← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4271/2017dismissed

Joga Singh v. Satpal Singh

2017-09-05Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal16 pages

                      

        



 !"

# $

   

     

  %&"'(%) %) 

     

    ! 

  "



  #   

  $

 

"

%   &&&    '()

   

   

 *+ *+(-   .

 /0

 1   .

    

*2"



 "

" "



+, *++(3  '*)

 ""%  "  " .." 

  "3

 " 

   

 +, *++(  

" 4  , 3 "  

"

 %

 '5)  

(2 +4 *++2

"

 



 



3

"

 

+, *++( 

"    " "3  "3



"  "

 

 "

 

 

   "



      

    "

 

 ""

7  "

 " 

   

      " " 3  "3



 "  " 3   

  ""  

  

 

   

 

 ""   

 3  

" . 

 "

  3 "3



"3 

" 

  3  '8) "

 "  

"  



3 3 *4 *+(+ :  



"



  "

 3  "3 *4 *+(+ "

 

 

 

"



   

  "

; 

 ""

7  "

 " 

 



 "

3 "3*4 *+(+



 ""   

 

 

',) "

   3  

"    



 

$ 1   3 *- *+(, :

"

$<  01 

.   . 



'=) :

  1 "



 3

 "3 

:  

3 

  3 "3*4 *+(+

  *4 +5 *+(+

 3   

(8 *+((    . .

    .

 :  

 

     "     "

"

3"

(821 '-) >+8 *+((

1 

"  ?   

               

  

    

      !  "#  !

!   



  $  %

    %      !

   

 & '2) >(8 *+((

1 

"  ? ' ( ) ) *+   , -    

        !   

       

     "# ,      !    

     



 ,  !   !      !  

  

       !    !  

  . 

 

 

  





 

 

/0 1 2+*3 *%1 3 4  5  "#& '4) !.  "

    

 (8 *+((      1  "

 



 

   

+8 *+((

  

3 

 " 

(8 *+((



   

 

    3

 "

 

    

 3   

      .

'(+) :

    1        

 

 !

"#$$%#&#

! #"



3   

3

   

 

    

""

 " ".

 " 

$<

 0 1     

 "      

 " 

 "3

  

  "  "

  ""  *, +4 *++2 

"



   

 

  " "

 "" 

"   3 "3

 

 "  "

 "

 

  " 

 

 7  "

  "

 

     

  ""

     .  

 3   1    



  

 "

 "" 3  

 

; +8 (* *++2"

3 ; 

3   

     



 .

 

"



   "

"

 .

 " ?

 

 "

;

 3

 "    

/0

1 

 

3 

   

 

 

3 





"

"



 

 " *.

 "

"



 "

;

$<  0 "

 3  

.

 

".

 3 .   

 *2@(A "

 

  "

 7



". "

"  3

 *.

*3 

$<  01 

" 

 "3

 3 

$



 $<  0 1    

         

 "

 "

     

3 

 '(() :

    1  "

    #  !" &'

(  $ 

!

"#!#$$%" )*+ 

    " ?

3

 "

 

3".3 "

 

 



 " "

 



1 :

  1      , &-$ &   '. $'

/!+" #!#$$%" +/

3 ""

3

  

   

  



 " 3  .3 "





".  "   

  "



 "



 '(*)

        1     

%$0 1 # $ 2$   #  %'--  ///!" # !#$$%" 3*+ 



 "  " 3 

.3  " 

   

3 "  

 "



. 

 

 " .   

   

     "  "

 

 ; .

  

3.

'(5) :

    1  "

    3

 

(8 *+((    



 

+8 *+(( >(( += *+(( 

/0

 1

 3   

 .

   



(- *+((

    "

  

".

 3   

 



 += +2 *+(( 7

3

"  

(( += *+((

/0

  

   "

 "

 

 

 

 3   " 

 



 

 ""

"





     

 "

 :  133   $: 3

: 133   



" "

3

    

+= +2 *+(( 3  "





 "



  

 "

 

     



     ;

 "   :  133 

/0

1  

+= +2 *+(( 



3





 :

    1 

  "

 "

 

 

 *2 "

 

  "

 

  B  .  "

   

 += +2 *+((  

 ? ' ( ) ) *+   , -  , 6  5/ +*    

7  ! 

   

 +

   7       !

       $  %

   ! %  6   ,$ *  %   

  $  %

     

 

  !    +   ,  

    



 8 !   , 69/0 !  !   :          ;    6 !5 !             

 6   !       ;    

   

/0 1 2+*3 *% 1 3  4  5  .& '(8) 7  " "  "

      1 



""

+4 +8 *+(+

"

 

 

3 "   

 5( +- *+(+ +4 +4 *+(+ +2 (+ *+(+ *4 *+(( *= +5 *+(( +8 *+((  (8 *+((  3

 " 

 3

   "

3

  3

   . 3  



 "

 

 +8 *+((  (8 *+(( .

 3   (8 *+((%(- *+(( 

"

  

(( += *+((+= +2 *+(( 3 

 1    

 "

   



 3

.

