Hawa Singh & ORS v. Maiperson And ANR
!"!#$
%&$ '(% ) % )
!
"
### $%&
'('))'%* +
","- ./ 01
"
/2
$)& "
4
"
"
2 %
%56 "
2 )
7
%56
"
2 8'
" )79+ ( + "
"
" "
2 %
%58 "
2 )
7
%58 " "
2 86
" )8+ '+ "
"
" "
2 %
%5*''
"
2 )
7
%5*''
""
2 %%7
" )')( + %' + "
"
" 3
'6%%%967 ," 2 *79
%967 "
: 2 %*'(
+
," , 3
+
"
$(& "
"
"
+ 3 ;" "
< <
1 "
86 + "
- =" <
" 3;" "3;"
"
< " /
" < " $8& "
4
"
3 ;"
"" %98'
%98* +
1
3;"
" "
"
2 %4
"
2 (
7-
+
" 3;" >2
""
%98*
" 3 ;" "
2 %
"
2 (
7
"> ""
-
"
$7&
1
- +
"
"
3;" $*&
-
+
/2
"1
"
+
/2
" +
+ "
1
" +
"
"
"
+
"
+
$?& "
/2
" +"
""
"
"
""
< !
""
"
+"
"
3;" 3;"
%98)
%98* 1
" " < " " +"
"
3;"
$6& " %8'8%9973;" )8'6%9?) "
+
< " "
%967 2
- >
%98? 3;" +
4 +
3;" = 4 " "
"
+ 2
""
"
3
@
""
+ "
" $9& >
"
/2
+
"
+
/2
+
+"
"
+"
"
>
+ +
+
A44A"
+"
+
"
"
3;"
"
%98?
3 ;"
" 3;"
"
""
"
%*
@"
$%'&
+"
"
"
"
+" "
"
" "
" >
"
<
"
%98?
"
3 ;" 3 ;" " )8'6%9?) 1
"
*7
+ /
"
" 3;" +3
1
- + "
"
" 1
3 ;"
"
"
>
"
"
"
3;""
"
"+ "
"
" $%%& >
3;" " 3;"
"
""
+
%98)
%98*1
?
B
3 ;"
%98?
+
"
+
"
>
"
3 ;"
" /2
""
"
"
3;" $%)&
!""#$# %%&!'
C+"
@,
+
: 1
+ +"
"
%%)
B
1
"" @
:
+"
D
""
+ +
2 +
+
""
"
+"
" $%(&
( )
*++# % #&,+
C+"
@ , @"
- . ) $
+"
+
>
"
>
" +
> "
"
@
"
""
>
" " @ 1
"
" "+
)%
>
+"
"
+ )%
,
>
" "+
" "
+ "
+3
"
"
"
"
""
+"
$%8& > /0 1 %2 . 3 0 %00 *+!+ &$ % %020 $,#
C+"
@,
"
- . ) $
- . ) $
: +
,
/2 @ "
"
E
"
"
"
+
"
1
"
+
+"
" @
,
"
,
@
"
+"
1
3
/2
"
/2
"
1 ,
"
%%)
B
$%7&
20 4 *+!+$5 %%*6#
C+"
@ , "
+" +3
:
"
" "+
"
:
"
"
+3
@
"
" + : "
"
"
"
+
)?
B
%6?)
$%*&
0 4 3 ( 708 0 *+!! *$ %02%% ''
"
+
%%)
B
8 @ " "
""
+ ""
+
D
"
"
"
3
+
%)7,,
"
""
+
1 "
%97*,"
,
%9?(=" ,
%968
+ "
"
+
%%)
B
$%?& -/ )9% 0 0 04 3 *+!! 5$ %% !#+ +
7(4
,"
)('*)''* +
/2
"
$%6& > 8 4 : 8 4 *+!&$* %%,56
C+"
@, +
+"
"+"
%%)
B
1
1
3
""+ + +
"+"
"
+ "
+
+"
F
"
"
"
+
"
"
"
$%9&
(0)803 / 3 *+!,$! %% #6,
C+"
@ ,
+
/2
+"
""
+
""
"
+
%%)
B
1 ""
"
+"
/2
"
""
+"
"
"
+
+
+"
"
"
"
+ >
+
+
/2
" "
"
"
"
""
%%8. 0
B
/2
"
""
A
/2
9999G
+
" @" "
" + " " ":
$)'&
%%)
> B
%6?)+
+" " +" " "
" "A
"
"
)6'
"
"
" "
+
1
"
+ ++"
+ " + +
+
"
E
"
+
"
+
> "
"
"
+"
1
"
+ +
+
"
$)%&
87
B
"
"
+"
/2
$))&
,
+3
/2
"
)'.(0
> E+ "
/2
"
4 1
4 +
/2
+
"
)'.(0
,
> " +"
"
"
> " + /2
""
"
1 "
" "
1 4 3 +
"
"
"
@
"
@ "
+
+
"
" "
"
+
/2
7(4,"
,
/2
+"
$)(& "
"
/2
+
+"
"+"
%%)
B
+
""
"
+"
+
"
3;"+ "
%98? +
"
1 "
3;" "
%98?
+
+
"
3 ;" %98)
%98* $)8& = "
"
" " +
3 ;"
"
+
" + "
"
+"
+"
"
<"
"
"
+" "
+
"
"
3;"+ "
%9?) 1
"
: +"
3;"1 "
"
: "
3 ;" +
>
:
+"
1
" + +
"
"
2
@ +
$)7& >
"
/2
1
" * % )+ %''%)'%?
,- - ..
"# /0"1 2!#3 "0 ,- - .. 1.
45 "0