High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4369/2018dismissed

Kailash Chopra v. Prem Madan And ANR

2018-11-19Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma6 pages

! ! ! !

! ! # $ ! ! # $ ! ! # $ ! ! # $ %& '()*(+,,-./(

0&)&)-10/ 0/+2+

/0%(3(1(13(1-&,0/

0+.-1301&+ #4 5

! ! ! #4 5

! ! !

/0+01&#

/0+01&# / (60130/'2%(/$37-8(&09-/&,0.0&)&)-10/

:;:;:;

! ! !$

4-9 1+&(1&(..*)8(&)-1,(+<0019)*032130/08&)-1=-9 &,0)%)&(&)-18&+00>)1?8-13-1(&)-1-930*(@-9 3(@+&,(& ,(+-882//03)19)*)1?&,0(88-%.(1@)1?/07)+)-1.0&)&)-1

&A(+)%.0/(&)709-/&,0.0&)&)-10/&-,(700B.*()103 0(8,3(@-930*(@ ,0?/-213+8)&03)1&,0(..*)8(&)-18(11-&<0 &(>01&-<07(*)362+&)9)8(&)-19-/&,0)1-/3)1(&030*(@-9 3(@+

/(@0/)+308*)103

..*)8(&)-13)+%)++03

()18(+0 =

,)+ )+ &01(1&5+ /07)+)-1 (?()1+& &,0 8-182//01& 0608&%01&-/30/+.(++03<@&,0(2&,-/)&)0+<0*-A-1&,0?/-213 -91-14.(@%01&-9/01&(+(*+-+2<4*0&&)1?

/)09 9(8&+ -9 &,0 8(+0 (/0 &,(& /0% (3(1$

,0/0)19)*03(.0&)&)-12130/08&)-1 -9&,0 (/@(1( /<(1-1&/-*-901&(137)8&)-18&$C +00>)1?

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

$ <2& &,0/0(9&0/&,0/01&A(+1-&.()3(13 /0%(3(1$/0+.-1301&

A(+)1&)%(&03&,(&,01809-/&,&,0.0&)&)-10/,0/0)1A-2*3 .(@ &,0 /01& 28, (//(1?0%01& A(+ 1-& (880.&(<*0 &- ,0/0)1(13+)180&,0/01&,(31-&<001.()39/-% =

-1A(/3+(13&,0(//0(/+-9/01&,(3+A0**03&-&,0 &210-9+ $ $D4$&,0.0&)&)-19-/07)8&)-1A(+9)*03-1&,0 ?/-213-91-14.(@%01&-9/01&(+(*+-+2<4*0&&)1?-9&,030%)+03 ./0%)+0+

.-11-&)80,(7)1?<001)++203$&,0.0&)&)-10/,0/0)1 8-1&0+&03&,0+(%0(139)*03(/0.*@ ,0/0*(&)-1+,).-9*(13*-/3 (13&01(1&A(+301)03 (&,0/)&A(++&(&03 &,(&+,0)+&,0 -A10/)1 .-++0++)-1-9&,030%)+03./0%)+0+(13/0+.-1301&

,0/0)1<0)1?,0/+-14)14*(A,(39/(232*01&*@-<&()103&,0 9)*0-930%)+03./0%)+0+(13,(3(++2/03&,(&,0A)**?0&&,0 +(%0&/(1+90//03)1,0/1(%0 ,092/&,0/8*()%03&-<0/0+)3)1?

)1&,030%)+03./0%)+0+)1&,08(.(8)&@-9-A10/9-/&,0*(+& @0(/+

,0 01& -1&/-**0/$ (/)3(<(3 7)30 -/30/ 3(&03 (**-A03&,0.0&)&)-1(13&,0./0+01&.0&)&)-10/A(+ 3)/08&03&-,(13-70/7(8(1&.-++0++)-1-9&,030%)+03./0%)+0+ A)&,)1&A-%-1&,+-9&,03(&0-9.(++)1?-9&,0-/30/ 2/&,0/ 3)/08&)-1+A0/0(*+-)++203&-.(@&,0(//0(/+-9/01&&-&,0&210 -9 + $ $D4 (*-1? A)&, )1&0/0+& E G .0/ (112% &- ,0/0)19/-%&,03(&0-99)*)1?-9&,0.0&)&)-1&)** (8&2(*/0(*)H(&)-1 ,0.0&)&)-10/,0/0)1./090//03(/01&(..0(* (13&,0+(%0,(+<0013)+%)++037)30623?%01&3(&03C

C .(++03<@&,0..0**(&02&,-/)&@$(/)3(<(3$&,0/0<@(99)/%)1? &,00608&%01&-/30/.(++03<@&,001&-1&/-**0/

0+2*&(1&*@$&,0)1+&(1&/07)+)-1.0&)&)-1

-21+0*/0./0+01&)1? &,0 .0&)&)-10/ ,(+ (/?203 &,(& &,0-2/&+<0*-A,(70./-800303-18-1608&2/0+(13+2/%)+0+

2/&,0/(/?203&,(&&,007)30180*03<@&,0.0&)&)-10/&-A(/3+ -A10/+,).-9&,030%)+03./0%)+0+,(+1-&<001(../08)(&03(13 ,(+ <001 </2+,03 (+)30 "0& (1-&,0/ +2<%)++)-1 /()+03 <@ 8-21+0*)+&,(&0701&,-2?,/0+.-1301& A(+8*()%)1?&-<0 &,0*(13*-/3$@0&1-/01&/080).&+,(3<001(332803-1/08-/3&- ./-70/0*(&)-1+,).-9*(13*-/3(13&01(1&)1&0/+0&,0.(/&)0+

