← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4332/2018dismissed

Suman Joshi v. Sunita Rani And ORS.

2018-12-07Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages



      

  

   

    !  

    !"#$%&'(# $ &()

# $  % &'

&(!%)

  * "

$ +

'(!%)

  * ,  ---      .,/

0!

1  "

 % "

2

!13 14,6" !+7%8!2 9%:(;!(<

+7)= ?=,

?=@ <

 +       * !

  !  < 8 2  !

2 "" 7 )= > 88 < 

> !" *82* <



 "

<2

!"" 7 ) > ?@8

!1A .1/ 14,6(  ""

 + 8* *

1 * )=  * ?=, ?=@ "" 7 2%  !

1 * )=  * * ! <   <

 +   ! !B 46 14,6** %!

"8 ** ;

(     !7( ==) * * ? @ 2"

2< )!

!!)= <!

!

 ""8)  * 2  <    !

" 2 * !

 7<*8 !(

* ("" 7 )= >

?A<

  .C/

8 **0 ,*8 ! *!

)8 ! * *87 

! 4A 144C  8 28( %8!!+!2+

<

"8 **!!

!* !

)8  "8 ** ! !

  A  ,4  <  "  * ""

  !**87

!4A 144C!*

 !

  1 ! C %  8 !7 8D    ""

 %!

  !**87 

!4A 144C!% 2 

 ""

!   

  B)  < 8 2 

&2  !

*

2 "

) *8 "  *  "8 ** ! 8 2 * ) 2) 7  !**87

.A/   ""

 * )!  *

 "2 * !!

!13 14,6(!

1!*2

""

)

2** !!

!!! )88 2

 7

 4, 4E 14,6(!

< )&** .@/ 

*8 ! 65,6*14,6

 2  ( )88 22  !

! 4, 4E 14,6"

+7

 !

!13 14,6< 8 ! * !)%8 %  !

<88<

!,@ 14,E+B "7 ) 9:* 14(4440= "! ""

" 

%8 !2  9 %:( ;! "  !

14,E "

 !

1!*8 %8

 "" 7 "%!

! +7  2 

  !B  1@ 14,E * *82 "8)  <

19*7:

 !7

(!

!46 14,E "!) !

!

#=  



  

     

         

!

 "  #  $ %    &%"

%'(  "%  )*%(     

      &    "

&    "%  



 % +      

   (  '(

 ),' )"

       

-$!!$ .  %   &%!-$-!$ . " &   

 %    !  ('(



/   

  !   %

  / !$$$$01 & "

 %   '( ),' )"

    (%   

 / 

    

  !  

%

   & '&2

 %   / !$$$$01 ) !# B!

2( : 14,E

!

# =4A1E %8!2 %( ;!F .6/

8 *  * ! !

 <8! <  *) %  +

 B+8   >

( +  *)   ! ) 8 * !

 **

! 

    % !    * 14(4440= 

&  "  1@ 14,E ! *88<2 !

 < " ! +7 %8 !2  9 %:( ;!#=  



  

     

   



!

 "  #  $ %    &%"

%'(  3   $#$-!$ .   '( ),' 4  (   ( +" 5'  )( )"

   & '(

   &  '( &"

& '

   "

 &      ' 5 '(

   

       $#$-!$ .

 &    5  6$.!$ .   " 

   % ),'5')()"

 



*!

# B!

2 B( : 1@ 14,E

!

#= =4A1E 0;!F .E/   ""

 * )!  2  !

!4E 4C 14,E!46 14,E" !+7%8!2 9 %:( ;! 2 2   "" 7  !

*8 <



88 !87) % * !

! ,@ 14,E " ! +7  2     65,6( "8 **0 , *8 !  C,61 * 14,E 

 !

<! 2

!43 .5/ 



< & "+7  !  )   ,E 14,5 !  *88<2 !

" !#=  



 



      ! 7& ! &28     

 "

 #  $ %         &% "

% '(

   ( &       "   % ),')"

 ' & 

    %



"

& 

       '  %  '(

 5'  )( )"

 

/&   

  

 !9$6!$ :& !   &2& % ;1 ;1-

   '  !' 

 %  ;1-+" "

 & %  &  %     %(    $:$9!$ : &   !   &2   & % ;1:     '   !  &    5  

 & 

   <  

 % &    5 $!$!!$ 6& % ;1- %"&

   ' ( 

!#,E 14,5 9 & : 0;! 

4CA,:F .3/   *)  * !

! 13 14,6 < !87

)!

!   * ! !

( <

 )  *

?@<

+ 8**!

1( +   !7( ==) ** ?@< )!

!  )=  < !

!

  !B 41 14,5*)= ?@!*

2 %!

 *  "8 **     < "+8 

) <!B ! ))  .,4/  ""8)  !

   ,@,   < *8 ! * )8*) *!

!4E 4C  *82* C,61 *14,E<2 !

!4E 4C 14,E!46 14,E <))8

!!8*

*8

"8 **0 ,  43   )"7 * !

,@ 14,E"  65,6*14,6< *8 ! + * 8    4E 4C 14,E(

* 8  2

! "" 7 * *82 <

 

 !

 +7 "72 ) 9:

   !

) !

!  <

+7 <8! 8 % 7 * !+  "

*)8*) *!

!4E 4C  !

! 13 14,6 " ! +7 8   < ") )887 

"

2"" 7*)=

? A +7 !

1  +    87 )  *

? @ < 8

 

 <  D  * 2%2 7 )8*)

!

4E 4C 14,5 

  )= ?A!8 !7+

+   .,,/

8*%=%!

 )!<8!<

 !

 < %8% !  !

872 ) ) % ""8) <*8 !+ *  ) !2 (;!*

* ) 1A ) !""8) < "8 ** 

87( !""8) <2 ! !< !<+7!

!4, .,1/  ""8)  !

   ,@,   *8 ! +7 "8 **< ** <8 ")2

4E 4C 14,5( !8 !7 )

"8 **

+287 ?@*)=  )= *   <   < !

)8  +       * !

1+7!



< % (< <"8!

! 

 % 8 ) <*> !* ?! *)= ?@87 .,C/ !

 " !   ! ""8) (  7 )!

!( " !    )88 * 7 

  )= D ?A!8 !7+

+ 8**!

14,6! !!

< % 8 !!

"

*82*  65,6*14,6! *) ** !!

< +2  )  <   C,61* 14,E<!

)!

43  .,A/ <2 )!)



)!(  !  < 2 7!82 *% * "

< 8 %  < +B "7 *7) 9:



))!287! !

  4E ,1 14,5  $ &()

) $%)#    ?

 !0"

&2 0 ?

" +8 0