← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5962/2007dismissed

Krishna Ornaments v. Phera Singh

2020-03-19Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal18 pages

 

    

 



"

!#

$ !

%!

&

$"! '

("

 ) 

 

 *

'! + #), $ !

%!

&

$"! '

("

  "!&("

-

 ) 

 

 *

.

"/ 0!#

$ !

%!

&

$"! '

("

  "!&("

-

 )     

 $!  ! $& 2 '! .3  "

! 56 !

'

(" .3  !

!

7   !  3 "& 1  .3  !

!

7  8    ! % /

9"2 '! .3  "

!

0!( .3  !

! ) ::::

 

 9, "

6&(# "! !3

;!

 8   8   

"22



)  

& 4"

!<& !

!

## 5" ! )22!

422

2!(!

;& 2 !# 4"

3



"

; !!

22 "

;,  !22!

! 2 

##

5" <& !(& ;, 2!

& 2 !

)!

3!, )

2,

=+""!

!!

3

)



3&!

22! (!& )!

2 ;  !<& !#

! 3

4&2

#  

22!

&!

) , ))2 !

!3

>?

'# 

! !<& ! ; 

 5" 22! " 2 "! 3

( "! ! 

&!

' 9 @ $&6;

A!;   !

.

 B

"! !

; !!!

=" B .

? !

2 3!,

##  )

(!& " 4!

8 

 7  4

# ; /

2

&!,

!

(  5" ))2



2 ;, 

&!

' C.

B .

!

(! 23

 "3 ;   ;,  !22!

4"

2 )

)! !!

5" 3

&!

' 9 B .

4! 2 ;, 4!

,!

 

 .2"&(" .

)!3 

!

D) &

) 2



( 3

##  )

22!

 ,!

"3 2)  22! 4" "

4 

&2  ( )

 )!#

&!

 #

5" ' $&6;

 ' 9 ;, $&6;

.

8 

B .

 4"

!

&! =

  

           









   !  

  

 

 

     

 

     



 

       

  



 !

 

 !!  "

 

 !



        

# $

     !! !      %

   

  !

  

  





       

  

 

& ' 

 

   



         

      !



 (  !!

   

!

    

B     



        

& ) 

 !



    %

  

      

   *!

!

  

   ( !



      

!!  "

         !



    

   (     &?

' C.

B .

2,

4 )! &! ; 224 ;,  !22!

 4"

2 6&



2 &!

'

.

9 B .

 ' C.

B .

D! 

&! = "

  

#              

   

     

  + 

!!

 

), 

)-   

    

! !



 

& ' ,  !!

 

), 

)-  "

   

 



 !

 %& ) .

 

'    

   

        

  

  

!

/0    %      "

    "

  $  234&."

    

   

  

   

  !

 (

  



   

  !   !  

                   

    !



(      

 

 * 

!

 !     ! 

 !!

 

), 

)-   &    (

 !!

        

                 

     

 

     ( 

    !!

      !

  !

  

      (     

   !       

  *   "

 

 

!

 ! 

   "

  

          

  

          



& 5 .

  

                     

)  

  

! 

 

   6              

   7  

      

( 

 !!



  

"

   !





    !!   !   

 

    !

    



 

            

    !

 6 



  

    

7     !!

    

 

 !!     



& 8 .  "

  

        

     

 !!

  

         

        !

    





     

    !

 6 

  



7  



         



    6              

   7  

 6

), 

)-7& 9     

 

 !!

"

  

  

 

 





 

    

 

      !!

 

             

  !!

 & : 

 

 

  ,

     

 !   

 !!     

 

!   !   "



% " &

  4   !!  

 !!     

   !



6               

      

7  "

 

  

! !

  %

# $

 ;

"



 !!



 

     "

   

        

  !   !    ( & 2 %     

  !

      

   !   !

   !!



6

), 

)-7      !        !

     !!

    

 ?

.

 ( 4"# &!

' .

!

9 "

; 2

!<& ! 2   3

/ 23

 ))2

 !

3

!# !22!  4"

!!

3

## 2, )

 5"

&! "

"! 2!

& 2 !

)!

"

;2

 ( "!&("

3!

&

!!

)

 ;, 2!  !22!

 " 2!

& 2

!)!    !

"3

&;#  "

4

&;

<& "

4! )!

2 

, 4!

"

2 

#    "!! !3

"&2 ; 224 4"!

"!

" 2!

& 2 !)!  4!

 " !!

C 3

"

; )

 ;,  !22!

