 %'&!2"&5'#"'!' 1"2"%' & -&!1"1 '#%0 21,&%'0

2#8&"";%'0 #"$2"" : '# !2<%'4,'$!%'#%2"$!%'0!1",&%'0

2# ! !2 '& "2 !1" .'"2&1%5 5 2!%$,- 2 - ! %' 3,2 !1"

5"!%!%'"2&1"2"%'5- %'!%

&%'!1 !&,%!'!1"> &%& .%--&! !"#!1 3"

>""'"@"$,!"#><0 /%'018.1. &!1"2%0%' - --!!"" !1"& %# - ! 1 !4,#0:"'!$5< ''"@,2"A*1"2".%!1%&&! !"#!1 3"

>"$:" %' -.%!1!1" 55" - %-"# 0 %'&!%!><2"&5'#"'!' 1 3%'0>""' #%&:%&&"#

5'G,"2<!-" 2'"#$,'&"- 55" 2%'0 22"&5'#"'!' 8 1"&,>:%!&!1 !1"1 &'%'&!2,$!%'& &!.1"!1"2 '<&"$'# 55" -1 & >""' %-"#%'!1 !2'! 1"/7 %-"#><2"&5'#"'!' 0 %'&!!1"4,#0:"'! !1%& ,2!%' ' ?

*8. & -&#%&:%&&"#3%#" '2#"2# !"#

5 &&"#%'/7%3%-'&

5'G,"2<!-" 2'"#$,'&"- 22"&5'#"'!' &!1.

!1"%:5,0'"#2#"2%&&,&! %' >-"%' '<: ''"281"2" "2&!,-"

2#"2

!1" &2"52#,$"#1"2"%' >3"8!&,>:%!!1 !&%'$"!1" & %#2"&5'#"'!1 # 3 %-"# .2'02":"#<><. < %-%'0 5"!%!%'

,'#"2/"$!%' ?8!1"!2% -,2!1 & '!"22"#%'0%3%'01"2-%>"2!<! %-" 2"&1&,%!8 ,2!1"2>&"23%'0!1 !&1"

&1,-#'!>"> 22"#' $$,'!-%:%! !%'! %-"&,$1&,%! !%& %2&!!>"'!%$"#1"2"!1 ! !!1"!%:".1"''!%$"

:!%'. &%&&,"#%'!1%&5"!%!%'' *

8%'!"2%:&! <B -- ,2!1"2 52$""#%'0&C8 1 # >""' 2#"2"# >< !1%& ,2! .%!1 -" 2'"# $,'&"- 55" 2%'0!# < 2!1"5 2!%"&>"%'0!1 !!1"& %#2#"2. &%'!1" $'!"@! !1"&,%! %-"#><2"&5'#"'!' !"2!1"%:5,0'"#2#"2. & 5 &&"# ?

!"2$'&%#"2%'0!1": !!"28%'!1"5%'%' !1%&,2!8!1%& 5"!%!%''""#&!&,$$""#&%:5-<'!1"!,$1&!'" ,-" 2#"2

!1"8%'.1%$18%!%&&5"$% %$ --<&!%5,- !"#!1 ! '<-%>"2!< 3 %- >-"%' !"2:& ,-" !1"& %#2#"28.,-#'!

"$!!1"- . -%:%! !%' '# % 2"&1&,%!%& %-"#%'!"2:& !1"" 2-%"22,-"8!1"5- %'!%

%'!1" 2"&1&,%!

.,-#&!%-->">,'#><!1"- . -%:%! !%' &% !1" %2&!&,%!1 #'!>""'

= %'&!%!,!"# 1"2"

2"8!1"%:5,0'"#2#"2%&>3%,&-<.1--<"22'",& %'!1" $" !1"&! !,!2<523%&%'%!&"- = '&"G,"'!-<8!1"5"!%!%'%& --."#8.%!1!1"%:5,0'"#2#"2 &"! &%#" &2"0 2#&!1">&"23 !%': #"!1"2"%''!1"%&&," -%:%! !%'

%' '< 2"&1 &,%! %'&!%!,!"# ><2"&5'#"'! ' !"2&1".%!1#2".!1"

5"!%!%' %-"#><1"2,'#"2/"$!%' ? 2!%"&!!1"&,%!5"'#%'0.,-#'. 55" 2>" 2"!1"!2% - ,2!'=

* 1."3"28!1 !&,%! -2" #<&! '#& #4,2'"#! '< 5 2!%$,- 2# !"8!1"<.,-# 55" 2'!1 !# !"8.%!1!1"&,%!!52$""#

2. 2#;""5%'0%':%'#.1 !1 &>""'>&"23"#1"2"%' >3"

'< 55-%$ !%' %-"#,'#"2/"$!%' !1"7%:%! !%' $!8 '# '<%&&,"2 %&"#'!1" 55-%$ >%-%!< !1"52%'$%5-"

.,-#' !,2 --<>"$'&%#"2"# 55252% !"-<><!1"!2% -$,2!

)

"#$"%&'

5;H3$0 20 ()*%+ E1"!1"2&5" ;%'0H2" &'"#

"&H E1"!1"2"52! >-"

"&H