Sukhvinder Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
"#$%& $'()(%*+
!"
# $
,,, - . //./..
- . ///01 0
2$)$*#
%&$' ()
*++' ,(*' !"
---- ./..
3 2"4!
& .
)+ / ) 0
1 (2 )+ 3 4 ( 5 0 6 (2 4' ."& "
$+ .
++ " $$ ++ ))
)+5 " +"+ $
"+'
& $$+ $
) 5 0 6 (2 4 (++ $ 7+ .
25 + 0 3 $ + )+ 25 8.'
& . +) +
+
+) ) )+ 0 5$+ 5 +
'
"5
.
+ & .
" $$
5& 5 "& + ) +
+ )) .+ 5 ++ $
)
$)
'
' ) 5$ $
+ $$ .
" .
$"+) 2)7 )+ 5 5
)
$&
. " ++.
:
; ) + $$ . .+
"5
$ .
$$ .
'
' .
" 5
+ ) + $ + $ +
(
' +
)+ /
1 <
+& . ) '
$) + + ) ,
) +) (5 +) !" +) + / . $
+= 5 +
( $ )+ / )'
$) )++& $
++ " .
< 5 > ? .//
"
)
@ ' + 0
>
4
!
"
# "
/
" 5 0 6 '
$) )++& 5 )+ 3 4'
++ " .
@5 ) + 5 2 )
$ $$ .
$) ) +
) & <
$ + " + "& 8A"+ $5
75 $$ .
) + $$ ++ $
"& $$ .
"
"& 8A"+ $5 )
+ ($$+ 1 :64' ) 3 :
+ > $
8. Now, the submission on behalf of the appellant that as per sub-rule (5) of Rule 16, all the 33 posts notified are required to be filled is concerned, the same has no substance. Sub-rule (5) of Rule 16 is required to be read as a whole and in its entirety and the same is required to be read alongwith the Guidelines issued. What is provided under sub-rule (5) of Rule 16 is that the number of candidates selected shall not be more than the number of vacancies notified. However, it further provides that there shall be no waiting list and posts, if any, unfilled for any reason whatsoever shall be carried forward for future recruitment. Therefore, there shall not be any
: appointment of more than the number of vacancies notified but that does not mean to prepare and operate the waiting list, which otherwise is specifically not provided for under the Rules, 2012. $% &
'
() #!
" #
##
"
"#
#
"#
##
# ##
#
'
& )* '
( ( #!
9 ) ' ++5$ B"
$'
$$ .
. $5
"+ 5 $$+)"+ #+ 0
; ) + "+ $ & ) ) $ )
$)
$5
"+ " &' )5 & +
9 1 5 $) . ) 2)$
& $$ . +
+
+
.
+ 2$ ) ) . 5 5
) ) 5 )++& & 5
) 5$+& $ .
+) $)
1 & ) )++ "&
2) ! ) ( )+ 0
9
C$ . )
))5
) "' . 5
.
)
./..!
/01 0!
+ + $D > % D 1 #$ "+ > % D 1