High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/470/2023allowed

Hitesh Shamrao Kohade v. Manphool Singh And Another

2025-08-29Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan11 pages

"#$%&$%'

"#$%&$%' () () () () *+% *+% *+% *+%% % % %(,) (,) (,) (,)

!-.-/0 1 - $$$2233" 40!5! ,"2-

3. "6-"

-0! $$$!2 "! () () () () *++ *++ *++ *++% % % %(,) (,) (,) (,)

!-.-/0 1 - $$$2233" 40!5! 7""

-0 $$$!2 "! ,# ,# ,# ,# 89 ,.$.

89 ,.$.

: 0!"# ,0$07".-0/; ;

0,0$.

-0- 53 ;

0-2233"(!)$ ,0$."

015/0

00!2 $ "*+%% "

00!2 $ "*++% (-0 56-4 0" "6)$ ,0$

23, 3; ;

00!2 $* "*+%%$ "

00!2 $ "*++%$

: ;$(03)

: ;$(03) , , , ,'+ '+ '+ '+ % % % % *+% *+% *+% *+%% % % % , , , ,<% <% <% <% % % % % *++ *++ *++ *++% % % % 0=0 "-!223 "! !

+& =! " 3 "6-20!"223!$

. ""

/ ">! 0 ? !!5 7 0

$%&$%; ! !5-; 20!" 223 "! !

/23 3= 33 > , "!(!) , "!(!) , "!(!) , "!(!) $ - - 223!; $$ *+%% *++% -7 ?" 3 ?= -

- ,05 0 ?0 "6 06 !0

$ %+ %*%(-0 " 00 00 !-@08) /256" "6-

// " >0 *$%$%&; 2!! ?= - , 0 3 /! 0 ?5"3;- >" (

0!- 0;@- 0 ?5"38);>-0?=-363 020!" 7!

2 "

"A50 7" -7 ?" 60" "5"

-, 04- 3!; &&(

0!- 0;@-8)$ $ . " ?

- - 223! 0 0 ! "6 5

// >0 ;!!5-;B"52 6-0

!2 !3$

>70;

0?07 =;

!0? "6B" /*+%%$ $ !20-?0 !; "%$%*$%'; 7">!6 "6

0 >- 3 0 7 "6 - 0 "

2 >! /2"= "6- /$!20-70!

7";?

5$%$/$; >-"-=0- "-0

3 . "1"B73 (1-03); - 0 6 /?3" ; !3 22 " - 0 !

!05B 6 "! 0$ !53"3=; ?

- - 52"! !5! " 70 5! "A50 !$ 3 /3=;."

2 "-!2 $ $ ,"2-

3 . "6- "

./$ -/3 7 ; 20"!

2 3 !20 3 / 2 " 6 "! - "A50 7"; >"0 !-.-/0 1 - "

-"!50" /2"=C

>-0!; 7" "A50 3 !20 3 / 2 " !B "6

/- >"0"

- "!500

-0$ $

-2233"

-0>!20 6 "!D 20?=- 0 ?5"3$ $ --3 /2 "!>033 > ?=- 0 ?5"3C

// " >0 " 7 50

- "A50 ! >33 ! 20"!

>!2!! C"

!5/

!$;+<;*%%E>!>0 "A50 7";>-0!;"/ 5"

!$;<%;%%E>!>0 - 20"!

>70; 5

- ! / 5"; - "!50" /2"= >! -3 3 ?3 2= !5/

!$'%;%%%E- - "A50 "

20"!

;>-0! -0!

-3 ? 3 =>! !" 52 "-2233"

0$ $*

-2233"

-0-! 3 *+%% 6 "! - 363 020!" 7!

- "!50" /2"=C>-0!;*++%-!?" 3 6 "!- "A50 3 /""

-"!50" /2"=$ $' 2 " "

; -! 223! -7 ?" "! ?= -

0 70

-0 7";>- !0!2 $ "*+%% "

0!2 $ " *++%; - >70; 20"!

,"2-

3 "

-/3 7 ; 0!2 !$ ; 0!2 73= "*+%%-7"

220 ; !2 /23

!07 !20-02 0

-6 !0=!5?/

0+$%$%$ $ 90" 5"!3

0 - 2233"

- 0 !5?/ - - 2233" - "66 ,E! D3 B0! "

, 70!(

0!- 0;@-B0!, 70!8)

0!- "6- !- 5!-

0 3! /

0$33-0 3! "35 "6-0>0 ?0"!2 0 " 05B?0 "6 $ '' '&*(

0!- 0;@-

05B8)$ - 2233" 2 !$**;%*'E >0 ! 2B6 "6 "

0"!2 0 "-06!;- >70; - !50!5020 !;-/ B"

> - "!