&;

<& "

22!*4!

4&2  "3 , 3!

 !!

3

 E

&;#  " ("

)!

!, 22 F , 3

4

2 ;!  !22! E &!"!

 " &2



)!3 "

; &

&;

<& 32)# (!& 3

(

2("!

) & !

 ! ;

2 #

D

 2,

) 2

&

 3!

2,  ("

4! E &!"!

&;#  " !!

3

"

; )



3&!

24!

; #

)!

  "!! "

24!

4&2  3!

2,  ("

2(2 " E &!"!

!4  &! !)2, 2 ;, 4!

))2

 2 ;, 

/ 23

 4"!

"

; )2 " 24!

# 2, ##;!

"3 D)!

E2 (# ", 4 4

# ; / ) "2

 )!#

7 4

&!"!

)2 " "!

(! ))!& , ) "2

#

 )!#

2  6& &

  24, ' 9"()&! E  "

 " !<& !#

)2

 2, !

)!

2 !<& !# 24!

;& !

# 2, ##;!

2 2,

!(&#

2!

& 2 !

)!  "

&! 4 )! 

D#  <&

 2 . & 

#& ; 

 " ' 9 B .

 ;2

8

 7  4!

2 ! 3!

##  )

;& 2 !

*"!

4 & !

!

& , ! !

2, "

) # !

"! 5"&  ' 9 B .

2 ! ( F

"  4!

  2, ))2, !

! 3!,

##  )

;& 2 !

*"!

& ;& 2  !

& , ! !

2, !

"

) # !

"!

"!

" '  )!3 

(!&

3

3 2;2 22! (



!#2

A!

'   

 B .

 4!

&  ! " =" !<& !

!

4 

&) ? EG;2 '&)!# &! "

!)! 4! ="?

2& !<& !#

##  # 2, ##;!

5" ! ;"

 !

!)! 4

( 3  )!3

.

)&!) &2 #! 7

!

"

! " 2(

2&! 4"

2

&;

<&2,  ' 9 "

 2, &  4! ="

!

"!

& ?

;& 2 

2& !<& !#

"!

# 2, ##;!

2  5"  "

4!*22! &!

) , ))2

!3

"

; !4  &!

!# # # 5" &!

"3 ; #/ !

2 "

!

"22(

! "

24 6&(# ;!&(" 

"

&!

$ %&'# # 



( )% * & ++,""# 7 ! 6&(# EG;2 '&)!# &! 4"

2 /  3!

&

)

)!  

&

"!

(!

4"

D! 

&!

 <)& %  

       

    

                   !    !



!   =  !  !!     

= 

      

!     *

!  = 

  

!   

  ! !     

>     

(    !       ? !  



   &@ .!

!3 & "!

(!



4

"2 "

22

(!, 8 D!  ;3 "

&;

<& "

24!

4&2   ("

4"

"3 2!,

!&

3&!

22!*24! $! B

D! 

&! <5& "                    

  *!  

    

 

 *!           

!   !           !    (   !! 



       &@ '  6&(# 4"

!! "

; #

 -.'#+ / - ( ) % *,&++ *

7 !

 "!

"! ))22

4

4!

& )!#

E 4

2  )!!

)!!

) !#

 5"

& 4

2 ;,

!

( 2 4!

2(4 "

4 "!

5" 3

4

&(" !

& )!#

;&



)!!

) !#

4"

" 4

)!! 5" !

2 &! 224  E43! ;"



4 &)

))2 &!

) , ))2  5"/!

 7

"

&#  

4

"2 !

&

6&(#

$"2 

'&)!

&! < 



  

 



5  A , *!

$

>     

 &

!





 

 B  ! 

    



 

B>         

&/          

  &    (

              ! 

  

 

                         

 

  &,  

 

  

 ( !         

!     

      

 ! 

 ! 

 

 

&C

           



    

       

  

 

  &@



&2 ! "!

))!

" 6&(# )

 ;, EG;2 '&)!# &!

$"2 

'&)! "

; !3!

 E43!

!&2 ! "!

))! " 6&(# )



$"2 

'&)! 4

3!

!3!



 !,

5"

D 2, 4" "

; D)2  ;, EG;2 '&)!# &!

&;

<& 6&(#

 6&(#

.

   '# 01)%233&4++**2 EG;2 '&)!# &! !

&

)!3 &

6&(#

$"2 

'&)! '" 22 5"/!

'&)! "2 " ;  !<& !# 22! "

; D# 



& )! 

;! &!

 ! 3

)

 "

22! &!