 

   

 

 

 "

C   "

 "  "

    



    . "   * .

  * 3   

$<  01 40!&-"



 

 .

$<  01 40!&-"



  (5 +4 *+(( 

"



     . " "  

" 3 

  



     

 

 

  

+8 *+(( (8 *+((  += +2 *+((

   



  

*2"



 "

"

"

(5 +4 *+(( '(,) 7 

 3 3  .  

 "

 '(=) 7     



.    

  "

  "

  



 :  

 3

    3 



*4 *+(+

"  +4 +8 *+(+ >5( +- *+(+3

 

1  ""

    +4 +4 *+(+  > +4 +4 *+(+

  "

  +2 (+ *+(+ 

  ;  " 3

  > +2 (+ *+(+

  "0  " " " 

    

   

 /0

 1  

33  . ""





 

3 

" 

7 "33 .

  

    *4 *+(( "

33

 > *4 *+((

 ""

 

  .

 3

   

3 

  3 7 "

3 .



    *= +5 *+(( "

33  " "

"." .

  > *= +5 *+((

  "

  +8 *+(( " 33      "

 '(-) /  .

   

 +8 *+((  

 "

"

3

 3 " 3.



(2 +4 *++2 

0."3   ".



 3

  

 

 

 (8 *+((" 



 . 

 "

 "

 "     

 .   

    "  "

   

3

 3

    

     . B3 "



 

(8 *+(( 3  7

  

/0

1 3

 3.



(2 +4 *++2.."

 " 

  

 

   .

 /0

  +8 *+((  6 "

    

 



 3

"

 

 

      

.  

 

    3

 "

    .

 (( += *+((  '(2) 

 1  

   

+8 *+((

3



   (8 *+((    .   



  

 

(8 *+((    



 

+8 *+((



3  ;   (8 *+((%(- *+((   

  7  " 

   

 +8 *+((  (8 *+((   . 3 

 B3

 

 " 3   

 

 *4 *+(+ 

:  

""



 +4 +8 *+(+"

"

 . 



 "

 3   (8 *+(( 

    

 .

   3  .

 $<  0 40!&-"

'(4) 7 ""

  3 

"

  5 $'

 !$0 0"  &'

$ (   -& 

3!"(+ 6 .

    

".    "

. .

/

      4 0 !&-"

 $<  0 1   

          

  "

 "

 "    . "

 3 

 6    

 

 





 

3"

*2"



 "



. 

 



"" 



  

3

  

   .

/

 

            $   7 $ /6 !"(+/



 



". "

 

     

 "



 " 

3

"

 "

"     3

  "0



" "  7



  



 ;

"? " 3  "  ;





    

  



    '*+) 

 

+8 *+((





    .

 "

  3 

 6

    .      " "

"?

3 

     '*() 7  "     &$- $'

   '.$ $'

 /6 !" ( /    &-$      $

      / )  &.8  1 *    $'  9%, $  //6 &.8 163 # $8 $98

 !%"

)  &   %' $'

   

+!" ( 6+  $ $'

 &$% $'

// !"( *     $%   

!)" # !#$$%" 3))  &0  $'

 (% !

):*"(

  D



".   



 

 ;

 " ?  " 

  

 "



".3 "

 



.3

   

      "

 "

 

 3 

 "

 6

  "      .

 .  " 

  3  3 .



" 

  

 

   "



 



 "

1  

 1  

 "

"



.3

"



 '**) /

 "

3 0"

  



"3

:  

 

 *4 *+(+  6

  "  "   +4 +8 *+(+

"



 "" " 33





        

 5( +- *+(+ +2 (+ *+(+ *4 *+((*= +5 *+(( "

+8 *+((



"

   

     





 

3

"

  (8 *+((%(- *+((    ".

.3   '*5) 6 

"

 "3

   

 

. 



   "

 3  6      3     3

 "  "

 E3. 

   



 .     " 

 " 

  "3

  

  

 

 

  



 ""%

  



". 





  





 3

 6

 ".         "

.

.

 6  1   5 $'

 !$0 0"  &'

$ (40 !&-" 

 "     6 



 "

 

 " 

    .

        "

" 

  "3

 .         3. 

 6  "

 

*8"

 

.

  . 

 

  

 

 





  

1    



'*8)     

 "  



 " 

      3 .  ?

3 .

 

" "



 





       

 

  " 1  

  1      

  "

 "

  3 .

 .  .     

      3   "  3 3







   

    "  



".3 "



 



'*,)

   "

   3 

 "

 

3

 

    .  

3 " 

+8 *+(((8 *+(( .

 /0

 1  

 *2 "

 

  "

  

     "

         ""   

       " "3



  

  "



 "

 

 6



 "

  

 "

 "

 

        3 ""

"



    " 

 "

 "

 

   "

 "

       

"

  3

   

 "   

    " "

        3

   .  







  '*=) 7 "

7 ".  ."3 .

 3    

 *+ *+(-   .

 /0

   . 



"  . "

"3  

3 

.3   * % ) +          +4 *+(- 



,-

- ..

 !

/0 1 2!3    0 ,-

- . 1.

45      0