High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4308/2018dismissed

Arun Anand v. Ved Parkash And Others

2018-11-19Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi8 pages

! "#$#%&' ()%% %! * ##% ( + ($)$ + ! (, $- %!- ($ ** $.%! %$ & /0 1 2 230 ( $ %& 1((4)%+ (2- (5 6!7"

(- . ##% ( 1(

)( 7 86!7"

(( $.%! %$ 999 :; 7#$#% . ##% - $ < % #8 ! )%! ( (#"8

= -

%$#)#% %!# ($ #%> $#! (! (!

!= .

$$ !<?- #7#8 )!> ( #76 0)!-# 7#! @-#"- - #% )%! (

(! ( )8 ( ! @#- 2 "#% A #8 ! <? - . ##% ( #5.8 !#%>-#5 $!

%#%"#7#8$)##%"

$ #8 ! $+ ! (, $- 1# 8 %- (75 %% %- (6@ $!#$5#$$ ! :

; (#

"$ - "

$ 8 !#%> - #8#%> - #%$ ( 7#$#%. ##% ( - "#7#8$)#@ #8 !<?( $.%! %$

#%$( $.%! %$ %! >( 5 % $ 88 !

! ' A B ") ! <? ( $.%! % $ %! #%

7)( ( $.%! % @#- ( > (! - $)# .(. (? # !)<8 $( ? -)$ < (#%>8'CD 5 $)(#%>A$E?

(!$- 7#%> 8 "(#"#?6@ ( $ @ ( > "%% "#% $#) - $ 6 (< % $ 6 - (# F %6

0)!-# $$-@%( !#%- $# .8

"- !@#-- .8 #% %!<)%! !

$)%! (&D

$& '=D 63 $&'AD 6(-&2( 62)-& #>-<)(@#- !#( "#% ( $.%! % B ") %!> ( >#$ ( !- $ 8 ! !

( $ #! .(. (?#%

7)( ( $.%! % 8$ (. (5 % %#%4)%"#% ( $( #%#%> ( $.%! % $ %! 6 - #( > %$6 (% ?$6 $ (7 %$6 5.8? $6 $$"# $ " (5 8# % #%>65(> >#%>6( %$ ((#%>6># #%> ( "( #%> %? "- (> 7 ( - <7 $ #! .(. (? )(- ( ( $( #%#%> - 5 (5 #% ( (#%> ( "

)$#%> %? #% ( ( %" %!G( !#$.$$ $$#%> ( "

)$#%> !#$.$$ $$ ( $.%! % $ (5 - .(#% - <7 $ #! .(. (? 8( !? #% - #( .$$ $$#% #88 > 88?6

("#<8? %!@#-) !.#%>!) .(" $$ 8 @%- < $#$ ( 8 !")5 % (? 7#! %" :; - . ##% (G %! ( $.%! % ( - $%$ 2- )8$- %0 8@-#8 ( $.%! %#$- @# ( $.%! % $.%! % B ") ! >( 5 %$ 88!

!' A#%

7)( ( $.%! % % - #% )%! ( (! ( )8 ( ! @#- 2 "#%A 6 # @ $"% %! !- >( 5 % $ 88 #%E) $#% @ $- ( $)8 )! $- $)#.(. (?@ $@% !<?2- )8$- %0 8 % %!# -

- ( - . ##% (G %!( $.%! % %!- - !% 7 ( B ") ! %?3#88#%

7)( ( $.%! %$ %! 88 > !

%!- - . ##% (G %- 8( !? #8 !"#7#8$)#"- 88 %>#%>-

88 > ! 3#88 #% @-#"- ( $.%! % $ %! @ ( ..

(#%> %! - .( $ % $)# - ! < % #8 ! <? ( $.%! % #% "%%#7 %" @#- ( $.%! % $ %! #% (! ( >( < - $)# .(. (? - . ##% (G % - ! !#( " #% ( $ #% - $)# .(. (? %! - @ ( E)#( !< #5.8 ! !#%- (( ? %$ (- .(. (! "#$#%

- "#7#8$)#%( $.%$ - ( 6( .8?@ #8 !<?( $.%! %$ ..$#%>- #%%- >()%!- $ 5 @ $%5 #% #% <8 - - "#7#8 $)# @ #8 ! % - < $#$ >( 5 % $ 88 !

' A#%@-#"-- . ##% (G %@ $% (?6- ( ( 6- @ $%#5.8 ! ! $!

