Balwant Singh Gupta And ORS. v. The Tribunal And ANR.

  
   
 

 !

"#$ %$&'(')*+ ,-
 

            
 * ./ 0
0 / ./ 0
 00  1$($)#* 12"3"')4%5&"#$ 1#6$7$#'#')$1(')
( + 4

")%1$(7)%$)#(8# ')
+- 9

(0:;") $5'0"<$)"4%5&"#$ 1 ( $$7"=':1'4%5&"#$ 1#6$7$#'#')$1')
 +9-

10:;$$#06$>")%4%5&"#$ 11$(7)%$)# ?

;715$;$)#1:(#')
( + 4 4 +9- 

")% 1#6$7$#'#')$1')
+- 9

 "2$(6')%"= 6'(1%$1@'==%'(7($ "A:)&6 7$#'#')(A$"1')B
 ( + 4 4 +9-")%+- 9

4"(&;;)C:$(#')( ="@ ")% "&#("1$')5=5$% )
( + 4 ")% +9-

4#6$=")%@)$1( "1$($$>')B :1#6$1$)6")&$;$)# &;7$)("#')"@"1%$%A3#6$1'A:)"=4

  ;715$;$)#1:(#4")('

1(61#4.#6$1'A:)"=.!4@6$1$"(')
 +- 9

4#6$71"3$1'( 11$%:&#')#6$1$ @$5$14#6$ "&#(6"5$A$$)$<#1"&#$% 1;
 +



1'$ =34#6$ "&#( #6$&"($"1$#6"#=")%;$"(:1')B>")"=( ")%+;"1="(')D6"(1"(,-8 +? !4,-- 8?9!")%,-9 ,?8!4('#:"#$% @'#6')#6$#@)(6'7 ")('@"("&C:'1$%A3@);715$;$)#1:(#4 ")(' 

1  (61#4  .#6$  ;715$;$)#  1:(#.!  5'%$  )#' '&"#')  %"#$%

  - '((:$%:)%$1#6$:)2"A@);715$;$)#1:(#&#4

1(61#4.#6$&#.! 1&)(#1:&#') /"27"#"' "1>$#:)%$10&6$;$ 96$(";$@"( ==@$%A3)#'

'&"#')%"#$% -  -+'((:$%:)%$1 0$&#')(  !")% #6$&#6$/")%&C:'('#')
==$&#1

1(61#4 .#6$
==$&#1.!45'%$"@"1%%"#$%+  9+"(($(($%#6$&;7$)("#')E
-8F?7$1(C:"1$3"1% 1#6$"&C:'1$%=")%BB1'$5$%"B"')(##6$"@"1%

#6$
==$&#14#6$="%)@)$1( '=$%A2$&#')(4@6'&6@$1$1$ $11$%##6$ 1'A:)"=6$1$('%$)# #6$1'A:)"=45'%$2:%B;$)#%"#$% 9 

"(($(($%#6$;"1>$#5"=:$ #6$"&C:'1$%=")%E
9,F?7$1(C:"1$3"1% G'%$($7"1"#$2:%B;$)#%"#$% 9 

4#6$(($((1(')#6$1'A:)"= "(($(($%#6$&;7$)("#')E
+,F?7$1(C:"1$3"1% 1#6$ 1)#71#')  #6$=")%:7# ,.@'%$(#1'7")%
-8F?7$1(C:"1$3"1% 1#6$1$;"')')B =")%(;"21'#37')')@"(#71$5"'=4#6$=")%@)$1(@$1$B1")#$% &;7$)("#')E
+,F?")%
-8F?7$1(C:"1$3"1%4"(;$)#')$%"A5$ B"')(##6$"

1$("'%2:%B;$)# #6$1'A:)"=4#6$7$#'#')$1("1$A$ 1$ #6'(&:1# 6$  7$#'#')$1(  1"'($%  "  A1'$  "1B:;$)#  #6"#  71'1  #  #6$ "&C:'('#')') C:$(#')4#6$1$@"( $"1='$1"&C:'('#')@6$1$)#' '&"#')

  :)%$10$&#') + #6$&#@"('((:$%)

 - 6$;"##$11$B"1%')B "(($((;$)# &;7$)("#') 1#6"#"&C:'('#')@"(&)('%$1$%A3#6'( &:1#')
8

, 9 H"=@")#0')B6")%#6$1(56$/")% &C:'('#')  1'A:)"=  ")%  #6$1(4  %$&'%$%  )  , ,,+  ")%  #6$ &;7$)("#')@"("(($(($%"##6$ ="#1"#$ 
8,F?7$1(C:"1$3"1%6$ "

1$("'%=")%@"(=&"#$%) $=6'?'(("11"%#@"("&C:'1$% 1 %$1) "1>$#&"==$%#6$)%'1" "1>$# $5$=7;$)#0&6$;$)#6"#&"($4#6$ 1'A:)"=6"%"(($(($%#6$&;7$)("#')E
8,F?7$1(C:"1$3"1%")%

,F?7$1(C:"1$3"1% 1#@%'

$1$)#&"#$B1'$( =")%
)('%$1')B#6$ 7#$)#'"=#6$1$ 4#6'(&:1#6"%"(($(($%#6$&;7$)("#')E
8,F?7$1 (C:"1$3"1% =")%6$"1$""&C:'1$%#6$1$')@"( >")"=(")%+;"1="(6$=")%')#6$71$($)#&"($'(=&"#$%@'#6')")(' @)(6'7")%#6$"1$"'(;$1$=3>")"=(")%+;"1="(#@"("&C:'1$%

