← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4474/2018dismissed

Harjinder Singh v. Kuldip Singh And Another

2018-09-28Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi5 pages

    

      

   ! "#$#%&

()#%! (*#%+, - ##% ( . ($/$ 0/1!#2*#%+, %, ( -- $2%! %    & 34 5*

*64 ( $ %& 5(0(7 8!9"

 (, 2 ##% ( :::    ;<  9#$#% 2 ##% , $ = % #1 ! /%! ( (#"1    , 

%$#/#%%!# ($ #%+ $#!  >2  @ %% >/(  A 2 #9#1 /!+  ( #98 

1$(! (!

 ! B%% >/( A2 $$ !=7, 1

#9#1/!+ (#98

C, ( =7 #%($ #%+ $#!  >2 )/!+? % %! ! "(  !

 !  @ C $ !#$?#$$ ! 1$ (! ( !

%% >/( A@2 $$ !=7, 1 (% !!!##% 1#$(#"/!+ 8

/(!

$2/(C, ( =7?#$" 11 % /$ 1, 2 ##% (C $!#$?#$$ ! (% ! "/%$ 1 "% %! ! ,  ,  #?2/+% ! (! ( C $ 1 + 117 /%$/$ #% $, 2 ##% ($"/%$ 1% 9 (#%(? !, 2 ##% (,#$ 9#%+= %2(" ! ! >2 ( %

@(( %7 9#! %" %(,  2 ##% ( , %7 D%C1 !+  =/ ,  2 $$#%+  >2 ! "(  = $#! $ ,#$ =$ %"  (? ,  2(" !#%+$ #% ,  "#9#1 $/# C $ % #% %#% 1%(C#1/1=/!/ /% =1 "#("/?$ %" $

 ;< (#   "$  ,  "

$  1 !#%+  ,  #1#%+  ,  2( $ % 2 ##% ( ,  >2 @C $2

#%$ ,  2 ##% (E!  %!

% #% ,  $/# ( $2 "##" 2 ((?

%"  

+( ? %  $ 11  > C, ( /2% ,  2 ##% (E!  %!

% ?9 ! %

#% ( $ #%+ $#!   > 2 %! ! "(  !

 @/%! ( (! ('/1 @  D#%+/2, 21 , ,#$ =$ %"  (?, 2(" !#%+$#%, "#9#1$/#C $%#% %#% 1%(C#1/1=/!/  /% =1 "#("/?$ %" $ %!,#$, 9#%+#1 ! % #%(?,  !

   D%C1 !+  * %!  ,  ( $2%! %$E21 #%#$ C $ ,  ,  2 ##% (E!  %!

%#% %#% 117, !% ( !#% /( %!, != % 2(" ! ! >2 ( C, %, !#!%/(%/21 ! 9#! %" ! $2#  #1#%+ $ 9 ( 122(/%## $+( % !,#? ;@< ,  2 ##% (E!  %!

( (? > ?#%#%+ ,#?$ 1 1$ > ?#% ! /(C#%! ( *#%+, (C#%! ( *#%+,  C 9 (8 %%   ,  %A C#% $$ $ /(% ! /2   "  "($$A > ?#% #% ""(!#%+178,  > ?#% #%#%",# $ #!C#% $$ $"/1!%= ( #% 9#! %" #%,  =$ %" , #(, 9#%+ " !"($$ > ?#% #% ;< 2 ( (? , 

=9 8 ( "(! ( 9 1$ ,  % #%## 117 #1 ! C(# % $  ? % %! "% $ ! ,  $/# C, ( /2% #$$/ $ C (  ( ? ! %  

  , (  (8 ,   $2%! %$E21 #%#$ > ?#% !, #(C#% $$ $ C 9 (8%  %%  /(% ! /2 % = , 1  ,  2 ##% (E!  %!

%  ""(!#%+178 2 ##% (C $2(" ! ! >2 ( %  C 9 (8%, = $#$

#%?9 !=7, 2 ##% (E!  %!

%89#! (! (!

 !  8 >2 ( 2(" !#%+$!

 ! C ( $  $#! %2 7? %"$$ $B

EA  , ( /2%8 ,  "

$  C $ #> ! ( 9#! %"   ,  ( $2%! %$E21 #%#$C,#",C $"%"1/! !% @, (  (8, 

 "

$ C $#> !( 9#! %" , 2 ##% (E!  %! %=/! $2#  #1#%+ %/? (/$22(/%## $8, 2 ##% ( #1 !1 ! 9#! %" 2 (/$ 1 , F#?#%7(! ($( 9 1$, %@ @#%, 2( $ %" "/%$ 1( , 2 (# $, "

$ C !)/(% ! '  @( %#(  9#! %" ,  2 ##% ( !  %!

% % ,#$ C% ( $2%$#=#1#7 =/ 9 % % ,  !)/(% ! !

 ! $2# "/%$ 1(, 2 (# $= #%+2( $ %8% 9#! %" C $2( $ % %= , 1, 2 ##% (!  %!