%#%- "#7#8$)# :; - 8 #7#8)!> (#760)!-# 7#! (! (!

A !#$5#$$ ! - #% )%! ( (! ( )8 ( ! @#- 2 "#%A <?-8!#%>- - . ##% (G %@ $% % " $$ (? (?- "#7#8$)# :A; )(#%>- ")($ .( 8#5#% (?- (#%>6( 8# %" @ $.8 " ! % ! "#$#% -#$")(#% !"

"#$% :C; ( %( 8 (% !")%$ 8 ..

(#%>%< - ( $.%! % $ ( # ( ! - ( $%#%> >#7 % #% - #5.)>% ! (! ( "% %! !- #%- "#(")5$ %" $6- $ 5 @ $#% ""(!

%" @#-8 @

%!!#!%@ (( %?#% ( ( %" :=; - 7 "%$#! ( !- $)<5#$$#%$ 8 (% !")%$ 8 ..

(#%>

(- .

(# $ %!. ()$ !- #8 . ()$ 8- ( ( 7 8$- - "#7#8 $)#@ #8 !<?( $.%! %$ #%$( $.%! %$ %! $. "# #" . ( %" >( 5 % $ 88 !

! ' A B ") ! <? ( $.%! % $ %! #%

7)( ( $.%! % - . ##% (G % @ $ % .

(? - $ #! >( 5 % % - < $#$ @-#"- $)# ( $. "# #" . ( %" >( 5 % $ 88 @ #8 ! - #7#8)!> (#7!#$5#$$ !- #%)%! ( (! ()8 ( !@#-2 "#%A %- >()%!- - ( @ $%.(#7#? "%( " < @ % - . ##% (G %! ( $.%! % $

)(- (- - . ##% (G %-

#8 !.(!)" %?!")5 %E)

-#$ @% ($-#. 7 ( - $)# .(. (? - 8 #7#8 )!> ( #7

)(- (- 8!- - >(# 7 - . ##% (G %- >( 5 % $ 88 !

! ' A @ (> !

<(#"

! ")8! < ># ! <? "- 88 %>#%>- $ #! >( 5 %<?@ ? $ .

$)# %!%<?57#%>

#%)%! ( (! ()8 ( !@#-2 "#%A :; - 5 (#$%8%> ( $- $ 5 - $< %!

8 @#-<?%/<8 - 2).( 5 )(#%"

$ #8 ! $&'

() * +, - *.*/0 * * * 1 *2 - *2 !3"

3 @- ( #% @-#8 "%$#! (#%> #$ (8# ( ! "#$#%#%42 ' )00 ,*'

#!%"

3 %!'

( 25/* 3!"

#@ $#% ( 8# - 8!- # . ($% , $ #% (< #%>#5.8 ! ! (?"% %!#%>- - #$ % " $$ (? .

(? %! # - )( #%!$ - - #$ % " $$ (? .

(?6 # "

#5.8 ! -#5 $ $)"- %! # %%D.

(? 5 , $ #% $ ,#%> #5.8 !#%> .(. (.

(? %!- )( #%!$-#5< .(. (.

(?6 - )(5 ?!#( "-#$ !!##% %<)# )( #%!$- -#$ !!##% @#88 8 ( - % )( - $)# ( #%(!)" % @ "

"#%6 # 5 ? !#$5#$$ - #% 7 % # - #$ )%! < .(. ( (?6# #! $%@ %@#! %- $". - $. "# %" $)# (- )(5 ?!#( "$)"- %< #5.8 ! ! .(. (.

(?6 #- ( )%"%!##% 88? ( $)<4 " (5$ 8 7 % B( " -

( 5 %#% !! "#$#%#%1)5< #% (% #% 8#(.(/$"

$ 2).( #$ ( .(!)" ! $)%! (&D

# ! " ! #$ %&' " %(' %(' "

%&' $

! " " ) $ " ! " $

$ *

% :'; !5# !8?6#% $)# "%( " $ 8 .(. (?6 -#(! .

(? - "%( " "

%% < !! ! !

%#%7# @ ! "#$#% %/<8 - 2).( 5 )(#% F $)(#/$ "

$ 2).( %F $)(#/$"

$ 6- .. 88 %- ( #%- #8 ! $)# #%$ ( $.%! %$ %! "%( " % ( !#% < @ %( $.%! % "#%> @ ( (% ? ( $.%! % %% - %!- .. 88 %%- - ( ($ 8 "%( " !.(. (? $.%! %@ !5# !8?% (?- "%( " %!- #8 !