1%$5$=7;$)#"(/"27"#"' "1>$##@"(=&"#$%&=($##6$6$"1#

#6$  &'#3  ")%  #6$  "1$"  "=1$"%3  %$5$=7$%  6$  1'A:)"=  "(($(($%  #6$ &;7$)("#') 1#6$$)#'1$=")%E 
9,F?7$1(C:"1$3"1%4@6$1$"(#6$ (($((1("(($(($%#6$(";$E
+,F?")%
-8F?7$1(C:"1$3"1% 1#@ %'

$1$)#&"#$B1'$( =")%(#6$;"21'#37')')@"(#71$5"'=4#6$ 7$#'#')$1(@$1$B1")#$%&;7$)("#')E 
+,F?")% 
-8F?7$1(C:"1$ 3"1%1#6$7:17($ "(($((;$)# &;7$)("#')4#6$1$('%')B $;A$1  #6$1'A:)"=6"%1$='$%:7)#6$"@"1%7$1#"')')B#$"1='$1"&C:'('#') ")%B1")#$%')&1$"($ 1#6$#';$B"7) "&#4#6$$)#'1$=")%6"5')B#6$ 7#$)#'"= A$')B:($% 1&;;$1&'"=7:17($(")%A$')B"(;"==&6:)>4 %$($15$(#A$"(($(($%"##6$(";$1"#$')(#$"% ")3A$=#')B(3(#$; )#6$#6$16")%4=$"1)$%&:)($= 1#6$;715$;$)#1:(# (:A;'##$%#6"#1$='")&$)#6$$"1='$1"@"1%'(##"==3;'(?7="&$% 1#6$

  1$"()#6"#=&"#') #@71#')( =")%'()#&;7"1"A=$6$71$($)# &6:)> =")%'(=&"#$%)')%?1"%4@6$1$"(#6$171#')@"(=&"#$%)

$=6'?'(("11"%6$(($((1(6"%1'B6#=3"(($(($%#6$5"=:$&)('%$1')B #6$$5'%$)&$A1:B6#)1$&1%A3#6$7"1#'$(6$"@"1%%$()#&"== 1 ")3')#$1 $1$)&$A3#6'(&:1# $"1%=$"1)$%&:)($= 1#6$7"1#'$(")%7$1:($%#6$7"7$1 A> )#6$&"($')6")%4#6$"&C:'('#')'( "(;"==&6:)> =")% ;$"(:1')B>")"=(")%+;"1="(6$(";$6"%A$$)"&C:'1$% 1/"27"# "' "1>$#6$1$('%')B

'&$1 #6$1'A:)"=4')6'(7')')46"( )#'&$%#6$ "&##6"#$5$)'

#6$=")%7$1#"')')B#$"1='$1"&C:'('#')@"( =&"#$%) $=6'?'(("11"%4#6$=&"#') #6$"&C:'1$%=")%@"()#=$(( 7#$)#'"="('#'(=&"#$%&=($##6$"A"%' ")('#@)46$)&$4'):1 7')')4#6$1$'()$111')7="&')B1$='")&$)#6$$"1='$1"@"1%7$1#"')')B #  #6$  "&C:'('#')    =")%  1  %$1)  "1>$#  &"==$%  )%'1"  "1>$#

$5$=7;$)#0&6$;$4@6'&6@"()$3$"1")%$'B6#;)#6(71'1##6$ "&C:'('#')')C:$(#')6'=$"(($((')B#6$&;7$)("#')A"($%#6$1$)4 #6$1$('%')B

'&$1 #6$1'A:)"="(($(($%#6$&;7$)("#') 1#6$ $)#'1$=")%E 
9,F?7$1(C:"1$3"1%4"( 1#6$$"1='$1"&C:'('#')4#6'( &:1#')"=@")#0')B6.(&"($ (:71"!6"%"(($(($%#6$&;7$)("#')E
8,F?7$1(C:"1$3"1% 8>")"=(")%+;"1="( =")% 6$A$=#')B(3(#$;@"(%)$"@"3@'#6):15'$@4#6$7')')$<71$(($% A3#6$1$('%')B

'&$1 #6$1'A:)"=@"(;1$1$"()"A=$"(&;7"1$% ##6$(($((1(4@66"%"(($(($%#6$5"=:$E 
+,F?")% 
-8F?7$1 (C:"1$  3"1%  1  #@  %'

$1$)#  &"#$B1'$(    =")%  )  #6$  71&$((4  #6$ (($((1(=(#('B6# #6$($##=$%71')&'7=$( ="@1$B"1%')B"(($((;$)#

8 5"=:$ #6$=")%4@6'&6'( '# 1:1A")'("#')")%'(=&"#$%@'#6')#6$ ;:)'&'7"==';'#(6$ "&##6"##6$"&C:'1$%=")%@"("(;"==7'$&$  >")"=(")%+;"1="(@"("=()##">$)')#&)('%$1"#') 1#6$1$"()(;$)#')$%"A5$4#6$@1'#7$#'#')( '=$%A3#6$ =")%@)$1("1$"==@$%4@6$1$"(#6$7$#'#') '=$%A3;715$;$)#1:(#'( %'(;'(($%6$=")%@)$1("1$6$=%$)#'#=$%#&;7$)("#')E
9,F?7$1 (C:"1$3"1% =")% 6$7')')$<71$(($%A3#6$ 1$('%$)# #6$1'A:)"='("&&%$7#$%")%#6"# #6$(($((1('(($#"('%$ 6$3(6"=="=(A$$)#'#=$%#"==(#"#:#13A$)$ '#("5"'="A=$##6$;:)%$1 #6$&#6$';7:B)$%"@"1%'(;%'

'$%##6$$<#$)#')%'&"#$%"A5$

"2$(6')%"=!

:%B$ "1')%$10')B60'%6:!

:%B$ + ,- ;> 6$#6$1(7$">')BF1$"()$%*

$(F 6$#6$11$71#"A=$*

$(F