High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4211/2018dismissed

Parvinder Singh & ORS v. Didar Singh

2018-07-31Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan15 pages

!" #$ % & '

(% )*( +(*+

(*+ ,

!!"#!"$% & ' ()* + , - & * .+ / 0 1 ) $2 ,, + (

3 00

4 / + +

3 0 !#"!!"$$ + 5 3 0 ( 6

/ 7 8 8 / & 0

9 *

+: &

, *

;"";!"$) &

+ !<$$!"$#* '0

/ 3

0 :

+ 0 0 + 5

0 !#"!!"$$ ' !#$"!"$$ ;$$!!"$< / 0 &0* & * 6 1 1 2 $$ ,, 3 4 / + (

& * + / +

00 / / ! = 00 ( + , - /

5 6 +

3 0 /

0 +

' 0 + /

,: 0 & 1 ) $2 ,,* /

+ ( ; = , - 00 + / 0 1 ) $2 00 / + 0 : +/

00 / + / 00 , 0

&3 00* 0 +

00 0 > 1 ) $2 00 /

/ 0 + ?

/ 0+ +

0 + ' 0 + , / + 0

00 5 + 6 ,: 3

/ / 0 < ,

+0 00 + 0

00 / + + 0 1 ! ! ,, > +0 + 1 2 $$ ,, / / + 3 0 +

+ +

+ / / 0+ 0 3 0

( 0 '

# 4

0 0 0 , -!

-./!0 1!2!3$/!2 2/!

23!

+!/4!2 +!

"/! (!25!#" !3//!

#2 !

# "/2 &, . %@%! !"$"* -20 #6"27 82!" *3"# - "62"$/+ 6"!" 2!"*3"# &!"$;* $ ,, )!# ) >

0 + /

' ' $ / +

+ (

/ 0 0 5 0 6 >/ /

!#"!!"$$ A

& ( $ ; B # + <* 0 ;<!"""C( +

0 ' + 0 0 / 0 $""""""C( 0

0 D 0 + + . + .+ !#"!!"$$ /

. & +

* / # ( -+ A + 03 + . 2 4 / A

+ "$$$!"$$ >/ !#$"!"$$ A

' ' +

: /

' / ;$$!!"$< / /

0 + 0 0 / 1 ;$$!!"$<

03 + . + .+ '

+ + . %

/ (

/ &

* +

+ '

/ / 3/ E /

' 0 !#"!!"$$ / A

0 0 $""""""C( / ' ' ;$$!!"$< /

/ 0 @ > 0 0 0 / 0 / ,

/ (

1 2 $$ ,, + ( / 0 + 0 / '

;$$!!"$2 /( 54 / +

;$$!!"$2 4 / 0 0+ / 0+ 0 + D

;$$!!"$26 + "@"#!"$) / 1 2 $$ + ;"";!"$) + (

1 ) $2 + ;"";!"$) / + ";"#!"$2

0 !!"#!"$% $$ 0 1 ) $2 ,, $@"% 1 ! ! /

00 / + + 5$2

00 ( D , 0 / 0

0 0 +

00 + 0 0 + 0 :

+/ 00 + / 00 ,

0 + 00 0

1 ! ! ,, /( 5! / 0(&$* 7 / 0 /

03 ? +

0 :

0 + / , &!* : 0

0(F

0 :

0 /

0 : &;* 10 (

0 0

? +

0 '

/ ,

/ 06 : / (

/ /

0 +

3 0 3

0 0 0 $! 4 0 1 ! ! ,, + 00

00 / / + +

+ 00 / +

0 . + + &!* &;* !

0 + 0 / : + 0 + 0 +: / +( 00 0 1 ) $2 ,

0 0 0

+ + /

00 + / , 1

+ 0 + /

/ + & / 0 + * / / ' 1 ) $2 ,, 0 . 0 00 + 0 + , 0 :

+/ ? $2 1 )

00 / + 0

00 , 0 /

+ + / 00 / 0 /

+ + + 00 0 4 + / + /

0? +

+ 4 +

+ + 0 +/ 0 & + <* / 0

+ 0 / /

/ + + 0 3 00

0 1 ) $2 G

+ , / +

$; 4 0 +

&* / 0 0

1 ) $2 ,, 00 +

D 00 + / + , 0 0 + >

, + / / /

/ /

/ 0 0 0 0 , 4 / + ' , /( 0 ;!$@@$ 0 +/

0 : !; = 0 : / 4 0 + 3/

+ ;!$@@$ /

: +/

/ 0 +

6 &70 + ,* '''''

'''''

5;; ,

$@@$ + 0 > + / /

0 / D , 0

: 0 0 + +

1 ! ! , ,6 $< =+ ;; + /

+ H /

+ + / 00

/ + 0 : 0 +

1 ! ! / >/ + !! !< & ;# ;%* / + + 0 , +:

/ 0 &

$$ * 0/ 0 3

' >

00 + / + 0 + + /

00 / / + (0+

0 $# 4 :

0 / + + 0 ' ' + ;$$!!"$< / + !<$$!"$# 00 +

+ (

;"";!"$)

0 / + +

0 + /

/ + 0 :

0 / / ? 1 !

! & * 0

+ $) > @ $2 0

0 ,

&* /

/( 5@ 1 ! $ : / 0 /

1 ! !

0 /

0 : 0 /

03 4

1 ! ! ,, 03 /

0 + 0 : 4 0 + 1 ! !&!* 0 0 : 0

0 / 0 0 + 3 3 / + 0 :

0 + 1 ! ! &;* /

+ 0 0

0 + +: 0 0 '

/ + + 4 0 1 ! !&!* &;* ,, / +( 1 ! !

0 /

0 : 0 /

03 /

0 : 0 4 /

+: 3

0 0

6 &70 + ,* ''''

''''

5$2 - >

+ + /

1 ! ! ,, / + + / / /

1 ! ! &;* / + - : - >

, 0 >/ / + /

0 / + + 0 1 ! ! ,, + 0 1 ! ! ,, 3 0

0 4 + / /

/ + 0 / + + 1 ! ! ,, / / + 1 !

! ,, / + D

0 0/ / 0 / + 3 >

, + + 0+ >

" # $2

&* 1 ! ! / / / / 00 /

0 00 / + 0 > + 0 + + $% ,0 / +

$ + / 00 0 1 ) $2 ,,

+ ' 3

00 +/

/ 0 , / + +/ + $2 / 0

+ / 00

00 , /

00 /

+ 00 + +

$@ >

0 4 / / /

+ 00 & * / / 0

+ + ( . + 1 2 $$ ,, /

(

3 0 / 0+ 0 3 0

' &/

* 00 +

00 + 4 ' + , /

00 !"

/ 0 00 0 0 , 9 #2!2!!#9 !

#5 +:!3 1/!2!4/#!9 &!"")* $!

,, $ + / / + /( 5)" + 0 :0 1 ) $2 / /

/ :0 / 0 /

+ + 00 + + , % " 0 00 / / 6 !$

/ 00 0 /

0 0 ' , +"!" (

&!"$$* $!

,, !)

+ ( 5% + 1 ) $2 ,

/ 0

0 0 + 00 + 0 0

0 + /

H+

/ +

0 /

.0 00 / 0 6 >

8 +

3 0

0 + + 0

+ 3 /

3 00 + 3

0 + +/

00 + / + + 0 !! ,: / 4

0 . 7(*+ 8 65&,

3 C E + E