#% 8%>@#-- ($ ($ #%>). "8 #5 #%! . %! %#8 .$$ $$#% 7 ( - "%( " ! .(. (? > !! ! $ !

%$ #% - $)# 8 7 % B( " - ! "#$#%#%F $)(#/$"

$ 2).( #$( .(!)" !

$)%! (&D + , --- --- --- .

/ 0

" ) " .

/ 0 ) .

1 - $ #!.$##%#$ 8$"8 ( (5- ! "#$#% %/<8 - 2).( 5 )( #% 1)5< # % (% #% 8 #(.( 7 0!/$ "

$ 2).(

3 @- ( #% # @ $ - 8! - # . ($% 5 , $ #% ( < #%> #5.8 ! ! (?"% %!#%>- - #$ % " $$ (?.

(? %!# )(

#%!$ - - #$ % " $$ (? .

(?6 $)"- . ($% "

% < #5.8 ! ! !

%!# %%D.

(?5 , $ #%$ ,#%>#5.8 !5 %% - >()%! < #%> .(. (.

(? %!- )( #%!$-#5< .(. ( (?6- )(5 ?!#( "$)"-.(. (.

(?< !! ! %<) # )( #%!$- !!##% $)"- . ($%@#88 8 (- % )( - $)#(#%(!)" % @"

)$ "#%6#5 ?!#$5#$$- #% 7 %# $)"-. ($%#$ )%!< .(. (.

(?6# )(! $%@#$- @#! %- $". - $. "# $)#(#%- 8 (% #7 - )(5 ?!#( "$)"-. ($%< #5.8 ! ! .(. (.

(? #- ( )%"%!##% 88?($)<4 " (5$ :; #$ $ 8 ! 8 @ - #% $)# ( $. "# #" . ( %" "%( " ($ 8 6- 8#$< @ %- .

(# $- $)#%8?$- 88< >% #% %!##$%. %- )(! "#! @- - ( (?@-- $57 !

#% (< #%>#5.8 ! ! %- "E)#( ! %?#8 ( .$$ $$#% - "%( " !.(. (? $- $ 5 @)8!%< > (5 % ! "#$#% - $)# - "%( " ($ 8 %!- "

%< ! "#! !#%$ .

.(" !#%>$ :; % - #%$ % "

$ 6 - . ##% ( - 8( !? #8 ! $ .

"#7#8 $)# #%$ ( $.%! % $ %! #% @-#"- - - $ "- 88 %> ! - 3#88- . ##% (#$% (?- >( 5 %$ 88!

!' A B ") !<?( $.%! %$ %!#%

7)( ( $.%! %$ %- < $#$ @-#"-- $)# %" - $< % #8 !-)$6 - ( #$ % .(#7#? "%( " < @ % ( $.%! % $ %! - . ##% (- "8 #5 - . ##% (#$- 88 > !3#88 B ") !<? -#$

- ( 88 > !8?#%

7)( ( $.%! %#$- $)<4 "5 (

$ .

"#7#8 $)# #%$#) ! <? - . ##% (G #%$ ( $.%! % ""(!#%>8?6 # - . ##% (G % - %? >(# 7 %" E)

>( 5 %$ 88!

!' A- %- ..(.(# ")($ "#% - . ##% (#$"- 88 %> - $ 5 <?@ ? $ .

$)# %!%<? 57#%>- #%)%! ( (! ()8 #%- $)# #" . ( >( 5 %!

!' A #8 !<?( $.%! %$H

#%$ ( $.%! % $ %! - 5 ( #$ $E) ( 8? "7 ( ! <? - ! "#$#% %/<8 - 2).( 5 )(#%1)5< #% (% #% 8#(.(7 0!/$"

$ 2).( %!F $)(#/$"

$ 2).( : ; ""(!#%>8?6 #%!#%> % 5 (# @#- - @ 88 ( $% ! (! ( $$ !<?- 8 #7#8)!> (#760)!-# 6- ( 7#$#%. ##% #$< ( 5 (# %!- $ 5 #$!#$5#$$ ! 23 8# )!> 7 5< ('6

5# 3- - ($.

,#%>G( $% ! & $G 3- - (( .( <8 & $G