0"!2 0 "6-0 "- 05B; >!? "6@ 0 7"8

0$ -0/> -" ""

>! 33=

/6 $ -2233"/ 7 "223 "(""D50*) 3 6 "!-B0!, 70!"

->!3!

2 !5/

!$;';++<E?=-"!50" /2"=!-0>!-7 "673 "!50"B6 3 =$ $ ! ""

-"D20>0 >!2!! 6 "! -2233"> - 5!07 "6"

52 "- / "- ! 00

0!!$

-2233"- 3

"-=0%'"

-0 0;-!- 4

0$ - 2233" / B"

> ?

5 - 20!" ! " /?0%;>-"-0 7 !5// "! "-D5 "2

3 ?=-"!50" /2"=$ $ ! 50-0 ""

"?-3

-2233"-- >0 2!! ?=- 0 ?5"3 !" "6-3 ? 3 = "-2233" ! >0 "6 ! " - 2233" - 2 "

"3 20/ 5/

0 -

0 70$ *$ ,0$."

015/0; ;220 "6 "?-3

"A50 0 70 7"!522 0 -0!

"!0 ?=- 0 ?5"3; - >70;!5?/ - "A50 !>33!- 0" 3 !B "!- "

B23 5 5!

-0$

'$ 90" 5"!3 220 "6 " ?-3

- "!50" /2"= ""

!-2 "05"

- !"

/ " "?3$ <$

0 +$ 0 / - 5"

!25 !; 0"!2 0! - "A50 7">! 0 7 "6-0"

2>!0733 "6 " - ! 0 - /

- "$ ! 20 - 70!

"A50 0 70;"

-07- 3 ! "7 37 "- "$!20- ! 70!

"; - 0 6 /?3" ; !3 22 " - 0 !

!05B 6 "!0;0!53 "6 " -! "$ &$ !20-70!

-2233";--"

70-0 - B0! , 70!

0 0"!2 0 "6 - !/ /

0$ - 56-;-0>!!20 !25 "0!-

-0"

-B0!, 70!060 "67 3

0 "! 0"!2 0-0-0 56- 05B;- >70; A5

"0 70!= ! "

- !5?A/0 " - 20!" 223! " 2233" >"0-!!200/ =F5-!/$ $ "-20!"223!; / 3=;-0 >" ?=- 2233">! 0 7"?=- 0 70E "A50 "

>!3!

0733 "6 "-! 7- 3$!!5-;- "A50 - !22 " !- !

>"0- />-"->! 0 7 "6-7- 3"

0"!2 0 "6 /

0$ %$ " 7 >

! "

05/!"!

- ! !; - F5! "-> 0 !

0/ " " !! >--0- 0 70 "

52"

-0> ?" 3

"5"

-;>-0"

-07- 3>! "7 37 "- " "F5! "G $ " " 3F5! ">! "!

0 ?=-

"8?32D 50 " "6// 4!$ " "

"!50" $ 9 $ (%%) "6// 4!$ " "

"!50" $ 9 $ (%%) .+% .+% .+% .+%$"-!;- >! 0 7 "6/ 0=3>- - >!?

> / !03 >"0"

/> -" "?= !- "6 6 "!?533 B0; $$

"7 37"= -0/ 07- 3$

- 3 / >! 3 5"

0 . " <

- ?= - 363 020!" 7!

6 "!-03

-7- 3$

"8?32D 50 ?!07 "

-3 -! "- -! !22 " -!- !

>"0;.

-""

223= >-0 " -

- 7- 3 - /!3 ! "7 37 $ "!F5"3=; >! "35 - - 363 020!" 7!

> "

-73 / "5"

-$ - ?!07 "!?=

"8?32D 500 !5"

0# H*$ .

-,4>! "!0 ?='*

*?=>=

3!50 =!-/$ !" 3!! !=--! 20 7 !

" !

?= !3 -! 20 7 !

"-!?" "!0 20

0"> 20 0/ " !0550

0/53

0 2=/"

" 0 "7 /! "-?! !

6E "

0-20!

0 "6 20/"" !?3/"$ " 7 >

- 3"656 5! " ! ! "-0 ?"

/""0

5?--! 20 7 !

"-!"

700 "6

! " "!"

?!"35! "0/!>-0

- / 0 7- 3 0 - 5- 0 I "!500 ! 3 ?3 2=

" "-!

- 020/"" !?3/" 5 0 ! "6 5

-5!

/ 07- 3;! "

"-. .- 53; -363- 0! 0-7 /;!-!/=?$ '$ "5/?0

"!-7?"0"

0 ?=- ! 50 "0!2

-. "<

-,4$"23 0 !-?- .

" 7$" "

"!50" $ 9 $;(%%*) ' . &'; 26 *%; "

5! (

"8?3 5! .$$. "-)-! ?!07 !

