← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4743/2013allowed

Babli And 2 ORS. v. Kumari Ruchi Bansal And ANR.

2016-08-29Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh18 pages





      

 

   !""#$%$&'()(%!*+,  -.$ !/"0% 



1(2 0$ (#/$ &% .  &!/"0     ' 34

 5  5  5    

    !"   "    #####   5  5+    ,67 $%  &  &    % '(')    *++ %   

       ,7 $%  &  &    %

'( ',    *++ %   

       *7 $%  &  &    % '(-    '(.                  *+      +



%   

      

     /      *  *  '

   &&         (0-,,-((     *      1  

*  (2  " 3*41  $5(6724    8(67285  *  '   & 

   !(.--9(7 &(67- :

    ;

++     & <.   *  &     

& 

 *

 '   *  * 

    -7-.,-(2 , =        &    '      

                

   !(.--9(7     !(0669(7 (.-(9(7/       >  & -)(((6674% ?'09$5  -((((667 2((-,--,   /     &4$%?'

29=5  *  

@  >        > 'A* ,--0       &   

                

  @  &           '    &     !(-2-    -2-.,--.



4$%?'295       *        &        *  9     &    2   

 &       

        '     >  

  = '

!(> = ' !,



 *   & :

   $ =$   &   :

      & 1 &1 

    & 1 &1   &    *  ! 

  !(.-(9(7   1 &1  

&@ &      

     &   !  

            



 *     *              -0-),-(,

                 6  * ,(  /  '  

  1   &  '

  &      9:

 0       1  &  '

   *             .  *+  * &

*+       





  1         */   *            '

        & 

'%  2)--9'  

     *   1    07)9'         '             &   :

   &   ,()--9'   2(-<,--0      & &   -2-6,--0*    *   (- /           ' 

    &   &  B         *      1 &1      B     

 &      &             :

9  

      1 &1    

  *&   *    &   &    * 1(.-2,--7'

C(?

      **  & D ,?

   :

     

   D



2?

      

  

D 0?

         1   

 D

.?

   *   D

)  E )      *           *           1       &                    :

        &                / 

         &      *      1  *

&  :

          

 7 B                  1      

  * &  (24254545  (672

           

& * & *   * &        (606   * * "             

 *    & +   8   

 &/              %''  *  

    '%:

    



 *          *       

  1    

  1 "     ?'0=   &  '%            '       

&                     B 

        

 + &   1 )$&8"0 5$&)/5 9/&":;% 0- &%4 .+   

"&!<6 A  = + &   1  &=" 2;%5/0$2 !$5 0 %> !$">$+ *   

"&!<*< < F1           1   &  &  

      &* 1  * &  

    9:

         '    

*  "  *                    !(.-(9(7  * ! > 

   :

      "  *      &

   * &  

&   * 1   *      &            *     6    1    

*        

 ;

++    

  *  & !(-2--2-.,--.   

 

                 

    "      ** & *   *                           

&      ** & 

 *

   '  :

   &       1 &  1              /   

&

                 

              

  

 

  & /

   * !(0.29(7 *    

  

   

& &  *  1 &1*&     *  

   

      :

 *  $             

      

   & &    ! 

  *%       

   

*   *&B        

           :

 

   

   & *  * /         &             *      

      &    



1 &1 (-   &     1    

  &  (24254545  (672  *     :

 *+      * &   A = + &    1     4

5

 1          *  &  :

            *    *       

    * *   &    & 

 *   

 *

  * 1     '  *+ * *       &   !   

 *  *  1 

    * *   * &B

      

 + &    1 5 ! 0= %// (8/ 0:;%1"9 .10$%/ & ./!0 + 

  $>$.66+(0- ?5$&)/;% 0%/! 25$&)/ !/"0%+ 

  $>$.<6+055 &&;%15/ 02 +    $>$.

< 21$%/ & %% 8"#" %"8!/0()/4 %;% 0>""&(. !$ <5 &4$&"

6, (( B   1     

   &  &  

&  &



 (, /     **

/     

 * * 1        '     &  (24254545  (672 (2 (24254545  (672    '

C>$#!$&!"& &!%'7 4(5 GGGG GGGG GGGG 4,5 GGGG GGGG GGGG 425 

 1  & 

    H 45    * & H 45 :

     

 

&   * & *          * &          (606  *IE (0 / "8*

1  0-$. % $ &% .;%5! !"

