Kartar Singh Deceased Thr Lrs And ORS v. Union Of India
!""#$%$&'
'
() * )+* )
!
"
#$% !
"
!
"
& '''
)+* ),
) (#
)" "*++,-./0, 1-12./0, ./3-./02 ./3+./02 .01,./02 .0,0./02 ..1+./02
022,./02
5#
)
-0/0./01 "5 # 8
5#
89
5
5
# 0213
9 !9 "5 # ! : 8
$ "
9
9 #5 8
5;
55# "
5
5 ;
8 ;
! 8
4
< ) "
# 8 5 &
-- 0 =
*< 8# ( (
3// > 0?,/ 9@ . =
3//
; A
5 #
56 ( 48 0? 9@ - =
9
,3/ 9@
%
8
5#
< )0220
"
" "
#
5 . 5 -4
)
"
B
#; !9 (
8
7
5#
5 .4
)
7 &&
5 . 8 "
7
5+&3$ 8# ( &( 8 +&3$ 8# 5 4
)
5
"
"
#. )
;
5
8 3//
#.<
#
#
--
" 8
"
"
# )
; !9 ) "
#
:
6 C ( )
( 5
8
5 - # 0 +1 ,. +,?-0
0 2 -, +20.1 D. 2- .21/+D 0 .. ,? -?/D. ?+ --, # ( 5
. -+ 0, -+/21 0 /2 -, +20.1D0 /3 2111/D 0 .. ,? -?/D,1 30. #5
?$ 0 5 ( 8 5 08
8 5 - # 5
. +/ 3, 13?21 0 /2 -, +20.1D0 30 ,+?13D0 .. ,? -?/D? ,. /3,23 ;
"
5# #* 0 #*.
# "
5
8 #*-;
5
) B
" # 8
"5 ?
1 , 2 0/
& ./ 0 ! %1"23"$&$!$&%! 4"5!# !"627, &75 &3 8$!0$& 3"1!09:"!"2%&"$!0"2%$3" !$& 5 $608 75" 3$&62: !0$&3 ! 2& 5 &57;< 5$$"% 2!0"%!4"5!##23$&657,!0"3"! $5%!0"5 &3= 2" 55%
-- <&3"2%!4"5!# !"627$%6$>"& %<&3"2'- *
%" $!5"!0"# %"
! 5 2" #;<$2"3 +0 %2 % &3!0"$2 2"%1"#!$>" 2" 55$&6 $&!%!4"5!# !"627 = #0 &*$&60 - 9==/ $& - , @=
- A + & 5 9 ?%
= *0 :*$&60 - 9=== - ,/== - , 9 9- ,/ - , ?% @ - ,9= 9- ,
9= - A+ & 5 /= &6$2*$&60%= -9$"=%0 2"
==:$& - , @- ,
BB &*$&60 5 &3:" %<2$&6 :$& - ,==/ - , -/ @ @-/ ,= 9- , ?% 9= 9- ,C=== - ,
- , @- ,C= @- , - ,= 9- , = 9- ,= - , @- , @- , @- , C= - ,= - , C=== @- ,9== - , @- , @- ,9 - , @=:$& - ,:$&
- ,C:$& - , /=== - ,=:$&
-/ A/+ & 5 C=
0 &3+ <2 -/ 9== -/ , - , -9 , /-/ ,C - , ?% - A+ & 5
@ 0 ! %1"23"$&$!$&&3 4"5!# !"627, &75 &3 8$!0$& 3"1!09:"!"2%2:!0" <&$#$1 5)$:$!% &3 2:!0""&#$&6!0" &!&:"&!4<&3 27 4<!!$&6!0"
23 10 %" 24 & %! !"%%$3"&57;< 5$$"%2!0"&3 4"5! D#"1!!0$%,&!0"25 &3;< 5$$"%2!0$%&3 4"5! 0"5 &3!0"12"%"&!% 2"%$!< !"3#<15"!0<% &3 :"!"2% 8 7 2: !0" <&$#$1 5 )$:$!% &3 !0"
# &!&:"&!4<&3 27 4<!!$&62310 %" 24 & %! !"% 0"2"2",!0"5 &3!0"12"%"&!%3"%&! 55$&! % $3&34"5!# !"627
-9- 0 !!0" #;<$2"35 &3!0"3"#2""053"2%& :"57 #0 &*$&60 "8"D"#<!$&= 0 %4""&%08& $&28<2, $&6 5*$&60 "8"D"#<!$&= $&"558 5<2, &6$2+ <2 "8"D"#<!$&= $& 0"227=$2:$#0$ 5<2, %< &3 * $&6 "8 "D"#<!$&= $& 2""& 5<2,*0 :*$&60 "8 "D"#<!$& = $& 22!= E 2$ 5<2, + 2! 2 *$&60 "8"D"#<!$&9= $& 2 &6" 5<2, &6$2 *$&60 "8"D"#<!$&/= $& 22! 5<2, "0 2 *$&60 "8"D"#<!$&= $&7 55<" 5<2,
0 &3+ <2 "8"D"#<!$&C= $&<215" 5<2, <1 + <2 "8 "D"#<!$& /= 8$!0 "&#$5 &3 &6$2 *$&60 "8 "D"#<!$& @= $& 2F 5<"
5<2 $& !0" 1=+0 %2 5 & 80$#0 $% D-- 0"
B4 0 1 %%$&6 !02<60 !0" #;<$2"3 5 &3 &3 $& !0" 4 3$>$55 6" "0& 2" 5%%08&$&7 55<" &3 "558#5<2%2"%1"#!$>"57 C 0 !!0"2": $&$&6 #;<$2"35 &3!0" 4>"% $3 %="D-5 &38&"2%&"$!0"2 55%8$!0$&6!0"3"1!09 :"!"2% &"$!0"2%$3"!0" !0$&3 2& 5 !$& 5 $608 7&2 55%8$!0$&!0"3"1!09:"!"2%"&#$&6 <&$#$1 5)$:$!%22:!0"4<&3 272310 %"
24 & %! !"%0" <&$#$1 5)$:$! &32310 %" 24 & %! !"% 2" 112D:2"!0 &+ 8 72: "0& ?$55 6"*$:$5 257,!0""&#$&6# &!&:"&! 3B$&$&6!
<&$#$1 5 )$:$! 2 3B$&$&6 ! 24 & %! !"% $% 5% 112D:2"!0 &+ 2 8 72: "0& ?$55 6"0"
2": $&$&6 #;<$2"35 &3 "D#"1!!0"5 &3%08&$&1 2 / 55%<&3"2%!4"5! 8&"347!0"12"%"&!%$% 2 8 7 2: !0$&3 - 2& 5 !$& 5$608 7 0 ! $& >$"8 !0" 4>", !0" 5 &3 %08$&6 $&
5<:&/,) - 55%$&%!4"5!# !"627280$#0!0"7 2""&!$!5"3!!0"2 !"%/1"2%;< 2"7 230"
-/- 2": $&$&65 &3!0"% 55%$&23 4"5!# !"6272 80$#0!0"7 2""&!$!5"3!!0"2 !"%9%;< 2"7 23% &57G
" 8
5 "5
5 .
) #
#
5
<
!
#
" 8
5"
%
)+* )
0./.././
$ A
@
5 *