>!#

H*$. "<>!;-5!;"

060"

// 03 !

-2 23>- !""53 "

/ !"

/ 0-"!*%;%%%-7 "6060 - "0/!

-0 > --. .- 53 22"

-0 ; " ! ?2 "!0550

0/53"

"3=-7 "6060 -6

-7 /"

- ! "

/ ?5 3!

-0 0! 037" -0

0$ " >0 / -05"

0;-0

0;!-33? " 533"

"3 !3/"

-3 / !> 220 /-

35/"! " " "-. .- 5322"

$ -!/ !"

"0 / ""50$ -"

22"

35/">- - 3!> - 3 "!/B!-2 !

50-0/ 0 30 ! "6 - / - 3 / 5"

"- 0 -0

! ? 0 5 "

-D2"!!>- --7 /> -7 "500 >0 !/ " " "6- /!3 - -?"3 7$ - ! 6-0> -- -0- !

"! " " 35/"! < -0

37! "

/""0

5? - 03 /" ""

3= /20-"! 7 !-/

0 !

7 /! >- > 0F5 0 - / 5"

" > - 5 6- "6 "= 20 0 3 6

7 "6 - - 500 > "6 "63 6" -20

0 70

-/ 07- 3 0"= -0 53 0 ! "6 5

/ 07- 3$ <$

- ! 50 50-0 ?!07 "0 "3"!50" $9 $7$," 40 =3;(%%+)'.*&;26*&# H&$ " >"

!!50" $9 $7$!-" - ! 50- !

" "!

0-!

-D20!!

H"=20!

"J 500 "6 ". "*+

-$ - ! 50 -3 # H<$ K--/" "6

-> !@"=20!

"8 /5!3!

?0 ?5 -7 "6060 "D " >- - -= -7 ?" 5! $$ @ - 0 20=8$ 12 "6 "7 >-20 7 !

-&&;> 0

2 "

" - ! - 20 7 !

"! -0

"A " "= !5 0= 3 ? 3 = " -

7- 3 6- !7- 3 "!50

0"=2!!"60 0733 "6 "6

!7- 3;- "!500!> "

?3 ?3-0

0$J

" -0 > !; - ! 50 303= -3 - - 220"3= > > ! H"= 20!

"J 0 F53 ?= - ! "6 " >- --= 50"

-H"=20!

"J ! ?5"

!- 0 20=$ L L L L +$:- "B--3>3

>" ", "5$,-7$ 3B0 !-" /-"

0 =" >! 2 ?= - 36 !350>- 3" "6-, 04- 3!;&&?= "0

5 "6.

-20 "6

02=/"

> -!"

"6"=- "6 " " "- 0 ""= -03>

0- /? "6 "

0--

/ 07- 3 0-5- 0 ! "!500!-33? 3 ?3 2= "-!

- 020/"" !?3/"

5 "0 ! "6 5

-5!

-/ 07- 3;

"; ! "

" - . .- 53; 363- 0! 0-7 /;!-!/=?;"

"3 / / 5"

0!5?! "()

-;- 3 /"!-33"

?0F5 0 23 0!?3 !---

- 0 20/"" !?3/" " 0!2

>- - - 3 /-!?"/ >! 5 "=>0 "6 53 0"63

-7- 3 "0" -0

0; -7 /

" 0- ! 2"

"!-7" 2 -0 20 5"

0 . " <<

- 0 5"

0 .

-$"-=220 -- 0 ?5"3 5"

0. "<<

-;-=-7"!!0 3= B "-/!37!-?50 "

!?3 !- "6-"63 6"

- 0 70

- 7- 3 "0" $ 5 -= 5"

-;- > 33 ? >0 " 0/!

- .- 53 > - 5 33 "6 "-7 / 0- ! 2"

"! !?3 !-"="63 6"

53 "-20

-7- 3 0- 0 70

-7- 3$ &$ " 5!-2? 50!- / !- 7$ "A "" "6 0!! "6 $ () 9 $; >

- 30" 5 6! >-

"! 5 -"- ", "5$,--3 ->-"0 ! 0 7"?=- >"08!/23 = >"08!?5! "!!;- 0/3 053 >! - >!

0 - 3 /"

" 20 7"63 6"$:-"-,"60

>"0 >- 3 0 7 "6 - 0 " - ?5! "!!

B " 2!!"60; > ? B" - - -

5- 0 =

; "!

0 "6- !2 ! "5"3!! -0> ! !- >"$ 5 - !"63 6" 0 7 "6" 500 "

- 2!!"60 ; - >"0 > ? 3 ?3

"$ - 50"

--/

0"0"

>! /B-/!03 ?3

- !!07">- -/= 33 > - " - D20!!

" H " - 50!

- ! /23 =/"J!

0/03=5"

$: -0!2;>- "B - - D"!

