Risala Etc. v. Ruldu Etc.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 26.08.2015 Risala (died) through LRs and another 1.. Appellants versus Ruldu and others 11Respondents
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Kuldip Singh
!"!
#
Yes
Yes
! Yes Kuldip Singh, J.
"
$ %&
'!
(! (
)!(#
*+,-
"
!(
)!(#
/+,*
&.
!&!( 00 '
1+
# ! (2*34 #
)!(#
%-%+,
&. !&!( '
$%5 %*%+, ! & ! & (!
(
!
(
% 6
!
1+
(!
! # ! (2*34 # ! .
! ( ) 7
"
)!(#
%-%+,
' ! $%5 %*%+,
!& !( ! &
! & (!
(
#
)!
!(
(
# (
.
#
0 .
!
$ !
!
8
#. & (
#
1+
."
$ %
& (!
(
&
.
(
# # &!
. &4 9 !
.!#
"
$ %(
!#&#
$00
!#
'
"
! ( "
$00
# (!
$00"
$00 9 !
!#
4
!#
& ( (
!
#
!
$00 &
7
!#& #
$00
&
(
: (
: ( ( .#
# .
$
.
# .
(
; #!
:
2551< 4
!#&!
#
&4
#
!
#
# 4
$ & #
.
!
&
!( !
(
#
&
$%5 %*%+,"
& ! #
. #
: =8! ( #
$ #
#
$00 "
$%
#
:
-55551<
(
) .
!
#
"
$ %
)
# . &)
#!
!
( &
$
$00&.
( &!
.
$00 (
#
&!
:
-55551<0
4
#
9 !
!# &.
#
* #
#
&
!&!( .
0
#
#
<
"#
$%%
&
'
$%% ( #)
* + , - .
#)/ + ' 0
$%% 1
$%!- / (
+
$%!
2
'
$%!
0
$%!
) '!
$00
&
'! #
$ ! ##
>!
.)!(#
.
( .
#
)!(#
0 !
! .(
!(
-
(
!
!&
>!
<
3 & '
'
&
#
( ( & < , 4 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 444 67 8 -
/ -
/ -
/ 444 9:, ,
-
/ -
/ - / 4 5555555555555555555555555555555555 444 , , , - /
#
! ##
!
& 7
'!
4
# &.
/
&
'!
$2 #
!
#
!
. ! ##
6! &
#
!#
0#
!
!
!
7 #
: =8! (
!
&
# !
!(
# ! '
?9@/
&.: =8! (
%+3+,5
(
# !
#
# !
# # (
4 !#&
!
(
7
& (
!
#
/2+,0 #
#%+3+,5 /2+, (
(&
(
. $
$0 #
&
#
' !( "
>!
.
%*%+, !
.
!
. %-%+, !
#
%*%+,
#
(
#
' .
?9@/12
.
)
# &.
!
' .
#
#
%*%+,
0 (
# .
!
#
#
.0
!
$
(
# ! ##
!
!
#
!
:
%-5551<
) .
9 !
%%+,7 ?9"27 ?
(
# ! !
< &, '
, '
8 ;'
, '
; '
'!
8 & <
"#
= #'; ('
("'("
'( 10= #0(502
8;'
!
8 &
'& + + '+ "#
'
7 9:'
6'
8 ;
+ +
(..."5- 5 + /' ...."5 (..."5
(..."5 '
'
= > !4
55#) ,"5 &, '
!
, '
8;'
, '
;
,
& + , &? , "
6 @
; ,"5,, "
;
+ &, "
;* @ ,=;' &
!#&#
!
!
# 0
&. (
( >!
) . (
7 9#
! 1+
!
!
:
%-5551<
:
55551<
:
-5551<
) .
( !
.#
:
%-5551<
!
! 1+
.7 9#
&!
1+
!
) .
!
:
%-5551< 7
#
#
!
%*%+,
0
?9"2
!
1+
:
%-5551<
!
!
# .
4
&4(!
# ( (&
(
.7
#
#
!!
9 !
# : (
+ .#
# !
.
(
!#
.#
(
0
.
! !
'!
&.
(
&
.
!
(
) .
!&
! #
( ( !
!
!( ! ##
!
.
! ##
&
( 1+
!
&.
!!
&
)!(#
(
&.
##& . !(
& (
# !
. (
## !
!
&
; !
.(!
&!
# (
( 0#
A
(& .
?9"2 ! &.
#
! :
%-5551<
) . !
& ; !
!
(!
>! # !
. (
5 6
! !
!
6, +;, ' ..
-/%8 (#'8 + ;' .. -/ * -* + /2(0' ,
+8 , '#)#%8 )'7+; +?, '#)#%8) #
.
>! (
.
= 0#
!
!
& &.
#
!
# .
&!
! >!
# !
. (
; !
!
(!
$ # #&
( # .&
!
&!
# ; !
(!
.
#
#
$ % (
#
# .&) $*
# # & #
7 !
.
# # 4
.
=
$0
# . # .
#
'! !&!( %-%+,
!
=
.
$0
(
!
4
( ! &
& 4 !
&
!
.
& (
(!
. # .
.
7
!
. , + , + ,= ' 3& #0 % 9 1 0' ! &. !
( (
#
# . #
#
!#
# #
#
& 4 & #
!&
& ( .
( ( !
)!(#
*+,-
"
!( 00 !
!
#
!
)!(#
%-%+,
' !
$%5 %*%+,
!&!(
(
)!(#
/+,*&. !&!( 00 '
( . #
& #
)!(#
26.08.2015 (Kuldip Singh) = Judge