 (&? -+**,  +

   @ =

+ &   1 ;"8 0= %/(@! ;%5! !" 0: &  &8 !/"0%+**  <       (672 

      '  * & /     &  * & *    &    (2  425  45  45         * &  

  /      (672     ' * & & 

 :

        * / ;

&=   

1  ="%/;$?;%0 2$&8"0 .5$&)/5"!/$+< 5< (. / A =    1       4

5

&  (24254545 $  +*3*  

 (606

  (672 <(,

     '

C6 B      *                 +& !8  4B (67) +,(54

5 *  A  =     1  @ 8   4B (6)2 +(54A=54

5   

 1 & 8  4B (6)7177254

5

   

  &   *'  4*545:

*    B            *             

   

    &   *'  4*5 45  (2 4254545  * * *   %        

 &   *'  4*545             

     &     *   *      B> F 8   4(6)(')2 F <).54

5 @ =

 &&     

   &         &   *' 4*545* *  



    %  

 &    * *    / * *     *'  4*545   

   *   *              &   3 *' 4*5  :

    

&         * &       *   3 *' 45  * *&   * &  **    B            &&     &   '    *                   B             * *      &  &B*                     :

        *            

&:

      

      +      

   * GGGG GGGG GGGG  GGGG GGGG GGGG  GGGG GGGG GGGG B      :

       

     

 &   *'

  4*545 :

    

    &  * 

   & 

 



*  DB& 

    * & * :

     

     * *   &&      

    

       &     

  

 * * 

     *    

  &  :

   *      

                  * + / 1   *:

&       *                        * &&            "& 1   

1   & *    

         && &   *'  4*5 45" * 



     &   *'

  4*545 

*         *               *   &   && &  & *'  4*5 45*  /      

         

&*       1 1  && &  () ! * A = + &   1   

    4

5                       



   &  :

         

&      9'   * &        * &   *            *       &  &/    :

**    +     (7 B  &9 0$  4 .  ;%  2  0= %/   &!/"0+  *  

 

"&!,  *      &  (2425        +      '

&  &      *+/  

   &  & +   *  &% * 

   

+    *  '

&9     B*        &  (672        

 &  (2425/ & &      * +   *  '

&   & * /     *    

   & *       *     

*   &&     *&       &  *     *

   +      (< / &   &*  * &  * &   * 



 *       & *  &  (24254545  (672 &*         &    /   &           &   (0669(7(.--9(7(.-(9(7

*    *   (0669(7 (.--9(7      (.-(9(7     ! > 

   $%        *     *  

*& &   :

  (2 (672   

 '  * & *   * &

     (672  

*  *    &  & 

 *  *  

    (2  (672 +    (6    *    *+  *  *    

 * *   *   *+!2  * 

& *          *     **   &

  /

    A = + &      4

5      &     

 * %''

 *       

* ** 



 

                       *     &  

**      &    *&* !(0.2

 *     

*  

     &  !(0.,

 *&   >    /                    '%   = 4?'(5 &    *%   !(0.2

 *      *  &  1 &1!'       

       '        &      ,- /    &  &   &  :

 (242545  * & &    * 

1 ?$!5$&)/  &!/"0;%$!

2  &!/"0+6    $>$.*+

 

1 

    ' 

  :

      *       *        

&   * &   * &     / "8*

1  &    

 + &  

1     4

5

  *     



* &  (24254545  (672

:

  &      

&   9' * &  *     9' * & ,( B*   &   

 !(.-(9(7

      ! >  

  

                  *               *    &      1 &  1   B    

  *             :

       

  :

      &  1 &1 ,, / + &    4

5

     *    *                *

*             

  &  

     *    

       

&      

                    ,2 B   4

5 1    

 *            *  &      *+!2  *  

 



 * 

  *+  *   *      *    :

          *   & &          '   * 

 

           

       

   

  /       

    

&      (24254545  (672& + * *   ,0 B      4

5  &        &  :

    *  

        

         4

5 ,. B   *  + & 

* 

 *

*           

  * * 1      ,) /     

 / 

& (0-,,-((  * 1   -7-.,-(2  * 

    *                 *         *   

 ,667 &8  ,7 B          :

*    

        *    @     

  5  5 ()(%!*+,    ! A/"!/"0%@" =$&)B0" %&"8'

"%B A/"!/"0 "@0! -."'

"%B