"! - 20 " 23

3 ? 3 = -7 ?" 0 6-3= "

"- ! !

"J$ +$ -

0! !

"! /B F5 30 - - 03 /" ?= "0

5 "6 . " < " - ,4 20

0 2=/"

"!0550

0/53?! !?=/"

"6--

/ 0 7- 3 0 - 5- 0 ! "!500 > ? 3 ?3 2=

";! "

"-. .- 53 "-!

- 20/"" !?3/" 5 "0 ! "6 5

-5!

-/ 7- 3; -363- 0! 0-7 /;!-!/=? "3 // 5"

0!5?! "()

-,4$" 0 20 7 3 /

- !"50-3 /"> "

?0F5 0 23 0!?3 !- -- - 020/"" !?3/" "0!2

>- --3 /-! ?"/ >! 5 "=>0 "6 53 0"63 53

-7- 3 "0" &$

>70; "- !

-20!"!; >!

0 533=065 ?= - 5"!3220 "6

0-0!2 "--3 /"!0"

-@- 0 20=8; "

-0

0; -= 0 "

" 3 3 / "= ?" 5"

0 .

-,4$"!522 0

-! "" ";- 5"!3 03 "- !

- ! 50 "-!

0 "3"!50" 9 $7$A" 7 ;(%%&)'.+<C"

!!50" $9 $7$ . ""

,5B- "

0!$;(%%).*+$ $ " 0 "3 "!50" /2"= 9 $ 7$ A" 7 "

-0!; (%%&)'.+<;>-0 " "

5!;"/3=;

"8?35! .$$. "- ! 20=; -! ?" 6 0 33= -3 - " ! >-0 - 0 20= ! "7 37 ;-3 ? 3 =

- "!50" /2"=> ?5"3 / $>! 3!

-3 "-! !

"->-0;- >70; " !3 /

0- -

-02!!"60

-7- 3;- "0

"!50"? "66 70" ?=- "0F5 "0;-3 /

3 /" 6 "! - "!50" /2"= > 2"

52 " - 0/! -0

$ %$ >!-3 "0 "3"!50" $9 $!-.

-,4""

?! -7"=223 " "0!2

" >-0 "-

-/ 07- 3- /!3 ! "7 37 - !

50-0 ! "

3 "60 0! "60$ - 3 ? 3 = 5"

0 ! " <

,4 ! "-

-7- 3$.

20!

"""

-;3 /" ! 3!

0 2 "; > - 0!2 3 /$ -0

0; - - 0!

-7/ " " 3 / "0/!

-,4$ $ " 50 "!

0 2 "

"; - 0

" " 0 "3 "!50" $9 $! !303=223 ?3 !

-20!"!$ " - 20!" !; - >! "

- / 0? B " F5! "$ ?

> - ! / 0? B / ! 03 >"0$ -

? -3 ? /23 =

- / 0? B 3- 56- - >! 5- 0 ! 0 7 - ! 7- 3 ?= ! >"0; "

-0

0;-> !2 " -!- !

-/ 0? B$: -7 30 = D0 . " <

- ,4 -0 "?

0$ ?0 205!3

-! 20 7 !

"> /B D23 3=30-20!

"!3 B - "-20!"!> !2 " -!- !

-7- 3$J $

0/" " ?!07 "!>0 50-00!!0 ?=-

"8?3.520/ 50 "/B- 3

/B- 3

/B- 3 "

-04!$" "

"!50" /2"="

-0;(%%).520/ 50!! "

"!50" /2"="

-0;(%%).520/ 50!! "

"!50" /2"="

-0;(%%).520/ 50!! "

"!50" /2"="

-0;(%%).520/ 50!! ''% ''% ''% ''%$ $ "7 >

05/!"!

- !!"

3>3

>" " "6//(!520) "6//(!520) "6//(!520) "6//(!520)"

/B- 3 (!520) /B- 3 (!520) /B- 3 (!520) /B- 3 (!520); - "A50 !>33!-363020!" 7!

" 3 "5"

-$ $ ! "!F5"

- ?

7 !5!!

"; ?

- - 223! 0 33 > C - /256" >0 2!! ?= - 0 ?5"3 ! 203= !!

$ - "6!

0 ?5"3 - "6 - 2233"

>"03 ?3 2=20

"0!!

>70; - "6!

0 ?5"3- "6-"!50" /2"=

-0 3 ?3 2=!5/

!$'%;%%%E - "A50 7""

-0

!5/

!$'%;%%%E - 20"!

0F5 0"= "0 0"$ $ 223!33 > *$ "

"6223 "(!); "=;!-333!

!2 !

$%& $%& $%& $%&$%'

$%'

$%' M

: N M

: N 53!-

:--0!2B "6E0!

" # !

:--02 0?3# !