(7)1?,0(/38-21+0*9-/&,0.0&)&)-10/(&*01?&,(13 ,(7)1? .0/2+03 &,0 )%.2?103 623?%01&+$ &,)+ -2/& )+ -9 &,0

8-1+)30/037)0A&,(&&,0/0)+1-%0/)&)1&,0)1+&(1&.0&)&)-1(13 &,0+(%030+0/70+&-<03)+%)++03

&)+(8(+0A,0/0/0+.-1301& ,0/0)1)1-/30/&- ./-70,)%+0*9&-<0&,0*(13*-/3-9&,030%)+03./0%)+0+,(3 0B(%)103 I "-?0+, '2%(/$ ! 2< !)7)+)-1 )&@ (**(<?(/,(/)3(<(3(13A,-32*@./-703&,(&&,00*08&/)8)&@ 8-1108&)-1,(3<001)1+&(**03)1&,030%)+03 ./0%)+0+)1&,0 1(%0-9/0+.-1301& I /(,(%600&$*0/>$-2+)1? -(/3 (/@(1(,(3<0010B(%)103(13A,-,(330.-+03&,(&(+.0/ /08-/3-9&,0-2+)1? -(/3$&,030%)+03./0%)+0+A0/0(**-&&03 &-,/))/0130/(13&,(&-1&,0*0&&0/-9(**-&%01&$ /0%(3(1 ) /0+.-1301& ,0/0)1,(3(..01303,)++)?1(&2/0+(+

-9,/))/0130/ I 92/&,0/30.-+03&,(&(+.0//08-/3$ /0% (3(1)++&)**( ,-*30/-9,/))/0130/ ,0&0+&)%-1@-9

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

-++0++)-1 -9 &,0 .0&)&)-10/ ,0/0)1 -9 &,0 30%)+03 ./0%)+0+A(+1-&)13)+.2&0 ,0F20+&)-1&,(&/0F2)/03&-<0

= 30&0/%)103A(+(+&-)1A,(&8(.(8)&@+,0A(+)1.-++0++)-1 &,0/0-9

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

701&,-2?,(.*0(,(3<001&(>01&,(&/0+.-1301&

/0%(3(1,(3&(>01(37(1&(?0-9&,0/0*(&)-1+,). )1&0/ +0&,0.(/&)0+$<0)1?+-14)14*(A-9&,0.0&)&)-10/(13$(++28,$( 9/(23,(3<001.*(@03<2&8-21+0*8-18030+&,(&1-8-%.*()1&(& (1@.-)1&-9&)%0,(3<0019)*03<09-/0&,0.-*)80(2&,-/)&)0+D 8-%.0&01&(2&,-/)&@(+/0?(/3+&,09/(23&,(&,(3<001(**0?03*@ .*(@032.-1,0/ &)++&/(1?0&,(&0701&,-2?,&,0.0&)&)-10/ 8*()%+&-,(70.2/8,(+03&,0./-.0/&@9/-%/0+.-1301& )1 &,0@0(/$@0&1-07)30180A(+9-/&,8-%)1?&-30%-1+&/(&0

&,(&(1@+&0.,(3<001&(>01<@,0/&-?0&&,0&/(1+90/-9&,0 30%)+03./0%)+0+)1,0/1(%0A)&,&,08-180/103(2&,-/)&)0+D -2+)1? -(/3$ (**(<?(/,

,0 +2<%)++)-1 /()+03 <@ 8-21+0* (+ /0?(/3+ /01& /080).&+ 1-& <0)1? ./-32803 <@ /0+.-1301& 0701 &,-2?, 8*()%)1?&-<0*(13*-/3A-2*31-&<0-9(1@8-1+0F20180 28,( .*0(A-2*31-&<00701(7()*(<*0&-&,0.0&)&)-10/(++,0A(+ 8*()%)1?&-<0)1.-++0++)-1-9&,030%)+03./0%)+0+1-&(+( &01(1&D*)801+00$<2&)1&,08(.(8)&@-9<0)1?-A10/(13A,)8,+,0 ,(+%)+0/(<*@9()*03&-./-70

-/&,0/0(+-1+/08-/303(<-70$1-)19)/%)&@)+9-213)1 &,0 )%.2?103 623?%01&+ .(++03 <@ &,0 01& -1&/-**0/$ (/)3(<(3(+(*+-&,0..0**(&02&,-/)&@ ,0)1+&(1&.0&)&)-1$(+ +28,$)+3)+%)++03-1%0/)&+(+A0**(+-1&,0?/-213-930*(@

!)+%)++03 ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

-&0#

-&0# I,0&,0/+.0(>)1?D/0(+-103# "0+D I,0&,0/0.-/&(<*0# "0+D