) , ))2 )!!! ;,   #/ !

"

!  2   5" '&)!# &! 2  "2 " 6&(# )



$"2 

'&)! "

 ; 3!!&2 5" )! 3 )! 6&(# )

 !

&! <3&.      !

    !         

      

 "

& #$ # 

 

(  * +%& ,%+&  

?  !!

  %

5   A  "

 , 





  !

  

! B  ! 

    





 

B&.,

 "

 

 !!

 !

  

 

  

 *

 

 &.!   !  !! ! 

    & .  

  "

 ! 

 

&  !!  



     

    !

 ?  "

 .   !  !!  ;

"

&.     



          &/    



 !  ) !

   # B)&                 !

   !



! 

   !  !! 

  

&B 3&                               !    !       !   (  !!  

       &+  

  !! 

   &

    !  

  "

  

   !



!

&-  

  

  

    

! 

   !

 

 

     !   !! "

&    

  (

*

>  

  > >  

    "

    !?  

>    

 

B

! 

&.    



   !! ! 



!



!



   

        !    

    

 

"

      !  

&;

            !  ?  !!

!

      !

 

 !

   

! 

 ! &/    ! >  



      

 (    & &   %    . (    &  "

   C    .  2:95%""5:  -   

  $



 &   ,

!                        

! 

  

   !

         

  & . 

(      

  

 ( ! 



!  

 

! 

! 

   

&. 

   

    







& - 

 0

( 5$ % &(      

  )  

   

 .      #! )   -.% &(

  (#.   

 "



  & D  $   &$ 

? ,  22:" 82%"#22:5%""5)

     !





* 

   !!



   

   

    

& +     !  !

;

"



 

    !   

    

 





& E $   &$ !%  '33" ''%"# '33'%""935        

         !!



&;        

 !        

   

   

&.  



   

 !

    !



?

$

C  %     ! &.    && ?

             

 

   (

 

         

!

&%

      ( E&"&D !

 & D -  '33'

" 53:%"#'33'%""93&.   !

 

 

            *

   

     

 

!     

 !     !

 !! ! 

 (

           & '& .;

"

 !  

 

   

      $

  

 %!   %  . (  !    !



 

F-   $&0&$ !

 & D&$ 

 225" 835%"#225 '%"")9&    "

 !   

    



 

;

"

  

    

     !

& .!  !

! 

 

&A  !   !



     

    & 



  !

 *!

   !!  !!  *

    &  .  *

 !



  "

  

!     ;

"

 

 

   



 

     !!  

  !   

   

*

    !  !

&  ,  *

    

"

  # B4&1  

 

         (!     



!

 

 ,  (



 

!!

  ?

     

    !  

    ( !  

 

   !

&. 

  !

   

   !  *    ?

  

       

&,        



    !        !!   !   

     * &B@

"!

6&(#

!!! !

6 ($'# $ 7  (  %&  0 8) % *&    ++   ) 9  $#  .'#

1 )%233"& ++

3

!)! 24

# 2!

 5"  "

&! "

2  ; !4 6&(# )



#11'#6(

6)23 4%2&+%&2"4 )

4 6&(#

)

 ;, EG;2 '&)!# &!

))! " '&

2 ! ( F



,  2, 4!

;& 2  )!

! !

2, !

) # !

"! "

24!

&!

) , !3

4&2  3!

2,  ("

" .





)!   !!

3

"

2!, ; )

 24!

"

 &!

) , )!  !3

C 5"

)

 ; D#  !# "!

)!

) 3 +"

2 "!

!3

 4"

&!

&!, (" &!

&; '  '  B .

 "

&!

!<& ! D#  2(2 ,

!! 

!!

4"

"

; )

 ;,  !22! 5" '& &

4!

" ("

&! #,

22 !

D#  ! ! !2 , !!

)

 !

)! 

/ &!

"

.

!

)&!)



,

2

2(2 , !

)!)!

,

& !!

!

)! 

#, )

& !!

!2 "!

#, #  7 "!

4!  6&!

("

&! 4"

2 "!

!3

( !!

3

# 

&;

<& 3 &2

#)22, )

4, !

!#3

 ! ;

2 # ("

&!

D!

!3

!, 6&!

4&2 ;

24 !3!

!!

3

"

(!& + "

;

!3  "

&! 

  , ( (!&

!! .

! (2, 22 !3

! !! ;

#

 .22 ) #

22&

))2

 

, !

)  

4 ;3 6&(# 





!

$

  "#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./