%C, ( /2%, "

$ C !)/(% !  @ ( !  %!

%$ 9#! %"   C% (#$D %! ( $2%$#=#1#78 %  1$ ! $2#  2( $ %"   "/%$ 1 ( 2 (# $ % !  %!

9#! %" C $2( $ %C, ( /2%, "

$ C !)/(% !

@( !  %!

% 9#! %"  $/=) "  1 $ 22(/%#7 %! $/=) "  2 7? %   $

EA $"$$= ! 2$# !C#,, 1 + 1 #! /,(#78 /(!

$2/(=/ 9 %%

@% #, (, 2 ##% (%(,#$"/%$ 12/#% %" 

 ( "

11#%+ ,  "

$  $ 9 ( 1 #? $8  @@  2? ,  2 ##% ( C 2(" ! ! >2 %! "

$  !)/(% !  

@ ( > 2 "%$#! ( #% % 

@ ,  "

$  C !)/(% !   @ % C,#", !

  > 2 %! ! "(  C $ 2 $$ ! , (  (8 ,  % ?9 ! % #% /%! ( (! ( ' /1  @ %

 @$  $#! ,  >2 @ ;B< 1,/+, ,  2 ##% (E!  %!

% C $ 2(" ! ! > 2 (  %

@ 9 %/ 1171 !#%+2 $$#%+ >2 %!! "(  !

@87  #%C $#1 !=7, 2 ##% (E!  %!

%%17 ( $ #%+ $#!  > 2 %! ! "(  C#,/ ", 11 %+#%+ (! ( !

@9#! C,#",, C $2(" ! ! >2 (  ;G<  2 (/$ 1  ,  (! ( 2 #9#1 /!+  ( #98 

 ( 9 1$ ,  ,  2 ##% (E!  %!

% C $ 2(" ! ! > 2 9#!  (! ( !

 !   %! $ #! > 2 (  (! ( 2 #%$ , 

 %C $$  $#! 9#! (! (!

 !@  , (  (8

#% 2 ##% (E!  %!

% C $ 2(" ! ! > 2 (  9#!  (! ( !

%! > 2 %! ! "(  C $ 2 $$ ! %  @ , %1721 , 2 ##% (E!  %!

%= ( , 1 (% !(# 1 /(C  ,#$ =$ %" 8 C $ % #% %#% 1 %( C#1/1 =/ !/   /% "#("/?$ %" $(!/ /% ( % $$9 1#!( $%, $= %2#% !/ (%%A %" , 2 ##% (E!  %!

%%

@( $/1#%+#% > (  2(" !#%+$ = #%+ (! ( ! #%$ ,#? %! >2 ! "(  = #%+ 2 #%$ ,#? %  @   $#! $8 2 (/$ 1  ,  (! ( 2 #9#1 /!+ 8 

 ( 9 1$ ,  $ 9 ( 1 22(/%## $ , ! = % +( % !  ,  2 ##% (E!  %!

%  !!/"  9#! %" #%"1/!#%+1 $22(/%#7=/$#112 ##% ( #1 !2(!/"  %7 9#! %" 1 , ,#$"/%$ 1!#!%#%(? =/, 2(" !#%+$( ,#$, 9#%+= %2(" ! ! >2 ( #$ 1 ?  >"/$ #%,  =$ %"  %7 "?21 #%, 9#%+= %#1 !E "#%, 9#%+= % D % #%$, "/%$ 1 5( 9 (8%" , 2 ##% (, != %2(" ! ! >2 (1# (8#C 11 ,  ?(  >2 " !  ,  2 ##% (  , 9  = % 9#+#1 =/ ,  2(" !#%+$, 2 ##% (, 1$%!#$"1$ !C, , (, , !"% " ! ,#$"/%$ 1 %!C, % 1$,C %!C, %/, =1/ , 1 (% =/ ,  >2 %! ! "(  , ( ( 8 # #$ "1 ( ,  ,  %, !#% %#% 117 %!C#1/117% ( !#%,  /( % @ @8 '  @8   @8

@ ( 1 !#%+ 9#! %"  9 %/ 117 1 !#%+  ,#$ = #%+ 2(" ! ! > 2 (  %

>2 %! ! "(  %  @   $#! $8 (! ( !

@(! (#%+ >2 ( 2(" !#%+$ #%$, 2 ##% (C ( % 9 ( ", 11 %+ ! 1,/+,,  >2 @C ", 11 %+ !

 ;< %,  =$ %"  %79 1#!( $%, 9#%+= %2#% !/( %% %" , 2 ##% (#% /(%

%! @8% +(/%! C, $ 9 ( #$ ?

!  / C (( %#%+ #% ( ( %"  C#, ,  C 11A $% !(! (2 $$ !=7,  /($= 1C ;

< ""(!#%+178#%!#%+%? (##%,  9#$#%2 ##%8, $ ?  #$!#$?#$$ ! *6 1#  /!+  

?# 6, , ($2 D#%+E( $% ! &  $E 6, , (( 2( &  $E